╌>

Why Is Occupy Wall Street a "Liberal Movement"

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  15 years ago  •  62 comments

Why Is Occupy Wall Street a "Liberal Movement"

Why is Occupy Wall Street a "liberal movement". After reading their mile long platform, it seems to me that they have much in common with The Tea Party; less Government, less corporate greed, giving government back to the people. These are all the things that the Tea Party stands for. So, why does OWS get that "Liberal" tag? Is it because of their methodology of a sit in, which isreminiscentof the "60's sit-ins? Is it because they have tag alongs that are mostdefinitelypart of fringemovements?

I am just throwing this question out there. As one of the only members here, who have attended OWS, I have some opinions of my own, but none that are well formed yet, since I think that movement isn't well formed yet, and the final outcome is yet to be seen. Still, what would happen if a member here said, "Yes, I believe in what OWS stands for". Would members of the Tea Party loose total respect for that person? Could they not see that they are very much on the same page? Just some thoughts.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

I think it is clear they are not right wing . No rightist would demand free college
education . And there are other demands along the same lines .

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Hi Perrie,

I left some comments about this topic on Bruce's similar article... But I would like to copy them over here because I think those comments express my views pretty well...

Before I start the copied comments I just want to say this... I don't see this as a Liberal or tea Party Movement... It is a movement of people (perhaps with widely varying ideological backgrounds) who feel the playing field has been tilted in a way that favors some (the 1%) more than others (the 99%).

Here are my comments from the other article... first responding to something Bruce said...

Bruce:
It's basis of protesting and demonizing the rich for being rich is counter to the American Dream of success in life.
Mal:
I have never thought that this was "protesting and demonizing the rich for being rich"!!! And for the record, I DO HAVE "compassion for the 99% movement." I have no interest in reading that absurdly long document... so perhaps my "compassion" is for something different than the authors of that document are about.

I DO NOT have any problem with anyone who is rich... solely on the basis of the fact that they are rich. My objection is to people who are trying to tilt the playing field so they have advantages others do not have. There are SOME rich people who are using there wealth in an effort to do that... many of those people have already had great success with their efforts to gain unfair advantages.

There are many rich people who do not try to gain advantages at the expense of others. In fact, many people, rich or not, very generously use some portion of their own resources to help others who have less and are in need.

I am pretty sure that whoever wrote that document cannot claim to represent more than 0.0000001% of the 99%.

The core issue in the 99% movement is very very simply...

EQUAL FAIRNESS AND JUSTICE FOR ALL

nothing else!


Then in a second comment... I replied to something wmolaw said in response to my first comment...

wmllaw:
Has that ever occurred? Do you actually think it can occur?
Mal:
I think the equality of fairness and justice has varied throughout history, including American history... Has it ever been absolutely equal for everyone??? Absolutely not... Does that fact mean we should not strive for the greatest possible degree of equality we can get??? NOT IN MY BOOK!!!

Here's my little rant on what this is about...

Some people in the Wall Street community (and large corporations) ask for rules changes, less regulation, ("tilting the playing field")... They get them... They abuse their new unregulated "freedom"... the result very nearly destroys the global economic system... They are bailed out... bailed out in large part by money coming from the 99%... Almost none of the people who created that mess are held to account for what they did (no justice, there)... Meanwhile... also part of the same mess, many people who are part of the 99% loose their jobs... and homes... their retirement... their healthcare... At the same time, Wall Street and many large corporations are dripping in unprecedented profits... profits they made on the backs of the 99% and the infrastructure paid for and built by the 99%... Now, as they are just finishing up wringing the last few drops of blood out of the 99% all they can say is... We must have lower taxes and less regulation (preferably none of either) before we can do anything to help you 99%ers... There's just too much "uncertainty"... If you would just get the government off our backs... then we might be able to help.

How breathtakingly disingenuous!!!!

