Occupy Wall Street Revisited... The Movement as it was Three Weeks Ago.. Much Has Changed
I did this report 3 weeks ago. Much has changed since then. There are now two movements; OWS and the 99% . They are both atZuccotti Park, but they have published different platforms. Also, finally, the media has taken note of the different participants in the park. That includes the actual protesters, the homeless and addicts that have joined them in the park and the mixed feelings about whether or not to feed and cloth these people. It has become more complex and more diverse, but the message that the middle and working classes are getting the squeeze is gaining support.
I am reprinting myoriginalarticle from when we were on grouply, because the videos are beginning to get out there, and I felt they needed a reference point. I will be going back to the park to try and interview some of the folks that I couldn't get that day and see what has changed.
As you approach the park where Occupy Wall Street has made their home, you have to go past the somber past of our history, the site of the World Trade Center. It was the first time I have done so, since that terrible day, and I have to say that it shook me to the core. And then it hits you as you walk one block past it, and approach Zuccotti Park, the irony of what you are seeing. The ruins of what was once hub of commerce, being protested about just one block away.
As you approach the park, it seems like you have taken a step back in time, to the 1960s. It looked from a distance like a massive sit in, with people holding up placards with their messages. Its only when you walk into the park that you get a whole different perspective. Things really do look different from a distance.
The people who filled the park where from many walks of life, from those who obviously wanted to protest the banks and the corporations, to two very nasty Native Americans, who wanted to protest 400 years of occupation of Manhattan Island. There were people who could articulate why they were there, and those who just complained that the corporations or the banks had taken overyet they couldnt give me a concrete thought on the back ground of the subject. They were just angry. There where homeless people, who had set up camp there to people and junkies who were just kind of taking it in. The fact is that Occupy Wall Street has no unifying message. They are just there. Some well meaning folks mixed in with some very hateful ones.
In fact, the thing that hit me the most about this protest is the contradiction going on.
When Fox News showed up to do some filming and interviewing of a group of protesters, the protesters started to chant, Fuck Fox News and Freedom of Speech, Leave Fox News. Rather ironic, I thought. Although I am not a fan of Fox News, dont they have freedom of speech, too? Hypocrisy seemed to be a one of the themes of the day. When I asked a protester who was declined to be interviewed on camera, why he was there, he said he was protesting against the corporations. A young man was standing next to me listening. The protester ranted on that all we needed to do was stop buying stuff at place like Walmart once a week and they would (the corporations) feel the pain. I asked him, But that would also put people out of work. He replied, Its the corporations fault. I noticed that he had several cameras on him, so I said, But you support the corporations. Look at all your cameras. To which he said, I dont need your bullshit and walked away. I have the audio of the young man who was standing next to me. He put it so well. Hypocrite.
One of the strangest moments was the juxdipacation of Lubavitch Orthodox Jews, encouraging Jews to say a prayer for Sukkot, the holiday that celebrates the harvest, next to a guy that was yelling that the Jews are taking over the world. I interviewed the Orthodox Jews and asked why they were there, thinking that they were there to counter this other man. Not so. They just wanted Jews in attendance to say a small prayer and said they were apolitical. They were pleasant and friendly, but kind of clueless. On the other hand, the man with the very anti-Semitic message was nasty and hateful, and although many people tried to counter his hate filled message that made little sense, there were other protesters, protecting him and his freedom of speech, while yelling down the people confronting him. Go away you Jew lovers. You look like a Jew! Why dont you go back to Israel?
I met families who were there, who were self described ex-hippies from the 60s. They wanted their children to see democracy in action. They were very pleasant and articulate. They were among the first that could actually express what they felt was wrong with the system and that the corporations had way too much power. That the people must take a stand against policies that give corporations too much power.
There was a spot where the unions unofficially set up home. They too, were very well spoken and very nice. Their concerns were the same as the ex-hippies families. He spoke of broken promises that the corporations had made to the unions and how he had to adapt to keep working. I asked him what was his political party and He said that he was a Democrat but that he believed in some socialist ideas, but that he didnt consider himself a socialist.
Shortly after that, I met some seniors and asked why they were there. A lovely woman explained to me that this movement was bound to happen because people are unhappy. They see the corporate greed with loosing their jobs and their houses. When I asked her if he ever heard of the 54% group, she said no. I said that they represent the 54% of Americans who pay taxes. She laughed and said that she paid taxes, too. So who do you support, I asked. The 99% or the 54%? She said the 99% since the 1% was under taxed.
Milling my way through the crowd, I came upon the strangest sign I had seen worn on a very pretty girl. It said Corporations dont own my womb. Thinking that this was a statement about abortion, I asked her if that was what she meant. She said no. It was that the corporations are taking over everything natural and soon they would own her womb. So I asked her did she mean corporations like Monsanto. She replied, no, all corporations, not just Monsanto. She said, that her statement was on a higher plane of thought. I guess Im just not that smart, because I didnt get it.
