Independents... Are you NUTS?!?!???
Dont get me wrong there is nothing wrong with being independent! Gather all the facts consider the pros and cons then make a thoughtful decision. That makes LOTS of sense! Hell, I am a flaming liberal, and I do my best to do that. But the situation today presents us with a set of facts that just dont need a whole lot of consideration.
On the one hand we have President Obama... He's done some good things, the Affordable Care Act saving the world from financial Armageddon a few other things, but hes been kind of a disappointment too. Yes, he did have the most obstructionist congress in the history of mankind to deal with, but hes a little over the top with his compromising peacemaker routine a very nice approach for a leader who must govern a population of very diverse ideologies but that only works if there is a general consensus supporting compromise and I gotta say hes been a little slow to recognize he is dealing with nothing less than the second American civil war.
Then on the other hand we have... OMG How is a flaming liberal going to describe the alternative? Well for starters They want you to think they are centrists that they are reasonable that they are the only true Americans that their intention is to save America from the evil liberals. What they really mean is They are determined to have everything there way! Interestingly, they are a pretty diverse bunch themselves Religious ideologues with a moral credo based largely on altruism who team up with Libertarian ideologues that disdain altruism . Many of these people are highly conflicted because they find elements of both ideologies appealing.
I could give you a big laundry list of differences but you Independents are smart enough to figure them out for yourselves. You may not want the kind of Social Democracy some us liberals want, but I gotta tell ya we are NOT the Nazi-Marxist-Pol Pot-Gulag loving evil people the righties would have you believe we are.
So in an effort to explain why you Independents are driving me nuts I provided some imagery to illustrate my views vs. rightie views...
Of course "they" want you to believe this is a choice between the "Nazi - Marxist America Hater" and... well... nice people who are trying to save America from evil liberals.
I gotta tell ya, Independents... IT'S NOT!!!!
I, on the other hand, see people who call themselves Independents... smart, thoughtful people who I respect... saying to themselves, "Hmmm... Let me see now... Over compromising slightly left of center brilliant man... OR... axe murderer... brilliant man... axe murderer... brilliant man... axe murderer... Oh it's so complicated... I'm just not sure."
All I can say to you Independents is...
Tags
Who is online
95 visitors

Well it's been a while... but I finally got inspired to write something...
[Mal puts he quill, ink, and parchment back in the saddlebag on his travois... hitches himself to the travois... and heads off get some cookies for Cassie and Arlo...]
"brilliant man... axe murderer"
Your perception of independent's perception is highly exaggerated .
A real independent has a far more nuanced perception of Obama than that . Clearly both sides are presenting biased views .
Hi Rich,
I will grant that the axe murder image is a bit hyperbolic... as is the Father Knows Best image ( in a different way )... I think the first pair is pretty close to reality.
You should know the imagery addresses my view of righties and my view of liberals , like myself... It is not intended to say anything about Independents except that they seem to see the rightie ideology as credible... which to my leftie way of thinking is utterlybizarre (both the rightie ideology and the notion that it is credible).
I amdeliberatelyexaggeratingthe imagery in order to make a point... which is...
If you think of yourself as any sort of centrist... voting for the crap therightiesareputtingforward is NOT a vote for anything remotely centrist.
I would also be interested in your thoughts on...
Especiallymy commentary on the altruism conflict...
FYI- I tweaked the imagery to clarify my point... Thanks for point that out Rich!!!
Right... It's all our fault...
[Mal wanders off shaking his head...]
Hi Mal,
Nice to see you writing again! Very colorful.
Well, humph!
As you read your view of us and then Mikes, it makes me say, "Stuck in the Middle with You!"
Rich said it best. We have a verynuanced view of politics. But as you can see, Mike is blaming us for the downfall of America, because we put Obama in office, totally forgetting that we also put Bush into office. Howmyopic! When we look atcandidates(and for the record, there is no moderate party as a choice), each of us goes through a check list of what each candidate has to offer, and how it compares to our personal list. Which ever has the most yeas is the guy or gal we vote for.
Also put into the equation is past track record. Now as President, Obama has a record that none of the candidates have in that position. But they do have records, and we look at those, too.
As for this country coming to civil war, I really doubt it. But I do see thegovernmentcoming to a complete stand still, and yes, it can always be worse.
BTW independent is code for liberal to conservatives, and conservatives to liberals. If I could only be that many things in my real life, I could get so much more done!
BTW, I see you remember how to do a great title, LOL!
I guess we were lucid when we voted Bush in a second term. Strange thing... we must be schizophrenic!
Mike,
All I have to say to that comments is....
Really? I mean Really?
Hey wait a minute...
Where's Randy????? He's going to let a chance to slam indies go by?
Hi Perrie,
I am only trying to let you know I don't understand why Indies make it sound like they think the righties are reasonable...
I know you want your own party... but things are so polarized that it will really be up to you Indies this November... So even though you may not have your own candidate, you Indies will determine the fate of America... And if you think President Obama can fix this mess by himself, you are mistaken!!! He needs a Congress that will work with him, making reasonable compromises to accommodate ALL Americans... Yes, that includes righties too... *sigh*
Hi Perrie,
EXACTLY!!! That's why I said...
I know that is a bit hyperbolic... but that is truly how I see it... There is no "nuance" in the choices we have.
Mal,
That is because you are a dyed in the wool liberal, and please don't get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with that, but it also makes it hard to see some of Obama's big flaws. I'm not in love with his ME policies, and I was not happy with the Patriot act, or rendition. I think that we have maxed out our social net because we can't afford it now.
On the other hand, the conservatives want to bring way too much of their "values" into my life. I don't like that either. They don't want any social nets and that's not for me either.
So as you can see, what seems like such a cut and dry issue, for indies (well the one that is talking now) it isn't.
Hi Perrie,
I completely understand... there are things to not like about President Obama...
But what is the upside of the "axe murders"???
LOL, Randy, that is most of us! That is because we don't have a third party, and those on the right and the left like it that way, so it not only forces our hand in an election, but it also gives you someone to blame when you ( the royal you) don't get who you want. All you have to do is read Mike's comments to know that is true. He, like you areabsolutelyclueless to how we vote. At least Mal is trying to get us to think a bit. Make his case to us. You guys just like to mock us and that is just plain insulting.
