John McCain’s Irresponsible Remarks About Sgt. Bergdahl - NYT Editorial
Mr. McCain’s Irresponsible Remarks About Sgt. Bergdahl
By THE EDITORIAL BOARD OCT. 14, 2015
Two military officers who have conducted lengthy reviews of the circumstances that led to the abduction of Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl in Afghanistan in 2009 have concluded that he should not face jail time for having left his base.
Senator John McCain, the chairman of the Armed Services Committee, however, seems to think he knows better. Mr. McCain, a Navy pilot who was held captive for five years during the Vietnam War and tortured, told The Boston Herald that Sergeant Bergdahl is “clearly a deserter,” and threatened to hold a congressional hearing into the case “if it comes out that he has no punishment.”
The Army’s decision to prosecute Sergeant Bergdahl for desertion and for violating rules that endangered his comrades was questionable, considering the abuse he suffered in captivity and the military’s failure to recognize that he was not mentally fit to be deployed to a war zone. During his five years as a Taliban hostage, Sergeant Bergdahl was beaten with chains and endured severe chronic diarrhea that went untreated.
While much of the nation was relieved to see Sergeant Bergdahl return home last year, Republicans have exploited the case to criticize President Obama for the prisoner swap he authorized to secure the soldier’s release. In exchange for his freedom, the Obama administration freed five Taliban prisoners who were being held at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba.
Mr. McCain is certainly not the first politician to have spoken irresponsibly about the case. Donald Trump, the leading Republican presidential candidate, said recently that Sergeant Bergdahl is a “traitor” who should have “been executed.” But Mr. McCain’s remarks are particularly troubling because Gen. Robert Abrams, the top commander at Fort Bragg, N.C., who will make the final decision on the Bergdahl case, will most likely appear before Mr. McCain’s committee for confirmation should he be promoted to a higher post in the future.
General Abrams is expected to decide soon whether the case should go before a court-martial now that the military equivalent of a grand jury proceeding has concluded. He could decide to impose nonjudicial punishment or simply discharge him from the Army.
Mr. Bergdahl’s lawyer, Eugene Fidell, rightly protested that Mr. McCain’s remarks could constitute unlawful meddling by the legislative branch over a military prosecution. The senator should make it clear to General Abrams that he will respect his decision.
The Army, meanwhile, should waste no time in bringing this matter to a close, forgoing a court-martial, and allow Sergeant Bergdahl to get on with his life.
Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook and Twitter , and sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter .
SAN ANTONIO — The general who led the Army’s investigation into the disappearance of Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl from his remote outpost in Afghanistan in 2009 said on Friday that sentencing the sergeant to prison would be “inappropriate.”
Maj. Gen. Kenneth R. Dahl, who interviewed 57 witnesses during his 59-day investigation, testified that Sergeant Bergdahl had unreasonable, or even delusional, expectations about his deployment to Afghanistan and about the soldiers in his unit and his command.
But General Dahl testified that he found Sergeant Bergdahl truthful during the day and a half he spent interviewing him as part of the investigation. General Dahl also said that Sergeant Bergdahl had shown remorse about how his decision to leave his base could have endangered others in his platoon.
“I do not believe there is a jail sentence at the end of this procedure,” General Dahl said. “I think it would be inappropriate.”
His testimony came on the second day of a preliminary hearing here. Another defense witness, one of the military’s top debriefers of prisoners of war, suggested that Sergeant Bergdahl’s captivity was the worst any American had endured since the Vietnam War.
Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl U.S. Army, via Associated Press
The hearing will help determine whether Sergeant Bergdahl will be court-martialed for desertion and for endangering the troops who searched for him. Sergeant Bergdahl, now 29, faces the possibility of life imprisonment on the endangerment charge — formally known as misbehavior before the enemy — and a maximum five-year sentence if convicted of desertion.
Held in a windowless basement room at Joint Base San Antonio-Fort Sam Houston, the hearing was adjourned Friday afternoon. The hearing officer, Lt. Col. Mark Visger, will now make a recommendation on whether there is probable cause for a court-martial, the most serious option available to the Army officers who will decide how to pursue the case.
But the unequivocal statement by General Dahl, which was elicited during questioning by Sergeant Bergdahl’s lead defense lawyer, Eugene R. Fidell, could play a significant role going forward. If the Army officers responsible for prosecuting Sergeant Bergdahl were to decide later to seek prison time, they would contradict General Dahl, whose investigation forms the basis for the case.
