╌>

Corruption in the Supreme Court: Scalia and Thomas dine with healthcare law challengers as court hears case

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  14 years ago  •  33 comments

Corruption in the Supreme Court: Scalia and Thomas dine with healthcare law challengers as court hears case

This is beyond belief. SCOTUS is supposed tooperateon principle of the law, but apparently, SCOTUS is exempt from the laws that govern the lower Federal judges and so we don't get real justice from SCOTUS, we get cronyism. People should demand that that theConstitutionshould beamended so that SCOTUS should be bound by the same rules and ethics as the lower Federal courts. As for Scalia and Thomas, if they werehonorablemen (and apparently they are not) they should recuse themselves from this case, which of course they won't, since that is why they attend these dinners. This is an outrage! I don't care where you stand on healthcare. This is about SCOTUSoperatingin an ethical manner, whichapparentlyit is not. (Please note, that this event happened in November of 2011)

From the LA Times:

The day the Supreme Court gathered behind closed doors to consider the politically divisive question of whether it would hear a challenge to President Obamas healthcare law, two of its justices, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas, were feted at a dinner sponsored by the law firm that will argue the case before the high court.

Clements law firm, Bancroft PLLC, was one of almost two dozen firms that helped sponsor the annual dinner of the Federalist Society, a longstanding group dedicated to advocating conservative legal principles. Another firm that sponsored the dinner, Jones Day, represents one of the trade associations that challenged the law, the National Federation of Independent Business.

Another sponsor was pharmaceutical giant Pfizer Inc, which has an enormous financial stake in the outcome of the litigation. The dinner was held at a Washington hotel hours after the court's conference over the case. In attendance was, among others, Mitch McConnell, the Senates top Republican and an avowed opponent of the healthcare law.

This stunning breach of ethics and indifference to the code belies claims by several justices that the court abides by the same rules that apply to all other federal judges, said Bob Edgar, the president of Common Cause. The justices were wining and dining at a black-tie fundraiser with attorneys who have pending cases before the court. Their appearance and assistance in fundraising for this event undercuts any claims of impartiality, and is unacceptable.

Scalia and Thomas have shown little regard for critics who say they too readily mix the business of the court with agenda-driven groups such as the Federalist Society. And Thomas wife, Ginni, is a high-profile conservative activist.

http://articles.latimes.com/2011/nov/14/news/la-pn-scalia-thomas-20111114



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I was outraged when I heard that Clarence Thomas heard theMonsantocase, since he had been legal council for Monsanto. Judge Breyer, had the decency to recuse himself, since he had ties to Monstanto, but not Thomas.But this is beyond the pale. Hearing a case while dining with with people who have a specific agenda, should be against ethics. Our court has become a joke.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I agree about Scalia and Thomas. They are totally unethical. I don't think that Thomas is a self-hating black man, just one without scruples.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

There are mostdefinitelyethical judges on the court. I agree with you about Roberts. He is a very honorable man. And this isn't about their decisions, this is about their behavior. These men and woman should behave all the time as an example to all other judges. Instead, they are a disgrace.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

But wait ... there's more ...

HYPOCRITE? We'll see.

California voters passed Proposition 215 in 1996, legalizing the medical use of marijuana . The United States Federal Government has limited the use of marijuana since the 1937 Marijuana Tax Act came into effect. Defendant Angel Raich used homegrown medical marijuana, which was legal under California law, but illegal under federal law.

In a separate concurrence to Raich 's majority decision -- which held that Congress could criminalize the production of homegrown marijuana even in states that approved of its medical use -- Scalia made what is widely regarded as one of the Court's broadest interpretations of Congress' ability to regulate commerce. Not only did the legislative branch have the "power to regulate activities that have a substantial effect on interstate commerce," he wrote; it had the power to extend itself into "those measures necessary to make the interstate regulation effective."

Scalia's opinion

Justice Scalia wrote a separate concurrence that had the effect of differentiating the decision from the previous results of United States v. Lopez and United States v. Morrison . Although Scalia voted in favor of limits on the Commerce Clause in the Lopez and Morrison decisions, he said that his understanding of the Necessary and Proper Clause caused him to vote for the Commerce Clause with Raich for the following reason:

Unlike the power to regulate activities that have a substantial effect on interstate commerce, the power to enact laws enabling effective regulation of interstate commerce can only be exercised in conjunction with congressional regulation of an interstate market, and it extends only to those measures necessary to make the interstate regulation effective. As Lopez itself states, and the Court affirms today, Congress may regulate noneconomic intrastate activities only where the failure to do so could undercut its regulation of interstate commerce. ... This is not a power that threatens to obliterate the line between what is truly national and what is truly local. [ 8 ]
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Gee, why am I not surprised.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

From which case and why? Was there an impropriety?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

What we are talking about is a pending issue.

And why should the SCOTUS judges be exempt from the same ethics as all other Federal judges? That is the real issue.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Tina,

I think you misunderstand me. I have as big of a problem Kagen doing what she did, as I do withScalia and Thomas attending that dinner,while the lot of them are on the bench. It is a breach of ethics in any other Federal court and especially, it shouldn't be allowed by SCOTUS. I was just as unaware of Kagen doing that, as I was about this. I just fell onto this article by accident, while looking up information from the movie "Food Inc"

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

No matter how you slice this, it is animproprietythat isn't allowed by any other Federal court. it should go without saying that it should be avoided by our most important court, the law of the land.

And as I pointed out to Tina, I am no more happy over Kagen's improper behavior then I am by Thomas and Scalia. I just hadn't heard about Kagen's misbehavior until Tina told me and fell upon this one by accident, while researching a food article, hence the reason I gave full disclosure about the date.

The Supreme court of this land, should have it's justices acting better not worse then the federal judges they rule on. It should be as simple as that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Furthermore, the "enhanced" title of this seeded piece as to "Corruption" is inaccurate.

I beg to differ with you. When you attend a dinner by people who are against a law that you are going to be listeningargumentsabout that law, you are breaching ethics and that is corruption. And the same goes with Kagen. This is clearly not allowed by Federal judges, something you want to ignore, but is not ignorable.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Importance of Avoiding Impropriety

  • Impropriety is any inappropriate behavior on the part of a judge, especially behavior that tarnishes his reputation or interferes with his ability to be impartial.

  • Avoiding impropriety has primary importance in the judicial code of ethics because i mproper behavior by a judge calls the integrity of the entire judicial system he works for into question , according to the West Virginia Code of Judicial Conduct.

  • Most judicial codes of ethics require judges to avoid even the appearance of impropriety. For example, a judge who joins a private club that is racist or homophobic may appear to be biased even though he only attends meetings during nonworking hours. Thus, he should resign his membership from such a club upon becoming a judge regardless of his reasons for joining.

Impartiality Requirement

  • Judges must remain impartial to preserve integrity in the judicial system. If a judge cannot remain impartial, that is, if she has strong feelings about an issue or knows a litigant or defendant personally, the judicial code of ethics requires her to recuse, or disqualify, herself from the case and ask the court to assign it to a different judge. Judges must treat all persons who come through their courtroom in the same courteous manner and make decisions based upon laws rather than personal feelings.

Enforcement

  • The judicial system requires judges to aid in enforcement of the judicial code of ethics. Without enforcement, the code becomes a set of guidelines rather than a set of rules, resulting in judges and lawyers being free to engage in unscrupulous behavior without consequence. Thus, if a judge witnesses improper behavior from another judge or a lawyer, he is required to take action. Action does not necessarily mean reporting the improper behavior to the American Bar Association or other governing body, although judges may do so if the situation requires it. In many cases, judges can resolve misconduct by speaking to the involved parties or by using judicial procedures such as declaring a mistrial due to unethical behavior by a lawyer. If a judge does report an officer of the court for misconduct, her communications regarding the matter are privileged, and involved parties may not sue her over this issue.

