GOP Plan to Take Away Itemized Deductions
The GOP is planning on presenting a new tax plan that will take away itemized deductions formortgage interest, charitable donations and state and local taxes, to raise money for the deficit. Gee, how nice of them. Screwing the middle class again. How about doing away with tax benefits for capital gains? That's not going to happen. That hurts the rich.
I have to say, I just don't get middle class Republicans. They must like being suckers.
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

The link had no story info ... Here is the corrected link :
Thanks Rich! I fixed the link in the article. Dang, I wonder how that happened?
I could tell you but where's the fun in that ?
Hey, you're derailing...Suspended...1 week!
Wait.... Opps.. that's some other place. Sorry! I take that back.
*snort*
Wait Randy... Your agreeing with my comment. I thought I was a republican in sheep's clothes?
Nadia,
Do you actually have any of those itemized deductions? And if so, why would you not also want capital gains taxed? Good for the goose, good for the gander.
I've got mixed emotions.
I've been clamouring for a simpler tax code. The fewer deductions, the simpler the code.
This'll cost me about $5,000 more in taxes. That sucks.
I guess I can't have it both ways.
What people don't understand is that this move is the GOP conceding to the Democrats. The Republicans want to cut taxes and spending. The Dems want to raise taxes and leave as much spending in place as they can get away with.
This is the cost of compromise. I wonder what the Dems will be conceding...
Exactly Max. I just don't get this. That is why I posted that article earlier this week about even the craziness of the tax code, if you work for your money or you get it from capital gains. And people wonder why all these occupy movements happen.
Jonathan,
I realize that for some individuals this is a loose/loose situation, since they have money in these itemized deductions and incapitalgains. But for the average working Joe, they count on these deductions. It even stimulates the economy with spending.
The democrats need to make cuts for sure. I have no problem with that. And I am for a simpler tax code, with no loopholes. But that isn't what is going on here. If we are overhauling the tax code, that's one thing, but this really stinks to high heaven!
Exactly. I'm all for cutting back government spending, and increasing the public coffers so that we can pay back some of this debt. But I am not for doing this on the back of working American's. This tactic is sure to kill the middle class. No economy recovers or grows with out them.
Is thatsarcasmI detect Max? LOL!
We're the only nation that allows 100% deduction of mortgage interest.
Same for capital gains Nadia. And we are also one of the few countries that doesn't have akillerVAT, and don't pay 9 dollars a gallon for gas. Should we be for those things, too?
They took away credit card interest and insurance premium costs from the Middle class in the late 80's and didn't do a damn thing to the upper brackets. Now they want to take what little the average working guy saves on taxes. Tell me, how much consumer spending do you think their will be if they do that? People depend on those breaks. The upper brackets will always spend. You talk aboutaggregate.. how about theaggregateof middle and working class not spending.
Nadia,
Read what I wrote again. I agreed that other countries allow capital gains tax. My point was that while we might be the only country that allows 100% of your PRIMARY property to be taken as a deduction.. key word being primary, it is also this deduction that drives our economy, since the bulk of Americans fall into thiscategoryand use this money to spend. Without spending the economy comes to a stand still.
While you might have paid taxes on theinitialinvestment, profits made by that investment, should be fair game as well. And there are manyways of avoiding this tax, as explained here . This is what we accountants call" creative accounting". The only true double tax, is the death tax, which I am against.
Also, you seemed to miss this article . Now explain to me how this is fair? Same amount of money made, but totally different tax rates. One for working and one for just investing. This tax system is punitive to people who actually work!
Also let us not remember, that those who invest in instruments and property which are tax as capital gains, are usually in a much higher tax bracket then those who have only their home as an asset.
On a different subject of this tax change, take away the deduction for charity, and I am sure you will see a big drop in charitable donations. Now I find this kind of funny, since the Republicans are always pointing to how people can help the poor other than government spending with donations given to houses of worship and other charitable organizations, and now they want to take away that incentive. Come on.. you can't have it both ways.
Nadia,
You keep going off the point and say that I have bought into the myth. First of all, I am not talking about Fannie Maes or Freddies Macs, I am talking about straight up capital gains, something that my family has made a ton of money on. You didn't even read the article, or you would be discussing that. Believe what you might, but capital gains isn't a double tax. It is you who have bought into the myth. Do you actually think that people will give to charities the same amount, if there wasn't a tax benefit? Come on, that is just common sense.
Again, the only double tax is the death tax, and I amagainstit.
If you want to talk about modifying and simplifying the tax code, I'm all for that. I am even for a flat tax, no loopholes. But thesedeductionsdrive consumer spending.
You do know, that when it comes to economics, none of it is a science. For every position, there is a counter position. None are every 100% right 100% of the time, and in reality we live in a mixed economy. Now that is a fact.
Nadia,
I don't care what some blog says. I was a practicing CPA. I know, that anyone who with half a brain in their head and pays a mortgage, and taxes should itemize. From the IRS publications:
When to itemize. You may benefit from itemizing your deductions on Schedule A (Form 1040) if you:
Do not qualify for the standard deduction, or the amount you can claim is limited,
Had large uninsured medical and dental expenses during the year,
Paid interest and taxes on your home,
Had large unreimbursed employee business expenses or other miscellaneous deductions,
Had large uninsured casualty or theft losses,
Made large contributions to qualified charities, or
Have total itemized deductions that are more than the standard deduction to which you otherwise are entitled.
It doesn't matter who opts to do this or not, it is a benefit to the middle class. Even a house in Levittown NY costs $350,000. At 20% down, their annual interest on a 30 yearmortgageis $14,000 with taxes of about $7,000. Do the math, Nadia. If they don't take the itemized deduction they are idiots, since most of these folks are middle class, with an income about $88,000 a year.