In his testimony, the first time he has spoken publicly about his investigation, General Dahl also impeached much of the news coverage of Sergeant Bergdahl since President Obama approved exchanging him for five Taliban detainees at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, in May 2014.
For example, despite claims that a half-dozen soldiers died in the search for Sergeant Bergdahl , General Dahl testified that he had found no evidence that any soldiers had been killed while specifically engaged in the effort. And Sergeant Bergdahl did not intend to walk to China or India, as some other soldiers had suggested. Instead, the general said that while Sergeant Bergdahl might have made the comment, it was simply typical idle chatter among privates with time to kill on a lonely combat outpost.
Nor, he said, did Sergeant Bergdahl ever intend to desert and join the Taliban. When he mailed his computer home, it was not because he intended to permanently flee, the general said, but because he knew that he might be imprisoned once he left his post, and he wanted his personal items to be in good hands.
The general, who was not cross-examined, laid out the reasons that he said Sergeant Bergdahl — who was then a private first class — decided to leave his base, leading to a manhunt involving thousands of troops across thousands of square miles of rugged eastern Afghanistan.
General Dahl testified that Sergeant Bergdahl had grossly unrealistic and idealistic expectations of others, and even identified with John Galt, the hero in Ayn Rand’s novel “Atlas Shrugged.” From the earliest stages of his Army career, General Dahl said, Sergeant Bergdahl felt that nearly everyone he came into contact with fell far short of his expectations. He said, Sergeant Bergdahl often found nefarious intent in the actions taken by his commanders, decisions that other soldiers viewed differently.
“He absolutely believed that the things he was perceiving were true,” General Dahl said of Sergeant Bergdahl, describing those beliefs as “unwarranted but genuinely held.”
So, at the end of June 2009, Sergeant Bergdahl left his base between 10 p.m. and midnight, with the intention of walking about 18 miles to a larger American base, known as Forward Operating Base Sharana. There, he planned to tell a general about what he believed were serious leadership problems within his unit, General Dahl testified. He believed the “problems were so severe that his platoon was in danger,” General Dahl said.
Sergeant Bergdahl realized that simply showing up at the other base as part of a scheduled rotation would not get him a meeting with such a senior officer. But he knew that leaving his outpost without permission, and setting off a huge reaction, would probably get him that meeting, General Dahl testified.
“He wanted to create that event,” General Dahl testified in explaining why Sergeant Bergdahl set off alone.
General Dahl said that he believed that Sergeant Bergdahl walked for 10 to 12 hours before he was captured, and that he had also tried to escape on the first day of captivity.
“He probably could have gotten to speak to a general, if he had made it to F.O.B. Sharana,” General Dahl added.
After his capture, Sergeant Bergdahl endured the worst time in captivity of any American since the Vietnam War, said Terrence Russell, who debriefed him as a senior official at the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency, the principal Defense Department agency responsible for recovering service members.
“His conditions in captivity were as horrible as you could imagine,” Mr. Russell said, including beatings with rubber hoses and copper cables. He also said Sergeant Bergdahl suffered from uncontrollable diarrhea for more than three of the five years he was held captive.
Anyone who treated a dog the way Sergeant Bergdahl was treated, he said, “would be thrown in jail for pet abuse.”
Mr. Russell, whom prosecutors declined to cross-examine, also condemned much of the criticism of Sergeant Bergdahl since his release last year, saying “the level of wildly inaccurate speculation is outrageous.”
In captivity, “He did the best job he could do, and I respect him for it,” Mr. Russell added, pausing as he choked up.
Tags
Who is online
117 visitors

The investigating general says his fact finding has led to the conclusion that Bergdhal should not be put in prison. If the person who led the investigation doesn't know the facts, who would ?
McCain should pipe down and let this thing fade away.
I have to believe that the Army's inquiry was fair, and based on military "law". Therefore, McCain should shut up. How can he know more about the case than the people who were investigating it?
McCain is irrelevant and should retire.
(a) Any member of the armed forces who–
(b) Any commissioned officer of the armed forces who, after tender of his resignation and before notice of its acceptance, quits his post or proper duties without leave and with intent to remain away therefrom permanently is guilty of desertion.