NOTE: It is my understanding that the Code per se does not apply to the Supreme Court justices; but this does not exempt them from the tenets and spirit of the Code.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

I don't like what you are implying. No I didn't google "apple pie" and so thealgorithmdidn't spit back SCOTUS. I was googling that in the movie "Food Inc" and it's claim that and that Thomas, who had worked for Monsanto, ruled on the Monsanto case, which was deemed animpropriety and in which judge Breyer, who also had connections to Monsanto, recused himself. The google search was "Monsanto SCOTUSimproprieties" and this article popped up. Go ahead and try it. It was also discussed on D'Wayne's food article.

Even as it MIGHT come down to "question of impropriety," steadfast is the need to see corruption as the only possible reason that a Justice could find any Constitutional problems which might signal opposition to Obama's Healthcare plan.

You just don't get it or want to get it. I am sick of this court in general. It is a partisan court, which does not serve the people, but the parties that put them in there. This has NOTHING to do with Obama's health care, despite your claims otherwise. If anything is going on here, is that you have made your decisions about where I stand on these issues and that is your spring board to your conclusions.

Further unable to analyze the actual as it yields a result in opposition to the preferred theoretical, "should Justices follow rules of conduct that other judges must follow, where rampantly bigoted political hacks might otherwise find opportunities to slander them?"

SCOTUS should follow the same code of ethics as any other Federal judge. As for your bigot comment, please point to where I said one. You know that I didn't. You also know, when I was presented with Kagen'simproprietiesthat I had the sameopinionof them. But hey, let's muddy the waters with allegations that are not true, as to take the focus off of the real problem. Slander? How ironic, since you just implied that I am a bigot, based on nada. I gave anopinion, based on an event. To slander him would be to call him a name, which I didn't, but I questioned his ethics, which I do. IMHO our most of our justices have no scruples, by their own actions.

*sigh*

Robert, I know that you would like topigeonhole me, but it does get tiresome.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

See Mike, you get it! SCOTUS no longer serves the people, it serves the parties who put them in there.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

You know the answer to your question already. They must serve the law of the land. Usually it works out. But we also know the reality that often it doesn't.

SCOTUS serves the people by upholding theConstitution. But since that paper is subject tointerpretation by those we place in thepositionofinterpretingit, it is just as subject to being corrupted by partisanship as any other part of government.

When people vote in an election, they are well aware that the man the name POTUS has with them the power of the balance of the court. I am not a historian of the court, so I will not pretend that I know if in the past (meaning over 100 years ago), before mass media, if the people appointed to the court were as partisan as they are now. This is what disturbs me. When they serve the people who installed them, then they don't serve the best interest of the constitution.

You picking through my words to prove myperceivedpartisanship is nothing new to independents. Randyperceivesme the opposite way.

Now puzzle me this. If I am sopartisan, why did I vote for Nader? Clue... utter disgust and no write ins in NY.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Oh, bullshit. Learn a bit before casting stones for criminy's sake. I tell you, lack of knowledge and jumping the gun is the worst threat to this Country we have.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Were you so shocked when Kagan refused to recuse herself on this case? Your "outrage" seems to be quite one sided, eh?

Do you even know what the hell the Federalist Society is?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Seems we have quite a bunch of folks who are themselves, closed minded and don't wish to look at facts!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Your response to Bruce's post shows just how biased your review of current events/issues are Perrie.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Oh, bullshit. Learn a bit before casting stones for criminy's sake.

Do learn me then ... inquiring minds want to know ... don't omit any specifics ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Let's be clear about the Federalist Society -- actually the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies

It touts itself as the seeker of reform of the current legal system in America ... but in reality sucks up to those "activist judges" it purports to disdain. And it's leanings are conservative and libertarian ... so then what "reform" is it looking for if not to advance some partisan agenda?

