Trayvon Martin : sifting the facts
There have been a lot of clarifying details added to the Trayvon Martin events since the initial news story broke . I like to give my take on what seems to have transpired in totality . This may not yet be the complete picture of what happened but there is enough detail to get a general idea of the scope of this tragedy .
Background events which set the stage :
http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/cutline/zimmerman-neighbor-rash-robberies-young-black-men-trayvon-145647987.html
There were 8 recent robberies in the neighborhood where this unfolded . Apparently they were all done by young black males . This set up a hair trigger reaction to the sight of a "disguised" [wearing a hoodie] young black male on the scene . This is not to accuse Trayvon Martin of any wrongdoing . I doubt there was anything on his part of a nefarious nature . Unfortunately , the appearance of possible wrongdoing is what triggered these events to take place .
Zimmerman :
His initial mistake was to assume the worst about someone who fit the profile of a potential robber . If nothing else this teaches a lesson about assuming based only on appearances . Profiling has its problems .
His second mistake was in being overzealous in his volunteer position as a neighborhood watchman . He followed Martin when this action was unnecessary . And in this case it would have accomplished nothing positive .
Other factors :
The fact that Zimmerman was armed with a gun had a large effect on events . If he was unarmed would he have died from the apparent attack by Martin ? I don't know how to answer that . But I have little doubt that the attack took place . And I have little doubt that Martin struck first . I arrived at this opinion by what I call the "Twitter Effect " . Martin had a Twitter account under the name "No_Limits_Nigga" . This sets up a predisposition for him to have to live up to his Twitter reputation . At the age of only 17 , there is not a lot of rational judgement going on , only the unrealistic expectations he places on himself . However , I expect there are extenuating circumstances which led to this attack . Keep reading .
Was Martin provoked ? In a situation like this where everyone involved was on edge it doesn't take a lot of provocation to start the chain of events . I have little doubt there were many crossed signals going on in this meeting .
Should Zimmerman have worn some kind of identifying clothing indicating he was part of the neighborhood watch team ? I think the answer to that is yes . That might changed how things played out . Perhaps that is another critical lesson to be learned in this tragedy . It was this "secret police" type of interaction which led to these events happening the way they did IMO . Who among us wouldn't be annoyed at being followed by someone with no indication of what his intentions are ?
Blaming the police for not arresting Zimmerman :
The police were also aware of these robberies [at least 4 of them ]
http://www.cnn.com/2012/04/03/justice/florida-teen-shooting-burglaries/?hpt=ju_c2
The fact that they knew Zimmerman from previous and apparently reliable contacts they had with him and the fact that he showed signs of injury were factors which corroborated his story . I don't think there is blame on the part of the Sanford Police Department .
The media news manufacturing :
The one thing that is clear from these events was the persistent overreaction of the MSM . At every stage they spun things to make them appear the most inflammatory they could be . From the news consumer POV the lesson to be learned is stark . Do not trust what the media throw out . They have an agenda . Put everything they say through a process of careful examination .
Do I expect that the consumers of MSM news will learn a lesson from this radical overreaction ? Unfortunately no . And that may end up being the most tragic result of all .

Rich,
Point-for-point,
Neighborhood Watch is a national organization with very specific rules. It is known that ...
The Sanford police did drug and alcohol tests on the dead victim but not on the living shooter. Zimmerman, his father and brother state that Zimmerman's head had been banged on the ground ... where's the photograph from the crime scene ... the DNA from blood on the ground.
Where's Trayvon Martin's clothing ... did the bullet enter his chest or his back? If he punched Zimmerman, why didn't forensics obtain images of his hands? Where's Zimmerman's bloody, grass-stained clothing. Where's the x-rays of his broken nose from the hospital HE DIDN'T GO TO?
Twice now I've posted the un-edited 9-1-1 call ... twice in the call Zimmerman indicated that Trayvon was running away and getting away. He was told not to pursue; Neighborhood watch rules state not to pursue.
