Judge’s dismissal of atheist's harassment claim against Muslim makes waves
A protester who ridiculed the Muslim prophet Mohammed claims he was assaulted by a Muslim who was offended by the stunt, but a judge has sympathized with the alleged perpetrator, in a case that has drawn national attention.
Self-proclaimed atheist Ernie Perce marched in a Halloween parade in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania last October, dressed in a costume mocking Mohammed.
In a YouTube video he posted, Perce can be seen wearing a long fake beard, a white turban and green face paint, calling out provocative phrases like: "I am the prophet Mohammed! Zombie from the dead!" Perce and someone else in a zombie-themed pope costume are carrying a banner that reads "The Parading Atheists of Central Pennsylvania / Ghoulish Godless God-Awful."

Another link
Hey Judge, not sure if ya noticed but THIS IS AMERICA, Not some Arabic speaking country! I really don't give a fliyin'-fig if they follow barbaric tribal systems of law but IN AMERICA we are allowed free speech and protection from being attacked for expressing views.
This judge needs to be fired.
another asshole ignorant Judge. They are all over the place.
Soknowledgeableabout the intent and purpose of the First Amendment...makes me want to puke.
Notice that the fella spoofing the Pope wasn'tattacked; and for illustrative purposes, if that character was assaulted, would the same judgement have been rendered?
" This judge needs to be fired. "
I think he should move back to those " predominantly Muslim countries " and stay there .
Good point Larry.
It's bad enough at the reaction going on inAfghanistan, but this is the US. Freedom of Speech it one of the foundations of this nation. Kick the judge out!
Thing of it is, I'm glad that the judge was so verbose in his judgement. His referencesbeliean obvious bias, one that is not just a little scary.