Reverse Discrimination for Asian Students. The Dumbing Down of the American University System
Yesterday, the first round of "EarlyDecisions" for acceptance into universities came back. In my daughters school, of the students that applied to Cornell, only two out of six Asian students got in. This was very shocking, since they are gifted students. What was more shocking, was that white students with lower GPA's and SAT's got in. It was a shock and a heart breaking experience for my daughter's friend, who is a top-notch student, but I was not shocked. I've been reading for a while on "CollegeConfidential", that schools who are not race blind. That schools like Harvard will try to balance their population, even at the cost of turning away better Asian applicants in lieu of other races. It has gotten so bad, that among the Asian community, they are told not to check the Asian box if they can.
While I understand the need to havediversityon a college campus, I also have to wonder if it is fair to pick a substandard student, over one with better qualifications, just because of race? Besides the fact that it's not fair, we are also ruining our university systems. We are not taking our best and educating them, but making the choice by reverse discrimination.
I have always been on the fence about "AffirmativeAction". Having been a teacher in an inner city school and I have seen how being poor comes with huge disadvantages that the middle and upper classes don't have. They don't have parents at home in the afternoon to help them with their school work, nor do the have the money for tutors. I have felt that giving these kids a chance and letting them into the university system with less thanstellargrades was giving them the chance at breaking the cycle of poverty. Still, when I heard of students with better grades not getting into school because the school had to meet a quota, I had mixed feelings.But it seems that things just took a step into the absurd; that doing better gets theoppositereaction. We are actually punishing Asian kids because they excel, which just seems twisted.
As my daughters wait to hear if they have gotten into their "EarlyDecision" school, I ponder over the system that seems to have backfired over race. I wonder which schools really have the top student populations that they tout, which in turn, produces the best students. I wonder at this point, are we dumbing down our university system based on race? It seems to me that we are.
http://news.yahoo.com/asians-college-strategy-dont-check-asian-174442977.html
http://racerelations.about.com/b/2011/04/25/are-u-s-universities-discriminating-against-asian-students.htm
Tags
Who is online
117 visitors

Yes.
OK, let's go with that. Do we just remove race from the college apps?
If we did that , then we'd have to remove religion, sex and ethnic group, as well.
I also have to wonder if it is fair to pick a substandard student, over one with better qualifications, just because of race?
Sorry Per, but that question was answered 40 years ago, and the answer is NO, but that's not going to stop it from being done. At the top universties, there are things at workother than grades to determine who is accepted and who is not, and race is certainly one of those criteria.
As far as the kids who were accepted in lieu of the Asian kids, my impression is that Cornell did not accept "substandard" students to fill the spots in question.
Forgive my cold reaction to this, but no one was around to successfully defend me and my white malefriends against the onslaught of affirmative action when we were attempting to establish ourselves as the cream of our respective crops more than 30 years ago.
It's a failed practice that is partially responsible for our decline as a competetive nation. And two wrongs don't make a right, but please forgive me if I can't muster up any pity for those kids. If they're smart, like me and my buddies, they'll figure out how to make their mark. And they'd be best served if you told them that, in your own, sweet, Perrie way.
See that? I lightened up a little at the end.
Well, Mike, you might have to wait till ya a bit older. Maybe grad school.
Gag...
Jonathan, you are aware, that males number females at Cornell, right? And that the child that was not accepted was a female. How does this bode to prove your point?
Also, you arereferencingsomething that happened 40 years ago. Well, also 40 years ago, a woman with the samecreditablydoing the same job didn't make the same wage as men did, so excuse me if I am not crying for you guys.
And 30 years ago, when you entered the work force, what was the chance that an Asian guy or girl would even be in the game for the same job as you? Jon, this isn't 30 years ago. This is here and now, and what is the big question is are we putting our best students into theuniversitiesor not? We arecompetingin an international world, and if we are going to succeed as a nation, we better get our heads onstraightabout this.
But you are still a god among men.
And maybe we are at a point in our nation, that we should be considering that.
Umm Mike, are not Asians a minority group?
They just don't want to be discriminated against because they are smart.
And they aren't doing anything about it either.
As a teacher, you might want to correct some grammatical errors in the third paragraph. You used the wrong form of break, and in the second-to-the-last sentence the comma is not necessary. Actually, there are quite a few weird comma placements in this article.
Ddant peple know a grammer knotsi when they se'm
I'll tell you what MT. I have to write my articles in 15 minutes or less so that I can cover my otherresponsibilitieshere. If you would like tovolunteeras a proof reader, I'd be glad to give you the job!
These students had more extracurricular activitiesthan any of the other students who were accepted. Not only in hours but in quality; medical labs, debate team, food kitchens, track and field just to name a few. One girl had shelves full of awards. Compared to the kids who did get in (also friends of my daughters)these two girls were way above the rest. These kids who gear themselves for this level of schools, are very competitive. They were always comparing as they fought to get into the top schools. My daughters were no different, and were shocked that these two girls didn't get in.
Perrie.... Lets put the shoe on the other foot
Not so long ago in the military, I watched a husband and wife take the same electronic exams and go through the same boards to become Chief Petty officers. He outscored her on the exam, and had several additional accommodations on his service record, and higher overall personnel performance marks. She made Chief and he didn't based on the quotas that the Navy had set forth for the year. The Navy wanted to promote women in it's ranks, but was it right to do so? Those with two "x' chromosomes were at the time receiving the benefit of their biological makeup at the expense of performance. Was that proper?
