In 2009, NASA's LCROSS spacecraft shot a spent rocket stage at the Moon to analyze the plume of debris it kicked up. The results indicated that water may be common on the Moon.
Colonizing The Moon May Be 90 Percent Cheaper Than We Thought
Only 12 people have walked on the moon, and we haven't been back since 1972. But a new NASA-commission study has found that we can now afford to set up a permanent base on the moon, by mining for lunar resources and partnering with private companies.
Returning humans to the moon could cost 90 percent less than expected, bringing estimated costs down from $100 billion to $10 billion. That's something that NASA could afford on its current deep space human spaceflight budget.
A factor of ten reduction in cost changes everything, said Mark Hopkins, executive committee chair of the National Space Society, in a press release.
The study, released today, was conducted by the National Space Society and the Space Frontier Foundationtwo non-profit organizations that advocate building human settlements beyond Earthand it was reviewed by an independent team of former NASA executives, astronauts, and space policy experts.
A factor of ten reduction in cost changes everything.To dramatically reduce costs, NASA would have to take advantage of private and international partnershipsperhaps one of which would be the European Space Agency, whose director recently announced that he wants to build a town on the moon . The new estimates also assume that Boeing and SpaceX, NASA's commercial crew partners, will be involved and competing for contracts. SpaceX famously spent just $443 million developing its Falcon 9 rocket and Dragon crew capsule, where NASA would have spent $4 billion. The authors of the new report are hoping that 89 percent discount will extend beyond low Earth orbit as well.
Similar to SpaceX's goals of creating a reusable rocket, the plan also relies on the development of reusable spacecraft and lunar landers to reduce costs.
Plus, mining fuel from the lunar surface could make going back to the moon economically viable. Data from the Lunar Crater Observation and Sensing Satellite (LCROSS) suggest that water ice may be plentiful on the moon, especially near the poles. That's important because water can be broken down into hydrogen propellant for rockets (and, conveniently, oxygen for humans to breathe).
The report envisions setting up a lunar industrial base that mines water from the lunar regolith, processes it into hydrogen, then sends the hydrogen into orbit around the moon so that spacecraft on their way to Mars (or elsewhere in the solar system) can stop by to get a fuel boost. Such an endeavor could shave off $10 billion per year in the cost of getting to the red planet. The report estimates that this industrial base would house four astronauts, and within 12 years of the initial landings, provide 200 megatons of propellant at a total cost of $40 billion.
How To Build A Lunar Mining Town
Here's the specific proposal, as laid out in the report:
Phase 1
Robots determine how much hydrogen is in the lunar crust, and where it's located. ( Note: this step is crucial. If hydrogen is not plentiful and easy to mine from the lunar crust, then the plan to return to the moon is not viable. ) One such robot has been proposed by NASA scientists. The Resource Prospector would deploy a rover that can search for hydrogen, drill into the lunar regolith, and heat samples to see what's inside. If the mission gets funded, it'll be the first mining expedition on another world.
Develop reusable spacecraft to get humans to and from the moon
Land humans at the equator, probably using SpaceX's Falcon Heavy rocket, which is still in development but estimated to cost $1700 per kilogram
Phase 2
Develop technologies to mine the lunar ice
Develop reusable lunar lander to carry equipment back and forth from lunar orbit to lunar surface
Send humans to the lunar poles
Select a site for mining
Phase 3
-
Use lunar lander to deliver Bigelow Aerospace inflatable space habitats to lunar surface for human occupation. The habitat modules could be located in a lava tube for protection against radiation.
-
Deliver a crew of four astronauts to live on the surface and assist in repair of the largely autonomous mining equipment.
-
Begin mining for hydrogen
-
Lunar lander delivers 200 metric tons of propellant per year to a depot at Lagrange point L2--a stationary spot in lunar orbit on the far side of the Moon
The plan calls for mining and transport technologies that do not currently exist, but they're within the realm of possibility. "There are no show-stoppers," said Hoyt Davidson from Near Earth LLC during yesterday's press conference. "There are certainly more things that need to be studied, and issues that need to be addressed."
Enlarge
Robo Prospector
NASA
A proposed Resource Prospector rover aims to be the first robot to mine resources on another world.
A Highway To Mars, And Beyond
In 1962, President John F. Kennedy famously said, "We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard."
Well, now that the Apollo program, Skylab, the International Space Station, and NASA's other endeavors have paved the way, it's not so hard anymore, says Tom Moser, who was the lead engineer and program manager for Apollo and the International Space Station. "Returning to the moon is easy, it's reasonable and affordable, and could be the pathway to Mars... But there has to be a will do it."
A 2014 Human Spaceflight Report found that the best way to send astronauts to Mars is to learn how to live on the moon first, but NASA went ahead with a cheaper paththe Asteroid Redirect Mission, which is largely irrelevant to the goal of traveling to and surviving on Mars. While there have been a few attempts to return to the moon after the Apollo program, those proposals had price tags ranging from $100 billion to a trillion dollars, says Charles Miller, the new study's principle investigator and leader of the Alliance for Space Development.
Up until now, there hasn't been widespread public support for going back to the moon, partly because it's always seemed so expensive, says Miller. "We think the idea that this has to cost $100 billion should die a quick death."
If mining for lunar hydrogen can be economically viable, it could pave the way for utilizing other valuable resources, such as helium-3, as well as making moon tourism more economical. "Now and forever, the most valuable thing in space is people," says Gary Oleson from the Space Frontier Foundation's board of directors.
The ideas in the report are just concepts and recommendations at this point, and NASA has no commitment to follow through on them as far as we can tell. But mining the moon certainly has the potential to restructure space travel. Rockets launching from Earth would no longer have to lift off carrying fuel and water for long journeys. Instead, they could pull over at the moon to top off their tanks. Leaving lunar orbit is a lot easier than leaving Earth, so these lunar way stations could potentially lower the cost of spaceflight dramatically, opening up a highway to Mars ... and beyond.
"A permanent lunar settlement should be a building block for settlement of the rest of the solar system," says Davidson.
http://www.popsci.com/colonizing-moon-may-be-90-percent-cheaper-we-thought

Colonization of the moon and subsequent exploration of other planets in the solar system may have gotten easier, or at least a lot more affordable according to this study.
As of 2013, the cost to put a kilogram of mass into geosynchronous Earth orbit is $27,063. Other sources I've read put the cost per Kg to land on the moon is $1.2 million. In today's dollars each of the moon landings would have cost an estimated $28-billion
Do the math from there.....
In short, this author needs to share what he's smoking. (Mining hydrogen...... what a gas!)
FLY
I am a fan of space exploration, but not an engineer or space travel cost accountant
I will bow to your expertise on the costs as currently envisioned and will try and see if I can find anything else about why the author thinks it could be getting cheaper (even if only relatively cheaper).
Other than as a byproduct of his choice of smoking products.
Glad to get your feedback and perspective
I am not an engineer of any sort, but I know enough of human nature and have spent enough time in and around DC politicians to know that trying to split resources between citizens of this planet.... the haphazard mish-mash of humanity no one cares about except during elections and when they can be used to further personal and political agendas... and select, elite citizens of aprized scientific moon base enclavewill have Earth being short changed, hands down.
All this talk of mining water for hydrogen is bovine feces; we have no right to expand into space until we face and deal with the problems world leaders are hiding from here. The first one is over population, which is too rapidly consuming natural resources.
scremminmimi
No doubt the problems of the planet are many and that there is much bovine feces in the actions and character of political leaders.
Whether there is a right to exploration or an obligation is debatable as well
I am a huge supporter of space exploration and many of the technologies we enjoy and depend on today are a result of earlier space explorations.
Appreciate your perspective thanks for the feedbac
I always thought (and still do) that we should have gone ahead with colonizing the moon. I think the Space Shuttle Program was one of the biggest wastes of money in American history, compared to other space exploration we could have spent it on.
I was recently reading about a plan to mine a particular asteroid which is claimed to have a core of platinum . But it has so much platinum that the price of that metal would likely plummet ...
RiO,
I was born in Huntsville, AL, the Rocket City, and am a big supporter of space exploration; the benefits we enjoy from technology specifically created for the first moon launch are numerous and would be surprising to millions of people who grew up taking them for granted.
We have ignored space travel as a government endeavor and now are looking at it as an option in conjunction with big business/corporations. If there is one thing the years and experience have taught me, it is that anything done by the government in conjunction with pure profit motivation as partnered with business enterprises, is a road map to environmental and human catastrophe due to short cuts motivated by profits and cover-ups of losses.
Businesses will insist on more secrecy than Pentagon war games, citing work product proprietary protocols to which even the US government cannot be entrusted and under the blanket of that security will place everyone involved in the program at risk for a few dollars more.
Corruption and under-the-table deals have always been a part of government contracting, but never on the scale it is today and with corporations a part of the project on a developmental level, government scientists will not even have the final say on safety materials.
But then, I am a conspiracy theorist.
Take it a little further and when the Middle East blows itself up in an atomic armageddon and makes the whole Earth uninhabitable, the moon may be the first place we can get to where the environment is safe.
To lower the cost of getting there, instead of using rockets - maybe there's another way?
One thing that most people don't think about that much is that there is water in the rocks, as a part of their chemical makeup. Break that apart, and there is water there...
We have literally only scratched the surface of the moon, and have no idea what kind of materials are down below the surface.
Dr. Harrison, the geologist/astronaut, came to the KGS and gave a talk about what could be on the moon, and it was fascinating. He is the one that reminded all of us that there are hydrosilicates on the moon-- which could be a good source of water.
Hmmmmm.... Might they have been subtracting the cost of the mined water from the total water needed to make the hydrogen fuel? It still would cost the same to get the equipment to the moon, but once there, if the moon is providing the raw materials.....
I dunno. Just a thought
That's possible
scremminmimi
I am not a conspiracy theorist, but there is certainly levels of validity to the points you make about efficiency and corruption
I would offer that we should wait and see how the private/public partnership on space exploration plays out, though I think we will see a more active government participation again in the future. A cyclical process of investment and priority perhaps
Buzz
I told scremminmimi that I was not a conspiracy theorist and I am also not a pessimist either and I do not see the end of the world on the radar just yet
Good picture by the way and one of my favorite movies.
Randy
A lot of learning and scientific advances have come from the shuttle program so it is hard to illustrate it as a total bust.
Petey
Supply and demand for sure
Dowser
Totally agree and hope we fix that going forward
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
The moon landing was an endeavor that the majority of the country was behind all the way and took great pride in. I would love to see that again before I walk on.... the united pride in American accomplishment that didn't involve the word "war."
scremminmimi
I agree and expanded space exploration is not about war, but rather about exploration and search for information and things that benefit the world as a whole