Then... People who have little else they can do... march in the streets asking for fairness and justice... and then they get maligned... I don't understand... I just don't understand it...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

In all fairness , I would have to say that they are at least left leaning . The fact that they seem to be anti-capitalist reveals that . The only question is : how much anti-capitalist are they ? If they really want to destroy the entire capitalist system then they are decidedly leftists . If they only want what Mal said :
"EQUAL FAIRNESS AND JUSTICE FOR ALL"
then it depends on how far they are willing to go to acheive that theoretical result . However , the issue of the partership between big government & big business complicates things .

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

damn, I'm agreeing with Bruce, where the hell is that button!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Nadia has indeed pointed out the ultimate test for determining the answer .
As to the like button , it only applies to the article , not to the comments .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Really interesting comments. I will have to go back to that mind numbing platform and see if they are for redistribution of wealth.

Mal,

I have to say, that I agree with your points. Very well said.

Randy,

Thanks for not using the TB word! It is noticed and noted.

Because the unwavering belief that it's an absolute truth that wealth inequality is bad and wealth redistribution is good

I am not sure if that is their goal. There are some interesting stats that I have to find to show you.

BTW, you guys crack me up. At grouply we had votes ups and no one used it. NOW you want them. [Perrie walks away shaking her headmumblingto herself.]

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

I agree with you, Rich... I too think the 99% movement is generally a movement from the left. That is, the people marching in the streets and many others who are not marching, but sympathize with the marchers are "at least left leaning." But whether the movement is from the left right or center just doesn't matter. People from one end of the political spectrum to the other are part of the 99% whether they recognize it or not and whether they sympathize with the marchers or not.

it depends on how far they are willing to go to achieve that theoretical result

I gotta tell ya Rich... referring to it as "theoretical" seems like a way of dismissing the issue as unattainable... That's what wmolaw was trying to do. YES, it's "theoretical"... but that doesn't mean it isn't VERY relevant!!! The point is the scale is tipped WAY off balance... and it is for THAT reason that people are marching in the streets. It doesn't have to be put back to a "theoretically" perfect state to fix the problem. Of course the "the partnership between big government & big business" complicates things... But the problem is NOT, as most righties would have us believe, how "big" government is... and it is NOT, as some lefties would have us believe, how "big" business is... it IS "the partnership" that is the problem!!! Big business can do good things... and big government can do good things... BOTH of those institutions should be here to server the interests of the American people... in a "BIG" way!!! But unfortunately, they are serving each other's interests... the result being that 99% of the American people come out on the short end of the stick!!!

One more thing... I gotta say something about that "anti-capitalist" terminology... The righties have been very clever in defining capitalism as something that is nothing but goodness and light, and if we just get out of its way, the "free market" will self-regulate!!! Well... businesses are human enterprises... and humans do good things AND bad things. We don't say, "Get rid of the cops, and then if someone commits a crime will let the 'free market' take care of things." That's called vigilantism... personally, I much prefer the rule of law. If we are going to have "big business" capitalism in America, then we need a government that is "big" enough to enforce laws keeping "big business" on the straight and narrow. Regulation is NOT "anti-capitalist"!!! Regulation is an absolute necessity for healthy capitalism!!!

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Here is a little "wavering" of that belief from a leftie for ya Nadia!!!

There is nothing wrong with wealth inequality... provided it is not achieved through unfair practices. When fairness prevails, inequality is automatically moderated.

Redistribution is bidirectional! It is only when redistribution unfairly favors the 1%, as it presently is, that most of us lefties start suggesting its time for it to go back the other direction for a while.

I am a flaming liberal... and PROUD of it... but there is nothing about Communism that appeals to me!!! So I would appreciate it, Nadia, if you would stop with the comparisons to Marx!!!!

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago
Hmmm... I tried to put my comment in as a reply to Nadia... but for some reason it is showing up at the end of the comment list... ARG!!!
 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, or some such.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

To reply to most comments, you hit the reply button under the comment. But if you want the comment to show at the end of the thread, then you have to go to the top of the thread and hit the reply button there. If you are not sure where the top of a thread is look at the faint little arrows by the side of your picture.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Max,

I agree with that!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Mal ,

"I gotta tell ya Rich... referring to it as "theoretical" seems like a way of dismissing the issue as unattainable "

Your perception is partly accurate . I don't think that ideal will ever be acheived
in entirety . However , that is not to say that things can't be made more fair than they are now .

