╌>

VW shows two sides of pushy culture

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kavika  •  11 years ago  •  9 comments

VW shows two sides of pushy culture

Edward Hadas: VW shows two sides of pushy culture

By Edward Hadas
October 2, 2015

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

The scandal at Volkswagen might look like the sort of stupid mistake that could easily have been avoided. Not so. The carmakers installation of unauthorised and illegal software capable of falsifying emissions test results in 11.5 million vehicles is the sort of problem that highly successful companies find very difficult to avoid.

Start with an obvious point: fiddling emissions was clearly not a good idea. Such defeat devices were explicitly banned in the European Union in 2007 and had not been tolerated by U.S. regulators for decades. VW itself had a run-in with the Environmental Protection Agency on a switch that limited emissions back in 1973, the Wall Street Journal reported. Then there was a 2007 letter from parts supplier Bosch warning of possible foul play, as reported in the German newspaper Bild am Sonntag. In 2011, VWs supervisory board received warnings of manipulation, the Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung reported.

So how was it allowed it happen? Look to the corporate culture. The feuding cousins at the top of Volkswagen and Porsche promoted people with the same basic management style. In that kind of environment, three things tend to occur. Talented and arrogant executives do well. Bosses fail to delegate important decisions. Subordinates are expected to succeed, not to moan about problems which they cannot solve.

The hard style naturally travelled from top to bottom. So it is easy to imagine the pressure on the engineers who had been ordered to find a low-price way to keep diesel emissions down on a new engine model. The companys reputation for technical excellence was on the line. So was the strategy in the crucial North American market, where VW was struggling. Failure was not an option.

The investigation now taking place at Volkswagen will reveal more details. But it is easy to imagine the reluctance of superiors, all the way up the line, to listen too closely to any hints of foul play. Asking probing questions could cost them their jobs long before any warnings saved the company from a great deal of trouble.

For anyone who has studied the numerous trading scandals at investment banks, the pressure to perform and the reward for closed eyes will sound familiar. At the banks, the desire for higher profits was much greater than the interest in a pure culture. Besides, in an environment where people were regularly fired for no obvious reason, asking hard questions promised more pain than gain. So few hard questions were asked.

In any company, a narrow focus and a lack of strong internal controls are an invitation for trouble. However, single-mindedness is not all bad. On the contrary, it is hard to think that Volkswagen would have grown into the worlds largest car company by revenue with the sort of cautious and open culture in which emissions cheating would be neither tempting not tolerated. More sensitive bosses probably would not have pushed as hard for technological pre-eminence or made the big bets on acquisitions and investments which pushed VW far ahead of its European peers.

Supreme self-confidence is especially important when companies challenge accepted ways of doing business. Uber would still be a small car service in San Francisco if Travis Kalanick spent much time wondering whether he was doing the right thing. But the strong hand of the now-global companys founder comes with all sorts of risks, including a regulatory crackdown.

A few enterprises have managed to maintain cultures which combine aggression and ambition with unflinching rectitude and constant self-examination, at least for a while. General Electric is a definite contender for the global all-round prize. Fans of VWs more luxurious German rival BMW might put it forward, but corporate life is generally easier for producers of luxury products with high profit margins than for mass-market players. Toyota was once the exception to this principle, but rapid expansion eventually compromised the Japanese companys commitment to excellence.

Volkswagen has vowed to change its ways. In resigning as chief executive, Martin Winterkorn said the company needed a fresh start. Toyota promised much the same after getting into trouble over hiding problems with unwanted acceleration. Even Ubers Kalanick sounds a bit less pushy these days. For most big companies, a single-minded focus on growth or profitability brings unacceptably large risks to shareholders, customers and the community. From the perspective of society, such firms cannot really afford to be reckless.

Cautious cultures can be installed by empowering bureaucracies to limit all sorts of risky behaviour. When these are present, companies are safe and dull. Rather than reshape industries, they generally keep doing what they always have been. Executives may emit a lot of rhetoric about change and excitement, but in practice stability usually rules. That is basically where banks are now, and where carmakers are probably heading.

The corporate tedium at is basically a good thing in the complex and already-rich economies of the developed world. The risks from malfunction outweigh the gains from too much radical action. As Volkswagen has learned, determination is a strength but overplayed, it becomes a great weakness.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

To us, (my husband and I), all this is very ironic. My husband has worked on cars since he was about 14-- their body work. That means that he also does all the complicated stuff associated with wiring harnesses, computers, and just about anything that can be damaged in a wreck. In other words, all the innards, too.

HE says that VW's are pieces of crap. Their technology is at least 20 years old, their wiring harnesses are poorly designed and a nightmare to fix, and that their general design is flawed-- causing needless expensive repairs. Sorry to all VW owners out there.

The original VW Bug, had a steering column that was attached to the front bumper, so that a 20 mph head-on crash could easily impale the driver with the steering column. They finally, in the general safety push of the 1980s, designed a steering column that broke in two pieces, to keep that from happening-- but how long did that take? Uh, 1930-1980?

Every corporation seems to have a "culture". Pretty much, no matter what the "culture" is, when it takes over completely, the company has some real problems.

By the way, based on his experience with fixing cars and maintaining them, he drives a 1.5 GMC truck, and I drive a Subaru Outback. My first Subaru lasted 12 years and was dependable. I loved it! His truck has also been dependable, in a rough-and-ready sort of way... VW's look good, and are put together with parts made with clock-like precision. But they are expensive to maintain-- think of all those Panzer tanks, breaking down...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

This ''culture'' that allowed this to happen, IMO, is really going to bite them in the ass. VW is a weak seller in the US, and this might just end it for them here.

Subaru has a great reputation Dower. I have a couple of friends that own them, and they swear by them. They are always rated as one of the tops cars/crossovers. A loyal following and a very safe car.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I think it's going to get them, too.

My car is very "sure-footed", no matter what the condition of the road. And, it does a good job, if maintained, (like any car!). I love that it is a smaller car, yet, I can load about a roomful of furniture in it. I love that it is easy on gas, and is reliable. Rosalie is her name, and practicality is her game! Plus, Rosalie was built in Lafayette, IN.

We have a tank museum here at Fort Knox-- or we did, anyway. It may have moved... Anyway, looking at all of the tanks constructed for WWII, you can easily see where the car's construction came from. I mean, the traits of the construction of the tanks, leads you to understand how the cars are made, from these different countries.

Italian tanks are rattly, break down frequently, and don't have a lot of "solidness" to them-- but they looked nice on the inside. Japanese tanks have millions of little parts that all fit together perfectly, BUT, one piece failing and the whole thing stops-- comfort of the passengers was not a main consideration. German tanks are made with clock-like precision, solid, comfortable, and beautiful, but must be diddled with, constantly. Russian tanks looked like plates of steel welded together-- comfort and beauty were NOT an integral part of their makeup-- but they were solid, even with several design flaws that made them vulnerable to attack. American tanks showed the progression of what they thought was needed, to more of what was REALLY needed.

It's all very interesting...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Corporate culture is a really big topic . I'm going to go looking for more material to link .

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

Subaru has, IMO, the best AWD vehicles around. If I remember they were the first to introduce AWD.

A ''Tank Museum''...Now that would be interesting Dowser. Word of warning, there difficult to drive...

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    11 years ago

I take Bosch seriously.

I use their precision tools regularly to keep the Enoch-abode ship shape.

E.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     11 years ago

I do as well Enoch.

And they did warn VW...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

How I longed for a tank today! A fellow leaving the liquor store pulled out right in front of me, ending up cross-ways in the road. Once again, I missed my old car, Nellie. In Nellie, I could have just kept on going, ("ramming speed").

Subaru seems to be the car of choice for all female geologists. We can't get stuck, because then we have to call the marines to come rescue us, and that goes against our grain, somehow... I must admit, even driving down on the beach by the river, in muddy fields, "climbing" steep hills, I didn't get stuck, once.

This tank museum is at Fort Knox-- at least it used to be. It was fascinating! Especially the Russian tank-- Oh my gosh, it was rough! It had one leather seat, for the driver. The rest were metal seats... I felt sorry for the poor Russians who were stuck in those things. The Italian tanks were somewhat "rakish", but rattled when you stood on it, to look inside-- like it was about ready to collapse in a heap.

The German tank, the Panzer and the Tiger, had about twice the dials as all the rest, innumerable handles, bristled with antennae, and had an interior that was PLUSH. But, German engineering, (and I am part German, so I can say this), defies logic. It's like their language-- the verb goes at the end. And everything "ist Verboten"... A peculiarity of negative German engineering and perspective, that may be seen today. Even today, the radiator of a BMW says, "Wasser ist Verboten"-- water is forbidden. I guess you can add wine, and it will be ok...

The best part of the museum was that you could get inside the tanks, sit in them, climb all over them, and really get the feel of them. I think they've moved it to Ft. Rucker, AL. Not sure-- but we still have a Patton Museum here. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Bosch is a good company, and makes fabulous products. I had a project once to "dewater" where they mined the pure quartz pea gravel used to make some of their products. Down in Boca Raton, FL. It was 99.99% pure quartz, and they further refined it. The formation was this beautiful clear/white pea gravel, deposited in Kaolinite-- the white powder used to make paint. Boy, when the sun hit all that whiteness, I was cooked!

 
 

Who is online


CB


71 visitors