╌>

The American Fall

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  15 years ago  •  141 comments

The American Fall

Heavy debate is going on media-wide about the Occupy Wall Street/99% movements and whether or not these protesters have a real basis for their complaints. Are they just whining because they are not rich, or are their complaints real? Are the middle and working classes being pushed out of existencebecause of the symbiotic relationship between the rich/corporations and our government, or have Americans at large grown fat and lazy and expect the government to provide everything for them? Has the average American lost all ambition, and is he waiting for government handouts?

At the end of WWII the American dream was quite alive. Men came home from the war, bought a nice little house in the 'Levittowns" that were springing up all over America on the GI Bill. They bought a domestic made car, which they owned, and worked at the same job knowing that they had job security, with the understanding that at the end of their working days they would have a nice pension. They sent their kids to school with the anticipation of them going to college and doing better than them. College was affordable, even the elite schools such as Harvard, and they knew that upon graduation they would have a job.

But something went terribly wrong. We can all look back to that time and know that isn't what we have now. If that was the American Dream, then the American dream is dead. The middle and working classes are shrinking and so is their net worth, and that is theflash-pointto where we are at this moment. The average American feels that they are being told, "Let them Eat Cake," and it is not their imagination.

The Congressional Budget Office has been doing a long term economic study on theeconomicconditions here in the US. The study spans from 1979 to 2007 and the findings are shocking. The study looked at net income after it adjusted for inflation, and found that over this period of time the top 1% of earners had real income growth of 275% while the middle class has grown by 40%, and the poorest fifth of the nation has grown by 18%.

Here is a graph that makes a bigger impact on this disparity:

INCOME-INEQUALITY.jpg

According to the New York Times:

"The findings, based on a rigorous analysis of data from the Internal Revenue Service and the Census Bureau, are generally consistent with studies by some private researchers and academic economists. But because they carry the imprimatur of the nonpartisan budget office, they are likely to have a major impact on the debate in Congress over the fairness of federal tax and spending policies.

Also cited as factors contributing to the rapid growth of income at the top were the structure of executive compensation ; high salaries for some superstars in sports and the arts; the increasing size of the financial services industry; and the growing role of capital gains, which go disproportionately to higher-income households.

The report found that higher-income households got a larger share of the pie, while other households got smaller shares.

Specifically the report made these points:

The share of after-tax household income for the top 1 percent of the population more than doubled, climbing to 17 percent in 2007 from nearly 8 percent in 1979.

The most affluent fifth of the population received 53 percent of after-tax household income in 2007, up from 43 percent in 1979. In other words, the after-tax income of the most affluent fifth exceeded the income of the other four-fifths of the population.

People in the lowest fifth of the population received about 5 percent of after-tax household income in 2007, down from 7 percent in 1979.

People in the middle three-fifths of the population saw their shares of after-tax income decline by 2 to 3 percentage points from 1979 to 2007.

The study was requested by Senators Max Baucus, Democrat of Montana and chairman of the Finance Committee, and Charles E. Grassley of Iowa, when he was the senior Republican on the panel."

This is not the imagination of the American people. This is not Americans being lazy and expecting their government to do everything for them. This is not an issue of the unmotivated. The truth lies in the numbers, and what the numbers tell us is that the present system isn't working. That it favors a specific segment of our nation. That the tax code is written in such a way that it benefits only those at the top, and does little if anything to help those in the middle or at the bottom. That executiveswho failmiserablyat their jobs, like those who were responsible for the banking defaults, will still get enormous bonuses, despite the fact that they got a bailout on the working man's dime, because our government allowed it. The fact that we need to end PACs and need campaign finance reform.

No, it's not the imagination of those protesting all over the US that our system is abusing the middle and working classes. The numbers speak for themselves. The system does benefit the 1% of thepopulation, leaving the 99% to pick up the tab, and that is divisive. And although people shouldn't look upon this as a class war, which is actually destructive to this nation, our government needs to wake up and smell theproverbialcoffee. If it continues down this path, the people are beginning to make it clear. It will not be tolerated. If the Middle East had "The Arab Spring," then this could be called "The American Fall."

http://cbo.gov/ftpdocs/124xx/doc12485/10-25-HouseholdIncome.pdf

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/26/us/politics/top-earners-doubled-share-of-nations-income-cbo-says.html?_r=1&emc=eta1

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/26/income-inequality_n_1032632.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

You want to make this as a right v left thing and I just don't see it that way. Many of those 1% are liberals. The athletes, the movie stars, themusicians.. most are liberal. The 1% flourishedbecauseof theallianceof big business with the government, but all who benefited are not on the right.

What I don't get, are those who are middle and working class, that support the system. They are a mystery to me. The present tax code is one of the things that they should beactivelyinvolved in trying to change. But they have somehow bought into this, idea of the "Lazy American" trying to leech off of the government. It just isn't true.

The American dream of 60 years ago, is long gone, Randy. I believe that we can do better than this, but it's going to take real change, not just word, but action and pressure on our government to make these changes.

There is as much danger in this left v right thing as there is to suggest social warfare. It is unproductive, andultimatelydangerous to us as a society.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Hi Perrie,

An excellent article!!!

I have a few thoughts on this...

Some people will say, business should be left completely unfettered... and if that means the very rich make a lot more than the 99%... well that's too bad... that is just how it goes. To that I would say they should remember that virtually every revolution in history has been inspired by circumstances where the disparity between the very rich and the rest is "too" great. How much disparity is too much??? I'm not really sure.

Some people will point to very real cases where "lazy" people game the system to get a free ride. There is no doubt about it... that does happen. But it never happens that a group of people who are exclusively freeloaders gets enough traction to amount to anything. When people march in the streets it's because they have real justifiable grievances. The 99% are NOT saying we want all incomes to be equal for all people. The 99% are only saying, I want to live in a society where, if I work hard, then I prosper... I don't necessarily need to become as rich as the 1%... I just want to believe that I can have a reasonable middle class life... and my kids, and their kids can aspire to the same thing if they work hard. The 99% are not upset because the 1% has so much more money than they have. They are upset because the 1% is making it difficult for the 99% to have a decent modest middle-class life. Because the 1% never seems to be satisfied with any amount of prosperity... they are constantly trying to get more... more... more... and the result is hurtful to the 99%.

The 99% says... "If you're rich... GOOD FOR YOU!!! I hope I can be just as rich as you someday. But stop hurting me and our country and our environment just so you can be richer than rich! Support the country that made it possible for you to become rich. If you don't value a clean and healthy environment, others do... and it belongs to all of us, so stop trashing it. And stop fattening your coffers by outsourcing our jobs, foreclosing our homes, making egregious profits on our health misfortunes, and doing other things that are unnecessarily hurtful to us. Just give us a reasonable chance for a decent life... that's all were asking for!!!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Mal:

Just give us a reasonable chance for a decent life... that's all were asking for!!!

What makes you think the "1%" can "give" you that? Seems to me that your entire thesis, belief, desire is built on that one little fact.

Seems to me it's up to them to do that, not other people.

It's that idea that, somehow, the 1% has to "give" something to the others that is so fallacious.

It is also extremely constraining to the 99%, eh? They DEPEND on the kindness of others (to paraphrase a famous quote) instead of on themselves.

Not a good way to be.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

LOL, that is funny as hell! I LOVE it!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Let me just make one more point.

Whenever I see bull crap like this:

No, it's not the imagination of those protesting all over the US, that our system is abusing the middle and working classes.

I know the entire article is crap. "The "system" is abusing? LOL, what an arsehole!

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

I need to agree with Randy here Perrie. Yes, there are plenty of lefties in the 1% (e.g. Warren Buffet) and plenty of righties in the 99% (e.g. 99% of the Tea Party)... You don't have to sympathize with the 99% movement to be a member of the 99%. BUT... it IS pretty much people on the right who oppose the 99% movement... and it is generally people on the left who sympathize with the 99% movement. So it really depends on whether you are talking about people who fall into to 99% category (regardless of their ideology) or people who sympathize with the message of the 99% movement.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

It is totallyridiculousto call Americans whobelieve the 99% movement has a point. (poll presented below) Over a third of Americans support the movement are communist. I'm not even close to that in my economic beliefs. And while yes, there is a fringe part of this movement, you could say that there was a fringe part of the Tea Party, which Randy will gladly point out.

The point of my article is a wake up call. There is something seriously wrong here. It is even now recognized by our government.

And for the record, I don't support communists either.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Agreed.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

In all due fairness, I don't have any numbers to indicate that. Do You?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mal,

I have to agree with that statement, but the majority of people are independents and how do they figure into this? From the most recent polls that I have looked at, they are split,with slightly more going with the OWS/99%.

And none of us really know what the 1% think. I haven't heard any of them say anything, other than Buffet. What we have been hearing is leadership on the right and members who agree doing most of the bashing of this movement. As for the 1%, who knows?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

I like dealing in facts so, since the above study was commissioned in 1979 and goes to 2007 the brake out of whocontrolledthe House is as follows:

20 years of Democrats/ 16 years Republicans.

There is enough blame to go all around.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

That comment of mine appeared in the wrong place, and now you are quoting me back my own words, LOL.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

wmolaw,

What makes you think the "1%" can "give" you that?

You mischaracterized what I said. By leaving the word "chance" out of your question, you changed the entire character of what I assert the 99% is saying.

They are NOT asking the 1% to give them a decent life!!!

They ARE asking the 1% to give them a CHANCE for a decent life!!!

My statement implies that the 99% expect to EARN a decent life, and they are only asking the 1% to stop making it so difficult for them to do so.

Your statement implies that the 99% expect to be GIVEN a decent life.

There is a very big difference!!!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

I know the entire article is crap. "The "system" is abusing? LOL, what an arsehole!

I wrote the article, so I guess I am the asshole, Terry.

Are there not protests going on all over the US?

Is it not even spreading to Europe?

The system is our government and unbridaled greed that has feed the government that has caused the system. Who makes the policy and who buys those votes is what it at issue. You might not like what that chart plainly showed, but it's there, bipartisian commissioned to see what is wrong with out tax code. If that isn't the system, I don't know what is.

But thanks for the compliment. But please don't laugh in my face.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, and even I have all done well enough (although I haven't done anywhere near as well as they have)... But they and I got our chance in an economic and social situation that is very different than the current situation. People were not marching in the streets at the time of our heyday because we and others DID have a decent chance... things are different now.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

are we too busy having fun shooting spitballs to figure it out?

Hi hate to say it Feronia... but I think many people are far more interested in shooting spitballs than finding solutions... ESPECIALLY not solutions that involve "middle ground"!!! For many people compromise is heresy.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Empty rhetoric. Copy/paste. Repeat.

I couldn't have said it any better Feronia!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

This isn't about who supports them, although it goes to show where the how many Americans feel about the subject. It is about the empirical information collected about the economic state of America since 1979. You want to ignore the numbers, I can't. And finally so is our government... maybe. You don't have to be in the park, to get where they are coming from. And BTW the 99% don't hang out all night in the park.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Nice group of cherry picked pictures Mike. Bravo. Why didn't you show the seniors that are there? The union workers? The very normal looking families? Talking aboutskewingthe truth. My interviews showed the good and the bad. That is called balance journalism.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

And this one proves what? A guy siting quietly? Wow.. terrible. Mike, quick get him!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

You're beginning to repeat your pics Mike. Running out of good material instead of dealing with the facts in that congressional study?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Exactly. If they even bothered to look at that chart or read the actual report, instead of just give the usual talking points, they might have a differentperspective...

There is no one so blind as one who WILL not see.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Or are we too busy having fun shooting spitballs to figure it out?

Feronia, I have found that when people do this, it's because they feel that they are loosing their case. The numbers speak for them self. Things have gone south but there is a mind set that really is impossible to change. Anyone who is moreflexible intheiropinionis called a name.

When I started this OWS research, I was a bit against them. The more I read about what our tax system has done to the mddle and lower class, one has to wonder who is really getting the free handouts. To me, I think it's become quite obvious who!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Hi hate to say it Feronia... but I think many people are far more interested in shooting spitballs than finding solutions... ESPECIALLY not solutions that involve "middle ground"!!! For many people compromise is heresy.

Spot on my furry friend!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

The fact that you are calling Feronia a communist is totally offensive.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

That is totally obnoxious and not funny.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Max,

What cracked me up about that statement was two fold.

One, that Terry really didn't read it, he scanned it, looked for one comment that he could dismiss the whole article by, because the numbers are just too much for him to explain away...especially since that was a bipartisian effort and

Two, he missed that I had written it. Which only proves that he scanned the article for the one sentence that he could dismiss it with.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

ROFLMAO!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

I am an asshole, and I believe in freedom, democracy, and capitalism.

Well guess what I believe in freedom, democracy and capitalism, but I'm no asshole!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike,

You are beyond hopeless. And the sad part is your going to be left behind. The fact that the American people are siding more and more with them, tells me something. This movement is not one of these selectpictures you try to portray them as, and only a cold hard man would want civilians shot at, no matter what they are saying or how they look.

Now that borders on the evil.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Goodwin again. Yeah Mike..you are the only lucid person here. God must have given you the insight that no one else has. It must be wonderful to be you.

Heck... where is Mac when you need him Maybe he can remind you of some of the beauties that came from the Tea Party. Maybe we should use them to represent everyone who was frustrated at those rallies.

This is my city. This movement started here. I am nothing more than an observer at this point. But the more you talk, the more I agree with them.