(c) Any person found guilty of desertion or attempt to desert shall be punished, if the offense is committed in time of war, by death or such other punishment as a court-martial may direct, but if the desertion or attempt to desert occurs at any other time, by such punishment, other than death, as a court-martial may direct.
He deserted - voluntarily - should be court martialed and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Bergdahl is a piece of crap and should be treated as such. We have nothing but pussies leading the military, thanks to Barry and his team, who are afraid to make any decision that may look "offensive".
Personally - I'd hang his ass.
JMHO.
The investigating GENERAL, the man who led the Army's response to Bergdhal's desertion, says he should not serve prison time. That should be good enough for anyone and everyone.
John - that Army General has, more than likely, been threatened with punishment if he even THINKS about going against Barry's wishes. Most of the top military brass have learned to keep their mouths shut on anything Barry does or else they will face immediate retirement with loss of rank.
Barry is a wuss - a community organizer who is wwwwaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyy outtta his league - butt - he will slap your penis if you go against his temper tantrums.
Bergdahl deserves UCMJ punishment - up to and including death for desertion. The "General" has no say so.
Obama doesn't care whether or not Bergdhal is prosecuted. You guys are hallucinating.
Why should he? I don't and don't think he will and don't think he should be. Time served, dis-honorable discharge and a fine and be done with it.
Obama doesn't care whether or not Bergdhal is prosecuted.
It would make the already controversial swap seem even more distasteful, and make Obama look worse. Stop obfuscating.
I wonder how many other American troops deserted from forward posts in Iraq or Afghanistan ? I bet it isn't zero. How many of them were shot or hung, or sentenced to life in prison? I bet you the answer is NONE.
People want it now because this case was in the news.
The investigating general knows what he is doing. Let the professionals deal with this.
I agree that people are more aware of this particular case, and that does influence the number of people calling for a harsher sentence. That however, does not allay the fact that Obama does have somewhat of a vested interest.
“the level of wildly inaccurate speculation is outrageous.”
this:
is fair. Odiern's comments are fair.
The other two are not. What kind of statement is this "Our Army has not trained for six months. " ?
What's up with this then?
Conspiracy groups question USASOC mission in Texas
- Army Times, March 23, 2015
All the posters here who think they know anything about what happened to Bergdahl who weren't there .... (expletive deleted)
He is guilty of being stupid and there area lot of stupid people in the world (some of them members here). Time served, a dis-honorable discharge and a fine of some type.
It seems Bergdhal was a follower of a right wing hero
"Army sergeant and rescued Taliban prisoner Bowe Bergdahl has been caught up in a web of conspiracy theories and political noise since his handover in Afghanistan early last month, but those who know him are rejecting suggestions that he was a "a calculating deserter." The Washington Post today published excerpts from Bergdahl's journal, which he mailed along with a laptop and his copy of Atlas Shrugged , to his close friend Kim Harrison just before leaving his post and getting captured in the summer of 2009.
"Trying to keep my self togeather," he wrote, mixing philosophical musings and misspellings. "I'm so tired of the blackness, but what will happen to me without it. Bloody hell why do I keep thinking of this over and over."
Bergdahl, his friends said , "sometimes painted his fingernails black and identified with Japanese samurai warriors and medieval knights." He called himself "the lone wolf of deadly nothingness." He'd also been discharged from the Coast Guard in 2006 for psychological problems (he told friends he'd "faked it") but was taken by the Army anyway in the dark, two-war days of 2008.
"I"m worried," he journaled before being sent off to Afghanistan. "The closer I get to ship day, the calmer the voices are. I'm reverting. I'm getting colder. My feelings are being flushed with the frozen logic and the training, all the unfeeling cold judgment of the darkness."
Bergdahl also developed Ayn Rand–ian ideas about finding "complete freedom":
On June 27, he sent an e-mail to his friends titled “Who is John Galt?,” a reference to the hero of Ayn Rand’s novel “Atlas Shrugged,” about individualism in a dystopian America.
“I will serve no bandit, nor lair, for i know John Galt, and understand . . .” Bergdahl wrote. “This life is too short to serve those who compromise value, and its ethics. i am done compromising.”
Three days later, Bergdahl walked off his post.
On the last page of his journal, the Post reports , Bergdahl imagined "a story about one going-crazy-to wander the earth alone." "
Bergdhal is a Randian. How about that ?