I live in Israel, in Iran's shadow. I voted for Obama. I'm glad I did.
Thank you, Mr. President, for this deal.
I live in Israel. I live in the shadow of Iran. I hold American citizenship as well as Israeli. I pay taxes to both countries. I vote in the elections of each.
In 2008 and 2012, I voted for Barack Obama . I'm glad I did.
I'm glad not only because of landmark changes to America on his watch, not only because of moments of inspiration, of unexpected hope, of enfranchisement, of movement on issues long dismissed as immutable.
I'm glad because I believe that no one but this president would have tried, and succeeded, to land a deal with Iran on nuclear weapons.
I'm glad because Israel is the place we raised our children. They tell us that this is the place where they want to raise theirs. And this deal, fraught as it is, stands a chance of making our future here safer.
Over the weekend I studied the text of the agreement. Start to finish. It makes for a sobering read. As a contract, it gives the sense of spending more time on what Iran gets out of this, than on what Iran needs to give up to get it.
No one can be sure if it will work. No one can know if Iran means to abide by its terms, and put off its bomb by a decade or more.
As complex and jargon-laden as the agreement is, evaluating it comes down to a simple question who do you trust?
The document is asking us to trust on a level that we've seldom needed to summon. Like it or not, fight it or not, we are trusting this document, and its signatories, with our very lives.
Whom do I trust with the lives of my children?
I trust people like former Mossad chief Efraim Halevy. The agreement, he argued Sunday , "includes components that are crucial for Israel's security."
Iran made concessions on a series of critical issues, Halevy wrote, noting that the Islamic Republic was "forced to agree to an invasive and unique supervision regime like no other in the world."
I trust Lt. Col (Res.) Uzi Even, a physics professor and former scientist at the Dimona nuclear reactor, who concluded in a detailed analysis that the deal "delays the Iranian nuclear program by 15 years at least, and maybe more.
"The deal was written by nuclear experts and blocks every path I know to the bomb," Even continues. "The Iranians may be celebrating, but they have in fact swallowed a very bitter pill, more so than they would like to let on."
I trust nuclear non-proliferation expert Aaron Stein, who told journalist Max Fisher that under the terms of the agreement, if Tehran tries to build a bomb, "the likelihood of getting caught is near 100 percent," meaning that the agreement "makes the possibility of Iran developing a nuclear weapon in the next 25 years extremely remote."
I believe that Barack Obama is making the best effort that anyone is, to keep my family safe from the possibility of an Iranian nuclear weapon.
And what about Benjamin Netanyahu? Don't I trust him? Don't I trust him to keep us safe, to safeguard Israel's vital interests, to keep war at bay?
No. Not at all. Absolutely not.
"The attempt to change the rules of the game and include additional demands from Iran in the agreement, like recognizing Israel and halting the support for terror," Halevy wrote this week, "shows that Netanyahu has no interest in any agreement."
Countering critics Netanyahu in the lead - who contend that having no deal at all would have been preferable to forging this deal, DefenseNews wrote in a Monday editorial : "Without a deal, Iran which suspended its bomb program 20 months ago to enter negotiations would be unchecked in quickly finishing the project: Iran would have a nuclear device, by far the worst possible outcome for the region."
Do I trust Iran? No. And that is where having a deal a deal with critical monitoring - makes sense. As does the page-after-page emphasis on sanctions to be lifted, part and parcel of selling the deal to the Iranian public.
I do trust Iran expert Meir Javedanfar, who describes a likely outcome had no deal been signed, or if the Israeli prime minister succeeds in his declared campaign to intervene in U.S. politics in order to scuttle the deal within the next two months.
"With what Netanyahu is suggesting, which is the continuation of the current tensions with Iran until Iran completely capitulates Iran would only need two months to make a nuclear weapon."
"Nobody is trusting Iran, the Iranian regime," maintains Javedanfar, an Iran-born Israeli, who teaches contemporary Iranian politics at the Interdisciplinary Center in Herzliya.