As I absorbed what was said to me and looked around at the various signs, I dont really think that these folks both well meaning or not, making a statement or not, have a cohesive message other than frustration. Who and what they are frustrated about, truly depended on who you spoke to. The perfect summation of the day was a Turkish man I spoke to, who was on a hunger strike. He told me that he was protesting the corporations who supported the Turkish government and that this support was not only leading to genocide in Turkey, but all around the world. When I told him that our government is not supporting genocide in Turkey, he shrugged and asked How can you be so sure? So I asked him the same question back. He looked confused and said nothing. Well, that said it all. Kind of like this movement, at this point. Confused and saying nothing.
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors

Nadia,
I honestly don't get you at all. You're not part of that 1% are you? In fact, what have the 1% done for you? BTW, to be in that 1% you have to be making a net income of over $344,000, far more than any doctor makes.
And no one is calling them evil, they are just about themselves. Isn't that human nature? It doesn't mean that we have to tolerate a system that gives them more. Current tax law benefits them, not the middle class. At least we should have tax restructure.
And yet you don't like Freedman. Go figure?
Randy,
I think that those who don't get it, just don't understand the tax code and have been led to believe that this 1% will provide them with jobs. In fact, that isn't the case, as we have seen with some of these CEO's bonuses and salaries and profits that yielded little if any jobs.
Still, taxing the rich to death isn't the way. They are taxed at a respectable rate. What they have that the average guy doesn't is loopholes in the tax code. These need to be plugged up. Also treating corporations as individuals has taken government out of the hands of the people and given it to the rich and the government who has developed asymbioticrelationship with each other.
The reason that conservatives support the 1% is very simple in June of 1776, Rich land owner and conservative, John Dickenson, a member of the 2nd ContinentalCongress said, "That most men would rather protect the possibility of becoming rich, than face the reality of being poor, and that is why they will follow us". Sounds about right.
There is an old saying about the economy :
" A rising tide lifts all boats ."
However when the tide rose only the biggest boats rose with it .
I understand the need to demand clarity and honesty from Wallstreet, and in this public forum. I say good on those who chose to voice an opinion and work towards dialouge. We have crooks in washington and wallstreet, workin' in cahoots to rip us off!
What bothers me is the idea that it is the rich against the poor. The violence bothers me. The bums and druggies bother me. There aresome noble ideas; I hope they have a chance to be explored and the extremists on whatever sides, get lost.
Mike,
You have no idea who or what I am. Without giving away much private info, I would say that a large portion of my family is in that top 1%. This has nothing to do with class envy. That is some ultra right wingrhetoric. I just was also an audtor and I have seen the benefits that they have that the real middle class hasn't had in a very long time, and only getting worse. If I was a true liberal, I would be saying tax the rich to death, but I don't. In fact, I think it's a terrible idea. I just want a level playing field.
Communist, heck, I would be one strange communist. Tell that to my coach bags.
What? Are you worried that they will stop buying your neat little toys? Don't worry, they won't. They will still have plenty of disposable income at hand.
Exactly! But be careful what you say.. Mike will brand you a liberal/communist, LOL!
Larry,
I am on the same page as you are. I am very concerned about class warfare. It takes a toll on a society. All someone has to do is look what happened in the French Revolution or the Russian one. It was a scary scene.
Is it? What it never happened before? I think it's an honest concern. When people are unhappy about anything, and there is enough of them, you have the possibility of anything happening. Or did you just miss the Arab Spring. And I am not liking what I am seeing over there.
The statistics are hard to argue with . The wealth is being concentrated increasingly
in the hands of the already wealthiest .
" That has been true for 1,000 years. "
It was true in feudal times . Then we got away from that in the US . There was a real middle class who had a significant portion of the wealth . But now things are returning to feudal times here .
However in China they have a very large and wealthy
middle class . That is where our wealth has migrated to .
Spot on, Rich!
Randy,
I just don't believe that as much as I don't believe what Mike thinks. I think that it's just a natural state of the human condition When you have a lot, and you can get more, you just do. If the little guy gets left behind, who cares... you don't see them... you don't even live near them.
This is no concocted plan except for the corporations. They are all about the biggest win. They are not even thinking about the workers. It's just the bottom line. And again, it's organic. Our government makes it easy for them to do it, so they do it.
I blame the government, but who bought out thegovernment? The rich. It is a symbiotic relationship. Each needs each other.
As for children, Mike, your wrong. Check out these tables.
Wait, I give you facts and you give me a deflection based onsociology, which most of the time you don'tbelievein, unless it suits you. Sorry, no good. Try again. Facts, notopinion.
And BTW that has to do with developing countries, not the US.
Naughty, naughty!
Oh, and when one cites, they should give a link.
Complete and utter bullshit Randy, because it has never left the human species. There has always been envy and strife. Actually turning this entire event into somebourgeois militant movement is not a reaction to a "Class beat-down" of any sorts. That is nothing but pure envy piled upon envy.
Shit, almost anybody can be rich if they live in America and want it bad enough. I can, you can, any of us can. But we don't.
Ya wanna know why?
Because money is moreimportantto some than others. If your life's ambition is to be a millionaire, and that's all you cared about, then you would do it.
I have more important things to enliven my day with than money.
Bruce,
I found what I was looking for finally, and it's not about who is getting free chit!
from Congressional Budget Office from 1979-2007
Here is a graph of the findings:
That is why people are mad. Who has created this inequality? An unholyalliancebetween big business and government, who have asymbioticrelationship toexist.
So true. And really after house number 7 do you really need house number 8? Oh yeah... Capital Gains! You do need house number 8.
Randy,
I thought us indies were conservatives in sheep's clothes? LOL!
But that is why we are fence sitters!
Hey, get that out of my butt!
Mike ,
You are talking globally but Perrie is talking about the US .
It is not class warfare. It is evening the field. It is making sure that the government represents us and isn't bought off by corporations or fat cats. It's about having our voices heard and making sure that the tax code isn't written to benefit a few.
That's not true Bruce. People can make it, it's just much, much harder. Somewhere in here is a long term government study about how things have changed since the "70's.
Bruce,
You keep saying it's about getting rich, but for most American's it's just about getting by. You know, a nice cape cod, a new car every so often, nothing fancy, not worrying how to pay the bills or if they have to make a choice between cutting back on the food one week to make the electric bill. This is what we are talking about.
Kids are going to college now, only to come out to find no jobs. They have huge bills to pay. They are moving back home. We have people who are too old to hire, who want jobs. We have banks who don't want to loan people money, because they are protecting their own hineys. This is NOT the America we grew up in, where men came home from the war, bought a home in Levittown, got a nice job that they had for life, with a nice pension, and sent their kids to college at a reasonable rate, so that they could do better. You remember that and so do I. I grew up in such a town. And that is what has changed, not the people, but the system. The system stinks Bruce. It stinks to high heaven.
I don't want a dime from my government. I want them to represent the people. They have forgotten how.
"Far more than any doctor makes?"
You on drugs Perrie? Hell, I know several docs making 2 million per or more, with all expenses paid, including office personnel, etc., etc.
True, not all docs make that much but docs do pretty damn well, especially those that cut.
Talk about not getting it! LOL
Make you a deal, WHEN our vaunted government stops all of the corruption, the waste, the fraud that it engenders and supports wasting tens of billions, more each month, THEN I will agree to higher taxes if they are still needed.
Until then, government and all those calling for higher taxes can flat out stuff it.
Cut spending, cut waste, cut fraud, cut corruption!
Amazing that folks don't see that increased government intervention has caused the increasing disparity in income!
But those who suck off the teat, or believe in government as the end all be all, refuse to see that.
How wrong you are.
Perrie:
Do you really believe that? You know lots of folks on the Island earning more than $300, four kids, all wanting to go to school, taxes out the ying yang.
You think they are worrying about their 8th house?
That's just rabble rousing crap.
Ah, a glimmer of reality. It's not unholy, it's purposeful. Government is all about securing power for those who exercise it, it is how they gain personal wealth. The ONLY way government secures power is through the exercise of regulation (financially). The more regulation, the more they in government are able to direct financial policy to those who will make them powerful and rich.
So, as Herman Cain said, they shouldn't be at Wall Street, they should be in front of the White House.
but those folks are too damned stupid and biased to understand this. They, many of them, are leeches and it is the government body they are sucking off (read you and me, well me at least!) so they cannot bite the hand that feeds them, or that they wish (as pointed out by Bruce and Mike) to feed them to an even greater extent!
Terry,
Of course it purposeful and unholy..
But you and I see regulation in different ways. Deregulation is what led to this banking mess. Some industries, when left to their own devices, will do anything, to drive up profits at the consumers expenses. Don't get me wrong. I believe that consumers have more power than they realize. Just look at what happened with Netflix and Bank of America. But the behind the scene stuff.. that we do need regulation for, otherwise you get what we got from the mortgage mess. Lots of useless paper.
Both Wall Street and our Government bare theburdenof this mess they have gotten us into. But people tend to protest locally. And lets face it, you can't protest in front of the White House, unless you want to be arrested. But they should be writing theirsenatorsand congressmen and woman, and letting them know that they will not be elected if this goes on and they want to see change now, not when they need reelection.
And I'm sorry Terry. I met these folks. You really need to watch video 4,6,7. There is a difference between the OWS and the 99%. They are not leaches, but hard working regular folk. This is a new movement. Mac and Randy will be all to happy to show you some of the stranger folks that came out in the early days of the Tea Party Movement. It's why I still fight with Randy over a certain term ( he's been much better lately, to his credit). These Yabos did call themselves that name. But we both know that isn't the Tea Party. So before we name call, lets see what happens. This has only been going on for 5 weeks now and it must be striking a cord with the American people because instead of loosing popularity in the polls, they are gaining. And that should tell you something.