╌>

A Liberal is....

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  93 comments

A Liberal is....
A liberal is someone who thinks tax increases on businesses are paid out of the secret stash of cash all businesses hide in their basement. A liberal is someone who thinks prayer in school is obscene but who believes schools should teach Nietzsche.A liberal is someone who wants stricter gun control but has armed bodyguards.A liberal is someone who wants guns out of honest citizens' hands but who also wants more lenient sentencing for criminals who use guns.A liberal is someone who thinks that poverty excuses crime even though most poor people are honest.A liberal is someone who believes atheists should never have to hear a Christian speak but who demand that Christian businesses support gay weddings.A liberal is someone who thinks that nuns who donate their entire lives to helping the poor should pay for abortions.A liberal is someone who wants to be philanthropic with other peoples money.A liberal is someone who thinks that the differences between men and women can be fixed with surgery.A liberal is someone who is excited by our "low" unemployment rate even though the Black unemployment rate is nearly twice as high. A liberal is someone who thinks it's ok for liberal politicians to decide which laws to enforce but who condemns politicians who object to Supreme Court rulings.A liberal is someone who thinks that taxpayers should pay for promiscuous people's birth control and that death panels are a good way to save money.A liberal is someone who condemns Nixon for erasing 18 minutes of a tape recording but thinks Hillary was smart to erase tens of thousands of emails.A liberal is someone who has no children and spends all their money on themselves who attacks big families whose children will fund the liberals social security payments.A liberal is someone who thinks the economy is great because the stock market is up but who professes to hate the "rich".A liberal is someone who calls Christians who don't believe in evolution stupid because they reject science but who claims the unborn aren't human.A liberal is someone who is horrified that anyone would abort an unborn child because that child is gay but quite comfortable with aborting an unborn child that might be mentally challenged.A liberal is someone who says marriage isnt about kids but who decries the feminization of poverty.A liberal is someone who attacks America for its interventionism and is silent about Chinas claims to the South China Sea.Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2015/07/a_liberal_is.html#ixzz3gd33byet Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

LMAO! A quick review...

A liberal is someone who thinks tax increases on businesses are paid out of the secret stash of cash all businesses hide in their basement.

The "conservative" thinks businesses shouldn't pay taxes at all, because all they do is pass them on to the consumer. The conservative is thus admitting that businesses feel no responsibility to the society and infrastructure that makes their success possible. They want their to be no 'cost' associated with doing business, only profit.

Poster does not dispute the statement and instead offers a liberal opinion on what conservatives think of taxes. Guess this should be marked as true.

A liberal is someone who thinks that poverty excuses crime even though most poor people are honest.

Poverty causes crime. This has been known for hundreds of years. The fact that every poor person doesn't become a criminal does not negate the basic truth.

Poster argues "excuses" should be replaced with "causes" Looks like mostly true.

A liberal is someone who wants to be philanthropic with other peoples money.

Social justice is not equivalent to charity.

Poster only takes issue with the fact that it is being called charity and not the liberal idea of "social justice". Again looks like mostly true.

A liberal is someone who thinks that taxpayers should pay for promiscuous people's birth control and that death panels are a good way to save money.

There are no death panels.

Poster only takes issue with "death panels". Mark as half true.

In summary, out of the 8 points poster takes issue with he still mostly agrees with half of them.24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

XXJefferson#51

I am liberal and I do not think those things. So don't be stupid and say that all liberals think these things.

There are lots of liberals out in the land beyond your self imposed bubble(s) that think any number of thoughts that run contrary to your screed (Which you couldn't even think up yourself). Every single one of the items listed is moronic. One would hope to see a sarcasm tag attached to this post, but alas, no luck there. You, through your continued postings of this type, have shown through your history on this site and others, that you have no intention of true debate and that you wholeheartedly agree with the idiotic sentiments expressed. If you are intelligent enough to form a reasoned opinion with backing argument besides because I said so or because my handlers who tell me what to think said so , by all means, please bring it forward.

In addition to being plain ignorant of what liberals and, I dare say, conservatives think about the issues mentioned, it would appear that you harbor the same delusional state as the authors whose tripe you post, as well as an almost inbred animosity for certain vast segments of the population at large whom you have not ever had a chance to meet or have a discussion with, yet you freely ascribe to them the notions that you and your prejudiced authors think people think so as to be able to laugh at them. This mentioned behavior is not only childish, but it sets you apart from thinking society who is able to see quite plainly that different people have differing views on a variety of issues.