Like you I see this issue as a double edge sword. Mike L. sees this as a survival of the fittest he is not wrong, but he is not right either (especially if he believes in teaching creationism in the classroom!!! Sorry I hate double standards.) Red states currently make up the majority of the bottom half of the chart when looking at ACT/SAT scores on a national level. Somebody has to answer the reason why. Are they going to blame it on minorities, or their inherent racial revulsion to paying taxes that allows all those "darkies" to go to school with their white kids?
As I posted somewhere else recently, as a nation, we need to be 1) Teaching to excellence, not just to an average. 2) Every child needs to be provided an opportunity to reach their full potential. To do anything less than that yields a poor return on the taxpayers investment.
Mike L. wants survival of the fittest. In America that now means survival of the richest. I hear the words of the plutocracy loud and clear in his posts.
Hi FlyNavy,
You know, I think we are in agreement here. Your story about the Chief Petty Officers husband and wife was wrong. We should be striving for excellence so no it wasn't proper. The reason in your case is clear. They both had the same chance before. If the husband outperformed his wife, that should have been all that mattered. Standards should be the same, when the the opportunities have been the same.
But it is a double edge sword. The reasons that southern schools are lagging behind are many. The structure of their public school systems, the lack of AP courses taught, the limitations place on the sciences by local school boards, like the exclusion ofevolutionin science. So if you don't live in one of the larger college town cities in the south, you're out of luck.
I couldn't have said it better!
Most of the time. But also it's about the structure of the public school system in the state that also makes a difference.
MT, NOT being ugly! But, please, don't come to my articles with that red pencil! I write the way I talk. Even though college educated, and attending the university with an English scholarship, I make grammatical errors all the time-- many of them on purpose, for the effect. Also, I was taught to put a comma in, every time I took a pause... I try to take the unnecessary ones out, but miss a few!
In high school, my English teacher, Crystal Edds, (and there are many tales I could tell about poor Crystal), wrote the words below on the board, and asked us to correctly punctuate the sentence. Only one person could!
John had had had while Brent had had had had had had was correct.
I'll come back with the answer!
This isn't right.
I think race, religion, politics, etc. should be removed entirely from the equation-- in fact, every student should apply with a number, not even a name. Select the best, and leave it at that. However it shakes out, is the way it shakes out. These poor Asian students deserve the same chance as everyone else.
You know, it has always been stunning to me, how some kids who can't do the work academically, are welcomed to schools on an athletic scholarship. They never graduate, because they can't pass the coursework-- even taking Football Physics. They stay in school as long as they can, and that's great-- but isn't that somehow just using the kids with athletic talent? Once they aren't eligible to play, they are booted out of the program, ill-prepared for anything. Shouldn't those who really need a different education be able to get it, rather than being pigeon-holed into, what must be for them, an academic nightmare?
I think the whole system is a mess-- and always have.
Whoa! The vitriol, the xenophobic language over affirmative action and the sweeping generalizations surprise me. SCOTUS is on the verge of killing affirmative action or severely crippling it. However, those who complain about race-based college enrollment never mention students who get into universities because they are legacies . Think George Bush. He got into Yale because of his relatives, his bloodlines.
Legacy preferences at public universities violate the constitutional provision thatsays "no state shall ... grant any title of nobility." There should be no taxpayer-support of hereditary privilege. So--maybe the high court should consider quashing legacy too.
In fact, legacy preferences continue to disproportionately hurt students of color. John Brittain, a former chief counsel at the Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights, and the attorney Eric Bloom note that underrepresented minorities make up 12.5 percent of the applicant pool at selective colleges and universities but only 6.7 percent of the legacy-applicant pool. At Texas A&M, 321 of the legacy admits in 2002 were white, while only three were black and 25 Hispanic. At Harvard, only 7.6 percent of legacy admits in 2002 were underrepresented minorities, compared with 17.8 percent of all students. At the University of Virginia, 91 percent of early-decision legacy admits in 2002 were white, 1.6 percent black, and 0.5 percent Hispanic.
Moreover, this disparate impact is likely to extend far into the future. In 2008, African-Americans and Latinos made up more than 30 percent of the traditional college-aged population but little more than 10 percent of the enrollees at the U.S. News's top 50 national universities.
( )
If someone isnt admitted to a university there are other reasons:
The National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) reported that in 2011:
Final observation: for anyone to assume that all beneficiaries of affirmative action are educationally deficient are the same folks who believe we live in a post-racial America because of the election of one man, Barack Obama.
Although not college oriented Perrie, here's a recent article that describes EXACTLY what is happening.
Minorities need only apply for tutoring at this school! Can you imagine that?
The answer is:
John had had "had"; while Brent had had "had had". "Had had" was correct.
Wasn't that fun???
Hey, I've gotta agree with MT Larue as to his/her basic issue, though not about the commas.
Come on folks, for criminy's sake, there are spell checkers! And one should never use the word "loose" for "lose" and all the other weird word usage. LEARN contractions! Its is not the same as "It's", or vice versa!
And if you're corrected, one should say "thanks!" That correction might prevent you from looking like an asshat when it actually matters!
As to why "not commas," it's because I have never, really, understood comma usage. My associate who does understand comma usage, corrects my writing all the time. I don't call him a "comma nazi!"