I am sure you have been wrong before. You will be wrong on this. What we are talking about has nothing to do with this movement directly. It's about how the middle and working classes are being squeezed to death. Sorry if you like the 1% because they are the only ones who can buy your expensive toys. Some of us are wondering how we are going to pay our electric bill.

But so long as you can pay yours, hey, not your problem.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

LOL Feronia .. you've got his game perfectly. I just skipped an entire page because it read"

I'm right, blah, blah, blah,

Your a communist, blah, blah, blah.

I love America. You don't.

Here are some screw ball pics to make me look even more right.

When he want to discuss the study, then I will have a discussion, But otherwise I amofficiallydone with this BS.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

And that was constructive how? This isn't about the OWS or the 99%. It is about the report out government put out. You know.. the little one that span from 1979-2007. This is about why a growing segment of the US, are sympathising with the OWS and the 99%. It is about the inequalities that have developed over this period of time, that created that outragous looking chart.

How nice of you to notice the meat of the article and go right to therhetoric. Well, maybe we should take a show of hands to see how many of these members are working Americans, just like you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

The point of this article is to discuss right,left and the middle, how to fix a broken system Reading that report was the braking point for me. Looking at it on a graph just took it more visual. What can we do... Lots.

  1. Campaign reform which includes no pacs and only individual contributions only.Lengthenthe terms of the congress, so that they are not always in need of money to campaign and limit the amount they can spend total. Make sure that congress works at least 200 days a day and that they work a day. They can't vote themselves pay increases, nor are they allowed a life time of salary or pension, unless they have served at least 25 years in Congress/ Senate.
  2. Bank reform. That means that they have better regulation. Support the Dodd/Frank bill. The banks make enough money without givingcontributingto the people in the way of loans and giving themselves bonuses on the dime of the American people.
  3. Reform Taxes. This can take many forms, but it must be done, if we are hoping to stimulate the economy. More disposable income means more spending. Making the middle and working class bare theburdenof taxes, is killing our economy.

How about that for starters?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

  1. I never mentionedMax Baucus, so how he got into this discussion, I am unsure.
  2. I am not going after the "Rich" Go back and read the article. I never even use the word "Rich" once. But we do need tax reform and that was the whole purpose of this study that ran from 1979-2007 and was bi-partisan. They saw this disparity happening even back then and wanted to see how it could be fixed. You should read the link.
  3. The American Dream, the one that our pops had is gone. Sorry Bruce, but it is. There is no job security. You can't expect a pension from said job. Yes, there is something to strive for, but that ring gets harder and harder to reach. This year I will be sending my kids off to school. My expected "Parental Contribution will be about $8,000 per child or $16,000 a year. It will go up the following year. That is more money than I paid for my entire college education. I have no choice in this, if I want my kids to have a better life than me. So this is not a choice.
  4. My article was about the net worth of the American people. It happens that it comes from a report that was issued because of taxes. I don't live in apanaceabelieving that if we tax more than we will fix everything. Go back and read the list of things that are a good starting point for change. Tax reform is just one.

There is a reason why so many people who went from not even noticing these OWS and 99% to actuallysympathizingwith them is happening. I myself, thought that they were a blip on the screen. They are not... because they are striking a cord that the American people have been feeling for a while. That with each election, it's meet the new boss, same as the old boss, and we are sick of being fooled again.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

  1. You seemed to have missedCharles E. Grassley of Iowa, a Republican and also part of this panel. I guess the name didn't ring a bell to me and so I didn't notice it. Besides, what was more important to me, was that it was bi-partisan study.
  2. Yes, please count. I mention the word rich twice and once I used it todescribewhat you and Mike and Terry have been calling these protesters. "Are they just whining because they are not rich, or are their complaints real?" My whole article is about how the current confluenceof big business, big government and a bought government has cometogetherto and is destroying the middle and working classes. It's a real simple question. When you look at that chart, do you think it looked like that in 1960?
  3. Please explain to me what method are we supposed to use? And besides, this isn't about becoming rich. This is about maintaining what we have and maybe making a little head way.
  4. Actually, I only want honesty. To end this partisan business and look at the problem and deal with it. That is what I want from you. Actually, that is what we should all want.

I have always said that I agreed with the 99%. They were the folks that I spoke to in the park three weeks ago. I never got near the OWS people. But the way the polls are treating them, is as a singular entity and those are the only polls that I have to go on. When they realize that there is a difference will also be the turning point for this movement.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

As my Dad says, "Fair Enough"

Besides, you're still a cuddle muffin, so I don't want us to go to bed without a kiss goodnight, *smack*... Good night sweetie.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Thinking back to the end of WWII, the American dream was quite alive. Men came home from the war, bought a nice little house in the 'Levittowns" that were springing up all over America on the GI Bill. They bought a domestic made car, which they owned, and worked at the same job knowing that they had job security, with the understanding that at the end of their working days, they would have a nice pension. They sent their kids to school with the anticipation of them going to college and doing better than them. College was affordable, even the elite schools such as Harvard and they knew upon graduation, that they would have a job.

First, do you think that was the way it actually was? LOL, you kind of forget having to work your ass off, deal with politics in the office, work when sick, not see much of your kids, etc., etc., etc.

You forget the alcoholism, heart attacks, all those little indicia of a tough, hard working life!

Just like these asshats are. They want all that crap, and more , NOW, without working. They just want more and more and more.

All without working for it. All just because, somehow, they "deserve" it for being asshats!

Bah, humbug.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Oh, come on! Work hard, take risks? You are so pitiless!

They have to be given success! You know it, I know it! It's the gumminit's responsibility!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

That's the problem, of course. As their (and the gummminits) cash cows disappear, they can't get the freebies they once did,

and that pisses them off! How dare a city say they can't afford the incredible perks to unions any longer! Those ingrates!

LOL, as Margaret said, the only issue with socialism is sooner or later the money runs out.

How right she was, and is.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Terry (it took me a while to figure out that wmolaw was you),

Do you remember this... I wrote it in part to something you said...

I agree... Working hard and falling on hard times does not, by the confluence of those circumstances, endow any sort of entitlement. As individuals we make choices, and some of those choices may be the cause of the difficulties we encounter in life. Other difficulties may come to us through circumstances out side of our control. In either case, whether we are personally responsible for our difficulties or not, we still have no automatic entitlement to relief from those difficulties.

As individuals we also choose how we use our resources, including whether we want to use our resources to help those who have been less fortunate than we have been. As a society of many individuals we can decide to pool some of our resources to do things which are beneficial to the society as a whole, and of course we can opt NOT to do that as well. There are many different things that can be done with those pooled resources, including funding national defense, building infrastructure, and helping those who have fallen on hard times. Some people may object to using our pooled resources to help those who have fallen on hard times. They may argue there is insufficient benefit to the society as a whole or possibly no benefit at all to using our pooled resources in this way. They may also argue that there are people who will abuse such a social safety net, people who will make bad choices knowing the society will save them if they happen to fall on hard times, and even people who will deliberately defraud such a system. I agree, fraud and abuse is not only likely, but in society as large as ours it is inevitable. This is true not only for social entitlements but for all the programs that use our pooled resources.

