╌>

Supreme Court to Hear Case Challenging Health Law

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  15 years ago  •  37 comments

Supreme Court to Hear Case Challenging Health Law

The New York Times Reports:

WASHINGTON The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a challenge to the 2010 health care overhaul law, President Obamas signature legislative achievement. The development set the stage for oral arguments by March and a decision in late June, in the midst of the 2012 presidential campaign.

The courts decision to step in had been expected, but Mondays order answered many questions about just how the case would proceed. Indeed, it offered a roadmap toward a ruling that will help define the legacy of the Supreme Court under Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.

Appeals from three courts had been vying for the justices attention, presenting an array of issues beyond the central one of whether Congress has the constitutional power to require people to purchase health insurance or face a penalty through the so-called individual mandate.

Question:

Is this alegitimatecase against Obama's Health care reform, or the use of a conservative SCOTUS todismantleObama's Health care?

LINK


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    15 years ago

The bill, as passed, was an extremely complicated and tedious document. It covered many subjects, and spanned more than 2,000 pages. Even under the best of circumstances, there were directives that are truly a challenge to our freedoms as Americans. For example, there is a directive that requires certain parties to purchase insurance. Whether it is morally right or wrong is beside the point. I don't think you can require someone to purchase anything. In this regard, I believe we need to have an interpretation and/or ruling as to the constitutionality of this requirement.

On a personal level, I find it unconscionable that the insurance companies were given a virtual pass. I purchase health insurance for my family, and saw a 17% increase in the premium last year. This year, the increase is 12%, with a reduction in services. My premium is rising more than 5 times the rate of inflation, with a reduction in coverage. A major problem of our healthcare system was the cost of insurance, along with the skyrocketing cost. This was not adressed to any degree. And the rates apply to Democrats and Republicans. I'm pretty sure this is not a political issue.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Jonathan,

That is a very well thought out response. On to some specifics.

I don't think you can require someone to purchase anything. In this regard, I believe we need to have an interpretation and/or ruling as to the constitutionality of this requirement.

Agreed! I don't think that any person should be forced to buy insurance.

I find it unconscionable that the insurance companies were given a virtual pass. I purchase health insurance for my family, and saw a 17% increase in the premium last year. This year, the increase is 12%, with a reduction in services. My premium is rising more than 5 times the rate of inflation, with a reduction in coverage.

Having worked Pru-Bache, this is the result of having an unregulated business. The increases that you see in no way mirror the actual inflation of actual health care. It is also because drug companies are finding new ways not to provide generic drugs by inventing slight changes in the formulation of drugs, and thus being able to say that there was R&D and you are now stuck paying new drug prices. Both need to be stopped. This is what leads to sky rocketing prices.

I'm on the fence about it being a political issue, and that is why I posed the question. I wanted some feedback. Contrary to beliefs... that is what a real indie does.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    15 years ago

Re drugs - That's broken out separately now. They have a completely different set of deductibles, copays and restrictions, independent of doctor care.

Re being an indie - You keep tellin' yourself that... ;-)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Re being an indie - You keep tellin' yourself that... ;-)

Oooo Jonathan... Are ya taking me on?

Maybe I won't vote for the guy standing next to your daughter?????

:-)

Re drugs - That's broken out separately now. They have a completely different set of deductibles, copays and restrictions, independent of doctor care.

I know that. But for group policies, it isn't. The company pays it as one lump sum per person.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    15 years ago

Indie means that you don't base your ideas or ideals on those of a particular, specific ideology. You reach your conclusions on a topic by topic basis, based upon your "unbiased" research on each topic. But we ALL have a bias of some sort in everything we do.

Vanilla or chocolate?

Golf or tennis?

Gin or vodka?

Comedy or drama?

Rock or hip-hop?

Missionary or doggie?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Jonathan,

Bias?

Bias:an inclination of temperament or outlook; especially : a personal and sometimes unreasoned judgment : prejudice .