This bunch is looking for the original intent of the Constitution ... as long as it's not too far to the left.

Look at the founders of this group ...

The society was begun by a group including Edwin Meese , Robert Bork , Theodore Olson , David M. McIntosh , and Steven Calabresi , and its members have included Supreme Court justices Antonin Scalia , John G. Roberts , Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito .

Please don't tell me there's no conflict-of-interests nor any ideology ...

I'll listen to any thoughtful argument for a Kagan recusal ... but please, no one piss in my face and tell me 'it's raining!"

 
 
 
aRTieA
Freshman Silent
link   aRTieA    14 years ago

I expect very little from our government and they have yet to disappoint me.... Frown.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

You are mixing up two of my articles and making them into one. I wrote one on healthcare. It was general in it's content. As it applied to Obama's plan, I said that we already have in effect that protection for those with preexistingconditions, so why throw that baby out with the bath water.Separatearticle,separatetopic.

I lament about the partisan nature of the court in this article.

From that, I would guess that your idea of a functional court would respond directly to the people. The People who are here, now, and today.

No I don't. I expect them to uphold the law of the land which is the Constitution.But since that piece of paper is open tointerpretation, partisanship can play a role in how it isinterpreted. That is my answer to your question.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I have answered it directly. You asked who the court serves, and I said it serves to uphold the law of the land.

My view that the court is partisan is based on how I have seen 3 justices behaved. It is just my personal observation.

I am not vested into this particular health care law. I am vested in anoverhaulof the system. And it may interest you, that before thisbecamea law, I had an interesting conversation with Lisaed about it. I actually sat down and read nearly 100 pages of both the republican version and the democrats version of the bill. Now remember I was in the insurance industry. Both bills, were so vague and as soon as you thought you had an answer to one part of it, they would contradict it later. In other words, no one could make heads or tales of either bill. So, inactuality, I have no idea what the total effect of Obama's bill will be, and neither do you and probably 3/4 of the house and Senate. So if you feel that I fully support it, you would be mistaken.

At this point, I am not sure what you want me to say. I'm saying Impasse.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

How 'bout we stop f'n around with this Federalist Society elephant-in-the-room bullshit.

These are its founders and it's clear that this is a right-wing agenda front organization.

Edwin "Ed" Meese, III (born December 2, 1931) is an attorney, law professor, and author who served in official capacities within the Ronald Reagan Gubernatorial Administration (19671974), the Reagan Presidential Transition Team (1980), and the Reagan White House (19811985), eventually rising to hold the position of the 75th Attorney General of the United States (19851988). He currently holds fellowships and chairmanships with several public policy councils and think tanks, including the Constitution Project and The Heritage Foundation. He is also a Distinguished Visiting Fellow with the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.

Robert Bork (born March 1, 1927) is an American legal scholar who has advocated the judicial philosophy of originalism. Bork formerly served as a Yale Law School professor, Solicitor General, Acting Attorney General, and judge for the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. In 1987, he was nominated to the Supreme Court by President Ronald Reagan, but the Senate rejected his nomination.

Theodore Olson (born September 11, 1940) is an American lawyer, practicing at the Washington, D.C. office of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher. Olson served as United States Solicitor General from June 2001 to July 2004 under President George W. Bush.


David M. McIntosh (born June 8, 1958) is a lawyer who served as a Republican representative from Indiana from January 3, 1995, to January 3, 2001. McIntosh was the Republican candidate for Governor of Indiana in 2000, losing to incumbent Democrat Frank O'Bannon. He is currently a candidate in Indiana's 5th Congressional district, running to replace Rep. Dan Burton.

Steven Calabresi - served under Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H. W. Bush from 1985 to 1990. During that time, he advised Attorney General Edwin Meese III, Reagan Domestic Policy Chief T. Kenneth Cribb and wrote speeches for Bush Vice President Dan Quayle. Calabresi supported former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani in the 2008 presidential election.

