Healthcare From A Common Sense Perspective.
As I watch and read about the hearings of SCOTUS, I am conflicted in my feelings. I didn't think that the mandate that all Americans to have to pay into the healthcare system would stand constitutionally. But on the other hand, gutting it totally is a crime.
After I left accounting, I worked for 3 years at Prudential-Bache, and I became friends with many of theactuariesthere.They respected me because I was one of the few reps who had a background in accounting and economics, and so they explained how they got their price points. Among thecalculationsfor health insurance was risk,litigation, the cost of drugs andhospitalization, commissions to the repsand of course profit. Let me put it this way, there was plenty of profit put into those calculations, but hey, it's a business, a fact that no one should lose site of.
I also have friends and family who are doctors. Most of them feel that health care in this country stinks. They point to tort reform and question if health insurance should be a business at all.
It was during my tenure at Prudential that I first became ill. It was 1985, and little was known about my condition. A very large mass was removed from the back of my neck. I was told that I had Kikuchi's disease, a very rare disease that usually only struck Japanese woman. They told me that it was cured when they removed the tumor. I was relieved. Three years later, a second mass appeared on the opposite side, with the samediagnosis. I had theprivilegeof being one of three people in the world to have had the tumor return.
During both times that I had a growth, I had group health insurance, and therefore, coverage. But as the years passed, we all came to the conclusion that the doctors were limited in their knowledge of my true disease, since the tumors kept coming along with other health issues. During my frequent visits to Memorial Sloan-Kettering my doctors began to see changes in these growths. It concerned them that one of these tumors could go cancerous. There I met many people from all walks of life. Most wanted to talk about their personal experiences. Many told me that their personal health coverage was dropped because of their cancer, or that their premiums had become almost impossible to pay. Many who did have group life, found that they had maxed out their coverage and were now either paying huge amounts to the hospital, or negotiating with Sloan over payments. One lady, a teacher, was fighting with Sloan, as the hospital was going after her home to pay for her treatment.Imaginethe stress of going through chemo and having to worry about if you will lose your home!
During that time, my husband lost his job. In one of the greatest ironies of unemployment, we were faced with either paying over $3000 a month to keep our group life insurance through COBRA, when we could least afford it, or chance it, drop the insurance, and hope I didn't get another tumor, before my husband found a job. We are frugal people and had savings, and not wanting to take the chance that things would go south with me or my children, we decided to pay the COBRA, which ended up costing us over $33,000 until my husband found another job. My husband and I were lucky that he made a very good living and could save money. Most other families' finances would have prevented them from paying the COBRA for insurance coverage.
As the years passed, andneurologicaldysfunctions appeared, I found myself at Columbia Presbyterian, which has one of the best neurological centers in the world. There, I got my truediagnosis. I have a genetic disease that I might have passed on to my children. To get the exact coding of my disease would require me taking a very specific genetic test, one my doctors cautioned me about. If the test proved positive I would be endangering mychildrengetting coverage as adults, since in this computer age, it would be an easy thing for insurance companies to find out. I decided, for their sake, to forego the test.
The reason I explained in such detail what I personally went through, was to point out the shortcomings of our present system. The fact that health insurance is a business makes people have to make desperate choices. From the fact that drug companies will not produce life saving chemotherapy because there is no profit in it, to having people make choices about whether or not they can afford insurance, to having to forego medical tests because of fear of the fallout from such tests, proves that our system is flawed. We have no protection from insurance companies for preexistingconditions, excessivepremiums, and denial of life saving tests. They make you jump through hoops to get reimbursements for claims, and try every trick in the book not to pay you. How can this be right?
So as I read what some of our Chief Justices say about President Obama's plan, I have to wonder when was the last time they lived in the real world. Yes, maybe there are flaws in theplan, but there are also many good things in it, like protection for those with preexistingconditions.So why the rush to throw the baby out with the bathwater? Have our justices become aspartisanas our nation? I guess we will find out in the days to come.

I would like to thank Doctor Taubman for a very enlightening conversation on this subject, that inspired me to write this.
Merely because there are good things in the plan, doesn't mean it's Constitutional Perrie.
You are, unfortunately, emotionalizing the issue when the Constitutionality of it shouldn't be emotionalized!
Tell you what, if you wish for it to be Constitutional, the change the Constitution.
Otherwise, this precedent will be used ad infinitum for every other type of government requirement, many of which you might NOT agree with, or feel personal emotion over.
That is the issue SCOTUS must deal with, what comes NEXT, which was the main thrust of their questions.