My opinions are based on what I have read, and what I have experienced. Some are stronger than others, but none came from a lack of reason. The list you gave above are not issues, but preferences, based on the level of enjoyment they give me. In politics I actually look issue by issue and read and follow. Nothing is written in stone, with the exception that I believe in compassion and ethical behavior i.e. The Golden Rule. To me, that is like believing in god. It is how I conduct my day to day life. Give me solid facts, and know that I will always play 'Devil Advocate" in my quest for the answer to an issue.

As for your list of personal preferences:

Vanilla or chocolate? Vanilla

Golf or tennis? Neither. Skiing.

Gin or vodka? Both!

Comedy or drama? Both! Add sci-fi to the list, too!

Rock or hip-hop? Dahhh... Rock in Roll

Missionary or doggie? I like to change it up you nasty boy. ;-)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Constitutional? I believe it is.

Why? Reasoning behind that.

Doggie, of course.

Only doggie? Really?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

I've spoken to people who don't like the Affordfable Health Care Act ... but who, when asked, can't cite one ACTUAL part of it! So, let's have the discussion based on what is, rather than what it may not be.

Key Features of the Law

The health care law offers clear choices for consumers and provides new ways to hold insurance companies accountable. The most important parts of the law are broken into groups below. Well highlight new features of the law here as they roll out between now and 2014.

Rights and Protections

If you have insurance, these consumer protections can help you get the most out of your plan.

Insurance Choices

If you need insurance coverage or have been rejected due to a health condition or disability, you may be eligible for coverage through one of these programs.

Insurance Costs

How does your health insurance policy affect your wallet? Find out how the law helps you get the most value for your premium dollar.

65 or Older

The health care law strengthens Medicare and provides access to preventive services and prescription drug discounts for seniors.

Employers

Tax credits and new programs are available to small businesses to help make care more affordable for employers, employees, and early retirees.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

It was Max! The very first president who wanted health care reform was Nixon!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Yeah ... Nixon enabled HMO's and killed full indemnity coverage for many who could not afford it.

(Mis)managed Health Care ... that's what created the need for reform.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

I didn't say how it turned out... I just knew he was the first.

I really don't think that was his intent. Sometimes the cure can be worse than the disease, and this was in the early days of the concept here in the US. I'm no lover of Nixon, for more than obvious reasons, but I think he thought that he was helping.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

You love life! Good for you!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

As for the law, I think it's Constitutional because of the logic that every American is involved in the health care system of America, if they want to be or notand therefore the federal government has a right to regulate it. Of course I am not a Constitutional attorney, so your mileage may vary.

LOL Randy! I always could see ya as a car sales men.

At some point, I think that the government over steps it'sboundaries. This is one. That would be like saying that the government can force us into vaccines. Disease affects everyone, but I should be able to say no to one.

Just playing devils advocate here

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Well, I guess we'll have to see how this plays out in the court. My bet is that they are going to find itunconstitutional... But not being a lawyer... I am not sure if there are grounds for that or not... but there is a lot of political motivation for it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Maybe...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Natural rights are not the government's to either give or take. That includes the right not to buy health insurance.

"Natural rights?"

Every law, ordinance, even traffic signs ... mandate that citizens, at the risk of sanction, do or refrain from doing something or other.

And a health insurance mandate actually HELPS people ... sometimes in life or death situations.

The same right-wing "personal responsibility" criers who rail against uninsured individuals using emergency rooms and thus costing those of us having insurance an additional $1100 in annual premiums, don't bother to mention that the mandate will end such practices!

I know ...

"I hope he fails" is driving this bus.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Tina,

LOL on Olivia! Gave me a morning giggle!

This one issue, has me befuddled. I see both sides of this issue, and that is why I posted it as a question, without a position. I have none.

I don't think (the key word here is think, as in IMHO)that it is constitutional. But I am far from an expert. On the other hand Mac's comment above, is also right. No matter what, we will always have people who can't afford health care, and will go to emergency rooms, etc. As a society, what does it say about us, if we turn them away? Could you personally sit behind a desk at admission to a hospital and turn a sick child away? I know I couldn't. So we have to have a way to support those who can't afford. Then the question becomes how? This issue is a toughie.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

And a health insurance mandate actually HELPS people ... sometimes in life or death situations.

Yes it does.

