If You Repeat A Lie Long Enough, Does It Become The Truth?...The Sandra Fluke Story.
My husband and I got into this strange debate this evening. We were talking about the Sandra Flukecontroversy. You know the one that the Republican pundits and party members keep repeating... that Sandra Fluke presented herself as a 23 year old co-ed at Georgetown University. Just your average student who dared to step up to the mike and talk about being able to get the pill.... Then the shocker! She is not a wide eye 23 year old that she and the Democrats claimed she was... but a mole... a 30 year old fraud. A untold female activist... who pretended to be 23 to win over the hearts and minds of the weak minded. A sneaky Democratic plot with a secret agenda of first getting birth control pills available for all woman... and ultimately leading to the real Democratic goal... the big secret... FREE ABORTION!
If you look on the internet today, you see on every Conservative blog the same story. That Sandra Fluke had knowingly misrepresented herself. That she did this, as part of the Democrats grandstrategy, to emotionalize this issue. My husband and I searched in vain to find the orginal source for her saying that she was a 23 year old co-ed, because, I was convinced that I had read that, but my husband was more dubious.
Now I really hate to say this... it pains me in so many ways..but we found the truth. It pains me, because my husband was right (he said just do the math.. you can't be a third year law student and be 23) and it pains me because I found the source on "Little Green Footballs." I should have known if anyone would get to the bottom of a right wingconspiracy, it would be Charles Johnson, whosuccessfullyfound me... an right wing mole, posing as an Independent. Not that I am holding a grudge about him booting me from LGF... I just hate giving him any props. Turns out that she never represented herself as anything but a third year activist law student at George town. Here is the actual C SPAN coverage. No spin:
OK.. so right now I am eating humble pie. Apparently, I, a person who prides herself on doing her homework, was duped. Apparently, it must be true, that if you repeat a lie long enough and in enough places, it becomes fact.. or so it seems. Even I was taken in, and I do believe in contraception. Sandra Fluke's only "crime" was that she testified about something she felt passionate about, and that she couldn't state at an all male, GOP ran hearing. She didn't try todeceive, as conservatives would have usbelieve. She said who she was, never mentioned her age and clearly explained that she was an activist and what she was hoping her testimony wouldachieve. One has to wonder why the conservatives would gone to such an extent as toconcoctthis story about some sort of "nasty truth" about Sandra Fluke. Maybe it was because they wanted to defend their god Limbaugh...
Rush Limbaugh...A decent, well spoken kind gentleman, who was standing up for the American way. Hey, you heard it here first.
Now go out and repeat that a lot./sarc

I hate it when Matt is right... but it's only right that I own up when I am wrong...
How many others out there also got it wrong too, I wonder?
Robert,
This wasn't started by the democrats. The discrediting of Ms. Fluke was started by the Republicans. I have to agree with you, that it is a distraction from what the issue is, but hey, the Republicans started the distraction and not the other way around. I can provide dozens of links to show you, if you need them.
And ..."an all male, GOP ran hearing?"
You have your facts wrong. Ms. Fluke tried to participated at the all male GOP hearing and they wouldn't let her. It's on video. Would you like me to find it? And the hearing was not a head count of Democrats or Republicans, just supposed men some of the cloth, discussing contraception.
Robert,
You have extrapolated from my article that I am discussing the contraception debate. That was not my point. It was about the spin. It was about the misrepresentation of the facts.
I wholeheartilyagree that one who attends a CatholicUniversityshould be leery that they might not get contraception. But may I point you to this:
I have 2 college bound kids. Gerogetown was on our list. When you go to Gerogetown, they make it sound that not only are they friendly to all faiths and progressive in this belief, but that they will provide full health care to all their students. This is on their website. That is a misrepresentation on their behalf. I went through this with John. If you are not going to provide contraception, they should be clear, that the school will and will not provide, because of their religious beliefs. Of course they won't, since they would loose many students to other universities at $60,000 a year. If you want the link to Georgetown's medical policy, I can provide that, too.
John,
She never presented herself as anything but what she is. She stated to the democratic hearing that she IS anactivist. She told the Today show, that she chose that school, because she is an activist and wanted to have Catholic universities to change their policy. How is that a loss ofcredibility? She was honest about her intent all along.
As for who said that she was a 23 year old , the best that we (my hubby and I) could find, was a NYT article that talked aboutseveralwoman, on of which one was a 23 year old college student, but not Fluke, and the contraception debate. Here it is:
You're right! I have done a series of articles in the past about how it's becoming harder and harder to trust what we read. That is actually the point of this article, not the debate about contraception. It is about journalistic deception.
Those woman were not part of the hearing. I watched the hearing, and this is a clip of what I heard being said right from the start of the hearing.
The video that I have provided was just showing that Ms. Fluke didn't misrepresent herself. The issue of not having woman at the GOP hearing and the democrats having their own, is because right now, the democrats are the minority party. But since you seem to think that I am trying to misrepresent events, here it is in the press:
I totally agree, Randy.