Having said that, I will say, this entire discussion has been extremely beneficial for this nation as it has exposed both the strengths and weaknesses of our health plan and that of other countries!
Take Sweden, nationalized health care, woman calls 911. The call is routed to nurses who are supposed to make the decision whether the issue is severe enough to warrant an ambulance. They say no. Woman dies. When forced to explain, it turns out they refused the request for ambulance because she was able to still talk.(no kidding)
That's nationalized health care. And no recompense, no ability to sue, as it's nationalized (and we wouldn't either under nationalized health care as it would be suing the sovereign).
We can have better, and deserve better. What Obamacare provides for is not better.
That is the way that most of Europe does it.
I addressed that in the opening Terry:
And pointing to this singular case is fear mongering. This doesn't go on in most other western countries, nor am I advocating for a national health system,specifically. What I am saying is that our current system is as flawed as the system you fear. While Sweden has nurses making life and death decisions, we have families that have to decide whether or not they can afford to take their kid to the doctor. The fact that I have had such a personal perspective on our current system, doesn'tnecessarilymean that I am making it emotional. It just means that I have had first hand experience with the system.
The justices were split on this... whether to keep parts and loose others. I think that the parts that have been already enacted should be kept. They are here and they are working. Why get rid of something that we know works?
The rest could go back to congress, if the court sodecided.
I totally agree John. Health insurance should not be for profit. Many doctors agree with this. With insurance companies calling the shots, their hands are tied when it comes to care.
You're right, math isn't partisan.
The "goodies" that I am referring to, are already in effect, and being paid for.
Who says? Where did you get this information from?
Tina,
I am not sure where you got your figures from on health care but here they are for 2010:
Good article.I oppose forced payments into the health system but I agree we need a system that provides basic health care for all.
NYS does have a health plans. It's something more than most states have.
As for wealth, it's all downstate, which is the smallest part of the stategeographically. Most of the state is upstate, and they are among our poorest, relying on farming and seasonal business, such as skiing. Downstate, many people have group health, but the inner city must rely on either medicaid or the above programs, and the kindness of the Catholic/Jewish hospital systems.
Sorry, I missed this comment.
I don't speak for New York. I speak for myself. And no where did I say that thisparticularplan was wonderful, just that the parts we have already, like that you can't be dropped forpreexistingconditions.
As for New York, read my comment below.
I was referring to insurance for profit. Doctors go to school for 8 years and then a residency and should be compensated. Hospital costs are out of control. A $.25 Advil shouldn't cost over $25. Sorry. No excuses.
Thanks Red!
I am with you. NYS kind of has it right. They offer a plan that has families pay a small amount for a dr visit, which means that people are taking personal responsibility without going broke. That and other reforms could make for ausablehealthcare plan.
Show me the cash flow statement. Nothing else matters. I was a controller for 35 years. I can make a company show a profit or loss anytime I want, and all within the pervue of GAAP. Cash flow is the only thing that matters.
LOL! Isn't that known as Cost Accounting aka Creative Accounting? I spent 3 year of my life defending people from the IRS from guys like you ( only kidding). But of course, no one see those, but you and the board. I can only present what the companies want to show.
Why do we have SS and medicare and medicaid? These are government programs.
And what makes NY a wealthy state? As far as I know, we are broke. Right nowGov.Cuomo is trying to balance our budget.
Because issues like being protected for havingpreexistingconditions should be nation wide. And I don't whine, but I do drink.
Cost accounting is a part of the managerial world. It isn't one of the statements that gets published for "public" companies. A lot of insurance companies are not "public" entities however.
As for the IRS, you are guilty until proven innocent. I have only been audited by the IRS one time, and then they did not question the "grey" areas and actually ruled to refund more money, which didn't matter really except as to keep the loss carry forward going.
Oh Steve, I know. I think we are both fluent in accountantese.
That was before the kinder gentler IRS. Now you are guilty until proven innocent.... urrrr... ummmmm... where did I just hear that?
You're killing me Steve. I'm crying I'm laughing so much! I was audited once, too, when I worked for Pru and I had a ton of business expenses. When the the IRS auditor came up to my chin, I was worried. When he announced "Boy, your a tall one (I'm 5'7"), I knew that it was going to run long. On day 4, when his supervisor came in and found that all he had on me was $64, he yelled at him to cut me loose ( notice the correct usage of the word), and apologized to me for the unnecessary experience. I had to wonder... how much money did the IRS lose (again, proper useage) on me. I gladly paid the $64 bucks and walked away with a smile.
