The answer to our energy problems is NOT clean renewable energy...
I was inspired to write this article by some blog friends and this article...
What NASA's Blue Marble Photo
Reveals About Climate Change .
Talking aboutunprecedentedprofits made by fossil-fuel companies the author said...
Telling the truth about climate change would require pulling away the biggest punchbowl in history, right when the party is in full swing. And that's why those of us battling for the future need to raise our game.
...and talking about why the fossil-fuel companies don't want to invest their huge profits in " new clean technology" he said...
...their value is largely based on fossil-fuel reserves that won't be burned if we ever take global warming seriously.
I hate to rain on things with my gloomy perspective, but there is something those fossil fuels offer that is not so easily had with other fuels... transportability. I got an email from Maria Cantwell today that said something about a new move afoot to open ANWR again. I'm all for keeping it closed... FOREVER!!! But when this issue first came up, I said to myself... There is no way to save it. We can close it now, and we can fight to keep it closed for decades. But eventually, scarcity and demand will overwhelm all efforts to keep that oil in the ground. Fossil fuel profiteers will scour the planet to find every last drop (or crumb in the case of coal)... and us consumers (speaking generally, not specifically) will sit eagerly at their feet hoping and begging for whatever morsels we can get... without a thought about the disaster we are leaving for future generations... or even any consideration for what we will do when that last drop is finally gone.
I have been fiddling around with a graphic I am thinking of using in an article on scale. Contemplation of scale has been one of the most influential factors in the formation of my views. Almost everyone considers everything in the context of their own scale... their lifespan... and the dimension of their own body. If we look beyond the scale of ourselves, we get a different perspective. In his State of the Union Address, the President mentioned something about having 100 years of natural gas available to us... Some people say that it is probably closer to 10 years. Well I say... SO WHAT!!! It really doesn't matter whether it is 10 or 100 or 1000... that span of time is inconsequential when compared to the time it will take to replace that fuel. All that anyone seems to be able to consider is what we need RIGHT NOW.
Since the sun isn't likely to burn out for at least a couple of billion years, then if we completely convert to renewable energy, will that solve our energy problems??? I don't think so. That would be a big improvement compared to dumping carbon into the incredibly thin and fragile atmosphere upon which we are so dependent, but it is theQUANTITYof energy we consume to fulfill all of our wonderful human endeavors that is the 800 lb. gorilla in the room nobody wants to talk about. Very few people are willing to consider the notion that we... collectively, every human on the planet... MUST DO LESS. Our "Blue Marble" has a finite capacity for dealing with the impacts of human activity.
The answer to our energy problems is not clean renewable energy... although that beats the heck out of the alternative... it is quite simply accepting the idea that we must learn to live within the limits of our precious Blue Marble's capacity to support us.
In another article I found this
In our day technical solutions are always welcome. it takes courage to assert that a desired technical solution is not possible.
To that I say...
It takes even more courage to assert that a possible technical solution is not desired.
I feel we need a paradigm shift... The acceptance of the idea that we need less technology, not more. We are absolutely in love with technology... and to be sure, it does some wonderful and amazing things!!! Unfortunately technology is the root cause of the ever accelerating RATE OF CHANGE on the planet. Rapid change makes it difficult to adapt... adaptability is essential for long-term survival. I may not be the only person saying these things... but there are damn few of us, and we get about as much credibility as the Flat Earth Society.

Hey Tree-huggers, before you get your knickers in a knot over the title you should know, Im a tree-hugger too, andIm a big supporter of Clean Renewable Energy even if I dont think it is the answer to our energy problems.
BTW- I gotta attend to my day job, so my attendance on this thread may be kind of sporadic...
[Mal steps down off of his soapbox]
Mal,
Recently, Rich put up a model of our fossil fuel energy usage, and it doesn't look so good. Whether or not the oil companies are willing to squeeze every ounce of oil out of the ground, my berelevantto this conversation. The the price of said oil, will out pace what people are willing to pay for it. The bottom line has always been the bottom line.
Human nature dictates that we only make changes, when it hurts. Well, it's not hurting enough, so the reality of us using less, should just be a given.
So that does leave us withalternativeenergy, of which I am a big supporter of. Whether you agree that man is harming the earth with fossil fuels, or you don't, it's best that we stop acting like junkies on oil. The good thing about the technology that has come so far, is now we have the capacity to change this paradigm. That should be our ultimate goal, as China's oil demands grows, the middle east becomes unstable, and the oil companies bring in record profits, investing inalternativefuel to me, makes common sense; for us and the future.
Ask people to give their highly mobile lifestyle... Many may be willing to convert to electric cars, and mass transit... but electric airliners??? I know technology does some amazing things... and 150 years ago most people thought flight powered by ANY fuel was not possible... But petroleum packs a lot of energy into a relatively light commodity, which is one thing that makes modern-day aircraft viable. I think there is going to be someone ready to pay whatever it take to get that last drop of oil.
