“The People” Have Spoken
Most of us have heard that "The people have spoken" bit. In his victory speech last Tuesday, Rich Santorum offered this advice to President Obama.
You better start listening to the voice of the people.
The voice of WHICH people, Mr. Santorum? This The People terminology automatically disenfranchises half the country. It suggests only The People who share his views are real American citizens. We frequently hear this kind of language from John Boehner, Eric Cantor, Mitch McConnell, and others in the Republican party.
In an interview with The National Review about his book, the interviewer asked Senator Jim DeMint,
I believe in compromise and cooperation, you write. And yet you also write: Republicans simply cannot cooperate and compromise with Democrats we must beat them. Failure to do so will only allow the Democrats to continue destroying this country. Senator, Democrats dont wake up in the morning wanting to destroy America, do they? And isnt this non-compromise talk the problem with Washington?
To which he replied,
I believe in compromise when both parties have similar goals in mind, but today, the goals of the Democratic and Republican parties are at polar opposites.
That sheds some light on his thinking. In case youre interested Senator DeMint here is the dictionary definition of compromise:
a settlement of differences by mutual concessions; something intermediate between different things
I hope you noticed they didnt say anything about similar goals, Senator. Apparently, you are only willing to compromise when compromise isnt necessary.
The thing Jim DeMint, Rick Santorum, and others dont seem to get is that as elected officials, it is their duty to serve ALL The People of America even the people who have ideas they dont like. Senator DeMint is quite correct, the American people are comprised of polar opposites and by the way, everything in between.
That interviewer asked, Democrats dont wake up in the morning wanting to destroy America, do they? A very good question... Speaking as a flaming liberal, please allow me to answer that question. NO, WE DONT!!! But these radical Republicans would have you believe that is exactly what we are willfully trying to do. Whether they believe their own rhetoric or not, they vilify everyone who doesnt share their views for one reason. They refuse to cooperate and compromise because they want it all, they believe they deserve it, and without hesitation they will walk over anyone standing in there way.
Almost 3 years ago, in an article titled, Conservatives Compromise on Health Care: A Liberal's Dream I wrote
We Americans are a very diverse people, and I believe our diversity is what makes us a strong nation. That is, even though I am a proud Liberal, I believe the conservative counter to my beliefs is a good thing for America. But it is ONLY good if we all recognize that none of us will get everything we want, if we look for ways to accommodate the needs and even the wants of the people who are most different from us, if we are not only willing but proactively seeking compromise; THEN diversity is good. On the other hand, if we are proactively seeking to divide, that is bad for America! It makes us weaker, less productive, and generally a less healthy nation.
I am still dreaming of compromise, and I sincerely hope The People of America share that dream. It sounds to me like Rick Santorum, Jim DeMint, and others have a different dream. It sounds to me like they are proactively seeking to divide us.
So When you hear someone talk about The People will you ask yourself, Am I one of The People? If you hear someone say they cannot cooperate and compromise will you ask, Is this person serving me? Is this person serving the best interests of our country? Is a country that rejects half of its citizens a strong health country?
I see the effort to disenfranchise half the American people, the unabashed vilification of those who are different, the refusal to cooperate and compromise, and the effort to pit one American against another as nothing less than
The Second American Civil War!

[Mal put his quill, ink, and parchment away... curls up for a good nights sleep...]
Much of the Santorum et al conservative blather is directed at religionist ideologues ...
... about which I have to say ... "the term 'religious thought' is ...
... an OXYMORON.
We shall win, the libs don't have enough weapons, though they clearly have enough wackos!
But, what is fascinating to me Mal, is you evidence the EXACT same position as Santorum. For the democrats, no matter their demagoguery, their misinformation, are also not compromising either.
In fact, when the nut hits the nutcracker, the pubs DO compromise, the dems do not.
Yet you have omitted the fact that there are as many intransigent dems as pubs.
Thus, evidencing the same mind set.
Terry,
Another thing you guys never miss is any opportunity to do the "pot & kettle" routine... I would never make the claim that there are no intransigent lefties... but generally speaking, it is in our blood to be compromising... after all, we are "liberal"...
Pulled these synonyms for liberal out of the dictionary...
progressive, broad-minded, unprejudiced, beneficent, charitable, openhanded, munificent, unstinting, generous...