"BOTH of those institutions should be here to server the interests of the American people... in a "BIG" way!!! But unfortunately, they are serving each other's interests"

Actually business is not designed to serve the interests of the people . It is only designed to supply goods and services . OTOH , government is supposedly set up
to serve the interests of the people . But instead it is acting mostly just to increase the GDP . That seems to be its main focus now .

"The righties have been very clever in defining capitalism as something that is nothing but goodness and light, and if we just get out of its way, the "free market" will self-regulate!!! "

The history of big business belies that description . Business definitely needs limits
put on it . There was too much deregulation under the Bush adminisration .
The results have not been of benefit to the public to say the least ...

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

The majority of the protesters who are career lazy?

Most of the the people who are in solidarity with the 99% movement are not marching in the streets (although we should be). I am wholeheartedly sympathetic with the cause and I am not "career lazy"!!! Nor are most of the 99%!!! Furthermore, I have no doubt there are plenty of "career lazy" T-people and conservatives... who BTW are just as much a part of the 99% as any liberal.

Wrong. Redistribution is the very act of taking from the rich and giving to the poor.

So what is it called when rich people take from the poor?

Ahhh... never mind Bruce... It's really pointless for you and I to converse... In order for that to have any hope of doing anything meaningfully productive, BOTH of us have to be interested in finding a way to make room for the other. As much as I dislike your ideology, Bruce, I AM interested in finding a way for you and I to coexist... but I don't get any sense that you would give any consideration to going 50/50 with a liberal like me.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

I understand that, Perrie... That IS what I did... In fact, after the first time I posted that comment and it went in the wrong place, I copied it and posted it again making extra sure I clicked the correct button... But the second post went in directly below the first post... so I edited the second post turning it into the comment about the post going in in the wrong place.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Actually business is not designed to serve the interests of the people.

I didn't say "business was designed to serve the interests of the people." I said it SHOULD be. That said, let me clarify. I do not think business was "designed" to provide goods and services... it was designed to make a profit... The motive is profit... the means is goods and services... all that is fine with me. But I would like to live in a society that says...

Hey there business man... we want your goods and services... so bring it on... and BTW I hope you make a handsome profit. But if you do it in such a way that it ends up hurting average people just so you can optimize your profit... that's not okay... you will have to be satisfied with making a little less profit... In short... you may have the privilege of making a profit selling your goods and services in our society only if you pay for that privilege by "serving the best interests of the people."

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Wait

Mike are you agreeing with OWS. Good for you!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Ahhh... you found the wisdom of our favorite dog.

Why does it always have to be considered a detriment to get along on some middle ground? This "my way or the highway", "screw you, I've got mine", "give me welfare until I die" stuff... has to find a course correction or we're going to be in a worse place in less than 2 years.

Who can argue with that ? This is no longer about left or right, it's about our nations recovery.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Hummm... it must be ahiccup????

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Since neither of us has taken a survey of their group demands there is no logic
for either of us . However , I am basing my statement on some earlier demands
that I read . You OTOH are basing your argument on the fact that you are just
itching to prove me wrong . In other words you got nuthin' .

BTW , there were other demands along the same lines .

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Bruce,

I gotta say something else about that career "lazy remark"...

The majority of the protesters who are career lazy? Those that have no desire to work hard?