As a self-described "Progressive-Socialist-Democrat" I feel the objections to social entitlements of those who do not share my views are absolutely valid. My feelings about social entitlements are rooted in my personal ethics, the foundation of which is The Golden Rule. I cannot enjoy the benefits of my success knowing there are others who have worked as hard as I have but have not had the success I have had. I have no wish to support those who are abusing the system. By the same token, I do not want to penalize those who have done nothing abusive simply because others are abusive. Of course I want to do everything possible to stop fraud and abuse, but for me, supporting some who do not deserve my support is a price I am willing to pay in order to ensure that those who do deserve support get what they need. Other people may not share my feelings on this matter, and I acknowledge their feelings are no less valid than mine.

In a society as big as America it is inevitable that whatever choices we make as a society will not be fully satisfying to everyone. In fact, it is likely that everyone will be dissatisfied with at least a few things. If we want to have a strong society, and because our society is comprised of diverse ideologies, we must figure out how we can accommodate the views of those who are most different from us. This kind of accommodation must be done with genuine reciprocity.

So my fellow conservative Americans, what say you to the words of this "Progressive-Socialist-Democrat"???

The issues of the 99% movement are not really about social entitlements (the comment above IS about social entitlements). The 99% movement is really about leveling the playing field. But you seem to bundle all of that together... not an unreasonable thing to do because, as someone who supports the idea of social entitlements and someone who sympathizes with the 99% movement, I do see a common thread running through it all... empathy.

In that comment I was trying to show you that I understand your view point... not only do I understand it, but I accept it as a reasonable view. It's not a view that appeals to me. Nonetheless I am willing... even eager to work together with people like yourself to find a way to live together and work together to make our country, a country of very diverse views, a good place for all to live. It appears to me that you have no such interest. "Asshat" you say... Apparently you want only to disparage those who are not like you. You lump everyone who sympathizes with the 99% movement together, and then characterize us as freeloaders who...

just want more and more and more.

All without working for it. All just because, somehow, they "deserve" it for being asshats!

Hmmm... "more and more and more"... Where have I heard that before??? To be fair... I did say...

Because the 1% never seems to be satisfied with any amount of prosperity... they are constantly trying to get more... more... more...

So I guess I am lumping people together too... On the other hand, I did mention (somewhere, I can't find it right now) that there are lefties in the 1% and righties in the 99%...

Some how your characterization of people who have little wanting more seems a little different to me than my characterization of people who have much wanting more. Anywho... Here is why I am writing this particular comment... to you... (BTW- I gotta hand it to you, Terry, you do inspire me to write... so thanks!) When I engage in "discussions" like this one I find myself wondering whether people like you and I will ever be able to live together in peace. I said I am eager to do that... You once told me (paraphrase), "There will always be a place for me at your table." What does that mean??? After listening to you on this thread, it sure doesn't sound like it means there would be any of the things I want in my world at "your table."

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Wanna get rich? Work hard, take risks.

The crux of the issue for the 99% is that the 1% is doing things that make it easier for their hard work to pay off and more difficult for the hard work of the 99% to pay off. The richer you are the easier it is to get richer. Furthermore, when you have lots of wealth, taking risks doesn't have to be as risky as it is for people who don't have much to risk. Many of the people in the 99% are saying, "Let me show you how hard I can work. Please let me show you." Only to hear from many of the people in the 1%, "No thanks! You want to much for your hard work. I'd rather get my hard work from people who are willing to take something less than the American middle-class lifestyle as their compensation for hard work."

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

I hope you read the comment I left for you below, Terry... The long comment... the one I am addressing to you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Terry,

Are you implying that the average American worker bee doesn't work every bit as hard as they did after WWII. Please, then it is you who lives in la la land. Those numbers didn't just happen now, they happened over time. And the reason that the report was first asked to be done, was because even in 1979, things were going south. Both parties saw it.

And there is nothing that explains that chart or the finding. I'm sorry, there just isn't. It didn't look that way in 1979. And if you don't think that there is something wrong after looking at that chart than bah humbug to you, too.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

Somewhere in your last comment you seemed to miss this last tidbit from that article:

"In 2007, the top one ten-thousandth of households took home 6 percent of the nations income , up from 0.9 percent in 1977. It was the highest such level since at least 1913, the first year for which the I.R.S. has data.

The top 1 percent of earners took home 23.5 percent of income, up from 9 percent three decades earlier."

Which is proving my point. Of course the rich have lost some money. They invested in property that collapsed when the housing market bubble busted. They are in businesses that rely on the middle and working classes to buy, and they have cut back. Yet, they still managed to grow. Everything maxs out during a recession, and we are in a recession. But the bottom line is that they are still doing way better than the other two classes.

Also from your article:

"In 2007, the top one ten-thousandth of households took home 6 percent of the nations income , up from 0.9 percent in 1977. It was the highest such level since at least 1913, the first year for which the I.R.S. has data.

The top 1 percent of earners took home 23.5 percent of income, up from 9 percent three decades earlier."

and:

"By contrast, pay at the median which was about $50,000 in 2007 rose less than 20 percent, census data shows . Near the bottom of the income distribution, the increase was about 12 percent."

and this:

I think incredibly high incomes can have a pernicious effect on the polity and the economy, said Lawrence Katz, a Harvard economist. Much of the growth of high-end incomes stemmed from market forces, like technological innovation, Mr. Katz said. But a significant amount also stemmed from the wealthys newfound ability to win favorable government contracts, low tax rates and weak financial regulation , he added."

Which is the point that I have been making all along.

As for getting rich, there is no guide. Some come into it from family, other hit is big (sometimes by luck, like Zuckerberg did), and some from hard work. The thing is, that there are many people out there who took chance and fail. Over 50% of business start ups fail within the first year. They took a risk. They wanted the American dream. What happened? Are you going to tell me that they didn't work every bit as hard as those who became rich?

Anyway, I digress, which is what I think people have been trying to get me to do. The point of my article was said so well in this NYT article. The system ( and that isn't the same thing as "the man"), works against the middle and working classes. The rich might have had losses, but not nearly the losses that the other two classes have now.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Terry,

This isn't about feebees. I am not even addressing that here, and you know it. I am talking about how those who have influence all level of government, including the tax code andcampaignfinancing.

As for socialism, I am acapitalist. But I am also a realist. I don't want something for nothing. I want fairness. There is a difference, you know.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Why the outrage?

1)

30 Top Corporations Paid US No Taxes, Despite Profit

Few companies actually pay 35% rate

By Kevin Spak , Newser Staff
Posted Nov 3, 2011 7:46 AM CDT
(Newser) America may have a lofty 35% corporate tax ratebut who actually pays that ? A new study from a pair of left-leaning think tanks examined 280 Fortune 500 companies from 2008-2010, and found that their average effective rate was 18.5%, with a quarter paying less than 10% and 30 paying no taxes at all, despite being profitable, Reuters reports. Least taxed of all was Pepco Holdings, a DC power company with an effective rate of negative 57.6%.

The free-ride list also included Boeing, Wells Fargo, and, of course, General Electric , according to the New York Times ; Wells Fargo wound up with a tax benefit of $651 million, despite $49 billion in profit. While all the tricks companies used to shrink their bills were legal, the reports authors chided them anyway, noting that the laws were not enacted in a vacuum; they were adopted in response to relentless corporate lobbying.

2)

As Corporate Profits Rise, Workers Income Declines

By FLOYD NORRIS

THESE are the worst of times for workers, and the best of times for companies. At least that is one way to read the newly revised national economic statistics.

Multimedia

The Commerce Department last week reduced its estimates of economic growth in 2010 and early 2011. At the same time, it said corporate income was much better than it had thought. Using newly available data from 2009 corporate tax returns, the department raised its estimates of corporate profits by 8.3 percent for 2009 and 10.8 percent for 2010.

The new figures indicate that corporate profits accounted for 14 percent of the total national income in 2010, the highest proportion ever recorded. The previous peak, of 13.6 percent, was set in 1942 when the need for war materials filled the order books of companies at the same time as the government imposed wage and price controls, holding down the costs companies had to pay.

In the first quarter of 2011, the latest figures available, the new estimates indicate corporate profits accounted for 14.2 percent of national income, well above the 13.1 percent that had previously been estimated.

3)

Victims of improper foreclosure practices can submit claims

Fourteen mortgage servicers have begun mailing out 4.3 million letters to potential victims of robo-signing. The letters will invite borrowers to submit their cases for a free review by independent consultants.

Victims of improper foreclosure practices can submit claims

About 70% of those potentially slated to receive letters about submitting their cases for review are still in their homes. Above, Renzo Salazar of Ace Post Holding Inc. places a bank-owned sign outside a foreclosed home in Miami. ( Joe Raedle, Getty Images / November 2 , 2011 )

Aggrieved homeowners ensnared by a foreclosure system riddled with misconduct and error are set to get their first shot at winning some cash back from the banks.
Under orders from federal regulators, 14 mortgage servicers on Tuesday began mailing out 4.3 million letters to potential victims of wrongful foreclosure practices. The letters will invite borrowers to submit their cases for a free review by independent consultants that are funded by the lenders but vetted by regulators.
Borrowers may be compensated if the reviewers and regulators find that the homeowners were harmed financially.
"These requirements help ensure that the servicers provide appropriate compensation to borrowers who suffered financial harm as a result of improper practices," said John Walsh, acting comptroller of the currency, whose agency regulates the nation's largest banks. The Federal Reserve has also issued the enforcement orders.

AND NONE OF THE CRIMINAL BANKSTERS HAVE BEEN INVESTIGATED, PROSECUTED OR JAILED!

BUT THAT'S ABOUT TO CHANGE!

Anyone who doesn't understand what precipitated OWS either does not want to understand because it threatens some right-wing political agendas, or, hasn't been victimized directly, or, is too blindly loyal to right-wing, THE-MARKETPLACE-IS-GOD ideology to realize they have, in fact, been victimized.

Don't bother to attack me personally ... because I'll throw FACTS in your face ... just rebut what I've posted ... WITH SPECIFICS, not rhetoric.

NOTE: Need more examples of why people are pissed at ORGANIZED WEALTH AND ITS OWNERSHIP OF BOTH REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS ... got plenty.

For the record ... a pox on both their houses!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Come on Terry, you can do better than that. Why don't you look at how many new start up business failed this year? Did they not work hard and take risks? Do they not have to pay off loans or loose their money that they invested?

Define working hard. Do you work hard? Matt thinks he works hard. Don't you think that most people who work, think that they work hard?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Well put Mal!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Mal:

Perrie and I are in agreement on one thing, it's not the "rich" which are causing this phenomena, but the government.

Though Perrie thinks it is an "unholy" alliance between business and government. But it ain't so "unholy" at least from the perspective of business.

After all, it is business's role to seek to maximize profits. That is NOT the role of the government.

So, if anything, it is the unholy government causing this increased disparity.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Perrie:

See my post above. Business isn't in the business of "fairness."

Government shouldn't be in the business of "assuring" fairness either. It should just not be actively participating in making things "unfair." With that you and I agree.

Moreover, "fairness" is a myth, a dream. The only thing "leveling" the playing field does is make sure that everyone plays on a lower playing field. Going to the LCD is not the solution, not at all.

and of course it's about freebies. To think otherwise is not rational.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Mal;

am composing answer, will get back.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

A.Mac:

Tell me buddy, WHAT and WHO made that happen? Don't give me that "right wing" bullshit.

You know, if you are honest, that the GUMMININT made that happen!

NOTE: Need more examples of why people are pissed at ORGANIZED WEALTH AND ITS OWNERSHIP OF BOTH REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS ... got plenty.

You ALMOST have it right there.

Why get pissed at the "wealthy" because they are able to buy crooked, corrupt politicians? After all, the business of business is to increase and maximize profit and if buying/influencing politicians is the way to do that, that is what they should be trying to do.

How about getting pissed off at the corrupt politicians? Why aren't the OWS and 99% pissed off at THE CORRUPT politicians like Obama, and the rest (almost every one, on either side of the aisle.)

For the record ... a pox on both their houses!

Yeah, right. Your entire post is how the "Right wing" is this, that, and this and that, and the cause of everything including measeles.

And then you say that. Why not start OUT with that and discuss politicians as a whole?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Perrie:

why did they fail? Look into that issue. I have a pretty good feel for that as I represent many of them, from soup to nuts.

Initially, most businesses fail in the first year. That has been SO FOREVER! This is mostly due to inability to actually run a business and collect their dough.

But many are also failing now due to increased costs, most of such costs being engendered by, you got it, gumminit!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Your missing my point. I grew up in such a family business ( my mom owned a children's clothing store... you're wife might have even shopped in it!). I am well aware that it has always been that way.

But my question to you, was did they not take the risk, that everyone here seems to attribute only to the 1%? Of course they did. Did they not work hard? Of course they did. The reasons a business fails in the first year variestremendously, but the point I was making is that it's not just hard work that makes you a success, it's luck, it's timing, it'stenacity.

But many are also failing now due to increased costs, most of such costs being engendered by, you got it, gumminit!

I am not sure of that. Yes, wedefinitelyhave an increase in costs, that makes it harder to start a business, and I am not sure how many start up there have been since the recession, so I can't point to anything in particular. I'm not sure why you think it's the government... or why you are spelling it that way.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Changed my reply here... I see in another comment that you are composing a reply... Thanks.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

So, if anything, it is the unholy government causing this increased disparity.

And how did that happen Terry? It's because our representatives that we vote for have already been bought by those who pay into their campaigns. They are beholden to them. Now you and I can give some money to a rep, but who do you think they listen to, you who might give $1000 or a company who gives, $117,000 dollars over a two year period? How about PACs who can give unlimited amounts to a party? Is that a level playing field?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Perrie:

Frankly, I'm not sure you have a point. Who the hell ever said that ONLY the 1% (whoever they are) are the ONLY ones who take any sort of risks? Not me, and not anyone on this site.

I was making is that it's not just hard work that makes you a success, it's luck, it's timing, it'stenacity.

Yeah, so? Is it not "fair" that it is so? I will note one famous saying by a golfer when asked how the hell he made so many putts. "Making putts is a lot easier when you hit your irons close to the pin."

I'm spelling it that way because that is what it has become, a joke! I can spell it regularly, but not sure it would get my point across as well. If it bothers, I will be glad to stop.

Again, not sure of your point and how this works into the 99%.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Perrie:

We agree. Why get mad at business for this? Seems to me that it is the corrupt politicians against whom we should direct our anger?

As, frankly, the tea party did. They got it right, they knew (and know) exactly who was causing the issues.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Of course business isn't about fairness, nor am I implying so.Business is about making money. But ourrepresentationshould be and it isn't. And that is what drive the whole economy.

And this fixation on freebies is acharacteristrizationof what is going on. Just look at that chart, and you know there is something wrong. People want to know that if they work, that at the end of the day, their buying power isn't diminished. They would like the same compensation for a job well done. That chart clearly shows that isn't what is going on.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

No problem. I am in the middle of some crap now and just can't give it due attention. I can post short quips, but not really take the time (attention) to post a lengthier post!

I will, though. However, chances are that it will boil down to what you said in your prior reply!

LOL, it'll just be longer.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Why get pissed at the "wealthy" because they are able to buy crooked, corrupt politicians?

That question seems so absurd that it is hardly worth answering. But I'll give it a try. For starters... Because they scream and cry about every thing anyone does stop them from buying what they want (you know what I'm talking about... it is that "regulation" you think is so evil). Are you saying only the recipient of a bribe is guilty and the briber is not guilty because he is only trying to make a profit??? Never mind that the briber is asking the bribee to do things that hurt people who have no means, opportunity, or desire to bribe.

After all, the business of business is to increase and maximize profit and if buying/influencing politicians is the way to do that, that is what they should be trying to do.

It absolutely is not!!! Your notion that the ONLY responsibility business has is to maximize it's profits does not even make good business sense... to say nothing of the fact that is morally vacant! Leaving aside the moral issues, the only circumstance in which it makes sense for a business to hurt the society upon which it is dependent for its profits, is when it feels the collapse of the society is imminent and there is nothing that can be done to restore societal health. I know... I know... You think that if we could just get the evil government out of the way then everything will take care of itself... a healthy society will be "naturally" restored by the "ecosystem" of a "free market."

How about getting pissed off at the corrupt politicians? Why aren't the OWS and 99% pissed off at THE CORRUPT politicians like Obama, and the rest (almost every one, on either side of the aisle.)

I am pissed at the corrupt politicians! But, as I am sure I don't need to tell you, you and I have a little disagreement about where the bulk of the corruption lies.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

How about getting pissed off at the corrupt politicians? Why aren't the OWS and 99% pissed off at THE CORRUPT politicians like Obama, and the rest (almost every one, on either side of the aisle.)

OWS is in fact pissed off at the politics of Washington and its marriage to the 1% ... including Obama; OWS in not a political movment, it's populist.

But it's primarily and consistently the Republicans who are fighting reforms in order to protect the 1% and the tax breaks for the wealthy that go with it. Kissing Grover Norquist's ass, in effect shoves it up mine ... and yours.

The record shows ...

1) The Deregulation of Wall Street leading to the near depression of 2008

...

The Subprime Mess and Phil Gramm: An Experiment in Deregulation

Paul Kiesel
Contributor

Posted by Paul Kiesel June 24, 2008 4:12 PM

In 1933, a few years following the stock market crash, Congress passes the Glass-Steagall Act, in hopes that regulating banks will help prevent market instability, particularly amongst Wall Street banks. The purpose of the act is to separate commercial banks that focus on consumers from investment banks, which deal with speculative trading and mergers.

The Glass-Steagall Act provided the proper oversight and entity separation that would prohibit banks and other financial companies from merging into giant trusts (conflict of interests) -- giant trusts or corporations being more powerful, naturally, and having the seemingly limitless capital to lobby their corporate interests, however, with a very myopic scope (particularly when it comes to factoring in potential losses -- most banks, as seen in contemporary times, chose not to anticipate losses in the mortgage market; they presumed home prices would continue to appreciate).

In 1999, former Senator Phil Gramm (who was, incidentally, Senator John McCain's economic adviser and cochaired his presidential campaign) set out to completely gut the Glass-Steagall Act, and did so successfully, replacing most of its components with the new Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act: allowing commercial banks, investment banks, and insurers to merge (which would have violated antitrust laws under Glass-Steagall). Sen. Gramm was the driving force behind the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, as he had received over $4.6 million from the FIRE sector (Finance, Insurance and Real Estate donations) over the previous decade, and once the Act passed, an influx of "megamergers" took place among banks and insurance and securities companies, as if they had been eagerly awaiting the passage of Gramm's Act.

2)

FACT SHEET | October 10, 2008

The Credit Crisis: The Bush Administration's Record of Denial and Regulatory Neglect

For more than a decade, President Bush and/or Congressional Republicans have controlled Washington. During these Bush-McCain Republican years, Americans have seen their dreams of homeownership and a secure retirement gambled away by reckless economic policies that put Wall Street and special interests ahead of middle class families. Not only did the Bush Administration ignore the warning signs about risky mortgages, they encouraged the very practices that are at the heart of the current economic crisis and stood in the way of efforts that would have prevented the crisis.

The epicenter of the current market turmoil has been caused by risky mortgages that the Bush Administration failed to regulate. Beginning in 2000, Federal Reserve Governor Edward Gramlich warned that predatory lending would "jeopardize the twin American dreams of owning a home and building wealth." (1/18/02) In 2006, Moody's Economy.com warned that "problems in the mortgage-backed market would spill over into the rest of the U.S. fixed income and stock markets... The turmoil in the U.S. financial markets would immediately reverberate around the world, engendering a global financial event." (Moody's Economy.com, October 2006) Moreover, the Federal Reserve staff observed a prolonged loosening of standards for mortgages starting in late 2003. (Federal Reserve staff briefing for Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee staff, 3/20/07)

3)

...

Obamas Jobs Plan Is Blocked Again by Senate Republicans

By ROBERT PEAR Published: October 20, 2011

WASHINGTON For the second time in 10 days, the Senate on Thursday rejected Democratic efforts to take up a jobs bill championed by President Obama .

The vote to advance the bill was 50 to 50 . Democrats needed 60 votes to overcome a Republican filibuster .

This time, the bill was narrowed to provide $35 billion to state and local governments to prevent layoffs of teachers, police officers and firefighters. To offset the cost, the bill would impose a surtax of 0.5 percent, starting in 2013, on income in excess of $1 million.

Obama, until recently, lacked the courage to call out Republicans/Teavangelicals for their continued sabotage of the economy for purely political gain.

Republicans indeed, as I have stipulated specifically, are the primary culprits in protecting corporate greed and crime.

The pox I place on the Democrats house is directed toward the blue dog cowards who forsake the citizenry as do the Republicans.

Terry,

If you can refute my specifics ... do it. If you can't, don't bother with rhetorical questions ... the case is laid out before you.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

quick response.

Of course, if it is actual bribery, then both briber and bribee are acting illegally, throw them both in jail.

But that is not what we are talking about Mal, and you know that. We are talking about legal contributions (according to, you got it, the government) which result in politicians being beholden to the contributor.

Not illegal. But, as we have discussed, ONLY the wealthy can undertake to contribute sufficient amounts so as to trigger the politician being beholden.

Because they scream and cry about every thing anyone does stop them from buying what they want (you know what I'm talking about... it is that "regulation" you think is soevil).

Hmm, not sure you are understanding what I am saying. Those who have the dough are NOT complaining about the government regulations since such entities are easily able to pay such costs and such costs act as a hurdle which competitors must clear prior to being a serious competitor!

Take GE for example. Or Microsoft, or any other huge company. Generally, they LOVE most regulation (note the most, they don't cotton to anti trust legislation, LOL) since they are able to meet or exceed it and smaller competitors (who might in the future be larger competitors) cannot! They are letting the government get rid of their competitors!

Hence, Perrie's "unholy" alliance.

Your notion that theONLYresponsibility business has is to maximize it's profits does not even make good business sense... to say nothing of the fact that is morally vacant! Leaving aside the moral issues, the only circumstance in which it makes sense for a business to hurt the society upon which it is dependent for its profits, is when it feels the collapse of the society is imminent and there is nothing that can be done to restore societal health. I know... I know... You think that if we could just get theevilgovernment out of the way then everything will take care of itself... a healthy society will be "naturally" restored by the "ecosystem" of a "free market."

Again, you mistake me or aren't understanding what I am saying, or are making unwarranted assumptions. It may well be that certain actions which you would consider to be "moral" are, in fact, in the best economic interest of the entity. Why do you think so many are so involved in their communities in a philanthropic sense? Why do you think they always advertise such involvement! Clearly, for the economic benefit they know it will bring.

Acting in what you consider a proper way is not always acting in a way which is NOT profitable.

This argument reminds me of the argument Ayn Rand always had vis a vis her assertion that there was no such thing as selflessness.

Damn, call, gotta run.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Ayn Rand...

From AlterNet...

Ayn Rand was not only a schlock novelist, she was also the progenitor of a sweeping moral philosophy that justifies the privilege of the wealthy and demonizes not only the slothful, undeserving poor but the lackluster middle-classes as well.

Damn if that doesn't sound just like you, Terry... Well... actually, I know nothing about any novels you may have written... sigh...

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Have you ever read any Ayn Rand?

Would not expect to read anything else from Alternet!

However, Mal, all I was mentioning was her position that there is no such thing as selflessness. That all of those actions which one asserts are "selfless" are actually selfish.

Can you dispute that?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

What specifics A.Mac?

You are the master of non sequiturs!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

OWS is in fact pissed off at the politics of Washington and its marriage to the 1% ... including Obama; OWS in not a political movment, it's populist.

Bull, I'll believe it when I see them giving him hell and blaming him and his corrupt politics the same as they do for the pubs, eh?

What the hell is OWS all about anyway?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

THESE SPECIFICS TERRY!

And you are the master of evading the question. The events stipulated (second time), logically answer the question at hand which is "why the fall," and why the resultant anger as manifested by OWS.

I requested that you, et al, respond to the specifics, rather than trying to mischaracterize and question my veracity.

1) The Deregulation of Wall Street leading to the near depression of 2008

...

The Subprime Mess and Phil Gramm: An Experiment in Deregulation

2)

FACT SHEET | October 10, 2008

The Credit Crisis: The Bush Administration's Record of Denial and Regulatory Neglect

...

3)

Obamas Jobs Plan Is Blocked Again by Senate Republicans

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

What the hell is OWS all about anyway?

Among other things it has precipitated this ... aimed at all Federal legislators ... all parties ...

I have asked a professional lobbyist and a series of Constitutional scholars. They tell me that it will require a large, unrelenting, organized group aligned around a Constitutional Amendment to Get Money Out of politics.

So here is a draft of an Amendment and here is a petition to start the movement.

Our goal is to get a large, unrelenting, organized group to sign on to a petition asking our politicians to ban money in politics. If we can get it big enough, we can use my show on MSNBC as a platform to force this issue to the center of next year's Presidential debate. Without you I am just a talking head. With you we are 100,000 American s for Justice.

Do your homework before questing my statements in your righteously indignant manner!

BTW ... it's good to be kicking your right-wing, faux-libertarian ass again! Good to see you.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

LOL, and just how are you doing that?

And how have I questioned your statements?

Once again into the breach my dear friend!

And by the way, it would take a Constitutional Amendment as it would be a limit on the first amendment, that little pesky thing that the democrats, liberals, and lefties hate!

Note, where does OWS say this is one of their stated goals?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Oh, you mean you wish me to refute the bullcrap in those articles about issues which weren't even being discussed!

Hence the "non sequitur" remark!

Can I take a rain check. I'm beat from working to pay for all those damned dead beats masturbating and defecating in the parks.

I'm on my way to a Ketel One at a very exclusive Steak House where they only let in the 1%, and then ONLY if they've kicked the ass of a 99% that very day!

Randall:

Don't need snarky shit from you. You have a question, ask it. You want to get involved in the discussion, do it. You want to snipe at a distance, shove it.

Hmmm was that a violation of the CoC, or just responsive to a violation of the CoC?

Night all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Yo, Terry ...

Do you read anything before commenting?

OWS and Dylan Ratigan met on Wall Street and that meeting precipitated the effort!

So here is a draft of an Amendment and here is a petition to start the movement.

