╌>

THE ARROGANCE CRISIS IN AMERICAN LIBERALISM

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  24 comments

THE ARROGANCE CRISIS IN AMERICAN LIBERALISM
When most American liberals first meet me, they assume I’m a European liberal. They ask me how I tolerate living in the United States compared to the EU-topia.

Their supposition is ill placed: I’m an American with a British accent and my politics are conservative. I believe government is necessary, but I also believe society is best served by smaller government, lower taxes, and fewer regulations. But that’s reality.

As I say, when it comes to first perceptions, most liberals assume I support European-style big government. And that I love Washington, D.C., for its brunches, modern art exhibitions and micro-breweries. And restaurants that emphasize presentation over portion size. In fact, though I do enjoy the pursuit of knowledge, I also like Bud Light, and my favorite restaurants are the Cheesecake Factory and Olive Garden.

Regardless, the assumption that a British accent in America means the speaker is a European liberal is itself worth consideration. Because it reflects an American liberal belief that European liberalism represents true enlightenment and that American conservatism is thus existentially retrograde, an ideology unworthy of interaction.

This arrogance is on display every time a supposedly objective journalist showers a liberal politician with deference, and a conservative viewpoint with open disdain. It’s on display every time liberal commentators insinuate that America is a dysfunctional nation solely because of its private medical system. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not suggesting that liberals should stay quiet and accept American conservatism. On the contrary, all Americans have the responsibility to engage in vigorous debate towards their ideal of a better nation. The problem is that it is difficult to have a debate when your opponent is convinced your ideology — and viewpoints — are intrinsically flawed.

The real casualties of this arrogance are liberals themselves
The real casualties of this arrogance are liberals themselves. Assuming that conservatives are at best delusional, and at worse immoral, many liberals forget the importance of facts. Instead, they resort to emotion to propel their arguments. It’s a vulnerability affecting the best of liberal commentators. Consider how Mika Brzezinski and Mark Halperin — two otherwise intelligent, open-minded liberals — interacted last week with Charles C.W. Cooke, a fellow British-accented National Review writer. Facing Cooke’s assertion that gun ownership in the United States is complicated and requires specific policy suggestions rather than emotional pontification, Brzezinski and Halperin doubled down on emotion. Accusing Cooke of moral apathy, they offered no policy proposals of their own. As Cooke attempted to spark a policy debate, his opponents simply raised their voices above him, while saluting the word “passion.”

Again, this isn’t to say that liberals have a monopoly on emotional obstinacy. Donald Trump, for example, centers his campaign on using emotion as a pretense for policy. In the same way, too many Republicans offer too many platitudes as alternatives to President Obama’s policies (something that is especially problematic when it comes to complex foreign policy questions). Still, today, liberal politics has experienced an undeniable shift into anti-intellectual emotionalism. The proof is clear. If America’s east and west coasts are centers of enlightened philosophy, why is it that liberals in these cities often express thinly veiled disgust for conservative speakers? Why, if not because these liberals — consciously or unconsciously —believe the debate is over before it even begins? From their perspective, two plus two equals four and bigger government equals righteousness. For them, the debate ends there. http://opportunitylives.com/the-arrogance-crisis-in-american-liberalism/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    11 years ago

D.C. has never been known for it's food.....it ranks far below almost every other major (and medium) metropolitan area for food enthusiasts.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

This gets to the core of it. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

This article is nothing but a rehash of the constant right wing theme.

"We are disrespected" "We are misunderstood" "We are persecuted"

yawn yawn yawn

The writer invokes tv personality Mika Brzezinski and hack pundit Mark Halperin as indicative of liberal emotionalism and dismissal of conservative points. Those two people are not liberals , certainly not Halperin , and Mika blows with the wind. They are tv personalities. 

This is another vague , pointless article. One of a long list by the seeder. 

 
 
 
Bloody Bill
Freshman Silent
link   Bloody Bill    11 years ago

My first assumption when I meet someone with a European accent is, "Oh great, a soccer lover."

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Bloody Bill   11 years ago

Mine is "bloody hell, a wanker!"

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    11 years ago

I like this article, addresses excellent points.

I am a liberal who is a math major, and as such reject emotionalism. I am a liberal because of logic and facts. As such sometimes I agree with conservatives, like this guy. I've seen him on Morning Joe a few times.

Let's look at 's comments.

               "I believe government is necessary, but I also believe society is best served by smaller government, lower taxes, and fewer regulations. But that’s reality."

 

Hard to argue against.

                   " American liberal belief that European liberalism represents true enlightenment and that American conservatism is thus existentially retrograde, an ideology unworthy of interaction."

 On this the question becomes what " American conservatism" means. When Republicans say they want to eliminate the EPA, the Department of Education, the Labor Relations Board, etc. it is hardly conservative. It is reactionary. It wants to undo the rights of labor, education, and the environment that have taken years to achieve. I think if we ask Mr. Rogan he will not go as far as the far right in the US are suggesting.

 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Cletus Wilbury   11 years ago

Gee, someone voted your post down because you are a liberal with a thought process and that actually has a mind of his own.  Go figure.

 
 

Who is online






113 visitors