Think. I know you can. It isn't hard and it can really be quite refreshing.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

Well said, Brioliver and much more diplomatically than I could have done. The lack of critical thinking displayed in these absurd seeds and the posts of the seeder is disturbing.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

A PRONOUNCEMENT WITHOUT ANY VALIDATION.

A CONSERVATIVE IS SOMEONE WHO POSTS VITRIOLIC PRONOUNCEMENTS LIKE THOSE ABOVE.

But O.K. see how you like it.

1. "Today's so-called 'conservatives' don't even know what the word means. They think I've turned liberal because I believe a woman has a right to an abortion. That's a decision that's up to the pregnant woman, not up to the pope or some do-gooders or the Religious Right. It's not a conservative issue at all." - Barry Goldwater

2. "I cannot help fearing that men may reach a point where they look on every new theory as a danger, every innovation as a toilsome trouble, every social advance as a first step toward revolution, and that they may absolutely refuse to move at all." - Alexis de Tocqueville

3. "Conservatism is the blind and fear-filled worship of dead radicals." - Mark Twain

4. "Conservatism discards Prescription, shrinks from Principle, disavows Progress; having rejected all respect for antiquity, it offers no redress for the present, and makes no preparation for the future." - Benjamin Disraeli

5. "Have you ever wondered why Republicans are so interested in encouraging people to volunteer in their communities? It's because volunteers work for no pay. Republicans have been trying to get people to work for no pay for a long time." - George Carlin

6. "Republicans approve of the American farmer, but they are willing to help him go broke. They stand four-square for the American home -- but not for housing. They are strong for labor -- but they are stronger for restricting labor's rights. They favor minimum wage -- the smaller the minimum wage the better. They endorse educational opportunity for all -- but they won't spend money for teachers or for schools. They think modern medical care and hospitals are fine -- for people who can afford them. They consider electrical power a great blessing -- but only when the private power companies get their rake-off. They think American standard of living is a fine thing -- so long as it doesn't spread to all the people. And they admire of Government of the United States so much that they would like to buy it." - Harry S. Truman

7. "Republicans are men of narrow vision, who are afraid of the future." - Jimmy Carter

8. "Latins for Republicans -- it's like roaches for Raid." - John Leguizamo

9. "A conservative is a man with two perfectly good legs who, however, has never learned to walk forward." - Franklin D. Roosevelt

10. "A conservative is a man who just sits and thinks, mostly sits." - Woodrow Wilson

11. "I like that about the Republicans; the evidence does not faze them, they are not bothered at all by the facts." - Bill Clinton

12. "A conservative is someone who makes no changes and consults his grandmother when in doubt." - Woodrow Wilson

13. "A Conservative Government is an organized hypocrisy." - Benjamin Disraeli

14. "A Conservative is a fellow who is standing athwart history yelling 'Stop!'." - William F. Buckley, Jr.

15. "Although it is not true that all conservatives are stupid people, it is true that most stupid people are conservative." - John Stuart Mill

16. "Even as someone who's labeled a conservative -- I'm a Republican, I'm black, I'm heading up this organization in the Reagan administration -- I can say that conservatives don't exactly break their necks to tell blacks that they're welcome." - Clarence Thomas

17. "In the United States I have always believed that there was a big difference between Conservative and stupid. Boy is it getting harder to prove that one by the minute." - Rick Mercer

18. "The modern conservative is engaged in one of man's oldest exercises in moral philosophy; that is, the search for a superior moral justification for selfishness." - John Kenneth Galbraith

19. "When a nation's young men are conservative, its funeral bell is already rung." - Henry Ward Beecher

20. "I wonder how many times you have to be hit on the head before you find out who's hitting you? It's about time that the people of America realized what the Republicans have been doing to them." - Harry Truman

21. "In this world of sin and sorrow there is always something to be thankful for; as for me, I rejoice that I am not a Republican." - H. L. Mencken

22. "A conservative is one who admires radicals centuries after they're dead." - Leo Rosten