We have nuclear powered aircraft carriers, but we know that isn't gonna work for the aircraft they carry... Is the navy going to say, oil is too expensive, so I guess we'll go back to battle ships???
Also, let's not forget about all the stuff we do with petroleum that isn't fuel related.
As I said, me too...
Mal,
There are other fuels in the pipeline for aircraft. Here is an interesting piece:
As for the stuff we do with petroleum, a lot of it is renewable. The rest, will come as need is the mother of necessity. We put a man on the moon in less than 10 years with just about scotch tape and a battery. Imagine what we could do now, if we so desired. The market will dictate these developments, no matter how greedy the oil industry is.
Mal ,
I'm all for conservation . In fact that is a law of physics , the conservation of energy . [Not exactly the same but the point is that energy is something which can be conserved ]
Your argument seems to be to ignore possible technical improvements we might make or different sources of energy we might find . Instead just bite the bullet and reduce our lifestyles . I think that doing both is a good idea .
One more thing : Your argument about aircraft does not include the quantitative aspect . What % of petroleum fuel usage goes to aircraft compared to the entire transportation infrastructure ? I'm thinking it is not a majority use . Thus converting everything but aircraft to electric will have a dramatic effect on the total amount of petroleum usage . In everything but aircraft the weight of batteries is not a problem as long as they have regenerative braking .
However , it is even possible to make electrically powered propeller aircraft . In fact my avatar is a shot of a real battery powered electric aircraft . [The problem is that you are not accounting for the differences in the engine weights . Electric motors are a lot lighter than combustion engines]
Hmmm... I thought that was "necessity is the mother of invention." And that " algae " idea is very inventive... But all of this serves to make the central point of my article...
As I said, that notion gets about as much credibility as the Flat Earth Society.
[ Mal packs his 8-track tape collection onto his travois... hitches himself to the travois... and trudges off to his mud hut dog house... ]
Very creative idea... I like it...
Hi Rich,
I thought this article might catch your eye...
Actually, I think I said that (in my own way) in the article...
True... but consider my point about scale...
And let me make it clear that I consider "right now" to include quite a bit of time... Most of us do not contemplate anything in terms of a time scale that goes much further than our own lives. I have no idea what the exact difference is, but I do know human impact on the planet in the last 200 years is VASTLY more than it was in the preceding 200,000 years. The main point of my article is to point out that all of us (me included) are so enamored with all of the things technology has brought us that we are not willing to consider giving up any of it. After only 200 years, we have made quite a mess... If we keep going the way we are going (or anything remotely like it) I don't want to see the mess 200,000 years, or 2,000 years, or even 200 years from now.
Damn... that mind of mine playing tricks on me, LOL! What a dork!
Mal, you misunderstand me. I agree that we must do with less.... but...Physicianheal thy self. I do believe that you are apractitioner.
BTW great graphic. Is it yours?
"I do know human impact on the planet in the last 200 years is VASTLY more than it was in the preceding 200,000 years."
Many events have had an enormous effect on the planet some of them natural . There was a mass extinction of almost all sea life several hundred million years ago . It was caused by a lot of volcanic activity triggering massive fires in large coal seams . The fly ash that resulted brought about the largest single extinction event in the geologic history of the earth .
As to the time scale you mentioned above : why do we have to "replace that fuel" ? All we need to do is get our energy elsewhere . BTW there is a theory [untested] that petroleum can be manufactured by injecting CO2 deep into the earth . After it cooks for a little while it percolates up as petroleum .
I, as a member of the human species, am not responsible for volcanic eruptions, asteroids, gamma ray bursts, or any of the other natural phenomena that can harm the planet and the life that is dependent on it. But I am inclined to feel some responsibility for the harmful things that my own species does.
We don't. But I am saying we should consider everything we do and the impact it has... not only for our own sake and the sake of future human generations, but for the sake of every creature that lives on this planet and their future generations. But VERY few of us humans give any consideration to anything that might limit what WE can do and have.
Yes. Ben gave me the inspiration. Did you see the graphic I added at the bottom of the article???
Huh??? Sorry Perrie... that one went right over my head...
Here's something else you can consider . Whatever the effects on species that warming has they are not as severe as the effects of cooling :
I am not so concerned about the effect of worming or cooling as I am the effects of mankind.
As a dog I would think you would be very concerned about the effects of "worming " . [:~ P
Geeeeezzz... Well... all I can say is typing ain't too easy with these big fat puppy toes...
And I don't want to hear anything about how far the "a" is from the "o" on the keyboard... ;-}
Solar powered plane:
Not a commercial liner by any means, but way cool none the less.
Technology is a wonderful thing, until it breaks or the batteries don't work. I think I can still use a slide rule. I have said before that everyone is going to have to start learning how to use what they need, not what they want. I am thinking that the paradigm shift you speak of is going to be the demise of the consumer economy.
Flat Earthers! Unite!
LOL Steve... I'm with ya!