When I present telling FACTUAL INFORMATION that makes a case, I resent that some just drone on as if the information did not exist.

The Federalist Society is right-wing regardless of how it sells itself, and Supreme Court Justices who wallow in the pool with its ideologues, are ever suspect for conflict-of-interests when some right-wing crap like Citizens United "money is speech" and/or Obamacare come before them.

... not to mention when one of their wives lobbies against Obamacare for a Tea Party group!


 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Even if you think it would be better if Justices joined the Communist Party after confirmation,

Don't put words in my mouth and create straw men because you have no viable rebuttal.

I don't know who said there should be no "ideology." "Democracy" is an ideology.

Actually, YOU said it because you have no case.

Judges are expected to avoid even the APPEARANCE OF IMPROPRIETY because it erodes the credibility of and the faith in the judicial system.

Anything that yields "they're partisan, but we're not" should cause a bit of a smirk.

Again ... those are your words not mine. Deal with the facts and address them.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The authors quote Reid as saying privately that Obama, as a black candidate, could be successful thanks, in part, to his "light-skinned" appearance and speaking patterns "with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one."

It's true ... it was a stupid thing to say ... I agree ...

But it was spawned from the realities of the ignorant, bigoted, racist morons who wouldn't vote for any minority candidate with the remote possible exception of one that wasn't too black!

How many assholes castigated CHRISTIAN minister Jeremiah Wright for his dumb-ass comment, tied Obama to him ...

... THEN TURNED AROUND AND SAID OBAMA WAS A MUSLIM!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Bruce,

I am going to agree with that post 100%. I am justdisgusted.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Spot on Artie!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Bruce,

I suppose I could fish side-by-side with someone who believes ...

Political Sodom and Gomorrah IS Washington DC.

But I get to fish off the port side.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Perrie, I pretty much assume "impasse" from the first word. I just keep tapping the bulb to see if it is out, or if there is a power outage.

Oh, the light works as does the power... you're just lost in the dark and having a hard time finding the switch.

The question(s) were...

Let me ask you something. If the SC takes a case involving a man molesting a child.... The man is a repeat offender. The SC frees the man who was found guilty, where a coerced confession was a substantial part of the case presented in the trial.

Answer: The court woulsn't take such cases. There is a long standingprecedentfor coerced confessions by the court The rest of your question is therefore moot. But I'll play along with your silly game.

Are the people served?

Should the court have considered the impact on a real victim? IE, The child?

If you agree with the decision; Why?

There is noting here to discuss. The courts sole purpose is to uphold the Constitution, even if there is unforeseen fall out, as in your case. But the court is also bound to makedecisionsnot on partisanship and in that way, it serves the people.

Now I have a question for you.Why do you constantly try to prove that I am not an independent? If I was a democrat/liberal, which obviously you think I am, why would I not be a member of that party? It would allow me to vote in primaries, which I can't. Whatbizarrepurpose does it serve to pretend that I am something that that I am not? I doubt you have the answer, since it serves none.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Evidently not, since Scalia was a member before he joined the Court, and at the time, Federalist Society was not illegal.

That's irrelevant ... once being approved as a Justice, if past associations/memberships continue, in going forward, if those associations represent even the possibility of a conflict-of-interests ... that constitutes the appearance of impropriety.

And again ... who said anything about "illegal"? Other than yourself. And making a ridiculous argument to mock a legitimate one discredits you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Partisan to me is blind devotion to ones party and party principles. To uphold those party principles despite the will of those who are not part of that party. In the US, there's about 40% of Americans self identify asindependents/ or moderates/ or swing voters, and we are sick of partisan politics.

I am probably right of you, when it comes to international policy. Does that make me a conservative. No.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I have to agree with Perrie!

She is definitely NOT a Conservative!

;~)

But come on Mike... I know you find it sexy that I love the idea of bombing Iran's nuclear sites till kingdom come... come on admit it!5.gif

 
 

Who is online