Copts: Behind You Is the Junta, Before you the Islamists
On October 24, the Coptic Pope Shenouda III met with (according to al-Ahram and other newspapers) or was summoned by (according to sources close to him) Egypts ruling military council for an urgent meeting at the Ministry of Defense. The ailing patriarch, 88, whose fortieth anniversary in office was celebrated November 14, was told to come alone.
There, he was berated by the top three generals. After the meeting, the pope wouldnt say much, but the declaration emphasized putting Egypts interest above all, an implication that Christians shouldnt complain or respond with demonstrations to their treatment. Many Copts thought that he had been bullied by the junta.
But if the junta wants to quiet the situation, why doesnt it address and try to resolve Coptic grievances?
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

"First, by dealing directly and only with him, the junta signals that the Copts will be treated as a traditional religious community (dhimmis) rather than as a large portion of Egyptian citizens with a grievance.
Second, that their religious chief will be held responsible for the acts of his people and hence is expected to control them, or else. By the same token, this is intended to intimidate the Copts (inside and in the Diaspora) since they do not want to place their elderly spiritual leader in danger."
Very interesting article Larry.
I am very disturbed by all of this. It seems that things were better for the Copts under Mubarak. These revolutions seem to come with many unpleasant surprises. Right now, the whole ME is in flux, with most of the countries having powervacuumthat groups like the Muslim Brotherhood are all to happy to occupy. Sometimes the devil we know is better than the one we don't.
Nope, no dhimmis here.
Next time anybody tries to make a case for dhimmis as a "protected" class under islam, I'm directing them to the case of the Coptic Christians in Egypt.
My concern has been mounting, and hope retreating.
Coptic Christianity is one of the oldest sects of Christianity, the world is now standing in witness to it's destruction. If we were talking about a mostly Christian nation, destroying a minority muslim population, there would be blood in streets across the globe.
They were somewhat protected before. It's been since the change inregime. I think that this has far more to do with the brand of Islam, as in the "Brotherhood", than Islam it's self. They are also calling for an end to the peace agreement with Israel. Nothing with make the Brotherhood happy, but a totally Islamic region. Oh, and maybe even Sunnis not allowed also.
Which really begs the question about degrees of islamic expression...
...dhimmi is dhimmi and ain't no way to live (I'm sure you agree, I'm just sayin'). While their treatment before Mubarak may have been a bit more benign,,,,,but still! With the Coptic population being just big enough, they represent a significant minority. A simple equation too judge true Democratic intentions, is reflected by it's attitude and behaviors towards minorities. I think that too many muslims stillviewCopts as "the other" and the more progressive will not make a difference.