The same right-wing "personal responsibility" criers who rail against uninsured individuals using emergency rooms and thus costing those of us having insurance an additional $1100 in annual premiums, don't bother to mention that the mandate will end such practices!

Question... How? There are people who can't afford to buy health insurance. So our government is forcing them to do so? What am I missing?

As for personal responsibility, I am on the fence about that, too. That question to Ron Paul, although extreme in nature, does kind of bug me. We all have to take some level ofresponsibilityfor our actions. Now, I don't mind helping a poor person in need of medical care, who can't afford it, but it damn pisses me off to support a person who can afford it, but chooses to use their "disposable income" in some other manner, gets sick, and I have to pay the bill. Now I know you will say that this is the exact reason that we needmandatoryinsurance. But on the other hand, it is this persons right to make that decision isn't it? When has the government gone too far?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that about 16 million currently uninsured Americans will receive coverage as a result of Title I by the year 2019, half of the 32 million uninsured who will get covered. The other half will get covered via Title II.

Title II: The Role of Public Programs . This title deals mostly with Medicaid , which most Americans think is the health insurance program for the poor. In most states though, Medicaid covers only certain categories of poor people (children and their parents, disabled, seniors), leaving out poor, childless, working adults, a large part of America's uninsured. Beginning in 2014, the ACA will make Medicaid the health insurance program for nearly all Americans with household incomes less than 133% of the federal poverty line (just under $30,000 in annual income for a family of four).

And ...

HSA Basics
Under a high-deductible health-care plan, individuals are required to pay the first several thousand dollars in medical expenses out-of-pocket. (Preventive services are often available without a deductible.)Insurance kicks in after that, often paying 80% of the bills with the employee shouldering the other 20% of costs until the individual or family hits the out-of-pocket maximum for the year. In exchange for the risk that you'll be on the hook for the high deductible and coinsurance amount, the premiums on high-deductible health insurance plans are usually quite low.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

"We'd?"

Whose we?

Charity Hospitals could not handle 30 million uninsured individuals ... that's a key part of the Affordable Health Care Act ... no one can game the system by failing to purchase health insurance ... then using emergency rooms.

FYI ...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Interesting two posts. They are polaroppositesof each other.

Tina,

There are no charity hospitals by us. There are some teaching hospitals.. not a savory choice but one none the less. Certain hospitals must take medicaid..but I am pretty sure you don't like that program... but I may be wrong.

As for going into debt... just read Randy's example and that is exactly what happens to the poor and working class, and the scenario plays out pretty much that way.

Randy,

Although you are probably right about how that plays out, read your own words:

I say force that worker, with a subsidy if needed, to buy insurance and spread the risk around so we all pay less.

Force? Sounds very unconstitutional to me. You are arguing with me about protesters right to sleep in a private park because of "Freedom of Speech" but here talking about forcing people to buyinsurance. Do you not see the irony in that?

Again.. to the both of you, just working through this. I still have no real opinion.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

A different perspective:

There are so many ways to argue this issue. Hence why I am still on the fence about this.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

There are some significant differences between health care insurance & car insurance . For one thing you are not required to buy car insurance if you do not drive . For another , you need to buy car insurance to protect others as well as yourself . Health insurance , by contrast offers no protection to anyone but yourself & sometimes not even yourself .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

For you, in your black and white world, you think that this is an easydecision. Yet I just showed you a different opinion. If things were so cut and dry, we wouldn't need a court... or had that notoccurredto you.

I am not waiting for the court to decide. Obviously, the court will decide what it will decide. I am not a specialist inConstitutionallaw, so I looking at if the court has alegitimatereason to even look at this law. I am trying to figure out, is if this law in it's current condition can beconstitutional.

This has nothing to do with how I feel about this law. I grew up in England. I believe in some sort of health program. I am just not sure if this one will stand the test of the court.

There is a difference between being an independent and being unable to make up your mind.

I have no problem making up my mind when things are crystal clear. But I have read many constitutional specialist, and none of them agree. If the experts can't agree, how can you?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

HUH ?

I read it . It is your typical illogical rant . Apparently they are going to take away your citizenship if you don't pay up . At least , that is by extension of your "thinking" process .

 
 

Who is online



87 visitors