And where the heck are all the indies tonight. Usually they are not so quiet.
LOL, Mike. Do you know how silly that sounds to me. First, I didn't vote for Obama, second, none of the indies that I know who did, think of themselves as having clean hands or otherwise. They voted for who they thought was the best candidate at the time. Principles? You mean like the high and mighty ones that the people they present us with for president have. Come on Mike, not one of the candidates have any principles. For gods sake, Newt has changed his faith 4 times now. You call that principles while mocking indies for trying to make the best choice when being presented with clowns and jokers.
I would take you seriously, but I know that tonight you must be a joker!
Saying there are NO independents kind of leaves out the voters who are registered that way , right ?
You can't be right enough for Mike... Just go for the ride. Besides, he only takes himself half seriously. The other side is just...just... damn, I'm at a loss for words.
I think that there are people in both parties that sound reasonable. I think that there are people in both parties that sound nuts.
And yes, for ME, it is about having my a third party. Not an indie party, since that would be an oxymoron, but a third party. We are the only democracy in the world with just two viable parties. A third one would make the other two more accountable. I'm foraccountability. I'm for a party that was bought and sold by business. This is what I am after. I know many others who are, too.
Randy,
First, I am a registered nothing. In NY you can't be a registered independent.
And I find that commentridiculous. Like I said, please tell me my voting record. Other than not voting for Obama, let's see if you even come close. Here let me start you with my first election which would be 1980.
And calling people mugwamps is an insult.
"They consider themselves to be somehow above partisan politics. They have a superiority complex."
Maybe they are just repelled by the religious like belief systems inherent in the 2 main parties .
Amen brother, Rich!
It isdemeaning, Randy! And I find none of this funny. So don't wink at me.
LOL! Randy just called me a moderate Republican and you are calling me a liberal? Hummm... I must be bi-polar.
*cough* Bullcrap!
I'm neutral on nothing. I just don't buy into party politics. I have voted in every election, including the last one, and until the last one, I voted for a real candidate. Frankly, I'm damn glad I voted for Nader in the last election, since frankly, when presented with the two choices that your parties presented, I would have voted for Micky Mouse.
Here is the problem, that neither party want to look at. Both have become so polarized and so extreme, that they don'trepresentwhat 40% of Americans believe in. When you finally wake up, you might realize that. Take a trip back 30 years, and you wouldn't be loosing so many members of your parties.
Finally,
I have known Mal for over 4 years now. If he wanted to say socialism, he would have. He's one of the most honest people I know.
I think you mean a party that WASN'T bought and sold...
The ONLY way to make that happen is to get the money out of ALL parties... Citizens United may be the undoing of this country.
Thank you for clarifying that comment. There are also those who call themselves indies that lean conservative.
This is one love affair that cracks me up!
I am an atheist so I guess that makes me a heathen... but I have no reason to hat God.
Sorry about the coffee...
No worries... there are lots of labels to replace that one... That seems to be all we do anymore... label absolutely everything... it's all about "spin"... "Marketing"...
Speaking of labels... Have you notice that righties don't use "Bleeding Heart Liberal" much anymore... makes us sound too nice... The new strategy is vilify... the Ax... er... Republicans love to vilify us lefties.
I think that it's sad that we have to label each other.
Just sayin'
Mal will attest to that!!!
That is very true, Perrie... But I would like to offer a hypothesis... Polarization was instigated by... not the Republicans... by the people who are to the far right of what used to be the Republicans... In reaction, many more moderate lefties were forced to move in the opposite direction in an effort to keep the boat from capsizing... I have heard that from many of my leftie friends... and it is most certainly true for me. I would also like to point out that when the extreme righties took over the Republican party and started "purifying" it... Lefties like me started begging and pleading for compromise because we could see that the far right was deliberately trying to divide the country (i.e. starting the "Second American Civil War"). God knows I don't want any of that Ayn Rand crap... but I recognize that compromise it the only way we can have a "united" country, so I was willing to compromise... even with the far right. It wasn't until I realized that the righties were using (more like abusing) our leftie propensity for compromise in an effort to shift the center to the right that I said "enough's enough."
But it's because that politics has become so reactionary, that both parties don't represent the other 40%. During the Reagan years, we had the "Moral Majority" and yet, there was still more moderation in both parties. You could say the same thing for Clinton. It seems that what has happen is that the word "Moderate" has actually become a dirty word. If you are a conservative, moderate means wishy washy, and if your a liberal, moderate means mugwamp. I have been trying to get a video from Bob Schaffer about this. When it comes up, I will post it. He expressed what I am trying to say so well.
Where is Feronia when I need to have to guys thrown into the pool?
LOL, yes!
I agree!
Well, it would depend on the axe murder....er Republican.
Newt.... too extreme.
Santorium...too religious.
Romney....looks more like a moderate. I like the fact that he didn't sign that Tea Party pledge. I would have to hear him in debate with Obama.
[looks for Feronia... not around....pushes Mike into the pool]
Damn! That felt good!
Thank you Bruce for saying what I couldn't find the words for!
I love it when you call me cupcake. BTW, I had to read back to catch a comment made by you. Thanks!
Yeah, that's right, the rest of us just hate America.
I'll just have to tell my dad that. He's gonna be very disappointed that he wasted his time for the first 15 years as an adult defending this country, because he really wasn't a good American, what ever that is.
Here it is:
So you are saying that one must be either for or against? Well then, I will choose against. I am against the Democrats and the Republicans. Am I nuts? Only because I can't afford the lithium. We are in this position because too many people for too many years have said, "I don't want to help my neighbor, let the government do that." Beware of letting the government help you.
Being a brilliant man does not preclude you from being an axe murderer. Your syllogism is incorrect and leads to a false conclusion.
I think I'll cast my vote for the bi-polar lady.
Well said Steve!
Thanks Steve! I guess we can both be nuts together! Nothing like good company!
I find it interesting (or perhaps disturbing) that those on both sides, who complain about the polarization of this country only offer more polarization. I do not see the consideration in that. I am simply unable to back track the logic to discover the premise of that solution.
This is very true. The reason that you can't track the logic to it, is that there is none. What is used for this polarization, is emotion, and emotion is never logical.
Randy,
Sometimes a moderate is just a moderate. Look, if I like somethings that the democrats say, and I like some things that the republicans say, (depending on the issue) what am I? A moderate.
It's you who have your mind made up and need to wake up and smell the coffee. Life is shades of gray. Moderate is gray.
I don't think that I'm superior. I have my beliefs and you have yours and Mike has his, Mal has his and so on. Superior has nothing to do with the current state of affairs in politics. When the TWO parties, start to represent a more moderate POV, well be more than interested. Again Randy, you are projecting.
Having grown up farming and ranching I know what to do with bullshit. You take out your knife and scrape it off. So how do you define an independent?
Or perhaps, being the crazy people we are, we are only figments of our own imagination? You may call me a moderate, independent, third party, or any other tag you wish. I am not so concerned with the label. Just don't complain about my work, I have always put in my hours.
Randy,
That is total BS. I happen to be involved with Americans Elect. For those other indies who are interested in moderation here is their addy:
You tell it as it is Steve!
The "moderate wings" have become less representative of the 2 parties . Now the rhetoric one hears on the media involves heated ranting from the most extreme elements of either party . That seems to be especially true of the GOP . The DEMs have their own weird distortions that they present .
And you call indies superior? LOL Randy, read that statement over. There couldn't be more arrogance in it if you tried.
Tru dat, Rich!
You are Randy.
You mock when we don't belong to a party. I tell you that I am involved in American's Elect and you mock that. I thought that liberals meant open minded. I guess not.
I know Max. But it's very infuriating!
You know Mike... sometimes you feel like a nut, sometimes you don't.
Almond Joys have nuts... Mounds don't
"Pick a President, not a party"?
What kind of dumb crap is that?
The way it should be. You should believe in what the person is saying. Not towing the party line.
And anything left of you, is left wing.
LOL... Good one Bruce!
But I bet they were tasty!
No one thought Carter could be elected because no one had heard of him. Your statement reminds me of something my mother's second husband told me back in 1971. "Why waste your vote on someone who won't win?"
Why are you so insistent that there is no alternative? There are always alternatives. Not always pleasant, but sometimes necessary.
Again, spot on Steve!
Mike..
You crack me up!
Randy,
Your no liberal in the truest sense. You are one of the most closed minded individuals here. That isn't liberalism at all. So your opinion counts for nada.
And I do haveprinciples, and so your comments stands, warts and all!
Mike,
Good for you! The extremes agree proving once again, why your parties are so unsavory.
Speaking of videos, Perrie... Did you happen to look at the Mike Wallace interview of Ayn Rand that I linked in the article... I think you might find that interesting.
Independents should not be confused with indecisive people . They merely don't jump to conclusions based on some ridiculous party line . As a result they have to actually think for themselves . People from a party DON'T HAVE TO THINK ! That's what makes it so appealing . They can be as intellectually lazy as they want but still "contribute" , at least in their own minds .
Romney is the "Just tell me what you want me to say and believe and I'll do it if you will just pleeeeeeeease make me President."
And BTW... I would like to point out that this is NOT just about who gets elected as President... It would be nice to have a Congress that has making life better for ALL Americans as its priority rather than doing everything it can do to make President Obama and the Democrats look bad as its priority.
Hi Steve,
Well actually, I am saying it looks like... if you choose to vote in November... you will likely have two choices for President that have a reasonable chance to get elected. I have characterized one as an "Over compromising slightly left of center brilliant man" and the other one (pick one there all very similar) as and "axe murder"... Okay... I admit my "axe murderer" characterization is a bit hyperbolic... but it is an effort to make the point that they all (the Republicans) want chop the American middle class to pieces. You may not like either option... but the contrast (between the two likely choices) is so stark I find it incomprehensible that any thinking person would pick the axe murderer...
Hang on a minute there, Steve... I... the flaming liberal... have been begging and pleading for compromise for more than two years... Ask Perrie!!! As I said said in another comment...
I must repeat this... God knows I don't want any of that Ayn Rand crap... but I recognize that compromise it the only way we can have a "united" country, so I was willing to compromise... even with the far right.
I am NOT a proponent of polarization... furthermore, it is very unfair and inaccurate (but I must say typical of Indies... no offense Perrie... and righties) to characterize lefties as "only offer more polarization"!!!!!!! It is the very nature of lefties to be compromising... that is why the righties are able to have so much fun taking advantage us. Personally... I think this whole "A pox on both your houses" bit is another strategy instigated by righties masquerading as Indies.
Perrie!!!! It is NOT true... and you know it.
[Mal wanders of... sad... dragging his tail...]
Mal,
It's not true with you! You do try and compromise, and that is why I have always respected your opinion when it comes to politics. But I would like you to read through all of the comments here, and tell me that I have not been put down and insulted, by both sides in your absence. That is what I am talking about. I would hardly call it compromise in any sense of the word. And this is abasicallyfriendly crowd.
So lift up that tail of yours, but be alert. Not everyone shares your outlook.
Your characterization is not supported by facts. It is one thing to say that you don't like that what he does or stands for. That is your right and something I can respect even if I don't agree with it. There things about his approach that I don't care for... not least of which is the "over compromising" piece... but there is LOTS of evidence to support the notion that he is highly competent. Characterizing him as a dolt is just simply erroneous, and thoroughly reveals your bias. As for the Constitution... there are Constitutional beefs I have with him myself... but your assertion that it is his INTENTION to "shred the Constitution" is another typical piece of right-wing propaganda. Neither you or I know everything he knows which undoubtedly factors in to his decisions. To be fair, that holds true for GWB and the real man behind the green curtain, Dick Cheney, who I saw as people who, if not INTENDING to "shred the Constitution", had no compunction about walking all over it.
Perrie,
Very succinctly summarized!
So what IS the alternative, Steve???