Randy,
More than that, is how twisted ourjournalismhas become. Also, the internet is the wild, wild west. When something goes viral, it's everywhere. No matter what search terms we put into the computer, we couldn't find nonpartisansource material about the matter. But we kept finding onlypartisanmaterial.
Information is a wonderful thing but disinformation is a very dangerous thing. It takes a lot of time to get to the truth, and most people don't have the time or the inclination to do so.
I beg to differ. She sly like a fox.
She did, because she was informed and had an ax to grind. But as we discussed some time back, Gerogetown did misrepresent themselves when it comes to health care. Since this issue, they added this to their student healthcare site:
Which is only right. Now parents can be fully informed about their children's healthcare.
She is both.
John,
I actually watched that panel, with those two woman at the end, and when the panel started that video that I showed you, was said. If those woman were part of the meeting, why was it not said at the time?
Here is an article from the Huff about it
and another from The Nation:
As there being a second hearing, well I find that disingenuous. There should have been woman on the first panel. It was only after there was a big brouhaha, that there was a second hearing ( of which I can't find any reference to, so if you could, please provide one) Oddly enough, I saw those two woman at the end of the table at the first one, where there were complaints that there were no woman... so what's up with that?
Besides, John, I am not sure what your point is, in regard to my article. The article is about professional journalism.. not thecommitteeand not contraception.
I've actually have never been on the pill, so I had no idea how much it costs per month. This is what I found as advice from several sources:
Now I have been seeing quotes that you can get it for as little as $9 a month, which isn't so. $28.00 a month is not cheap to a college student.
Now personally, I have taught my daughters, who are not sexually active, that condoms are the way to go, since the pill doesn't offer STD protection... but that's just me. But your a guy, and you know how much a box of condoms are, and they are not cheap either.
And again, the point of my article, was not to rehash this issue, but the dangers of getting our information on the internet.
That is true, but it is not spin. It is theatrics to play to sympathetic individuals. Something that both parties do.
It's in a post somewhere on these comments.
But just for you:
And just for comic relief... Jon Stewart:
What does any of that mean??????
First of all, my article wasn't about this, so why would I misrepresent it? Second, upon looking at all the sources, I am not misrepresenting it, not purposely or otherwise.
And yet I foundmultiplesources that show that it was all male, even a picture and Jon Stewart. But OK...
Yes it was.
LOL, Robert. The conservative news sources and blogs are the ones making a fuss about something that she never tried to mislead. My point in this article... which seems to go unnoticed, since it is a partisan issue, is that journalistic integrity was notpracticedin order to prove apartisanpoint. I really don't know how any one can read my article and not get that?
I said panel in many places... so please allow me a misstep in my wording.
Oy! But the panel did.
That is a silly statement. A herring. It was a meeting about religious freedoms that was called because of contraception. It didn't happen from no where. So in the context of that, yes they should have had at least one woman on it.
Kind of a leap there. And I do believe that both parties have been doing a lot of talking about religious freedom and individual freedoms, and how sometimes they step on each other's toes. I don't see anyone running from this issue.
And we even threw the ME into the pot for some more fun.
They also don't provide it, which wasn't clear on their website for potential students until justrecently... since this whole mess came out. You do remember we discussed truth in advertising John, right?
I'm actually quite fine with how they have it now on their site. Parents and potential students can make informed decisions. Now I will be curious to see in two years from now, where their rankings will be. If this affects the number and quality of kids that apply. Right now they are ranked at 22.
LOL! But no.
BRUCE!!!!
So long as the guys keep it in their pants.
And you may not like what she said, and that is yourprerogative, but that woman is no flake.
But I guess you liked the way that sounded.
No. Just capable of independent thought, thank you.
Oh... I love you.. you're the only girl for me. We'll be together... always...
Baby.. this will bring us so much closer together. Don't you want that? You me together...
Bruce.. I thought you might have been a Meatloaf fan. "Paradise by the Dashboard Lights" remember????
Me too. I have this whenever I go afterpartisanspin.. though. Don't worry Randy.. the next time I go after the Dems, you'll be all over me, too.
Such is the life of an INNO.
Actually independents think that both the left and the right are ridiculous [although they are entertaining] .
True dat, Rich!
That's true.
Gotta agree Bruce, don't much like the homo word myself. I have members of my family that are gay.
And I don't get what any of this has to do with political spin.
No actually I'm a conservative Democrat.
INNO = Fencesitter
No one sits on fences. It hurts the butt. But I will tailgate every now and then.
[yawn].. Really? this is the best you both have, because we indies have freedom of thought. Damn, got to remember this and share it with my indie brothers and sisters before the next election. 40% of the vote going to Nader could be funny.
I was unclear about that. I found this for clarification:
So the second panel did had 2 woman on it.
Actually, I hadn't even heard Rep Carolyn Maloney talk on the subject until I went looking for reference material. So no.