I don't mean to be preachy, (but I am peachy keen). I only know you live in a place I really like. Perhaps someday we will be able to sit down together and talk, say Seattle. I've never been to the NW.
Did I say something wrong? I am unclear to your response.
No, you didn't say anything wrong. I am just never sure who really knows what on-line, and I haven't followed you enough yet to know what you know, or think about subjects. I thought maybe I was being too preachy about the accounting thing.
No. Not at all. As for not knowing me... hopefully, you'll get to know me better.
No. I used to sell a lot of health insurance from The Hartford, which is in Conn.
First cup of Coffee, and my head isn't quite in the game yet..
I hope you don't mind, but I am going to jump around the two posts.
LOL Tina, when I said full disclosure, I just meant that part of your job was cost management... right? I wouldn't want to work for an HMO for the reasons you didn't
First, I checked the first five companies on that list, and they all offer PPO's and PPS's so they are not all HMO's. As a matter of fact, United Health Care was our provider until last year, and we always pay extra to get the PPO.
Which is a huge if. First, it would require the drug store to have a doctor there, since they are the only ones who are qualified to do the quick test and the culture, andprescribe a med and that just isn't going to happen. There is no money in it for the doctors and the AMA isn't going to allow pharmaciststo do it either. And right now, if unless you are talking about medicaid or medicare, no one is on any tit right now, and I don't see either going away in the near future.
I don't, since I havevolunteeredmy accounting services at both Long Island Catholic Charities and Long Island Jewish Hospital, and I am very aware, that there is a limit to what they can provide. Both need huge benefactors and endowments, and these dry up eventually for various reasons.
How do you figure that? Right now, it's the middle class that is struggling with health insurance costs. The poor are getting some of it met by medicaid, but the middle class gets nada. Right now, a self employed contractor with a family of 4 must pay monthly over $3000 a month for health insurance in NY. That means over $30,000 a year. It's health insurance that is killing the middle class already.
First I will only address the above post, since it isn'tcondescending like the bottom one is.
First, no where in this discussion did I say that I thought that Obama's plan was the way to go, so please let's stop discussing that. What I said is that we need to reform healthcare, which my mean laws like tort restrictions, or making it a not for profit operation, like an bad drivers auto pool and yes, you can't be dropped forpreexistingconditions. I am a CPA and I agree that you shouldn't spend money that you don't have. Yet our government has found money, as you pointed out, to supportforeigncountries, many of which are not our friends, and other such sundries like that. Like everything else, we need to evaluate our cost/benefit and in most of these cases, there is none and this is money we could be spending at home.
As for NYS, thegovernoris trying to balance our budget. The main cause of that is union contracts. There are going to be cut backs. It isn't our insurance program that has us in the red, which he has no intent on cutting.
Then the jump to schools in Mississippi. Of course I would like them to have better schools. Hey, they can! I pay about $16,000 a year in school taxes to get my kids the education they have. I chose to do that by moving to a town where I knew that I was going to pay that, to get that education. The state pays gives our town the same small amount that it gives every other town in NYS, which isn't enough to run a bad district. So if folks in Mississippi want a better education, they better be willing to pay for it. Does that put them at a disadvantage... of course it does. But as you pointed out, ourgovernmentcan't do it all. So while we are picking and choosing what is important to life, I'm going with healthcare and healthcare reform, since that can mean life or death.
I'm going to end this with a singular point. There are noatheistsin foxholes. I don't know your economic status. I don't know if your married or have kids. But most of all, I doubt you or a loved one have ever been truly ill without recourse, or we wouldn't be having this discussion. I have never met a person at Sloan-Kettering, be it rich or poor, that feel any different than I do.
Robert,
Instead of making snarky remarks, counter me. If I am wrong, tell me. And in my post, I said:
Which implies it's not unique to me. I mean what is it that you think we do as we sit around waiting to see the doctor, other than share war stories.
That is whatpoliticianson both sides of the political fence think, as they get their full pensions, and full medical coverage, and go on to lucrative businesses in the private sector when they get sick of all the perks they get.
We keep talking about Obama's plan, when this article wasn't about Obama's plan, it was about a plan. The short comings of this system. A few good parts of Obama's plan that should be kept. But the bottom line, is that middle class gets screwed one way or the other. NYS program has worked well for us. It makes the those who need care and want care, still responsible for themselves, without blinding them with cost. That is the direction we could go. And yes, the insurance industry needs regulations, no matter what. It is a for profit industry, in a field that needs to have compassion. If your doctor treated you the way your insurance company did, you would fire them.
Other than that, I think we have reached an impasse.