23. "Conservatives define themselves in terms of what they oppose." - George Will

24. "The Republicans are looking after the financial interests of the wealthiest individuals in this country." - Edward Kennedy

25. "Liberalism is trust of the people tempered by prudence. Conservatism is distrust of the people tempered by fear." - William E. Gladstone

26. "Republicans don't like people who talk about depressions. You can hardly blame them for that. You remember the old saying: Don't talk about rope in the house where somebody has been hanged." - Harry Truman

27. "You have to have been a Republican to know how good it is to be a Democrat." - Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis

28. "Brains, you know, are suspect in the Republican Party." - Walter J. Lippmann

29. "Herbert Hoover once ran on the slogan, 'Two cars in every garage'. Apparently, the Republican candidate this year is running on the slogan, 'Two families in every garage'." - Harry Truman

30. "Suppose you were an idiot. And suppose you were a Republican. But I repeat myself." - Harry Truman

31. "Democrats legislate; Republicans investigate." - Lyndon Johnson

32. "A gathering of Democrats is more sweaty, disorderly, offhand, and rowdy than a gathering of Republicans; it is also likely to be more cheerful, imaginative, tolerant of dissent, and skillful at the game of give-and-take. A gathering of Republicans is more respectable, sober, purposeful, and businesslike than a gathering of Democrats; it is also likely to be more self-righteous, pompous, cut-and-dried, and just plain boring." - Clinton Rossiter

33. "The Democrats are the party that says government will make you smarter, taller, richer, and remove the crabgrass on your lawn. The Republicans are the party that says government doesn't work and then get elected and prove it." - P.J. O'Rourke

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

XX, this constant painting all liberals with a broad brush, and many times a very false brush, isn't making any headway at all. In fact it really is pointing out what a group of malcontents the far right wing is.

I'm liberal and most of what was listed isn't my position at all. In another words it's pure and simple bullshit.

You would do much better, taking conservative articles that bear some reality and debating on that level.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

XXJeff,

Do you have any liberal friends, family members, coworkers, anyone? Surely you know someone that fits the liberal "label" you are fond of posting seeds about, I'm wondering if they reflect the attributes listed here.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

But O.K. see how you like it.

Yep.

A liberal is...

I'm very liberal and about 99% of what you say (or the author you got it from says) is pure horseshit. I don't believe almost any of those things. Obviously he (this Tom Trinko guy who wrote this garbage) doesn't know any liberals.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Ok, but do you?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

But all the conservatives suck and GOP/Tea Party bashing we see fro far left of center seeded sources are of course A-OK with you. It's just that many on the left, used to having a monopoly on the media, are not used to having to take it as much as they dish it out.

Go ahead and give specifics and I'll match you source-for-source and then some. No generalities and summary demagoguery as usual back it up; I never bash a source without giving counter information to a source's bad content. And frequently I tell the names of the individuals and organizations behind the source.

If you want to link right-bashing links, I'll more than match those as well.

Try me.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

This whole Liberals vs Conservatives shtick is so old hat, but most everybody obliges. What this old hat shtick does is pretends that there are just two contending political orientations or philosophies, and they exist at either ends of a simple, linear spectrum, with X and Y at either ends, ignoring the third second and third dimensions altogether.

Without taking a position on which specific existing models should replace the simple-linear Conservatives versus Liberals shtick, I offer the political compass as one model which at least stretches the the imagination wide enough to incorporate what the simple-linear opposition of Conservatives vs Liberals offers. At least this example shows that political views are indeed more complex and diverse than what Mainstream (Corporate) media and politicians would have us realize.

The items listed in the opening post have the aroma of trolling about them.

Scroll down here for a few other examples of possible ways of graphing and charting political views.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Welcome James!

As an independent, I hate being pigeonholed. I am divorced of a party and make up my own mind, issue by issue. But I have nothing against people who want to be in a party, and I could live without the slamming that goes on.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

A liberal is someone that believes lots of money should be spent and laws passed to advance a certain set of causes that half the country disagrees with. A conservative is someone that believes lots of money should be spent and laws passed to advance a certain set of causes that the other half of the country disagrees with. Seems they share a common desire to turn ideology into law.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

A liberal is someone who condemns Israel, which lets Arabs vote, and extols Hamas, which calls for genocide against Jews.