Pulled these synonyms for conservative out of the dictionary...
bourgeois, die-hard, fearful, firm, guarded, hard hat, illiberal, in a rut, inflexible, obstinate, reactionary, redneck, unchangeable, unchanging, uncreative, unimaginative, unprogressive, white bread...
Yes, I cherry-picked them... contrast "charitable & generous" with "inflexible & obstinate"... which of those characteristics sound like they are more predisposed to compromise???
"white bread"... I'm getting faint from laughing... Personally, I prefer "wry" bread...
Terry, pick one please. I think the later statement is the most on the mark.
Both parties are guilty of being intransigent. That is why they have the congress has the lowest approval rating EVER. So let's be real about this. As a matter of face, I got so real, that I checked out the Pew. Here is what they found:
It seems that there are more democrats who want compromise by 15% Shockingly, independent are morestubbornthan democrats. But I accept that. That is why I laugh when people call indies "fence sitters" when clearly, we have strong convictions.
I watched Mr. Santorum speak on 'Meet the Press" this weekend. He proudly said that one of the first things he would do is reverse Roe v Wade. Got news for you, that is NOT what the people want. He is a deeply religious Catholic, which is fine, if his beliefs don't become public policy. But that is clearly not the case.
Again, from The Pew:
Over the same period, there has been movement toward a liberal position on abortion. In 2009, for the first time in many years, the public was evenly divided over whether abortion should be legal or illegal in all or most cases. But support for legal abortion has recovered and now stands at about the same level as in 2008 (55% then, 54% today).
You'll erode his position by citing particulars ... it's tedious to rebut point-for-point ... make it easy on yourself ... just reply as follows ...
"Bullshit! LOL!"
Oh yeah... I forgot to mention that liberals are really pragmatic too! Good one A Mac! I love it!!!
I'm just being the "dispassionate chronicler of events," Mal ...
Mr. Objectivity ...
That's me!
And, as a "pragmatic liberal," I sometimes decide to fight fire with fire. And, as a typical, giving and feeling liberal, I flatter by imitating.
Or, is it mockery?
Wait ... have I been mocked all these many times?
Could it be that "Bullshit, LOL" is just an off-handed, summary dismissal used in place of actual, point-counter-point dialogue?
I'm fucking crushed.
Gotta agree Mike. OMG... I must have lost my mind!
And conservatives believe in the ...
... economy ...
... and their mantra ...
"Fuck you, I got mine!"
So then you like Occupy Wall Street after all!
Atta' guy, Mike!
"chronicler of event"... absolutely... and a damn good one!!! "dispassionate"... I don't thinks so!
Fair enough ...
One-outta'-two then.
Hey Mike,
Nice post. Gotta agree.
I'm sorry Perrie... Remarks like that make me nuts!!! While that statement is "technically" true, it isa false equivalency !!! Yes, as I said...
But... you and I both know who the real obstructionist are...and it ain't the lefties!!! So I have to take A Mac's advice and say... "Bullshit"!!!
[Mal packs up his 8-track tape collection on his travois and heads out in search of... fairness and justice...]
MAL!!!! BAD DOG!
Did you selectively read my post... let's try again!
I even said that independents didn't compromise as much as dems.
Now say your sorry!
[Perrie takes away Mal's dog toys]
But really nice graphic!
Good!
Don't be diverted by the orchestrated attempt by the 1% and their paid legislator-shills to make OWS look like a mere "movement."
And ...
And ...
And ...
This ain't all!
Mike does have cooties. Ick. Quick I need a cooties shot!
Nahh.. you still need a cootie shot after an infection.
I did read your post Perrie... Those stats are about how people want their elected officials to be... NOT about how they actually ARE!!! Saying...
IS a false equivalency about how they actually are. If 53% of independents prefer politicians who stick to their positions then perhaps that explains why Indies are not happy with us lefties... We have been WAY too compromising with these greedy righties who...
I know you really want to be truly "fair and balanced"... that is commendable!!! But these righties are screwing everying for their self-serving Randanista ( love that term ) ideology... There is absolutely NOTHING fair or balanced about their approach!!!! And I am SICK of being put in the same basket with them!!!
[ Mal sulks... ]
One more thing...
If Indies like politicians who stick to their positions, then what do they find appealing about "blowing with the wind" Romeny????
Also... "Sticking with one's position" can be said to be having convictions and standing by them... I, a flaming leftie, think that is a VERY desirable characteristic in pretty much everyone, especially my government representatives!!! But standing up for your convictions is a very different thing than opposing anything and everything the "other side" does solely for the reason that it was done by the "other side." Furthermore, standing behind your convictions does not mean there can be no "cooperation or compromise"!!!!!!
The most fundamental point of this article is this...
Standing up for our convictions does not mean there can be no "cooperation or compromise"!!!
Let's go to the charts!
GOP Filibuster Record: Republicans Using Obstruction Tool With Astonishing Frequency
And ...
Analysis: Republicans setting filibuster record
GOP senators are on pace to triple previous uses of procedural obstruction
That's cooperation all right!
Or is that co-opting cooperation?
BRAVO A Mac!!!
I'm not sure that the word would be appealing. I think the word would be reactionary. There are many issues that I am less than happy with Obama, and I am pretty sure, that is why indies are looking at Romney. There is a long way to go till the election, and it may be a moot point, if any of the other candidates get the nomination. But if Romney does, I will be listening very carefully when he debates the president.
I totally agree! Again, I recognize that the dems have compromised more than the repubs, but still, this congress as a whole, sucks. The lowest approval rate came from all of America. Now no one can find who compromised more than who, since we don't know the wheeling and dealing of Washington, but it does appear to the American people that the dems compromise more than repubs. What else can I say?
Mike is correct here .
Okay Mike,
The "projected" figure on A Mac's (not fully up to date) chart was 70. The actual figure ... 63. A bit less than the projection, true... but from this article I found this...
It is also more than the sum of all instances during Ronald Regan's entire Presidency... It was used on average about 18 time per year during GWB's 8 years in office... and has been used on average 28 time per year in the three years of President Obama's time in office.
Let's try to stay with the subject rather than create similar-sounding but not analogous comparisons.
How many specific incidences shall I post?
Number 1
Republicans Prefer Filibuster to Putting Americans Back to Work
by Mike Hall , Oct 11, 2011
All 46 Senate Republicans voted against President Obamas American Jobs Act Monday evening. With 60 votes needed to end the Republican filibuster against the act that would create as many as 2 million new jobs and keep 280,000 teachers from being laid off. Thisbill is unlikely to see any other action.
AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka says:
The 99 percent of our country who want jobs now should take note of how each and every senator voted today on the American Jobs Act. And we should ask each one who voted nowhat is your plan? How would you put our country back to work and give hope to our nations families? Because the truth is the Republicans who unanimously blocked this courageous bill have no plan and seek to profit politically from the countrys pain.
Along with the 2 million jobs, the American Jobs Act would:
Weeeeeeeell... [Mal thinks for a minute...] How about... The Republicans are a bunch of greedy, self-serving, Randanistas, whose real agenda is the abolition of all social entitlements, the abolition of all regulations that might encumber their profit making ambitions, and the dismantling of government in general (except the parts THEY like).
The right-wing attack is a bogus smokescreen consisting of demagoguery, vilifying via propaganda, tax-supported programs so that their owners, CORPORATE AMERICA, can take them over and privatize them for-profit!
Vulture Capitalism.
Clean your glasses Mike... Except for the slight difference between the projected number (70) and the actual number (6) for 2009-2010 They are exactly the same.
Isn't that thestereotypingthat you are offended by?
I mean I have to play devils advocate here.Ironically, I am taking the opposite position elsewhere on this site.
But it's exactly these extreme views that both parties hold about one another, that has gotten us to this place, which isessentiallya stalemate.
LOL. Mal, love you buddy but dems ain't "liberal" no more, certainly not in the "classic" liberalism sense.
They are much more fascist or communist, depending on which way you wish to categorize them.
The only difference between your "bullshit" and mine, is I'm correct!
LOL.
and all conservatives are racists (and dems saints),
and all conservatives are religious fanatics,
and all conservatives are, take your pick.
Know what, the only way this Country has succeeded, has provided YOU with a fricking living, and now a retirement is the desire to get ahead, to "fucking get mine" in your lexicon.