Lots of spin no doubt ... but it's not all spin and to declare that the MSM has totally distorted or concealed ... is just not so.
I think in time this tragedy will be seen as a case of crossed signals and miscommunication . I have to wonder what effect these events will have on the neighborhood where it happened ...
Bruce ,
Are you saying that he didn't make a mistake in the case of Martin ? Are you implying that Martin was , in fact , attempting to commit robbery ?
As to the pulling of his weapon , I expect it probably was an action of "last resort" . But I neither said nor implied otherwise . We may never know with certainty about that .
A Mac ,
It doesn't sound like there is a lot of disagreement between us . I agree that Zimmerman was overzealous in the way he performed his task . But I don't think he committed murder or even manslaughter .
Robert ,
That would be some major work to identify exactly which media outlet did what . But in general it seems to be confined to the liberal media . I agree that the POTUS should not have gotten involved in this . Do you have exact quotes ?
The members of the African-American community who involve themselves in crime do that community a huge disservice ... no question ... to the point that they encourage stereotyping, racial profiling and suspicion.
That however does not excuse, nor justify ACTING ON THE STEREOTYPING, PROFILING AND SUSPICION WITHOUT JUST CAUSE! Anyone who is predisposed to aggressively pursue, assault and/or kill any individual without regard to the circumstances leading up to such aggression, if that's his ONLY defense ... HAS NO DEFENSE!
What would any reasonable person, simply walking on the street do, if actively pursued ... at night ... while talking on his cell phone to his girlfriend (a fact that is established by virtue of the time of the conversation, a recorded 9-1-1 call from a witness to the sound of the confrontation and the gun shot)? What?
Might he try and fight being in fear of his death or injury? Logically ... yes. And that would put the SYG law on Trayvon Martin's side wouldn't it ... which is but one example of what fucked-up law it is.
To imply that burglaries by other blacks, no matter the number, somehow justifiy the murder of one who was NOT in the act of committing a crime is the "reasoning" of bigotry at worst, or weak-ass thinking at best.
And weak-ass "thinkers" empowered by the NRA and their ass-kisser, bought politicians, are precisely why sane people raise the issue of gun laws when some asshole who takes his gun to the supermarket and on the way home, kills an innocent. Understanding that enforcing those gun laws already on the books is a fair argument ... adding laws that actually make it harder to enforce all the other laws is what we reap when the NRA sows its oats then can't figure out or give a shit why there's crop failure.
" But perhaps what he should have done was pull his weapon and say "Hey, Dumbass! What the hell are you doing here?" That's what I would have done, if I lived in an area that hat been plagued by burglaries, and I saw a black kid in a hoodie moping around. "
If I'm not mistaken , it is a violation of the law to pull your weapon without being under physical threat ...
In addition , there are black people living in that neighborhood . How long do you think it would be until there were repercussions to such an aggressive unwarranted action ? In any case a neighborhood watchman is not the police . Even the police are very careful about when they pull their weapons . It wouldn't be long before you ran afoul of the law by an aggressive action like that .
"And they tend to answer your questions, and leave the area pretty quickly. "
Uh ... you do realize that Martin actually was living there , right ?
Unless of course some paid-off NRA ass-kisser legislators give us "Stand Your Ground" laws. WTF ... if the first shot, stab wound or baseball bat to the head doesn't get it done, keep going until the killing is accomplished. Then, in the absence of any witnesses but the killer ... the killer just says ... "self defense, I stood my ground."
Case dismissed.
There are a lot of potential dangers in a SYG law . However , implying that was what happened in this case is unfounded . But it is classical political spin to make such a claim ...
He was more than an overnight guest . You can't say he wasn't "living there" .
Accurate but irrelevant ... the fact that he had a legitimate reason to be there is all that matters.
And even if he was passing through on his way home from somewhere else, the only relevant piece of information is that Trayvon Martin was doing nothing wrong!