Amazingly candid of of you Mike!
Perrie,
First of all... I have only seen two lefties in this discussion... Randal and me... I don't concur with Randal's characterizations but whether I do or not says ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about whether liberals are generally willing to compromise or not. It speaks only about our views of what it means to be an Indie. If you find Randal's comments insulting that does not mean he is not willing to compromise. If Randal is not willing to compromise, it does not mean that characteristic is common to all lefties. As a leftie, I am NOT unique in my willingness to make reasonable compromises. There were once many Republicans who were willing to compromise... Democrats and Republicans once worked together to GET THINGS DONE for the benefit of the whole country. I don't know where they have gone, but they have been overwhelmed by these right-wing purists.
As I told you... It was YOU who provided a large part of my inspiration to write this article. I see you as a very smart, reasonable, "thinking" person... Being independent is VERY important to you... so much so that you want to have something significant upon which to make an "independent" choice. As I have said... there are plenty of things about President Obama to find fault with... but no matter what you don't like about him and other Democrats... he and the Democrats offer a FAR FAR more reasonable and MUCH more centrists approach going forward than the alternative. Much as you may want it to be, it is NOT a "nuanced" decision that is before you.
You are confusing "envy of the rich" with "resentment of exploitation by the rich."
Well good! You might want to consider that other people have different life experiences than you have had. Of course if you subscribe to what Ayn Rand said in that video I posted... (paraphrase) "Being concerned strictly with yourself is the proper moral credo. Altruism is bad." Well... then you probably wouldn't want to give much consideration to other peoples life experiences.
I did. I have never been a big fan of Ayn Rand. I find her making excuses for being selfish. Even "The Fountainhead" gets on my nerves.
I think that they are still there. I think that there are elements within both parties that want to work together. It's just that they are drowned out by the louder voices of those who don't want to compromise.
The only one of the republicans that I am looking at is Romney. He was the governor of a blue state, so he must be able to compromise. He also refused to sign the tea parties various pledges. Still, one can only tell when it comes to the debates. None of the other candidates are a good fit for me.
Sadly, my main gripe about all of them, is that they have been bought and sold by big corporations and PACs. The reason I so long for a third party... any third viable party, is that I think that it makes them all accountable.
Now I have a story for you. You say that there are only two liberals in this discussion, and that is true. But one of my last discussions I had on the vine, was with Jack Gillis. He was yucking it up on one of lisaed's articles with her and other republicans and democrats at the stupidity of the idea of when congress had to sit mixed. I said I liked the idea. He scoffed. I said it made for compromise, and he told me in no uncertain terms, that he DIDN'T want compromise, and he wished that us indies would get over that idea.... and stop trying to pollute the democratic platform. He was joined by many others on both sides saying the exact same thing. It was then that I realized that there are very few Mal's in the world. Iactuallyfelt badly for you. You have a big heart Mal, but you are more unique then you give yourself credit for.
Mal ,
if you subscribe to what Ayn Rand said in that video I posted... (paraphrase) "Being concerned strictly with yourself is the proper moral credo. Altruism is bad."
Here is where my position as an independent is more realistic than either your liberal views or the Ayn Rand style conservative views . It doesn't matter how much your heart bleeds for the underprivileged . You CANNOT help them ALL . There are just too many needs that exist .
OTOH saying that the only thing that matters is the market mechanism and being concerned only with yourself
is a completely heartless POV . There needs to be a compromise view somewhere between the above 2 extremes .
And , in fact , that is how things are done in the real world .
I don't feel exploited by the rich. I feel exploited by a government that favors the rich. There is a difference. When a government doesn't serve the people but business and corporations, then it stops being a government for the people and by the people. Being Rich isn't a crime. Using your money toinfluencepolicy is.
Otherwise, I have nothing but respect for the self made man.
Wow... way to go Mal!
I don't believe you .
Mike, it amazes me how you can pull one sentence out of a comment and build a wholeargumentaround it. I said that when the rich influence government I have a problem. When Monsanto can put mom and pop farms out of business because they have people on SCOTUS and the FDA, I have a problem. When corporations are treated as individuals I have a problem. It's not class warfare, which is what you are driving at. It's what our government allowed to happen.
Yeah, damn those people working for less than $30,000 a year for doing the jobs that no one else wants but the illegals.
The irony is by using the term "filthy poor", you set up the exact class warfare that you claim that I am doing.
Mike
You asked and now eat your words:
Hey, they do the dirty jobs so you don't have to.
Be glad!
Well the thing that comes to mind for me right off is the near collapse of the world wide financial system brought about by abusive investment bankers, colluding rating companies, insurance companies, and others to peddle junk investments... requiring unprecedented bailouts using tax dollars supplied in large part by average people in order to prevent the collapse. The people who perpetrated this crime suffer no penalties, and are currently more profitable than ever... meanwhile the people who bailed them out... average people loose their retirement savings, then their jobs and homes.
While I did experience some personal losses because of that fiasco, I am far more fortunate than others who had little or no investments to loose... people who, after after loyally working for many years, are thrown out of their jobs because the company to which they gave years of hard word has discovered it can be more profitable hiring labor in some other country.
All this justified by the notion that "free market capitalism" is has a better moral basis than "regulated capitalism." Well even though I haven't personally lost my job to outsourcing, I can certainly understand how someone who has worked hard for decades would feel "exploited" by a person who discards them just to get more profit than they would otherwise get.
These are not people who are envious of the the wealth their bosses have acquired. In fact, were it not for having been discarded by their bosses with unabashed Ayn Randian self-interested justification, many of these people would respect and admire their richer bosses. These are hard working people who are resentful because they are nothing more than a means to an end for the rich folks they would otherwise appreciate for having given them opportunity to work hard for a decent standard of living.
Good Answer Mal! Good Dog!
Well Perrie and Mike... I have to say it is class warfare... Mike, you see it as the poor waging war on the rich because they are envious... I see it as the rich waging war on the middle class (nothing to be gained by waging war on the poor, and gain is want its all about) because it makes them even richer and they never seem to be satisfied with being just plain old rich... they want to be as rich as they can possibly be... They want to own all the hotels and have all the money from Board walk to Park Place.