That statement demonstrates your bias very clearly. There are tens of millions of people who want to work very much... people who have lost their jobs because business found cheaper labor overseas... and students who, having worked very hard to educate themselves, are discovering they have no opportunity to demonstrate how hard they can work in their chosen career... because businesses are concerned only with optimizing their profits at the expense of many people who, given the opportunity, would be very hard working. These unemployed people, and others like myself, who are fortunate enough to be employed, but see the American middle class under attack for the sake of optimal profits, we are the "99%ers"... most of us are not sitting in Zuccotti park... but there are millions of us... millions of hard working Americans who are sick and tired of rules that allow the 1% to redistribute all the wealth to themselves.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

There it happened again Perrie... That comment was supposed to go under Bruce;s comment... I'm not sure, but it may have something to do with the fact that it sometimes takes me quite a while to craft my comments...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

OK Mal . I accept that . Your statement is more accurate than mine was .
I expect that there is no practical way to cover every contingency that could
occur to require business to serve "the best interests of the people" .

For one thing who decides what that best interest is ?
Also it is all well & good to say "BTW I hope you make a handsome profit"
but are you willing to back up any business that doesn't make sufficient profit to keep its doors open [assuming it is serving those public interests ] ?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Let me test with this comment

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Yeah, it's because someone is beating you to the post, Mal!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Bruce,

I don't think that the example you gave anyone in their right mind would argue with. There are those who try to skate by by doing the least they have to and bitch the most. Yet the inverse is true. As you pointed out, there are always those who go the extra mile, many times without any compensation or even a verbal thanks. Sometimes, they are even the first to get demoted, because they put up the least amount of fuss. I have seen that, too. Bothexistin this world.

 
 
 
Kori
Freshman Silent
link   Kori    15 years ago

I already stated weeks ago that the Tea Party and OWS have similar philosophies(in some though not all respects) and if they joined teams,would be a force to be reckoned with. Unfortunately theirlack of organization (OWS), their egos,desire for power and attention (both sides) willprevent them from really buckling down and working together.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Well , thanks so much for looking after my logical inconsistencies . I am not basing my info on every new list of demands that comes out . I am basing it on a previous one that I linked when we were still on Grouply . And that one included a demand for free college education . It was a statement which was issued by a subgroup of the OWS .
Yes , it may not represent every single OWS marcher but so what . Nothing does that . No one can characterize these protesters completely . But that was an early attempt by them to get their message out . If "they" have changed since then there is no way to tell that those previous protesters have renounced their former demands or not . From my POV just because there are new lists of demands doesn't mean they have given up on their older naive demands .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Rich,

I read both, and I think this is the "OfficialVersion". It's not a list of demands but more an outline of what the problems are. The other one read like a ransom note. This reads like a mind numbing version of the Constitution. You should try and read it... my advice is to take it in small doses though. A lot like the new CoC... which for the record is having it's final revision... taking everyone's concerns into consideration.....including making it shorter.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

That's yesterdays news. We had that on the old site. The one in yourarticleBruce, is theofficialone.

And when did liberal equate lazy?

I know lots of self identifying liberals who are not lazy and in fact quite well off.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

You're hired!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Perrie ,

I might take a look at the Bruce article list . But I don't know why I should take it as more representative of this group than the other lists . Do we even know who issued this latest & greatest ?

Since they have no way [as a movement of miscellaneous stragglers] of signing off on 1 list and retracting another I don't think anything will be the finalized version . Do you ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Max ,

One thing I've learned from the study of the sciences and statistics is that not everything is quantifiable . As a result not everything is "logical" . Even the use of logic is often illogical . In this case I am fairly confident that no one has a handle on what this group is about . For all we know the guys are just there to pick up girls .
[see my new avatar] .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

I came back unpicked up. Damn!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

"the bought and paid for puppets in dc"

Now who's overgeneralizing ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Perrie ,

"The one in your article Bruce, is the official one."

How do you know that one is more "official" than the one on the OWS website ?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Well, let me do a little research on that Rich.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

OK, I'm back.

Here is the way it's going down.

OWS made that list of demands that was on our old site. There is another movement called the 99%. They are the ones who wrote what Bruce has on his article. They are two different movements under one umbrella. There are no demands with the 99%. It's a bit murky... but that seems to be the difference.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Now you've gone and made me hungry! Damn you Man!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

I hope you're right about that one umbrella .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    15 years ago

Aw c'mon . You had that big bruiser of a husband with you ....

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

ROFLMAO!!!!!

You're on a roll today!

*Snort*

Opppps.... sorry lolololololol

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

Official or not... I have to chime in on these with some of my "liberal dogma"... er... "liberal Malamutema"...

#1 The minimum wage tries to do this... but I don't think it quite gets there, so I would be for boosting the minimum wage.

#2 ABSOLUTELY!!! [Mal does the liberal dance...] I especially like the part about banning private insurers... But I suppose we could let private insurers form a second tier so that rich people could give themselves extra luxuries.

#3 This sounds a bit like unemployment insurance... and even as a liberal I have to say this one seems like an incentive to be "lazy"... I think regular unemployment insurance should be sufficient... I don't know what they may have in there about retirement... but I do think we need a robust retirement plan... something that able-bodied people earn... and disabled people just get... especially disabled Vets... Hmmm... I think that is social security... but I would like it better if it provided a bit more than it currently provides...

#4 EXCELLENT!!! [Mal breaks into another round of the liberal dance...]

#5, #6, #7, #8 Perfect!!!

#9 I'm all for immigration reform... but this ones sounds a little TOO loosey-goosey to me...

#10 An absolute necessity!!! And while were at it... lets get the money out of elections!!!

#11 This one is WAY over the top!!! There are some places where debt forgiveness makes sense... and other places where debt mitigation makes plenty of sense... But I can't get behind blanket debt forgiveness for everything everywhere.

#12 I don't know enough about credit reporting agencies to have an opinion one way or the other on this one... Actually, if you want to get a loan... what is wrong with proving that you are capable and responsible enough to deserve a loan.

#13 What could be wrong with this idea???

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Hey, I'm confused. Which one are we looking at now. The demands of the platform?

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    15 years ago

That is my commentary on the "demands" that MJL put up...

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    15 years ago

Actually, the worst are the greedy left wing Americans who are too fricking rich.

Know any of them Randall?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    15 years ago

Randy,

I am not sure if you are referring to anyone inparticularwhen you call them "right wing fringe apologists" that "bleat out the right wing bullshit lie that everyone can be rich" with "Their tiny selfish minds can't conceive" since we are trying to have a civil dialog here. There are some real issues here, andalienatingthe right is no way to get the messageacross, except with Mike ;-)

Here is how I understand theconservatives. There have been a major change is our social landscape that many are not comfortable with. I could go on, but I think you know what I am talking about. So they look at the other side as "the enemy" and so do you, because you don't mind these sociological changes. There are those of us in the middle, who watch and wonder where it is all going.

Now these things pull at our emotions. Both sides feel passionate about these changes. The two party system plays on these emotional issues, and ties it in with our economy. They make it like it is part of the same thing, and people buy into the whole deal.

Our government is being run by corporations and the fat cats that go along with them. There needs to be a change in the tax code. But it's not taxing the rich to death, it making pay what they should be paying, and taking away the loopholes that are in the system, like Capital gains, trust funds, "charitablefunds", off shore accounts. I could go on. Leave the current tax rate and make them pay just like the middle and working classes have to pay with no loopholes.

The American dream isn't dead... it's just been bought. It's time to even the playing field. That is what the 99% is really about.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    15 years ago

Populist! Neither liberal, conservative nor libertarian.

It's populism ... a populist is a person who holds, or who is concerned with, the views of ordinary people

Liberal ... one who is respectful of individual rights and freedoms

Point of information: By definition ... libertarianism

belief that private morality is not the state's affair and that therefore activities such as drug use and prostitution, which arguably harm no one but the participants, should not be illegal. Libertarianism shares elements with anarchism, although it is generally associated more with the political right (chiefly in the U.S.). Unlike traditional liberalism, however, libertarianism lacks a concern with social justice.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Reversing the question, why does the Tea Party get a conservative label?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

So what? The OWS folks were Obamaites through and through.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Wow... who found this? A blast from the past.

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors