Thomas Sowell: What Do You Mean 'The Rich' Don't Pay Their 'Fair Share'?
At the recent televised debate among candidates for the Democrats' nomination for president, Hillary Clinton declared: "The wealthy pay too little" in taxes and "the middle class pays too much."
Some people might wish to argue about whether that is true or not, but no rational argument can be made on either side of this issue, because the words used are completely undefined. Nor is Hillary Clinton the only one who talks this way.
It is one of the signs of the mindlessness of our times that all sorts of people declare that "the rich" are not paying their "fair share" in taxes, without telling us concretely what they mean by either "the rich" or "fair share."
Whether in politics or in the media, words are increasingly used not to convey facts or even allegations of facts, but simply to arouse emotions. Undefined words are a big handicap in logic, but they are a big plus in politics, where the goal is not clarity but victory — and the votes of gullible people count just as much as the votes of people who have common sense.
What a "fair share" of taxes means in practice is simply "more." No matter how high the tax rate is on people with a given income, you can always raise the tax rate further by saying that they are still not paying their "fair share."
Advocates of higher tax rates can get very specific when they want to. A recent article in the New York Times says that raising the tax rate on the top 1% of income earners to 40% would generate "about $157 billion" a year in additional tax revenue for the government.
This calculation ignores mountains of evidence, going back for generations, showing that raising tax rates does not automatically mean raising tax revenues — and has often actually led to falling tax revenues. A fantasy expressed in numbers is still a fantasy.
When the state of Maryland raised its tax rate on people with incomes of a million dollars a year or more, the number of such people living in Maryland fell from nearly 8,000 to fewer than 6,000. Although it had been projected that the tax revenue collected from such people in Maryland would rise by $106 million, instead these revenues fell by $257 million.
There was a similar reaction in Oregon and in Britain. Rich people do not simply stand still to be sheared like sheep. They can either send their money somewhere else, or they themselves can leave.
Currently, there are trillions of dollars of American money creating jobs overseas in places where tax rates are lower. It is easy to transfer money electronically from country to country. But it is not nearly so easy for unemployed American workers to transfer themselves to where high tax rates have driven the jobs.
Conversely, there have been some reductions in high tax rates that brought in more tax revenues at the lower rates. It has happened as far back as the Coolidge administration in the 1920s. It also happened in the Kennedy administration in the 1960s, the Reagan administration in the 1980s, and most recently in the Bush 43 administration. There was a similar reaction in Iceland.
There is nothing inevitable about either a higher or a lower amount of tax revenue, whether the tax rate is raised or lowered. The government can only set tax rates. How they will affect the tax revenues actually received depends on how people react, and you can know that only after the fact. Sophisticated projections have often been laughably wrong.
Contrary to the way that some people on the left conceive of the world, neither rich people nor poor people are inert blocks of wood to be moved about like pieces on a chess board in order to carry out some grand design from on high.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-on-the-right/101915-776278-thomas-sowell-left-uses-vague-terms-not-facts-to-push-tax-hikes.htm#ixzz3p5bgNz5m
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Some people might wish to argue about whether that is true or not, but no rational argument can be made on either side of this issue, because the words used are completely undefined. Nor is Hillary Clinton the only one who talks this way.
It is one of the signs of the mindlessness of our times that all sorts of people declare that "the rich" are not paying their "fair share" in taxes, without telling us concretely what they mean by either "the rich" or "fair share."
Whether in politics or in the media, words are increasingly used not to convey facts or even allegations of facts, but simply to arouse emotions. Undefined words are a big handicap in logic, but they are a big plus in politics, where the goal is not clarity but victory — and the votes of gullible people count just as much as the votes of people who have common sense.
What a "fair share" of taxes means in practice is simply "more." No matter how high the tax rate is on people with a given income, you can always raise the tax rate further by saying that they are still not paying their "fair share."
Advocates of higher tax rates can get very specific when they want to. A recent article in the New York Times says that raising the tax rate on the top 1% of income earners to 40% would generate "about $157 billion" a year in additional tax revenue for the government.
This calculation ignores mountains of evidence, going back for generations, showing that raising tax rates does not automatically mean raising tax revenues — and has often actually led to falling tax revenues. A fantasy expressed in numbers is still a fantasy.
When the state of Maryland raised its tax rate on people with incomes of a million dollars a year or more, the number of such people living in Maryland fell from nearly 8,000 to fewer than 6,000. Although it had been projected that the tax revenue collected from such people in Maryland would rise by $106 million, instead these revenues fell by $257 million.
There was a similar reaction in Oregon and in Britain. Rich people do not simply stand still to be sheared like sheep. They can either send their money somewhere else, or they themselves can leave.
Currently, there are trillions of dollars of American money creating jobs overseas in places where tax rates are lower. It is easy to transfer money electronically from country to country. But it is not nearly so easy for unemployed American workers to transfer themselves to where high tax rates have driven the jobs.
Conversely, there have been some reductions in high tax rates that brought in more tax revenues at the lower rates. It has happened as far back as the Coolidge administration in the 1920s. It also happened in the Kennedy administration in the 1960s, the Reagan administration in the 1980s, and most recently in the Bush 43 administration. There was a similar reaction in Iceland.
There is nothing inevitable about either a higher or a lower amount of tax revenue, whether the tax rate is raised or lowered. The government can only set tax rates. How they will affect the tax revenues actually received depends on how people react, and you can know that only after the fact. Sophisticated projections have often been laughably wrong.
Contrary to the way that some people on the left conceive of the world, neither rich people nor poor people are inert blocks of wood to be moved about like pieces on a chess board in order to carry out some grand design from on high.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-on-the-right/101915-776278-thomas-sowell-left-uses-vague-terms-not-facts-to-push-tax-hikes.htm#ixzz3p5bgNz5m
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Tags
Who is online
102 visitors

Rich Americans are fond of 'blackmailing' their fellow citizens by threatening to leave the country, the state , city, whatever, with their money if taxes are raised. They will move it off shore, to another country, another planet, or bury it in the backyard if that would eliminate taxes.
The "fair share" is what is in the tax table. Before all the havens, scams, loopholes and fraud enter the picture.
Any loopholes were legally created by Congress not using them would be stupid.