Well... yeah... That actually makes lots of sense!!! Because it isn't reasonable to ask people to pay taxes if they are having trouble putting food on the table and a roof over their heads. I know... You seem to think that the poor like being poor because the government give them lots of free stuff that's paid for with your money. But that is a twisted piece of rightie propaganda... Oh, I'm sure you can find a few cases to support your assertion, but that is not the case for most poor people... Give being poor a try some time and see if you get so hooked on all the free goodies that you just want to stay poor.
That isn't supported by the facts... Most of the rich pay less as a percentage of their income than middle class people pay. Yes they pay more as a percentage of their income that the very poor pay (at least some of them do, other rich folks get away with pay no taxes at all)... but as I said, that (poor people paying no taxes) is as it should be. When we don't make enough for basic survival we should not have to use any of our very limited resources for the common good. When we make more than that but only modestly more, then we should contribute to the common good accordingly... modestly, and when we are very very successful we should give back even more to the society that provided the opportunity for the success we have enjoyed... Unless of course... you agree with Ayn Rand's notion that working for the common good is a bad thing to do.
I know Perrie tells me you say stuff like that just because you get a kick out getting people riled up... Well... I hope your having fun, cuz it worked on me... I find that kind of rhetoric patently disgusting whether it is serious or not!
Mike,
Unregulated investment bankers do unscrupulous things and in many cases commit crimes.
The Government does what is necessary to avert an unprecedented catastrophe caused by the unscrupulous greed bankers.
So... the Government is at fault. WOW!!! Very "creative" reasoning Mike! I see how this works now... no matter what happens or who does what... The government is just bad, bad, bad, and always, always, always at fault. Got it.
Dun da dun dun... DUNNNN!!!!
[Government agents enters stage "left"... Woman is sitting quietly watching "I Love Lucy" reruns...]
Gov: I'm sorry mam... You must go with us now...
Woman: Huh? What... Why are you doing this...
Gov: We'll explain later mam. Please get up.
[Woman stands looking confused... The agents drag her out of her rented dwelling...]
[Agents and women enter upstage center... Mortgage broker is refiling through reams of unimaginably complicated legal documents...]
Gov: Here she is. You got the paperwork ready?
Broker: Yep. Please sign her mam... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... and here... aaaaaaand here.
[Looking bewildered... the woman signs... and signs... and signs... and signs...]
Gov: Thank you mam. You are now the proud owner of a a house we know you can't afford...
[Evil laugh from Gov and Broker...]
Mike,
I did my best to find out where you get the notion that the "government forced companies to lend money to the filthy poor."
The best I have found is Ron Paul's Op Ed on CNN ... In which he "asserts"...
The Community Reinvestment Act , passed in 1977, states...
The law was pass in an effort to prevent the practice of red-lining, a well documented practice that made it difficult, if not impossible, for people in certain geographical areas to be considered for housing loans. These geographical areas were populated overwhelmingly by poor people, and significantly by minority race poor people.
The government did not "force" banks to make loans to people who were not properly qualified to undertake the loans as you and your Ayn Randian hero, Ron Paul, assert! They encouraged institutions to help meet the credit needs of the local communities in which they are chartered consistent with the safe and sound operation of such institutions .
Ron Paul is conveniently ignoring the "consistent with the safe and sound operation of such institutions" piece of that act.
Ron Paul asserts, as most likely you do, that the government should keep its nose out of almost everything... and that it is inevitable that anything government does will have a worse effect than if government does nothing at all.
You can choose to lay the blame on government because it...
a) Enacted an anti-discrimination housing law...
b) Then repealed the Glass Steagall Act and other regulations (hmmm you probably think that was a good thing because it brought about less government regulation)...
c) Made it possible (not mandatory as you assert) for lenders to engage in predatory lending practices (the unscrupulous things I was referring to)...
But as I said, I see that as VERY " creative " reasoning. Reasoning that supports your desire to view the government as the root cause of most (if not all) problems.
I don't feel the government is without fault... It hasn't made much effort to prosecute the law breakers... That may be because many of them may not have broken the law because the government acquiesced to pressure by the lending industry to repeal regulations like Gass Steagall which helped to prevent abuse. Unlike you, I feel the problem could only have been averted with more government regulation... not less.
Mankind keeps giving us proof that most people will, as Ayn Rand asserts they SHOULD, server their self interests without consideration for the negative impacts their actions may have on others. Ayn Rand asserts that this is morally good. I assert that it is morally vacant.
One of the necessary functions I see for government is to establish rules of conduct that make the world as "fair" as possible for everyone. Ayn Rand asserts that "fairness" is not a reasonable consideration. She she is an advocate of the "survival of the fittest" approach for pretty much everything, especially economics.
I suspect you like that approach, I don't. I don't find the "absolute collectivism" she claims is the ONLY eventual alternative to her survival of the fittest approach appealing either... but I don't believe those are the only two choices.
Mal:
Thought you stayed away from politics, especially "flame on" politics! LOL
Hi Terry,
I haven't written anything "substantive" for quite while... I just gotta wait for the inspiration to happen... not something that can be forced.
I have another one simmering on the back burner... It's will be mostly about Ayn Rand... partly about how odd the collaboration between "altruism disdaining" Libertarians and ostensibly "altruistic" Christians seems to me. Also I plan to touch on some of the "borderline sociopath" statements Ayn Rand made in the 1959 Mike Wallace interview (linked in this article). That will one of your favs I'm sure... ;-}
Now even I am curious!
Well, you know the drill buddy, once in the lion den expect to be chewed on some!
Seems to me that Rand has had a pretty good run, the lefties' gods, such as Lenin, the Little animal, Mao, not so much.
Ahhh... the birds and the bees...
Oh there been plenty of chewin'... Ive got the teeth marks to prove it!
You've also got some scratches behind the ear, Mal!
Ayn Rand is one of my fav sociopaths of all time ...
Aren't they fun... those sociopaths...
Number 1. Holy Moly. Conrats Mal!
I have no doubt! Well... Mal might have more bones in his crawl space!
Ah, now I see where this came from. Already made my stance clear on NV.
So true!
See Mal, we can agree on something. I do believe that we, as individuals, should help our neighbors. However; far too many people have decided that it is easier to let the government do it for them, and so the government has been taking more and more. Which leads me to your question of what I thought the alternative is.
At this point in time I see two paths. (Maybe if I had some spice I could merge those paths.)
One path leads to some real ugliness. Civil-class warfare of some type. And I don't think it's going to be a war of words either. This path will leave America nothing but a burned out shell. Not the kind of future I'm really looking for, especially for my grand kids.
The second path is one of community based government with a far more limited role for the federal government. (I still need to do more writing and research to fully flesh out this thought process. But I'm working on it.)
Mal ,
"Aren't they fun... those sociopaths..."
The sociopaths are OK in my book . The psychopaths not so much . BTW have you seen the newest version of "Sherlock Holmes" on PBS ?
Mike...
Do they whisper in your ears at night?
You might want to repeat it here Jay. Some of the members can't get over there, if you know what I mean.
Hey... how do you know that they had unwed mothers... anyway... that's in these days.... get with the times.
Wait.. is that PC?
I know that you do!
My replies there have snowballed somewhat, but my stance is that both major parties are irreversibly corrupt and beholden to special interests and lobbyists, with very few exceptions.
The GOP appears geared primarily toward tax cuts, cutting Social spending and increasing Defense spending. That is a recipe for more debt.
The Democrats appear geared toward raising taxes (primarily on the rich), increasing Social and other spending, cutting only Defense spending. That too is a recipe for yet more debt.
Neither party will bend toward the other, and the only thing that gets accomplished is the accumulation of more debt. That is not sustainable. Note that our national debt now outstrips our GDP - that is not good, and we will not long survive under such a system.
The race for President (and frankly Congress) is governed by who can raise the most money, and we can see who Big Money is backing here (and who they're not backing). IMO, of all the career politicians (to be fair, I don't trust any of them), Dr. Paul is our best answer, as he appears most geared toward cutting spending in all categories.
Hi Jay,
Thanks for coming back and explaining your POV. I'm sorry, but I have not really been following Mal's article on NV, so I didn't notice what you have said there or what was going on, other than our few comments about the electoral college. It seems here, the discussion has taken a different path. We have been more focused on who should win, from a very practical POV. I actually agree with you about not trusting our politicians. I know that many here agree with that. I am worried about our National debt. I am presently watching the debate, and I do find Dr. Paul interesting and honest. But I don't think that he's electable. I could be wrong, but I don't think so. So that leaves Newt and Mitt, with Mitt being probably most electable. Now your chart is very interesting, since it shows that both Obama and Romney have the most amount of money behind them. I guess that should raise doubts about who are they working for; us the people or corporations.
Agreed. It is hilarious to me that so many see Gingrich as the conservative savior. Hell, that guy, other than being a total asshole (coming from a guy that has met him several times), he is also one of the most "big government" guys going for that is where he secures his power and money.
Somehow, one must discover how to take the growing power and money out of government "service" (said with a smirk.)
Terry,
You met Newt? Huh. I trust a man's judgement when they meet another guy.
Good luck with that. Big money comes from big corporations who have their fingers in every pie. When Monsanto not only has people in SCOTUS but also in the FDA, how can you remove the money from the equation? The word "service" has gone out of these government jobs. They serve themselves, and there in lies the problem.
Sad... isn't it?
It is sad, and depressing when one realizes that given our current crop, all roads will lead to tyranny.
Granted, if the choice were Newt or Obama, I would, with great misgivings, go with Newt as he is an unknown.
In this case, the old saying must be reversed. It's not "the devil you know", but the "anyone but the devil you know!"
I KNOW Obama is leading us to tyranny. I suspect Newt will. Hence, Newt gets the nod.
Thanks Perry and Randal! WOW... I'm honored.
Nothing beats a happy pup!
Actually, It was here FIRST!!!
Well Steve... I think you and I have our hearts in a similar place... we just have different visions for how to make things better. But I am all for finding ways to work together.
I too see the downside path that you see, although I sincerely hope there will never be more than words... You may note, I said...
I think the "words" part of that war is already well underway... Perry doesn't see that.
Hi Rich,
Psychopaths seem to have a generally worse reputation, but I think many people mistake sociopathic disorder and borderline disorder for psychopathic disorder. Psychopaths can be very destructive, but so can sociopaths... but sociopaths often are more purposefully malevolent, whereas psychopaths are usually just plain cuckoo.
I saw a trailer for that Sherlock Holmes episode but haven't seen it myself... Mallarina is more likely to watch it than I am... I don't watch many movies... I have trouble enjoying stories where I don't know the ending... especially where there is any sort of peril involved... and if there is four-legged peril involved count me out... I won't watch even if I know the ending and I know its a happy ending. I prefer documentaries... Okay Rich... which psychological disorder is that... the "I can't stand suspense syndrome"... "cowardice"???
cuz nothing could be worse than Obama...
Riiiiiiight...
Funny how we come to "KNOW" things...
[Mal does his happy dance... chasing his tail...]
Yes Mal, I did note what you said. I had also noted the discussion about class warfare, which is why I hyphenated the two.
I just don't see the Republicans or Democrats as offering much in the way of substantive solutions. Over 25 years ago I decided they both wanted what I had so they could give it to their buddies in ways I did not approve.
The word war seems to be the most strident I can recall in the last 40 years.
You ARE and Ayn Rand fan, aren't you Mike... Here are a few of her quotes that echo some of the things you said...
Right on Randal!!!
For the record, I have no problem saying I favor some forms of socialism. There is nothing about it to be ashamed of. Oh, some righties will say it will inevitably devolve into totalitarian communism... Not any more than Libertarianism will inevitably devolve into anarchy. We can't expect to set the rudder for the course we want and then walk away... course corrections are constantly needed.
Some righties will say, they despise the notion of ANY socialism even if it is maintained in some limited form. Well, that's their right, and I respect it... After all, I despise the notion of ANY Ayn Randism even if it is maintained in some limited form. Here's the deal... The righies and the lefties are all Americans... we need to figure out how to coexist... the alternative is civil war. Please note, Mike, someone I see as having strong "Randian" leanings is saying he favors war because he wants to get rid of people he sees as "problematic" (my word, not his). I have no idea whether he is saying this in jest or not (a little hard to tell at times)... But I am emphatically saying I don't want civil war (even though we already have a relatively benign form of it). I also say I truly do not want any of that Ayn Randian crap... BUT I am willing to work hard to find ways to coexist in the interest of avoiding civil war. Doesn't sound like the righties have any interest in this coexistence idea.
I base my beliefs on facts, what about you Mal?
Note, one fact leading to tyranny, allowing the feds to track you with GPS without a warrant.
You on with that?
Facts are tough to beat, Mal.
Again, merely because you say folks don't have evidence of their claims does not make it true.
In fact, I might posit that you saying one has no evidence should be taken as the opposite.
In fact, we just discussed an issue pushed by Holder and Obama which was a fact that they wish to lead us to tyranny by the government.
Soylent green coming your way if he is elected again.
Note, democrats lie, lefties lie, Obama lies, as do most other politicians. Yet, you only disbelieve those on the right? LOL
Nice to see ya Mal and great article ~woof woof~
Many comments here and very interesting takes on our political system and government. If anything, it seems to me that only having two viable political parties lend to a polarity, one that does not need to be in place. Sure there are issues that folks will either come down on one side or the other, but that does not mean that there isn't another mode of operation to see our selves through issues...one that is moderate in tone and application. I'm not sure that's me (LOL) but I do see that as part of the problem.
Mal ,
I'm not sure where the line is between sociopathology and Asberger's syndrome . Are those considered related ?
As to your "problem" I suspect it has to do with providing a stable home life for your spouse . That would be my guess .
That PBS show "Sherlock" was one of their Masterpiece series . And IMO it was a masterpiece and well worth seeing . This is old concept really needed an update and I think they did a splendid job on it . This modern version goes more into the psychological makeup of the 2 leading characters than the older versions . And the lead character is a self admitted sociopath but a fascinating character . Watching him in action is truly inspiring as to the upper limits of what human beings can accomplish with their mind . Let me know if you want a link .
Just curious Mike... Who, very specifically, are these "lazy" people you find so disgusting???
I do my best to base my beliefs on "facts" too.
Terry, I would never say that I am "on with" everything the government does. There are many 1984-ish thing happening that give me the willies. While I may not approve of everything the government does, I don't believe the government has nefarious plans to subjugate me. No doubt, there are a few bad apples in that barrel, but most are well meaning even if they may be inept. Most especially, I DO NOT think President Obama has any nefarious "tyrannical" plans... which a great many on the right wail about as though they can see "factual" horns growing out of his head.
BTW- How are the feds going to track me with GPS???
Sheesh Terry... You JUST said you base your beliefs on facts... then you say that... which has no basis in fact.
Randal,
Excellent!!! Of course Ayn Rand would say...
or
Also Randal,
Not only are we not "America haters"... I assert that those who accuse us of that simply because they do not like our credo are the ones who are damaging America.
Mal:
"BTW- How are the feds going to track me with GPS???"
Seriously Mal? Again, I base my positions on facts, TSA actions and the actions of our AG.
Holder, our AG, approved methods by which the FBI attaches a GPS tracker to your vehicle. No probable cause, no nothing. And they track your movements, EVERY movement.
He says it was fine, constitutional. Obama agreed. SCOTUS says no, but in a very narrow way.
TSA, investigate their actions?
Fast and Furious, ring a bell?
Come on buddy! We see it happening before our eyes and because Obama says "let's care for the poor" everyone shuts their eyes?
Man, that's scary.
Hi Larry,
Good to see you too!
I am all for having a third party... what the heck, lets have a half a dozen... That said, I believe that vitriolic vilification of those who are different is what polarizes us. We were able to get along reasonably well for many years with only two parties... Yes, there has always been bickering and a nasty comment here and there... but NOTHING like we have today. It is when peddlers of hatred started advocating that people should hate their fellow citizens and think of them as fundamentally evil that we took on the sever polarization we have today. Throughout the history of this nation we have gained strength as a nation by accepting one another in spite of our differences... with a willingness to work together. Now the peddlers of hatred are saying we must fight against each other. Arguing with your fellow citizens for what you believe in and what you feel best is just fine... more than fine, it is absolutely necessary for a healthy democracy. Seeking compromise with those who are different... that is the hallmark of a strong healthy society. But advocating that compromise is absolutely unacceptable... saying that your fellow citizens are evil and their wish is to damage the country...that is "civil war."
I think we have it recording on our DVR... but I'll let you know if we need the link. Thanks for the tip... I'll pass it on to the wife... what the heck, I might even watch it myself... If I do, I will definitely get back to you with my impressions.
BTW- My understanding of Asperger's syndrome is that is NOTHING like sociopathic disorder. Hmmm... I need to look into this... interesting...
Oooo yeah... it is...
[ Mal digs deep into his den... peers our... eyes shifting from side to side... looking... looking... looking... ]
Sorry about the sarcasm Terry... As I said... "There are many 1984-ish things happening that give me the willies." If one WANTS to see nefarious evil intentions... that is what they will see.
I'd be interested in your reaction to what I said in my comment to Larry here ...
I agree that politics and it's discussion in general, seem to grow unhealthy when couched in evocative arguments about morality. I believe that part of the issue is our ability to communicate so quickly andefficiently...world-wide. I'm sure that there was fear-mongering and even out right hatred in various previous political maneuverings; but, most of it was kept locally until we had the technological ability to broadcast shotgun-style, any kinda bullshit a person can think of...and then some. The charlatans have been around forever, now they have the means to con on a larger and immediate scale.
:~)
Precisely!!! And they have discovered, as you said, they can say...
and get away with it... there is no downside to lying, especially mass media "shotgun-style" lying. Imagine that... Lying is protected by the First Amendment... sheesh!
Mal:
I disagree. Hell, I remember reading articles about Lincoln that NO one would consider publishing today.
Larry may be closer to the point.
When you say you hate republicans, it is communicated to many, many republicans nowadays.
100 years ago, it might have been communicated to three, and only then if you were in a strange pub and didn't know who was there.
Mal:
How else are we to judge a person's intentions?
Are you able to read into a person's soul? I'm not, and I suspect most (99.999999999999999999999999999999999999999%) are also not able to do so with unerring accuracy.
Hence, the old saw, "if it looks like a duck, ......"
As to your other post, I would say:
BALDERDASH! I think you are suffering from the "I walked twelve miles in foot high snow, without shoes or underwear to get to school when I was young" syndrome.
Others were NEVER accepted, they had to fight for their acceptance, most times violently, throughout the history of this Country.
Our Country was born of conflict, grew from conflict, and continues in conflict.
You think our Country is more polarized today than in, say, 1861?
Note, I have also noted that those who are constantly bitching about how the other side should "compromise" are doing nothing of the kind themselves.
Their idea of compromise is do exactly what we say and do not expect any (meaningful) compromise on OUR part!
Well, yes and no. I mean yeah, some seem to get away with lying, while others rep's never recovers from a lie ordeceitfulness and they flounder until gone.Some are just plain better at lying than others.
This goes for both parties.
"I'm not at home "
What ?! Get back in the kitchen where you belong woman ! [:~ P
Well presented and I do agree.
Here's how it went down in South Carolina in 2000 and in 2012
"Food (Stamps) for Thought" ... The Republican Primary Race(ism) in the South
Spare me the objective-sounding rhetoric from the right-wing, holier-than-though hypocrites!
With the South Carolina Republican Presidential Primary at hand, common sense Republican voters (if any actually exist there), might have considered jobs and the economy in selecting a candidate; but bigots and religionists considered racial innuendo and Mitt Romneys Christian credentials instead.
Don't think so? It's nothing new.
Lets not forget what George W. Bush and associates did to John McCain in the 2000 South Carolina Primary. After McCain won in New Hampshire, Bushs campaign strategists, i.e. Karl Rove, conducted a push poll against McCain. South Carolina voters were asked Would you be more likely or less likely to vote for John McCain for president if you knew he had fathered an illegitimate black child?.
The objective was to suggest that McCain had a black child. That ugly lie appealed to hater/racist-voters and was particularly disgusting since McCains black child was actually his adopted and dark skinned Bangladeshi daughter!
Bush won.
Given the effectiveness of such race-baiting, one can logically speculate that defeating the black man in the White House, and voting against the Mormon-faux Christian, played a significant part of the outcome in the 2012 South Carolina Presidential Primary.
Winner Gingrichs food stamp President accusations against President Obama, this election's racist buzz-talk got him the victory. it was the Bush tax cuts and a bullshit war in Iraq that put Americans on food stamps and more whites than blacks at that (34% of all on food stamps are white). A significant portion of the WORKING POOR are eligible for food stamps ... WORKING POOR. Republicans who make it easy to export jobs and who defeat legislation to bring the jobs back to the U.S., also kill legislation to raise the minimum wage. The children of the WORKING poor are entitled to eat.
Not all, but many individuals who cry "racism, are often the victims of racism; and many who accuse the victims of playing the race card, often
... LIVE it!
_____________________________________________________
Well done, Mal.
Don't confuse righties with the facts ... they'll one-line quip you every time.
No... But I did characterize what I see today as the "Second American Civil War." No bullets yet... Let's hope it stays that way!
You may have "noted" that but that doesn't make what you noted correct.
That can be said of people on both sides... I would never claim there are no uncompromising lefties... But... from my leftie perspective... that syndrome is far more common from people on the right. Of course, I certainly don't expect you to see it that way. In fact, that is a VERY accurate description of several of the recent "negotiations." Take the debt ceiling "negotiation." Boehner and the President negotiated a compromise involving $3 of spending cuts for every $1 of tax increase... Cantor and the T-people said, "TAXES!!! Uh uh!!! No way!!! No How!!! Not gonna happen!!!" I believe that deal even included cuts to Medicare. Liberals were apoplectic about the Medicare concessions but the President offered it in the interest of making a "meaningful" compromise. This pot calling the kettle black thing is a very common tactic for you righties... but I guess you gotta do that cuz you really have little else you can do. You are smart enough to know that what you really want is not gonna be easy to sell, so you spin your sales pitch (and you guys are really good at spin)... and then yell and scream about how us lefties are doing all of the unconscionable things you are actually doing yourselves.
Like I said Terry,
There are THOUSANDS of examples of stuff that goes out in Ads and now on the internet that is either grossly distorted or an outright lie. People who want to believe these things latch on to them and that's the end of it. Meanwhile, fact-checking organizations debunk the false information... too late... people who want to believe are convinced... Do the lairs get prosecuted... Almost never. Look at the stuff Gingrich is saying... I'm sure I don't need to list it... but just about everything that comes out of his mouth is well documented as false... LAUGHABLY false!!!! Does that matter... No... People who want to like him go with the info that suits their desired "truth." Does he suffer from his lies... well, he probably won't become the next President... and he probably won't even become the Republican nominee (hoo boy it will be fun to watch Karl Rove melt down if Gingrich does get it)... But so what... He is getting filthy rich off of nothing more than his notoriety. Notoriety built on lies.
Thanks A Mac!!! I'm glad you found this. I love some of your... I'm not sure what to call them...
are two excellent examples. I try to avoid mentioning anything about racism because the immediate retort will be "There you go again... pulling the race card." People have all sorts of reasons for hating the President. They certainly can't say, "I hate him because he's black." So they invent all sorts of wildly irrational stuff. Convince themselves, and then make fools out themselves spouting their irrational ideas. I know there are people who don't like him for non-racist reasons as well, but their reasons are not much easier to sell than racism. So... more irrational crap.
I know... and they do have some goodies. I gotta hand it to them, they are masters of spin.
Does that make them news "torquers" ?
It's just simple physics . You can't get spin unless you apply some torque ...
Good one Rich!