A liberal is someone who hates the Confederate flag but who has no problem with the hammer and sickle.

Wrong (again) on both counts. You really don't know any liberals, do you?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It is likely he knows well the typical big city urban progressive leftie quite well.

That's me and I still don't believe almost anything that is on that list. Apparently he hasn't the slightest fucking idea of what a liberal is. What he wrote is just a bunch of old stereotypes that only some (in a bubble) Conservatives think are how liberals feel, but that are a load of shit. The list is just plain wrong. I doubt he knows a single "typical big city urban progressive leftie" at all

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

You mean the ones that you don't know and so feel free to make stuff up about?

Right.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

That is politicians and what they want you to think.

If we could actually have a straight talk without the whole demagoguery and labeling bullshit, we would find that most people agree on the core issues with the disagreement coming on certain specific issues, and those issues are the ones that are amplified by the politicians to gain traction and to divide the people up into more easily manipulated voting blocks.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

But it's still just plain wrong. First of all we don't engage in "group think" or have a "herd mentality". If we did those things, then we would not be, by definition, liberals. It is impossible to be a liberal and do those. We are all too individual, especially in our thinking, to do those. No two liberals are exactly alike enough to fit those categories. We are all different.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

I have taken the test long, long ago and was at -4,-3, making me a liberal libertarian.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

If you agree with the article and you don't know any of the subject group, then you are saying, in effect, this is what I think about this group. Therefore, even though you didn't actually make the lies up, you agree with them, and that is as good as making them up yourself.

Actually, I think it is worse than making them up yourself, for you accept without batting an eye what some talking head tells you to think.

Think for yourself, damnit.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I am -1, -1,

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I won't take the test. I don't believe it's accurate. It's far too simplistic. I believe it would take much, much, much more extensive testing to see how a person fits in the political spectrum.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Well, it does force you to make decisions that I don't find accurate to me. There is no neutral to pick from. I think I would have to agree with you somewhat Randy.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Then I am somewhat happy.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

It does "force" one to agree or disagree with certain statements that should be given a more nuanced take, but still in agreeing or disagreeing you can build a somewhat accurate profile.

I had the same problem when I first took the test, so I did it multiple times to see what the variation would be, and have taken it several times, spaced years apart, and still it puts me in the same relative area.

Shrugs.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

I went deeper...

Your Political Compass

Economic Left/Right: -7.38
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -7.54

personalised chart

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I figured it out! The original list of what a liberal supposedly is was written as a satire! NOW it makes perfect sense! Grin.gif

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

On all of the graphs of the same basic kind, I always end up way down near the left bottom corner of left libertarian.

I've had capital L Libertarians tell me "There's no such thing as a left libertarian". Heh.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Well, I'm certainly libertarian on social issues. And I'm not so certain I'm a "statist" at all. How would you define a "statist"?

I lean strongly toward the anarchic left, which does not mean I'm against democracy. It does mean that, to my eyes, we need radical transformation in how we do democracy. Currently, in the USA, there is no real democracy at all. Everything is pretty much controlled by monied interests for monied interests. Political and economic power (two aspects of one thing) is concentrated into the hands of a relative few.

I think we need non-violent revolutionary change. A violent revolution is unnecessary, and would not work anyway. We need folks to wake up and assume power. That's democracy!

I recommend reading David Graeber's The Democracy Project , which shows that the founders never really intended to create a democratic society. In fact, the deeply feared democracy and tried their best to prevent its rise. They succeeded.

In the USA, there is a pretense to democracy only. Not the real thing -- and that's even on the basis of evaluating in terms of the notion of a democracy as a system of majority rule! Never mind "radical democracy," whlch would reject majority rule as the very definition of a democratic society.

We really would need to have radical transformation ... of our thinking, of our discourse, our politicies -- most everything.

In all honesty, anyone who believes America is a democratic nation is just terribly misinformed.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

"I know you are, but what am I." Really? The Pee Wee Herman defense? Your response was right out of the 3rd grade. Pitiful come back.

The truth is that neither you, nor the author, have the slightest fucking idea of what a real, genuine, all-American liberal is, because this "article" doesn't even come close. Because if either of you say you know what liberals are really like, then I'm saying you are just plain lying or you do not actually know a single one in your life.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I'm certainly not going to waste my time digging them up but I think you would have a hard time with the source-by-source and then some on just one particular members past posts alone. (Not naming names, probably don't have to). I will say that poster seems to be XX's arch nemesis though. Looks like people who post these kinds of articles don't like competition. LMAO!

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

In his classic book, On Democracy, Robert A. Dahl explained that, when taken in world historical context, the only meaningful distinction between the meaning of the word "democracy" and "republic" is that one word is Latin and the other is Greek. These two words -- historically speaking -- have always had the same meaning. He got into matters such as the frequent claim that, ostensibly, "a republic" has "a scheme of representation" and "a democracy" does not (is direct). But this does not hold up as a matter of historical record.

There are many ways of having a democracy -- including the form which has a scheme of representatives (or not). But I can say one thing with confidence, a system which concentrates both political power and economic power (now utterly intertwined) in the hands of a small minority is neither a republic nor a democracy. It is an oligarchy. Even if it wears a "democratic" or "republic" costume or veneer.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Perhaps so. But since almost everyone connotes anarchy with chaos, confusion, murderous mobs running rampant and raping / pillaging, we will have a little intellectual work to do before we could decide if this is so.

I associate anarchy with the lack of a ruler, or rulers. I associate anarchy with true -- and radical -- democracy. I do not associate anarchy with bombs or violence or chaos. I associate anarchy with distributed and shared power -- in contrast to concentrated and centralized power.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

And those are?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"Do you associate anarchy with government?"

Yes, but I only associate it with democratic governance -- or government of, by and for the people.

I don't associate it with "government" if "government" means that the people are governed by some elite and special class of people, such as is the case in the USA -- which is an oligarchy, like most ostensibly "democratic" societies.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I have never read the book, but do certainly agree with the premise that there is no real difference between a Democracy and a Republic. I also agree that we either are or are quickly becoming and Oligarchy. The difference between "are" or "quickly becoming" depends on who you are talking to. I am still in the latter camp myself.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

The USA is a bit of a mixed condition. The nation is an oligarchy when it comes to certain important aspects, such as who has power and influence over monetary and financial interests -- which power is concentrated in an existing oligarchy. But when it comes to certain matters of little concern to the oligarchs (e.g., same sex marriage, abortion, social freedoms), the USA is among the freest and most democratic societies in the world.

Bear in mind that environmental and ecological issues are under the control of the oligarchy, as they require constant economic growth to keep their economic system going. They will happily render Earth a dead zone if it will keep them in power.

It helps to understand how power is concentrated in a pseudo-democracy such as the USA. The method of control is largely a matter of manufacturing "consent".

See:

Manufacturing Consent - the film:

See also - The Corporation - a film:

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"OWS broke down, fell apart and was ineffective. Nostalgia value aside."

It broke down, to some extent, and fell apart to some extent and was only partially "effective".

It was also infiltrated, teargassed, and hit with flash bang grenades (and pepper spray) by a militarized police (and state) which fought it as an enemy of the state.

"I'm not worried about anarchy becoming a universal system of societal organization. I am worried about it being a distraction at some point though."

Worry? You'd be in something nearer to bliss if you lived in a world in which a democracy was of, by and for the people -- which is one very realistic interpretation of the word.

"One of the organizers of Occupy Wall St. believes in no borders, for the US or any other country. The United States of America would simply go out of business."

Why should it not go out of business? Sure, perhaps the name of the country could be retained. But should it not "go out of business" under its current form of empire "leader"?

If all of humanity has a common purpose of freedom and justice, of what ultimate value are borders? Maybe borders are useful in a short term scenario in which we are all learning how to transcend them?

"Do you actually believe that is something you will be able to sell, ever, without an accompanying cataclysmic series of catastrophes and disasters, natural and man made ?"

It need not be "sold". People are waking up from the dream of separation which underlies the old familiar world of economic competition, wars, etc. Spend a few hours over the next several weeks learning about the words and works of Charles Eisenstein. He's one of the true prophets (used in a non-religious sense) of the transition humanity is going through.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Reply by JohnRussell 23 minutes ago

"Occupy Wall St broke down, in part, because they had a goofy system for determining what course of action the movement would take, since it had no 'leaders'. They inadvertently provided an example as to why their ideas were ultimately inadequate."