The deadbeats, sucker fish don't contribute a damn thing.
Sure. It's being intransigent when the dems come and suggest a position that is clearly, unequivocally unacceptable, and they know it. Then they just slightly come off their bizarre position, and the pubs move twice as far but not all the way to the hate filled dems' position.
And folks like you assert that it is the pubs who are intransigent!
LOL. There are lies, then damned lies. the dems practice both, all the time.
Come on Perrie, you know damn well that it's only generalizations when pubs do it.
when dems do it, why it's truth!
Just part of the hypocrisy, doncha know.
That doesn't show shit A.Mac.
As usual.
The fact is that if a bill to intern all muslims came to the floor and a filibuster was used to prevent passage,
wouldn't that be a good thing?
LOL, the mere fact that filibuster is used doesn't mean SHIT.
It's what it's used for, who moved how far BEFORE it had to be used, that is the subject of this argument.
As usual, A.Mac has introduced a fallacy into the discussion.
You make my point perfectly A.Mac,
a bullshit, budget busting bill, bullshit, budget busting.
In this case a filibuster was a good thing!
Guess you don't care how much debt we leave, incur, default on, eh?
LOL, see Mike's post re: pipeline.
Dems lie Randy, you know it, I know it.
Dems are all about making everyone dependent on gummenint.
I think in order to qualify for "correct," is ...
... actually being correct.
WTF ... splitting hairs I know.
My bad.
FLOLIBS
Mike,
This is just for you... I took the data straight off of the Senate website ... put it into a spreadsheet... turned it into a graph... overlaid it with A Mac's chart... set it up so that A Mac's chart lets my spreadsheet chart bleed through (50%) and this is the result...
Agreed.
The message was right on, the "solution," ie, more government involvement/interference was dead wrong, as usual.
LOL, foreclosures.
Do you know what the government involvement/interference in this area has resulting in A.Mac, smaller banks, and even some larger banks, not making any sort of home loan, period, end of discussion.
Gee, GREAT result A.Mac!
Soon, due to the incredible interference of the government in the ability of private lending institutions to enforce the contracts they made with deadbeats, the ONLY source of home loans will be a government funded/related entity which means all those that produce will, once again,
support all of those that don't.
Straw-man...
Absolutely correct!!! But A Mac's argument is not a "fallacy"... Frequency is relevant!!!
Mike mentioned oil pipeline and jobs.
Oil Pipelines ... you mean the one filled with oil sand?
Good old oil sand ...
If the pipe leaks, say into the aquifer that supplies the water to much of the midwest ... there will be even more jobs ...
hospital
undertakers
demolition companies
moving companies
Pipeline.
Oil Sand
Yup!
Ah, so now we destroy jobs, increase costs because of "coulda, possibly, maybe, under some inane circumstances?"
Right A.Mac, got it. Then, what the hell, EVERYONE should be taking cancer drugs now because, who the hell knows, you MIGHT get cancer.
Great rationalizations. Great way to force people to live their lives.
I do note, however, that you don't dispute the fact it would have created good, NON GOVERNMENTAL jobs.
So, that fact alone puts the lie to yours, Mal's, and Randy's position vis a vis how the pubs (and only the pubs) are preventing bills that would create jobs.
Terry concluded, even though no one ('cept for Terry) used the word "all" as a quantifier, that ...
Terry, you just love those f'n straw men, Dude.
Your list is crazy inaccurate.
This f'rinstance ...
Who would they be ... the 34% of food stamp recipients who are white, lost there jobs to Romney-care and thus became eligible for food stamps ... or ...
How 'bout the poor guy who lost his job and his health insurance because Republicans don't want a public option so health care continues to be tied to employers ... that guy ... who after losing his job found out his wife had breast cancer ... so ... he spent all his assets on her treatments ... and funeral because the treatments had to be delayed until he sold his house ...
His children had to eat so he applied for food stamps ...
Is that the sucker fish, Terry?
Grow a heart ... I hear 28.6% of ALL conservatives have ...
... considered it.
What would Jesus say (liberal that he was).
The (willfully) blind often cannot see, Terry.
Great rebuttal point though ...
Oh ... there was not point-for-point rebuttal ...
My bad.
So the banks join the conservatives in holding the country hostage, and you applaud?
A.Mac:
You know that when you create a logical fallacy, any rebuttal is useless.
The chart shows nothing to support your position.
If you cannot see that, well, the blind often think because they cannot see, no one can see.
A.Mac:
If you don't want to owe money to a bank, DON"T BORROW ANY!
What you want is the ability to borrow, sign a contract, then renege without any consequences.
Sound familiar? LOL, it ain't the banks holding folks hostage, it's deadbeats who enter into a contract then breach the contract, whining about how it's "not their fault."
All you wish to do is do away with the integrity of contracts, not a good thing.
As I said, the result is that the banks will just stop extending credit/making mortgages and the government will do it.
Just more income transfer to dead beats who should never own a house to begin with.
The jobs numbers touted by Republicans were contrived ...
...
And you jobs-for-Americans hypocrites don't ever bitch that the steel for the pipeline itself was made in India and China! And it's inferior.
But it's still early, Terry; there's still time for you to post an accurate statement today.
Your inability to deduce certain cause and effect relationships is a serious impediment in these discussions, Terry.
I will type more slowly going f-o-r-w-a-r-d.
Fuckin' tedious though.
LOL, not even I would have posted a "refutation" from "treehuggers.com!" And their "refutation" is, at the very best, pitiful!
Ah, well, how about those 3,200 bring their families, kids, with them, and well ,they spend money! And then folks come to visit, and you get the idea.
Just because that dipshit has no clue how multipliers work (Pelosi, et al do when it's to their advantage!), doesn't mean it's false.
But, hey, don't worry A.Mac, you never did have much credibility when it came to politics!
Now, photography, that's a different story!
Possibly under Romney-care.
That's right, I forgot ...
Trees ... bad ... so let's go here ...
But thank you for the photography compliment ... that is much appreciated. And did you ever get a new camera?
No, but what I did was get into wordworking, keeping me busy, building pipes, other wordworking articles.
My basement is now a shop! Two drills, two sanders, belt, flat disc, a table saw, a band saw, and my next purchase is a midi lather.
LOL.
Stereotype or not... that is my view... sincerely.
No, it isn't... Stereotyping, or even honest expression of my disgust is NOT what got us here. It is the refusal by one party much more so than the other to compromise. Just because I don't like anything they stand for doesn't mean I am not willing to give them SOME of what they want if they will give me SOME of what I want. I think I said that in the article...
I know that you do. But saying that all Republicans are:
Isn't fair either. You have to remember, that in a discussion like this, you will have those who are like the above, and then, this conversation is wasted on them. You will have moderate Republicans ( and yes they doexist) who would be highly insulted to read that comment, and so you have shut their mind down to any further discussion. You have indies like me, who are tired of this partisanism, and while many of us do think that the dems have given more in the way of compromise, are turned off when they read statements like that. What to win us over? Show us! Make your case for when and how there was compromise. Give examples of the good that Obama has done. That is what will get people over to listen to you.
Mal, you know I love you, you wilydog! So I am hoping that you are not taking any of this personally. I understand your frustration, as I have been frustrated by an article I posted here today. But keep your eye on the prize.
This is my fault for taking the bait... allowing the discussion to change from who will compromise and who won't into what we don't like about each other.
People who fit the description I provided will NEVER listen to me...
While my description is obviously caustic, it is also very accurate... Not base on imagined qualities like the qualities they attribute to me, but base on things those people actually say...
Jim DeMint is quite correct... we are at a pivotal moment in history... They have made it clear that they have no interest in finding common ground, so it makes no sense for us to waste our time trying talk to them about compromise. I'm sure we can find middle ground with you Indies... but my position with the righties is very clear...
If the righties decide to be reasonable and fair some day... Then I am always willing to compromise with fair and reasonable people.
I have to say that I tend to agree with that. We indies are interested in hearing how to make things here in America better. We want the the cold hard facts . How you are going to fix things. That is why I said in right from the start, when you asked me about Romney, I said that we won't know until the debates. As far as I am concerned, the GOP doesn't have anyone else I would even consider.
Humm... I don't know if you saw this reply or not...
Mal did see it Perrie... Thanks!!!
I still don't understand why you would give any consideration to someone who is so eager to blow with the political winds... After all of his position changes, what can he say that will convince you that he is sincere???