I stated that it's about a Constitutional Amendment ...

a DRAFT of our Constitutional Amendment for public debate this fall:

"No person, corporation or business entity of any type, domestic or foreign, shall be allowed to contribute money, directly or indirectly, to any candidate for Federal office or to contribute money on behalf of or opposed to any type of campaign for Federal office. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, campaign contributions to candidates for Federal office shall not constitute speech of any kind as guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution or any amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Congress shall set forth a federal holiday for the purposes of voting for candidates for Federal office."

Another DRAFT of the amendment.

"No non-citizen shall contribute money, directly or indirectly, to any candidate for Federal office. United States citizens shall be free to contribute no more than the equivalent of $100 to any federal candidate during any election cycle. Notwithstanding the limits construed to be part of the First Amendment, Congress shall have the power to limit, but not ban, independent political expenditures, so long as such limits are content and viewpoint neutral. Congress shall set forth a federal holiday for the purposes of voting for candidates for Federal office."



 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Again ... did you read the article ... this in particular ...

Also cited as factors contributing to the rapid growth of income at the top were the structure of executive compensation ; high salaries for some superstars in sports and the arts; the increasing size of the financial services industry; and the growing role of capital gains, which go disproportionately to higher-income households.

The report found that higher-income households got a larger share of the pie, while other households got smaller shares.

Specifically the report made these points:

The share of after-tax household income for the top 1 percent of the population more than doubled, climbing to 17 percent in 2007 from nearly 8 percent in 1979.

The most affluent fifth of the population received 53 percent of after-tax household income in 2007, up from 43 percent in 1979. In other words, the after-tax income of the most affluent fifth exceeded the income of the other four-fifths of the population.

People in the lowest fifth of the population received about 5 percent of after-tax household income in 2007, down from 7 percent in 1979.

People in the middle three-fifths of the population saw their shares of after-tax income decline by 2 to 3 percentage points from 1979 to 2007.

That delineates "the fall" and tells who fell; I delineated the evolution of the acceleration of the fall which started with Reagan and got shoved further up our middle class butts by Bush 43 (see my earlier posts) with follow ups from Norquist, Boehner, Cantor, McConnell, Ryan and the Teavangelicals who want to repeal Dodd-Frank ...

The Wall Street reform bill will for the first time bring comprehensive regulation to theswaps marketplace.Swap dealers will be subject to robust oversight. Standardized derivatives will be required to trade on open platforms and be submitted for clearing to central counterparties. The Commission looks forward to implementing the Dodd-Frank bill to lower risk, promote transparency and protect the American public.

Enjoy your vodka and steak and, toast one from me to the 1% clientele ... it should be short and sweet ... just two words ...

"F .... ,

... excuse me, my phone's ringing ...

I'll get back to you.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

It was...

a sweeping moral philosophy that justifies the privilege of the wealthy and demonizes not only the slothful, undeserving poor but the lackluster middle-classes as well.

that reminded me of you.

That all of those actions which one asserts are "selfless" are actually selfish.

I think it can be reasonably argued that everything we do has some personal motivation behind it. If I say

I cannot enjoy the benefits of my success knowing there are others who have worked as hard as I have but have not had the success I have had. I have no wish to support those who are abusing the system. By the same token, I do not want to penalize those who have done nothing abusive simply because others are abusive. Of course I want to do everything possible to stop fraud and abuse, but for me, supporting some who do not deserve my support is a price I am willing to pay in order to ensure that those who do deserve support get what they need.

It is not unreasonable to suggest that part of what motivates me is the desire to comfort myself. Furthermore, one can argue that the Golden Rule itself suggests a selfish baseline motive. Nonetheless... I do not think having some personally beneficial motive negates the merit of any empathetic motives I might have.

Rand's assertion seems like a way to justify the abandonment of empathy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

It's only a "dead horse" to the wishful thinkers who don't like the handwriting on the wall, which says ...

"YOU AIN'T SEEN NOTHIN' YET."

Going back to the original NT site, I have called every shot ... starting with saying to Terry (during the Egyptian uprising ... also London, Paris, etc.,) that America would take to the street in protest over the same issue ... "THE UNHOLY MARRIAGE OF GOVERNMENT AND BIG MONEY AT THE EXPENSE OF THE MIDDLE CLASS AND POOR."

Terry said it would never happen.

You ain't seen nothin' yet! Wait until the voter suppression begins ... wait until lines at polling places extend for blocks and the Republican machine greased with Koch tells people who have voted for years, that they can no longer vote ... even at the very polling places where they've voted again and again!

SHIT STORM COMIN'!

Possibly some will remember what I wrote.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Come on, Mike ... touting your most positive qualities on this board is shameless self-promotion!

Save the egomania for the "Let's Make Obscene Phone Calls to Elderly Shut-ins" Blog on Rick Perry's website.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Mike,

You're not hanging on my every post ... I already gave information about a possible Constitutional Amendment to get money out of Federal elections ...

One step at a time ... take the corporate money out of the pockets of legislators>take the lobbying out of Washington>unrigged game

The effort began with Dylan Ratigan and OWS after they met at the occupation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

One "protestor" in a tent ... one photographer ... and cops all around.

Seems fair.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

ROFLMAO!!!

Bruce,

Gotta say you got that one right... or is it left, LOL!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Terry,

Because the implication of this whole dialog, is that the 1% have worked harder than any other people, and therefore deserve what they have. In fact, many don't work that hard at all. There are those in the other two classes that work every bit as hard, if not harder and are being pounded into the ground by the current economic system. And that is my point.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

and of course it's about freebies. To think otherwise is not rational.

Why? Because you say so?

I don't want anything from mygovernment. We have a pension (private), investments, insurance.... so what do I want?

What I don't want, is to be taxed at an effective rate, that makes me pay a higher proportion of my income than the top 1% do. That isn't a freebee. That is the government representing me...

Or have you forgotten about taxation without proper representation?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

An issue with OCS is that the TOP 30 CORPORATIONS IN AMERICA BENEFIT FROM ...

REPRESENTATION WITHOUT TAXATION!

30 U.S. corporations pay no income taxes

Thirty large and profitable U.S. corporations paid no income taxes in 2008 through 2010, said a study on Thursday that arrives as Congress faces rising demands for tax reform but seems unable or unwilling to act.

ALL THIS WHILE THE CEOs and BANKSTERS EXPORT AMERICAN JOBS TO MEXICO, INDIA and CHINA and get BONUSES and the BUSH TAX BREAKS!

The average teacher salary in the U.S. is about $43,000/year ...

THE AVERAGE WALL STREET BONUS IS $125,000/year!

Read more: 30 U.S. corporations pay no income taxes - Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

Let's stop playing dumb, Righties.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Mike...

Did I miss something or were you having some sort of flash back?

The 70's were a lot of fun ;-)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

You speak the truth, Randy!

Damn... what is wrong with me...I keep agreeing with you today.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

In retrospect this article is BS ...

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors