╌>

High Court To Decide If Law Enforcement Officers Need Warrant For GPS-Tracking

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  rebecca-mcfarland  •  15 years ago  •  7 comments

High Court To Decide If Law Enforcement Officers Need Warrant For GPS-Tracking

Seems like the DoJ ought to be renamed to something that more appropriately represents what it stands for these days. Maybe something like "Department of Snoops" "Department Against Freedom" or "Department of InJustice" would better describe what the DoJ is really all about..?

The Washington, D.C.-based appeals court ruled that the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures require police get a warrant before affixing a GPS device to a car or truck.

The federal Justice Department, appealing the warrant requirement, argues that drivers do not expect their movements to be kept private. "Officers do not conduct a 'search' when they observe matters conducted in the open, which anyone could see," U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli tells the justices in his brief.

Officer.com/USA Today


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Great find Rebecca!

Oddly enough, Terry had an article on a similar topic. I am getting very freaked out about the invasion of privacy that has seeped into our legal system. It started with the Patriot Act and is now going to places that 11 years ago, would have never been tolerated. In fact, I think that the DOJ is using terrorism as an excuse to be intrusive into our lives for reasons of their own. If the SCOTUS allows this, big brother really has taken over.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

As a New Yorker, we have grown used to our police being intrusive. They are at our tunnels and bridges. We have the army in the subway and the railroads. We can always tell when something is up, when we see more of them. But they generally don't bother the people. On the other hand, being pulled over by the police by the tunnels or bridges is, which has happened to us, since we own a minivan ( don't laugh at me!).

I can't see things playing out in favor of our privacy and freedom.

Neither can I. That Patriot Act really sucks.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Of course I am very, very concerned about the trend of this, have been for some time, decades really.

The Patriot Act was a specific and necessary reaction to an unprecedented event. The problem was, as usual, the damned legislators made it too broad! All that was needed to make the Patriot Act acceptable to any liberty loving person, including myself, was the clear statement that it would ONLY be used against FOREIGN terrorists.

But no, far too limited for government. Government, you see, seeks to aggrandize ALL power to itself. It does this as politicians and administrators understand very clearly that THEIR personal power and wealth is directly tied to the power and omnipresence of government.

No matter what any apologists say, this intrusive, 1984'ish imposition of power and theft of freedoms have accelerated greatly under the democrat/Obama admin. Which, of course, only makes sense as democrats (as opposed to TRUE conservatives) believe that government is a force for good, not a threat.

Me, I see it as a clear threat, as should anyone who loves freedom.

I have also posited that the continuing disparity of wealth in this Country is closely tied to the grown of government regulation and interference. Such regulations and interference significantly increase the cost of business formation and operation. In short, when the government gets involved, ONLY the wealthy can afford to begin new businesses and expand existing ones.

I am afraid that I am pessimistic about the continued survival of this Country as a Country of freedom.

Sad that my children, and their children will not experience true freedom. Like Europeans, they will believe that they are "free" as long as the government leaves them alone.

Americans, however, at least those of my age or older, understand that freedom is NOT when government just leaves one alone, it is when government CAN'T undertake to legally impose itself on your life in intrusive ways.

Put another way, freedom isn't the absence of government interference, it's the legal inability of government to interfere!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

I agree with almost except on two points. I think that the Patriot Act is/was equally abused by both administrations. I understand why Bush felt the need for the creation of the act, but at the end of the day, if it falls into the wrong hands, the abuses that can happen are unlimited. Think of what happened after the burning of the Reichstag, and you get the full picture.

I have also posited that the continuing disparity of wealth in this Country is closely tied to the grown of government regulation and interference. Such regulations and interference significantly increase the cost of business formation and operation. In short, when the government gets involved, ONLY the wealthy can afford to begin new businesses and expand existing ones.

OK, here is where we disagree big time. Although I do agree that the disparity of wealth in this country is taking us down a bad path, I think that it's the lack of regulation that has caused it. Take a look at the whole bankingdebacle. That was from a total lack of regulation. I have been trying to find this article that I recently read, where in the last 10 years, richest part of our population has had an increase of net wealth that has increase, of four fold, while the middle class has actually lost money. This just point to that these CEOs are not spending money on creating new jobs but rather making themselves more comfortable.

I am not saying that All government regulation is good, but obviously there is a need for some.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

The federal Justice Department, appealing the warrant requirement, argues that drivers do not expect their movements to be kept private.

Well then, since citizens should not expect a right to privacy when in public, it logically follows that all PUBLIC OFFICIALS, since, by definition, are perpetually PUBLIC, should therefore wear recording equipment 24/7, should have all transactions, phone and personal conversations including internet activity, written correspondence and so on, available for public review ... on a PUBLIC WEB SITE and other venues.

Further, all PUBLIC officials should be required to carry and keep continually active, cell phones with an activated GPS, that too, available for public review.

A petition to this effect might prove interesting ... let's see ...

WHEREAS, the FEDERAL DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE HAS CONTENDED, etc., etc. ...

BE IT RESOLVED ...

You get the idea.

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors