Occupy Wall Street? What Would New York Look Like With a Smaller Financial Sector . . . ?
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 14 years ago • 26 comments![]()
After a disappointing year, the big banks are pulling back on their bonus pools. A lot. This is going to be hard on bankers whose salaries are usually a very small part of their overall compensation--and yes, yes, before you drag out the world's smallest violin, let me agree that they have no entitlement to anything more. Nonetheless, people tend to build their life around their expected salaries, and in New York, this choice is particularly important. You not only acquire a large mortgage that's often difficult to unload quickly (closings in New York take months at minimum, longer if it's a co-op), but also things like enormous school fees, higher food costs, and so forth. ( Cont'd )
Tags
Who is online
94 visitors

Here's an interesting related article by Nadia T. Pugglesworth, III :
Hatred of bankers is one of the worlds oldest and most dangerous prejudices
They reeeally recovered quickly from the 2008 slump .
It never ceases to amuse me how those people who are the loudest voices of protest against the "establishment" don't seem to be able to give up the benefits that were provided to them by same. Technology would not have advanced to the levels it has without the needed financing. Let the "occupiers" burn their iPhones and iPods and iPads and all their iShit before they start shouting. The finance industry is an essential component of the engine of economic growth and prosperity. If you don't like it, there are plenty of shacks in Montana that you can live in. I know Ted Kaczynski isn't using his anymore.
Jonathan,
It wasn't a no corporation sit in. It was about the abuses that both banking and corporations do, with the blessing and help of the US government. I'm agreeing with Max.
My take on OWS is what I glean from what people articulate about it. Their manifesto is all very nice, but the underlying theme is that there should always be a leash on financial industry, because they're an inherently corrupt and greedy group. Any good they've ever done is completely discounted as happenstance, while it is presumed that their motive is always personal.
This is articulated most clearly by the people who summarily dismiss Mitt Romney as a robber baron. He, and the rest of the people that participate in corporate finance, are assumed to be participating only for the purpose of making themselves more wealthy. When they succeed, it's in spite of their alleged excessive fees, and when they fail, it's because they were in it for themselves.
Everyone has great ideas, and great points, but it always gets washed away by those who'd point to the failures, and act as if that's all there was.
Same with the OWS people. They have great ideas; they just don't know how to separate them from the torch and pitchfork people.
Stillborn.
Still.
Ahhh.. Mitt. And your primer on equity groups. I should have seen that coming.
So I pose to you, are you not doing the same thing here. I get where OWS gets their anger from. I also don't think of Mitt as a "Robber Baron". So where does that put me? And there are loads of me-s out there.
Whether or not OWS is a still born or not isn't the point. The point is that we can't let industry take over our government, because it then stops being the government for the people and by the people. Anyone who I would want for Prez, would have to get that. Does Mitt, in your opinion? If so, please give examples.
Common folk have no concept that financial transactions involve the risk of loss as well as the possibility of gain .
Whether we choose to acknowledge it or not, we're all "me-s", as you put it. I think I said that in my last post:
I agree - we cannot let industry take over our government. Perhaps. But it is the captains of industry that have a better handle on how to manage, and how to correct the ills that plague us. We see the ivory tower economists constantly offering conclusions based upon complicated financial models. So complicated, that we feel dwarfed by their brilliance. So we implement these Smithian and Keynsian plans. And they work.
Until they don't. They stop working when the game changes. And it's the corporate, real world people who recognize these changes prior to the intelligentsia. Bottom line - industry should not take over government, but they have to work together. And government has to let corporate America take the chances that they need to take, just as they did the first 200 years of our existence. And they have to LET THEM FAIL, as they allowed them to do the first 200 years of our existence. It's not as delicate a balance as you'd propose. And we don't always need a businessman to lead us. But it would be a damn good idea at this moment in our history.
You shouldn't know from it. You can explain something until you're blue in the face. You can get them to sign letters that they understood what they were being told, including risk of loss disclosure.
When they go to arbitrate, they claim that they didn't know what they were signing. And the arbitrator gives them an award.
You have no idea, Rich...
Max ,
You have actually learned that honey is a better come-on than vinegar . Well done !
"the problem is stacking the deck to better insure the possibility of gain."
I agree with that . But the problem is in determining who has stacked the deck and who hasn't . Anyone involved with issuing original CDOs is likely to be in the former group . Most of those would be what are called "investment banks" . But there are many other financial institutions which did not get involved with issuing those instruments . It would be a shame to lump them all together in the guilty group .
It is sticky and messy . OTOH vinegar is stinky . Take your choice ...
What is included in "Wall Street" and what isn't ?
"geez Rich, is your brain on vacation tonight or what?"
As usual Max , you manage to oversimplify . Banking , for example is not exclusively a Wall Street function . But you have managed to lump them all together in the guilty category . Not all of them "stacked the deck to better insure the possibility of gain " .
I can always tell when you are losing an argument .
2 things have been established here :
1] I'm now through with this dialogue
2] You have violated the CoC . I'm exempt from acting as a moderator here . But I'm calling for backup . [unless you'd care to modify your comment now] .
Rich & Max,
Major violation of the CoC. Please remove the personal attacks:
Rich:
I can always tell when you are losing an argument . You get snarky .
Max:
now, i'll keep it simple for your tiny little brain.
pull your head out of your ass
Sometimes, familiararity breeds contempt. I think that is what happened here. Plesse make the edits or the comments will be removed.
Feronia,
I agree. Seems like an off day. I'm waiting for the the changes and I'll be happy.
Max,
Rich removed his comments. Please do the same.
Thanks!~
Gentlemen, thank you very much for your cooperation!
Well , this thread is finished .
C'est la vie
MHO
I think that many folks were monumentally pissed off about the bailouts; more than most bankers or politicians credit them. I would personally like to see us continue free enterprise with an eye towards constant improvements oftransparency.
But what it comes down to is what has free commerce, thefinancialindustry, and banking done for Me? Well, pension plans ain't lookin' so hot for about 6 years. Beyond that, I've bought two houses and five cars in twenty years. I've got a job, a stable one. My wife works a good job also and we manage to manage. We never float over the clouds or flounder under the waves. We've been blessed, and we've worked hard, and our financial institutions have helped build and grow our family and home.
I believe that that message is the one lost.
I have to agree with your analysis Larry. Very well put.