"Its not about trust its about mistrust and verify.
Barack Obama could have taken the easy way out, and ducked the most difficult foreign policy challenge of his presidency a nuclear Iran. Instead, against all odds, against some of the most stringent pressures American politics can dish out, he has driven forward.
Thank you, Mr. President, for this deal.
http://www.haaretz.com/blogs/a-special-place-in-hell/.premium-1.667121

I'm really pretty disgusted by many of you that couldn't read the released agreement for themselves, do the analysis, and make up your own minds about the agreement. Nope, you had to wait for your far-right talking points from the likes of Fox, or just parroting what BB wanted to tell you.
Some of you didn't even want to read the document, but felt free to comment on it thinking you knew what the hell you were talking about. You just proved how shallow your thought process really is. I keep asking people to use their heads, apply some science to thing. That's been a true waste of my time.....
Does this agreement give the US and Israel what they want? Hell no and far from it. But the reality is that after 36 years, the sides are trying to take some much needed, and painful steps to improving relations. Put all the rhetoric and pontificating aside. Both sides are swallowing a difficult pill, but it is the only pill that will improve relations with Iran in the long run.
I picked the furthest left-wing response I could find from within Israel, to counter so much of the far right bullshit posted on NT of late. Honest people know that the truth of this deal lies somewhere in between the two....
For good reason, nobody trusts each other in the ME. But you HAVE to start somewhere.
You want to get down to it...... Right now Israel is the most dangerous country in the ME. They have the military and weapons, to really throw a wrench into the tinderbox that is the ME. What is really bothering me is that I believe that BB has the mindset of a person that would be willing to toss a match into that tinderbox.
Bravo and thank you to Bradley Burston. This agreement may be the only way to avoid war, which is why it makes some people so angry. They hunger to send young men and women off to die for their anger and hate. Fuck them! Enough invasions and fuck ANY so-called Middle-Eastern leaders depending on us to lead the way into another war just because they want one! We've given far too much already! Let the ME leaders get together and fight themselves.
This is no surprise American Jewish voters overwhelmingly vote Democrat. They are a dime a dozen and this guy makes his living writing these opinion pieces he knows what to say to his target audience.
You more than succeeded there - had you tried to go any farther left you would have dropped off the end of the world. Bradley Burston is a senior editor and columnist with Ha'aretz, the most left wing anti-Israel medium in Israel. I do not deny that the quotations he uses are true quotations. He must have gone to some effort to find them. However, he gets paid for writing these articles, and in that I question his veracity.
We are all entitled to our opinions, and some of us are not paid to state them, like he is. I suppose if I were paid I, too, would write whatever my employer wanted, even fairy tales. My sources get attacked all the time so I feel justified in attacking this one. I have posted many articles already that include quotations from highly respected personages from around the world whose views are opposite those you have posted. So let's just wait and see what really DOES happen.
One thing you can be sure of is that if it ends up a mess or starting WW3 the Dems will certainly say it was 6 other countries fault and that if it goes OK it will be all BO's doing.
I'm not sure that blaming everything on Netanyahu accomplishes much . He is merely reflecting the will of the Israeli voters .
You obviously didn't look very hard:
Probably because your ignorant biases makes you think israel is some sort of facist disctatorship.
But guess what? They allow something that even the "model of democracy" the U.S. does not-- they allow the Communist party-- and Communists can run for election in Isael.
(And of course Israel's Arabs, who make up over 20% of the population, can vote-- something that, ironically, they would not be able to do in most other Middle estern countries!)
Your bullsh*t goes on and on and on..will it never stop?
Let's look at the facts (as much as that my upset you
.
To all: A springboard for discussion. Test your knowledge of the "dangers" in the middle east. See how many you can get right without clicking on the links. (Don't feel bad if you don't know the answers-- I had to google to get a few of them myself
1. There is a country who has invaded a neighbouring country-- right now they have elite forces fighting in Iraq. Which country is that?
2. What country has large numbers of fighters who have invaded Syria and are currently fighting there to prop up Syrian tyrant Bashir Assad?
3. "Has the weapons?" What unusual fact do you know about Saudi military purchases?
4. What country's military invaded Libya? and has had had forces fighting there recently ?
5. What country has been destroying Gaza tunnels by flooding them, and has leveled houses on the Gaza border to keep Gaza terrorists from ...
6. What ruling Party has a Charter which clearly states that their goal is to exterminate members of an entire religion?
7. Israel currently has troops fighting in which of the following countries? Lebanon, Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Yemen?
8. Israel definitely won't launch a pre-emptive military strike on Iran, because it would be suicidal-- resulting in a huge number of Israeli civilian deaths. There would be no way to prevent that. Why...and why?
9.Iran will definitely not launch a military strike on Israel. Why?
10. The current nuclear agreement will have no effect on military confrontations between Iran and israel. Why?
I guess no one will be asking Mr. Burston about his "dual-citizenship" and the nature of his ideological followings.
He's badmouthing Israel and supporting Obama.
He's a good Jew...
...because he agrees with you.
There is no doubt that Israel's form of democracy is a purer form than seen elsewhere, notwithstanding its having to fend off constant criticism.
However, you have been unfair to FLYNAVY1. He is not at all ignorant, and in fact is quite intelligent and has very broad knowledge. Besides, he certainly isn't as biased as I am. I have considerable respect for his comments and have learned much from them and from the dialogues he and I have had. I don't think you have had much opportunity to read what he has written or posted. What he posted here is out of frustration with those of us who have a right-wing view of the "deal" because he feels that if we had spent the time to read the whole 159 pages of the deal we would not be so positive of the outcome or alternatives. Personally I cannot be bothered to spend that much time on it, but I rely of persons for whom I have considerable respect who have a more intelligent, experienced and studied view of it and the situation it covers. I have never agreed that the only alternative to that deal was war, but it could have been a BETTER deal. In this regard I have respected the viewpoints of the many military and political experts who have voiced the opinion in an article I had posted here and just spent an hour trying to find but couldn't...
...and the essay written by Alan Dershowitz, the brilliant Law Professor at Harvard University for whom I have the greatest respect (he would not be a Law Professor at Harvard if he was stupid) and I agree with his take that the deal was ineptly negotiated by the USA (the other nations really just relied on the USA) and it could have been done more competently.
I had to smile when I saw his "so true" allegory:
I think that's changing somewhat.
The will of the Israeli voter says clearly that they don't want to be exterminated . How dare they stand up for their lives . They should just lie down & accept the inevitable ... with Fly cheering from the sidelines ...
In case you hadn't picked up on it JP, this seed was aimed straight at you!
The other day you commented that you hadn't read the agreement, and had no intentions of reading the contents of the agreement. The document is was only 159 pages, and a good chunk of it just listed corporate entities. As such, your comments on the matter could not have held anything other than what you wanted to parrot from other sources.
I don't have a problem with informed differing opinions, and I accept them as the way of the world, and good one at that. Self imposed ignorance on the other hand is damn near criminal, and at epidemic levels it would seem.
John Russell has lived in Iran and approves 100 % in the govt there !
No Buzz, this wasn't targeted at you my friend. I had someone else in mind.
You and I have gone round on things in the past, but we both know when to call it quits before it gets into a food fight. This seed was primarily about taking time to try to be accurately informed when you make your mind up on things. We both know that it's impossible to demand in depth thought here on NT, but someday, I would like to hope it can happen. Call me an optimist.
I'm going to take a break from NT for a bit. Were going up to visit our old neighbors and friends in Finland for a few days. Shortly after that we'll be on a cruise up and around the British Isles in an effort to learn about their history. Kavika, and 1st have given me my reading/homework material on NA culture which I'm looking forward to getting into. I'm sure they will have an essay test for me when I get back.
You take good Buzz, and keep the wheels on this place.... (full time job I know.)
Really Petey? Really?
You should know me to be much more in-depth than that by now....
Looks like my research got me what I wanted to seed. I was pretty sure this thing was way left of center Buzz. Call it firing for effect!
You and your family have a safe journey. I look forward to your return.
And yet here are your exact words :
Come on, Petey. You know I must be one of the most steadfast supporters of Israel on this site, and I guess I know FLY a lot better than you. There is NO WAY that FLY would cheer a Masada event in Israel.
I spent half the night reading the Iranian Nuclear Deal the other night. I just browsed through the last part as I realized by then the "Greedy Bastards" (Corporations) from the various countries didn't care about the final outcome, but the money they were going to make from this deal. That includes France, Germany, UK, Russians, USA and all the corporations who expect to make a windfall in this agreement. As far as Obama is concerned, he's just one of the corporate puppets. Countries worldwide are in desperate need of financial rescue and this they expect to provide it for them.
You don't have to worry about Israel, because these countries are going to protect Iran whether they follow through with the deal or break it. There will never be sanctions on Iran ever again no matter what they do. These corporations and countries will have too much invested.
...
Well Jonathan P, perhaps you'll be more inclined to listen to what this " Good Jew " has to say about the deal and not dismiss his informed opinion out of hand, just because it differs from your own.
Thanks Buzz. I want the state of Israel to live a long and rewarding life.
I want everyone the region to be able to raise and educate their kids as they see fit towards a rewarding and safe future.
I don't cheer for anyone's demise....... At one time Soviet submariners maybe, but even now I regret my thoughts that I had back then.
You know AH, there are Jews and there are Jews. Just the same as there are liberals and there are conservatives, Just the same as there are Democrats and there are Republicans. There are as many opinions as there are people. At least it isn't a world in which everyone is a clone of everyone else, a zombie, a robot. I can't help but think of the words of Ari Ben Canaan (played by Paul Newman) in the movie Exodus, when speaking to Major Caldwell (played by Peter Lawford), when he said something like "Put two Jews together you have an argument, and if three you have a revolution". The point is there are different points of view, and obviously Ami Ayalon has HIS point of view.
Correction on that quotation:
Actually, since then I did take the time to read the deal.
The fact is, there is nothing in that deal that can stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. The deal provides for all kinds of mechanisms to make Iran more uncomfortable and "on the spot", should they be in violation at any point. But the major takeaway from the language is that it places far more requirements on the world, rather than Iran.
What nobody chooses to address is the truly heinous nature of this country, and how the world is attempting to normalize relations with them in spite of that heinous behavior. And to compound further, those same nations choose to assist in the collective punishment on Israel, their violation being merely to attempt to continue to exist.
In today's news, there are 2 stories, side by side, that illustrate my point. There are articles about the EU's plans to start doing business with Iran. In the same publication, there are EU directives to figure out a way to further pressure Israel financially, vis a vis the Palestinian situation.
FLY, that takes moral equivalence, and twists it into a pretzel. Don't ask me to support anything this world wants to do, until the world stops rewarding terrorists, while attempting to squash democracies.
And yes, the treatment of Israel has everything to do with this.
Yesterday July 22, 2015 there was a protest in New York City about this Iran Deal, as I observed the attendants, mostly what I saw were "OLD GRAND AND GREAT GRAND MOTHERS AND FATHERS" None of Whom are going to fight, they want American Children to Fight their War..I Say, "Go to Hell"...Hey Look who is making the speech, Right Winger former Governor of New York George Pataki running for President...
Oh I agree Buzz.
I brought Ayalon's thoughts on the matter forward because his backgroundadds some gravitas tohis opinionand, (truth be told), because Jonathan P's snarky "Good Jew" comment grated on my ears a bit.
I suppose America doesn't want veto power over issues that affect its security, but it's okay to give Iran 150 billion dollars so they can fund Hamas and Hezbollah and upgrade their weapons. Iran has clearly made the point that there are to be no restrictions to its support of its surrogates. That gives Israel no reason to be concerned, eh?