And "open carry" laws in any state don't give brandishing rights ... or the right to commit murder!
Since this was placed in response to Bruce's comment , I will let him make the response .
Spin this ... SYG is the only reason Zimmerman was not arrested on the night of the shooting. And if you think you can rebut anything I say ... just do it ... if you make your case, you'll then negate any "spin." But accusing me of "spinning," amounts to you ...
"Spinning."
I explain and thoroughly back every position I take in these threads ... it doesn't make me right necessarily, but you'll have to prove me wrong before you can accuse me of anything other than disagreeing.
Oh ... "classical" spin is it? Not just everyday spin, but classical spin.
Well then, that's a whole 'nother animal.
Come on Rich ... pretend you're in a court room or laying out your position before a arbitrator ...
As it should be; I was responding to Bruce.
" Spin this ... SYG is the only reason Zimmerman was not arrested on the night of the shooting. "
I don't agree . My entire article is about the motivations of the police for not making an arrest . And there are many such reasons . Assuming it had to do strictly with SYG is completely unfounded . If you can't address what I wrote in my article you are doing nothing more than derailing this thread .
There is no way to separate SYG from the Zimmerman/Martin case. As previously stated, that law gave the Sanford police an excuse to be sloppy ... since that law went on the Florida books, there have been 95 related cases and 65 deaths.
OK Mac , I have given you fair warning . I am telling you to address what I wrote in my article . If you can "shoot down" what I said there then you can proceed to introduce SYG . If not I am telling you not to introduce any SYG arguments here . The next such comment will have to be deleted as will the other SYG comments . Give it a rest . Address the article material . This is your last warning .
Since you have unilaterally decided what is and is not germane to your position, I won't comment further in your article.
You prevail by default.
I think this exchange highlights the difference between rural white America and city mixed America . What Bruce calls profiling can only be done where the "profiled" population is a very small % of the total population .
If you lived in Florida you would learn to not "profile" against whites in hoodies [or any other race] .
"I have seen too many people at this site argue that Martin somehow bears some responsibility for the events there because he either knowingly or inadvertently looked 'suspicious'. "
That has not been brought in to this thread until you decided to do that . Don't bother doing it again . If you want to get into those issues , go back to the threads where they happened .
"I really question your supposition that Martin was ready to attack Zimmerman because he has to live up to a twitter nickname .... you cannot make that assumption. "
And yet I think it is the most likely explanation . And I'd like to add that what you just said has not swayed my opinion even slightly .
" He instigated the confrontation. He shot an unarmed person. His injuries do not appear to be commensurate with someone who feared for his life. "
Instigated is a funny word in these circumstances . I have addressed that in my article . Try reading it . He shot someone who physically attacked him . Whether or not he was in danger of losing his life or just being permanently damaged is almost impossible to determine at this point . The fact is , when someone pounds your head into the pavement they are not trying to become best buds .
" Zimmerman needs to be put on trial for homicide against Trayvon Martin. "
Why am I not persuaded ? Is it because you have not refuted anything in my article ? Yes .
Well Rich, you're going to have to decide whether or not to make good your threat to delete any comments regarding the Stand Your Ground law; this statement by YOU ...
... Is exactly the essence of the Stand Your Ground law ... you just implied the very thing it advocates.
The law ...
Delete this and we'll have an issue ...
" Is exactly the essence of the Stand Your Ground law ... you just implied the very thing it advocates. "
Where do you draw the line between SYG and plain old self defense ? I think we can eliminate SYG if there was no way to retreat . If G Z was , in fact pinned to the ground he could not retreat and therefore it was just plain self defense .If you can't counter that argument , you don't have a leg to stand on . But feel free to start your own thread when you find your arguments lacking .
First ... we don't know if a punch was thrown; the funeral director stated that there were no bruises, abrasions, etc. on Trayvon Martin's hands to indicate that he had punched, etc. Zimmerman; based only on that information, one could logically speculate that Trayvon Martin was the one threatened in that Zimmerman and not Martin had a weapon. So, if Martin was thus under threat, ONLY he under the SYG law could, had he lived, claimed the legal position of SYG!