Was it all that "goofy"? Unpracticed? -certainly. But "goofy"? Maybe.

It was certainly MUCH more democratic than the current dominant system in the USA.

Was it perfect? Hell no! But was it worse than the current dominant system? On what basis? What's your argument for it being worse?

When a system is dysfunctional to an extreme, it makes sense to try and experiment with new forms, other methods and approaches -- innovations. Will the first experiments be ideal, just by chance? Probably not. Should alternatives be experimented with? Heck yeah!

"Anarchy, like libertarianism, is one of those societal ideologies that is somewhat fun to talk about, and acts as a utopian fantasy for some, but are completely impractical."

Specifically, Why?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Because every person would be a law unto themselves. Every person would decide what they thought the law was or even if one exists at all and act on that. There would be no society. There would be only mayhem. There might be little tribes of people who sort of agree with each other, but you can be sure they would make war with other tribes that don't agree with them. Pure anarchy or pure libertarianism are not functional for the same reason pure communism isn't. They all leave out the human element. They all leave out how people act and feel and desire. They leave out people's goals or ambitions. In the end they will always collapse. And I doubt it would take long.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

I see we have some Hobbesians among us here.

Thomas Hobbes:Moral and Political Philosophy

hobbes

The English philosopher Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) is best known for his political thought, and deservedly so. His vision of the world is strikingly original and still relevant to contemporary politics. His main concern is the problem of social and political order: how human beings can live together in peace and avoid the danger and fear of civil conflict. He poses stark alternatives: we should give our obedience to an unaccountable sovereign (a person or group empowered to decide every social and political issue). Otherwise what awaits us is a "state of nature" that closely resembles civil war a situation of universal insecurity, where all have reason to fear violent death and where rewarding human cooperation is all but impossible.

" ... a FALLEN state ... " I.e., humans are really, really bad animals, created by Gawd (a.k.a., God) but overwhelmed by The Devil in a Tug-Of-War in which the All-knowing and All-Powerful Lord of the Universe (heh) blundered so horribly that it allowed The Devil a Foothold..."

Really? Theology? Is this what we're talking about? Gawd? I thought we were discussing political theory. But no, we're discussing systems of belief in invisible Sky Beings. Sheesh.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"Will there be laws in your anarchist society ? Who enforces them?"

Yes, sure, why not?

Do you think everyday citizens make laws in the USA? Who enforces those laws? For whom?

Maybe you think The Laws in your country are made of, by and for the people? Just who are these The People, and why would you think so?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

I'll have a look at your videos, JohnRussell. Meanwhile....

"In a Hobbesian world, the only actors of consequence are the state and the individual. In a Burkean world, the institutions of civil societyfamily, religious congregation, voluntary association, business, trade union and so forthmediate between the individual and the state, and the just state takes care to provide an appropriate legal framework in which those civil-society institutions can flourish."

-- from

Now, I'm not saying I'm a Burkean, but isn't that interesting? A "civil society" becomes something of consequence in relation to Hobbes' state versus mere individuals. Imagine that!

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"Deregulation" and a "Free Market" are nothing more than assertions that humans can exist happily in a state of anarchy so long as the anarchy is a Capitalist one where we are grouped into corporations and look out for our own interests. The belief in corporate anarchy is just as delusional ..."

That's for damn sure!

What we have got in the USA now is a form of "corporate anarchy" in which ostensible "Conservatives" ensure the "right" to "freedom" for an oligarchy to extract resources / money at all costs without regard to humans or ecosystems / biosphere.

Of course, this is NOT "anarchy" at all -- it's a system of domination and control -- oppression andexploitation.... It is not "anarchy" because the law and the state are puppets of powerful economic interests who are the real puppet masters -- not real "anarchists". Sheesh.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"We are so far away from the possibility of basing all human society on compelled altruism , which is what anarchy is, that it isn't worth discussing as anything other than make-believe."

Compelled altruism?

Altruism need not be compelled, which is ... um... why we call it "altruism". Could it really be "altruism" if it is forced at the end of a gun?

" ...which is what anarchy is ..."

Is that right? So anarchy -- or non-coercion by a "state" -- is accomplished only by state coercion? Hmm. Interesting. Who knew?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

XXJefferson#51 ,What do you like about each, L ocke, Burke, and Smith?

Do these seem to be compatible in outlook to you?

Do they seem to have strong or significant contrasts?

How do they agree or disagree on important matters?

How do they contrast in comparison to Hobbes?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

He poses stark alternatives: we should give our obedience to an unaccountable sovereign (a person or group empowered to decide every social and political issue). Otherwise what awaits us is a "state of nature" that closely resembles civil war a situation of universal insecurity, where all have reason to fear violent death and where rewarding human cooperation is all but impossible.

But he is wrong because it isn't an either or. We don't have a choice between an unaccountable sovereign or complete chaos. There are many, many degrees of different politics between them. I do still believe however that both anarchy and libertarianism both lead to chaos. That there is no other outcome for either of them possible. Both are doomed from the start.

Really? Theology? Is this what we're talking about? Gawd? I thought we were discussing political theory. But no, we're discussing systems of belief in invisible Sky Beings. Sheesh.

Personally I am an atheist. Invisible sky beings (Gods of any kind) are pure fantasy and do not exist any more then the tooth fairy.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"How does one explain the willing apologists for such, given they have little to profit from it?"

(a) Forgive them; for they do not knowwhattheyare doing. But in forgiving them, also inform them, so they know what they are doing.

(b) Their "consent" is a product of the manufacture of the folks who own the country.Frown.gif

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

People who are free are free to reject, or support, whatever they will. That is why it is called "freedom." How could it be freedom if it is imposed against the will of the people?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Are these birds dwelling within chaos?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

We are not birds. No offense, but that is a horrible example. It's meaningless to the discussion. Humans are no where near analogize to birds.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

It is not an example. It is an analogy.

What, specifically, makes it a poor analogy?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

The point I was making -- regards the birds in that video -- was that intelligent order (social organization) need not take the form of hierarchical structure, authoritarian control, coercion or threat of coercion.... That is, "anarchy" (non-authoritarian social arrangement) is not necessarily a condition of rampant chaos and disorder. It may just result in a very different KIND of order than the one with which we are most familiar -- such as the one maintained by concentrated power and force.

The birds in that video were rather obviously involved in a marvelously ordered collective dance -- but a dance in which none of the birds were leading the dance. This is one of the most beautiful kinds of dynamic intelligence in nature. It is something I've experienced in watching, and participating in, improvisational dance forms such as Contact Improvisation. Whole rooms full of people can share the lead so much that it is the group itself which intelligently leads itself -- not any one person.

But the consequence in whole societies is not a dis-individualizing collectivism like the Borg . Rather, the individual becomes MORE empowered in his/her individual freedom -- not less. The collective goes into action to support such freedom. And a kind of "higher" (or superior) kind of order/disorder emerges, which just works well for everyone.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

Parts of Spain actually prospered under a brief flirtation with anarcho-syndicalism, that is until German-backed fascists and Soviet-backed commies spoiled all the fun.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
"Whole rooms full of people can share the lead so much that it is the group itself which intelligently leads itself -- not any one person."This is great in the entertainment genres - in governance related matters like infrastructure, not so much. Unfortunately, populations reach a critical mass that requires libertarian philosophies to be held at bay, for certain critical social/fiscal obligations.
 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Can Libertarians design/review/fund/build/manage/maintain nuclear reactors/mass transit systems/national defense/ etc? I think not. In fact, the go-to scenario that they like to claim they would thrive at over government, is social services. This is laughable. Give Americans back their taxes with the trust that they will coagulate and address essential government functions, and watch how quickly everything fails.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

The birds in that video were rather obviously involved in a marvelously ordered collective dance -- but a dance in which none of the birds were leading the dance.

Obviously. However it is just as obvious that's not possible with humans. Pure anarchy, pure libertarianism and pure communism are not possible with human beings. So while I understand that the birds move as one with no leaders, humans are not birds, so the video of the birds is completely irrelevant. It is a fantasy example. It is not on point with any of the the political systems of humans at all. It has no bearing on the discussion. It looks pretty, but it is non-functional among humans. The same with anarchy, libertarianism and communism.

It does not fit or work. Humans are not birds, not bees, nor Borg.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

The interesting fact is that right libertarians (e.g., members of the capital L Libertarian party) and left libertarians have ever so much in common, and might even collaborate with one another in such a way as to swing the political discourse into an anti-authoritarian direction.

But..., but...

Right and left libertarians are unlikely to do so ... because left libertarians want nothing to do with corporate (and monied interests) rule, which is what the capital L Libertarians would too often accept gladly. And the right libertarians have no interest in any kind of lower case s socialism -- or lower case c collectivism -- which is total anathema to them, generally.

Am I right? ... Um, I mean, correct?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

You can't really believe that average Americans on the political left are more likely than average Americans on the political right to become " Borg -like," XXJefferson#51 ?

America's political right has obviously been doing more to concentrate politico-economic power in the hands of a small minority of millionaires and billionaires than the left has done. And this is clearly where politico-economic power is maldistributed at present, right? (... um, correct?). Surely, no one here would argue that poor people are the ones holding the politico-economic purse strings ... um, power, in this nation?

Or maybe Donald Duck and Micky Mouse have conspired with the Easter Bunny and Jah-aeezus-[H.]Cha-rieeest to concentrate the politico-economic power ... in vast glowing, golden reserves deep under Mt. Shasta ... with flying soucers from the eighth dimension ... and little green telepathic men-women..., but I digress.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"Humans are not birds, not bees, nor Borg."

Ain't your mamma never sat you down and told you about the birds and the bees and the Borg?

If she ain't, let me a'tell ya all about it....

Go ahead and enjoy the birds and the bees, just don't forget your raincoat. Every Grammah knows it.

But when it comes to them Borg? Now you don't awanna go amessing with those Borg. But ifn you do, let Grammah tell ya how to handle 'em. Don't feed the Borg! That's right. Don't cut 'em any checks. Don't get your credit card out for 'em. Starve 'em to death, chile. Just starve 'em to death before they starve you!

Least that's what my Grah-mammy tol' me before she went to meet her Maker.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Surely, no one here would argue that poor people are the ones holding the politico-economic purse strings ... um, power, in this nation?

They would be, but the political right wing that supports the millionaires and billionaires have convinced them, by using social issues, to vote against their own economic (and therefore power) interests. For every poor or working class white person you can get to vote against gays, minorities and atheists, you make a billionaire smile.

Fortunately they are shrinking in numbers quickly, as minorities increase in numbers, as well as those who are more gay friendly and identify with no particular religion, if are not out right agnostic or even atheist. The poor/working class, Sunday go to meetin', god fearin', white American (especially male) is becoming an endangered species in this country and their support alone is not enough to win the White House any longer. You can not win the White House without the Black vote. You can not win the White House without the Hispanic vote. You can not win the White House without the female vote. And you have to have a large majority of each and most of them are not Conservatives. If you have a minority of any of those three, you will lose.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Perhaps a day will come -- soon, I hope -- when both bread and circuses and divide and conquer will be as transparent a game / ruse to the majority is it is to you and I.

'Course, we'd have to kill... um, recycle ... all of the televisions (very non-violently, of course) first. Or at least the ones chronically tuned to Fox.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
No, it wouldn't work at all. It would be like deconstructing an entire process that has taken many decades to refine, back to square one. By the time we realized what a mistake we made, the world would have passed us by and left us in the dust, while we struggle to recreate a working process, otherwise known as government.I'm not saying that our current process is flawless, as you simply cannot please all the people all the time. However, a prudent gardener continually trims the branches - he does just cut them all off at the trunk.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
No branches should be cut off at the trunk. They are there because there was a need for them in the first place. Like any ecosystem, removing a symbiotic element only creates new conflict someplace else.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

A truly libertarian government is unsustainable and will collapse as quickly as one based on anarchy. Libertarianism is fun to talk about and kick around as an idea, but it simply is not going to happen.

It, like anarchy and communism, leave out the human element. The human desire to become rich, to control other people, to obtain power, etc. It looks good on paper (but then so did what PNAC was pushing and we see what a fuck up that was), but in the end there will be a power structure of some type and it will not be libertarianism.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Uh....huh....

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

ROGLMAO

We need more people like that peasant.

 
 

Who is online





Dismayed Patriot


65 visitors