Mac ,
For the purposes of this thread you are going to have to prove that the punch was not thrown . And especially for the purposes of introducing SYG you are going to have to prove the punch by Martin did not happen .
If you can't do that you cannot second guess the reasoning of the police who decided not to press charges .
That is exactly what I wrote in the above article . Try reading it .
"an article that answers nothing and does not provide the most likely scenarios outside of Zimmerman's self-serving statements."
For some reason you are in love with the idea of screaming for the blood of a neighborhood watchman who was a little overzealous in doing his duties . You say these are not the most likely scenarios but have done nothing to dispute them . I think you have brought up exactly one good point . This issue is going to be decided almost entirely by the bullet trajectory . And we don't currently have that information . So why are you screaming for this man's blood without any evidence ?
Wrong ... regardless of the purpose of this thread, the law does not require that anyone prove a negative; the burden of proof is on the one making the allegation.
Aside from which, the best evidence of any such punch would emanate from the police investigation at the scene of the crime showing photos of Trayvon's hands/knuckles. The Sanford police fucked up tht whole crime scene investigation. No such evidence apparently
Trayvon's body was examined by the funeral director as I posted ... I repeat ...
So you're off on your entire comment. I'm not second guessing the police ... I'm saying that the only forthcoming statement on the matter contradicts the outcome of the police investigation.
And stop with the "try reading" your article stuff; just because someone doesn't agree with it doesn't mean they haven't read it. In fact, no one makes the kind of in-depth arguments here that I do. If you can refute them with counter information, do it.
Regardless of the purpose of your thread, it cannot trump realities.
Thanks . In and of itself this statement is not extreme either way although it was unnecessary . But what the hell . If the justice department wants to waste money investigating something that is going to be decided by a bullet trajectory then let them have their fun . Too many prosecutors ruins the case ...
Zimmerman is/was NOT a neighborhood watchman ... he was a joe blow running around the neighborhood with a gun. And had he been acting in the capacity of a Neighborhood Watch volunteer, he violated at least three of it's iron-clad rules ... NO GUNS, NO VIGILANTE BEHAVIOR, NO PURSUITS.
And killing someone is a bit beyond being "a little overzealous in doing his duties" which, by the way ... WERE NOT HIS DUTIES!
Zimmerman is/was NOT a neighborhood watchman ...
Huh ?
And killing someone is a bit beyond being "a little overzealous in doing his duties" which, by the way ... WERE NOT HIS DUTIES!
He has a duty to protect himself if he is being attacked . That comes under the laws for self defense .
OK , If you're gonna' change your comment , I'm changing mine too :
There is no question that G Z was the official neighborhood watchman . If he was a little overzealous in his duties and even if he did not follow protocol [which may not even apply in Florida] he was still the neighborhood watchman . You denying this is purest political spin .You left wingers are obsessed with finding racism .
Any more platitudes from your storehouse of forensic expertise?
If a police department made as many mistakes regarding a matter involving a family member of yours ... you'd be pleading with the Justice Department to come and have fun.
The Mayor of Sanford made the police department release the video ... he did not want the city to be seen as hiding information ...
You mean you didn't know that Zimmerman is not a neighborhood watchman?
You're playing with words ... initially you (mis)identified Zimmerman as a watchman doing his duties ... now you're pretending you meant those terms generically.
I don't know how to break this to you ... that's pretty much the SYG law!
"You're playing with words ... initially you (mis)identified Zimmerman as a watchman doing his duties ... now you're pretending you meant those terms generically."
You can say that G Z was not the watchman till the cows come home . But he was . All the fancy footwork you have done above is meaningless .
He has a duty to protect himself if he is being attacked . That comes under the laws for self defense .
I don't know how to break this to you ... that's pretty much the SYG law!
I told you before that you are going to have to prove that GZ was not attacked in order to declare SYG applies .
But you continue to ignore me . Now I'm telling you to remove all references to SYG in the above comment .
If you don't I'm going to insist on a deletion . What's it gonna' be ?
And I told you about "burden of proof."
Delete if you want ... I'll dispute it if you do.
I will not remove the references. They're germane to the discussion.
Your decision.
I told you what my rules are for this thread :
1] refute my article in a substantial way if you want to proceed to discuss the SYG issue . If you can't do that then
stop putting SYG distractions in my thread .
" And stop with the "try reading" your article stuff; just because someone doesn't agree with it doesn't mean they haven't read it. "
That did it . Get off my thread now . No more comments from you . Also remove or edit the comments concerning
SYG arguments .
For the record:
...
Rich,
You are entitled to tell me to leave your thread ... and I will ... but I will not remove or edit my comments.
And if you remove my comments I will take that to mean you don't want anyone to scrutinize what led you to boot me.
Robert wrote,
I left this thread at Rich's request ... SO YOU DON'T GET TO TAKE FREE SHOTS AT ME! Again, I'm leaving ... and will not comment unless you take another shot.
Back off!
" SYG provides that "self defense" is an affirmative defense requiring the state to provide probable cause that the force used was unlawful prior to any arrest. Therefore, by invoking self-defense, Zimmerman implicitly invoked SYG. "
Your description is simply incorrect . You are starting out this long and detailed comment with an error whether purposefully misleading or not . In other comments on this thread there has been a distinction made between self defense and SYG . In fact the SYG defense implies that the threatened party is not required to retreat from danger even if that option is available . But in the more restrictive situation in which the retreating option is not available [such as what Zimmerman claimed] then self defense is the defense which would apply . SYG could NOT be used in that situation .
As to the conflicting witness descriptions those are pretty much standard in police work .
A Mac ,
I'm 100 % in agreement with your statement that others do not get free shots at you after you leave the thread . I'm going to search now for the comment you are complaining about .
Thanks Rich ...
No hard feelings.
Peace.
OK Mac ,
I found the comment you were referring to . You were not the subject of that comment . You are acting irrationally or else you are purposely skirting the CoC rules . You are out my thread . Stay there . If you take issue with this do NOT comment in this thread . Contact me via chat or email if you want to get into this issue .
Iarn ,
" Wow. I was completely unaware that Stand Your Ground only applies in situations where someone is NOT being attacked. Do you bother reading your own comments before you post them? Maybe you ought to hire an editor. "
Your comment is both snarky and wrong . If you want to get into a discussion of SYG start your own . I'm not going to prolong this distraction to the main thread . You are clearly trying to provoke me into this distraction . Do not do it again . This is your final warning .
There is an additional factor at play here . I detailed it in my article . It was the hypersensitivity to young black males since they were implicated in several robberies in that neighborhood . It is not racism because it is focused on preventing robberies and on profiling potential robbers .
MY NAME WAS MENTIONED IN THE COMMENT ... then referred to as ...
Acting irrationally am I? Purposely skirting the Coc rules too.
Contact you via chat or email when my name comes up in a negative light in your thread ... nah ...
Tell you what I may do instead ...
If you will not allow my dissenting views because of your arbitrary decision that certain related facts don't concur with "the point of your article," I'll write my own article specifically critiquing yours. My article will be specific, detailed and accurate.
Had I actually derailed your thread, you'd have a justifiable position; but my raising the issue of a law that has everything to do with the Trayvon Martin case is hardly derailing. Still, I backed away ...
So you decide; allow me to comment in the specific manner I always do ... backing my positions with detailed information, or, censor me by banning and deletions.
I tried to honor your request and only returned when mentioned as a kind of bad example ...
Bad moderation, Rich.
Your choice now.
iarn ,
Thanks for your over the top way of disagreeing . I am not going to respond in kind . However I will point out how you are suffering from selective literacy . And that reflects a temporarily non-functioning brain [although I haven't said odious ] .
1. My description was "the appearance of possible wrongdoing" . I did not say that the appearance was an accurate reflection of reality . I think it wasn't . But I am saying that GZ was responding to certain possibly misleading appearances and that is what triggered these events . I really don't care whether you agree or not . Your over the top opinions have no affect .
" The cause of "suspicion" on Zimmerman's part was, without a doubt, Zimmerman's own zeal to play cop. "
Your explanation assumes a rather mystical ability on your part to know what was in the mind of GZ . Saying it was
"without a doubt" is presumptuous on a level that could even be called odious . The extenuating circumstances
were those I outlined in my article . There were prior robberies commited by young black males . It is not surprising , under those circumstances that GZ was hypersensitive to the appearance of unknown young black males . The word for that is profiling . It is a dangerous practice but is is understandable .
2. I addressed all of that in the above response to 1.
3. " he followed Martin despite being told not to by the police operator. "
Actually there was no such order . The words were something to the effect that such an action was uneccessary .
4. " Second, of the millions of unarmed altercations which take place daily on this planet, few result in the death of one of the two participants. "
That's nice . I guess the people who are maimed for life from such encounters is irrelevant . And you are not even considering other arms besides guns . How about knives ? How about hammers ? Actually there was a recent incident in Sanford , Fl. in which 2 young black males attacked a 50 yr old white man with a hammer . He is still in a coma . But who cares . That would never happen to anyone you know ...
5 and 6 . It is my opinion and it is still my opinion after your odious non-rebuttal .
" Well, no-- most of your article is about providing cover for Zimmerman having shot Martin, not about why police didn't make an arrest. Your argument for that comprises a whole three sentences near the end of the article. "
More selective literacy . Your brain does not seem to be functioning particularly well today . You can read words and interpret them any way you choose apparently or in this case filter out the ones which go against the case you are desperately trying to make .
Mac ,
Although you are technically correct about bringing up your name when you are not here , I don't see that comment by Robert as being either inaccurate or inflammatory . Do you ? Nevertheless I will warn Robert from bringing up you as a topic .
As to writing your own article , that would be for the best . The issues you are attempting to bring up are points of law which may or may not apply . If you want to get into that in your own article then I would be willing to come there to discuss it . If not , this is a good time to let me know .
Robert ,
Sorry about this but even though you used a non-inflammatory tone , discussing Mac in any way when he is not here is expressly forbidden by the CoC .
Rich,
I don't know what I'm going to do. If I post the article, you'll know as it will appear on the Front Page as a headline and in the forum as the article in full.
The issues I broached are inseparable from any discussion regarding the Zimmerman/Martin case ...
As for Robert's comment, he both referred to me by name and, in the same comment conflated his assessment with what I did on your column with bad behavior on Newsvine ... and you then placed me in the position of not being able to defend myself in the very forum in which I was named, etc. .
My bottom line is the future of this site ... if this conversation goes on either here or in a separate article, there will be more bad feelings ... I don't think it's worth the potential acrimony.
So, with that in mind, I will back away from this.
Iar ,
I have been instructed to inform members making comments to not discuss Mac's participation . I already informed Robert , now I'm telling you . Do not discuss someone who is not allowed on the article .
Mac ,
I'm sorry things got out of hand this much . If I've been heavy handed here I apologize . I will respect your decision no matter how you decide to handle things .
I am closing this article to further comments. Oddly enough, the events in this article seem to mimic the events being discussed. If Rich had not been heavy handed in his moderation, then Robert wouldn't have played moderator, and Iar wouldn't have made inflammatory remarks to Rich in defense of Mac. I would like to thank Rich, for his last comment as he did recognize that he was being heavy handed in his moderation, but at this point, without me making heavy moderation, which would result in nothing good coming from it, this article will officially be closed.