╌>

Fact Checker ----Elizabeth Warren’s claim that the bottom 90 percent got ‘zero percent’ of wage growth after Reagan

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  1 comments

 Fact Checker ----Elizabeth Warren’s claim that the bottom 90 percent got ‘zero percent’ of wage growth after Reagan

During a speech at the Edward M. Kennedy Institute for the U.S. Senate on Sept. 27, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) gave a version of her often-repeated remarks on wage growth from 1980 to 2012. (Edward M. Kennedy Institute for the U.S. Senate)


“From 1935 to 1980, we’re coming out of the Great Depression. What do we do? We do two things. We put a cop on the beat on Wall Street and we started investing in our future together — in education, in infrastructure, in research. And we build America’s great middle class — the 90 percent, everybody outside the top 10 percent. The 90 percent get 70 percent of all wage growth in this country. So GDP [gross domestic product] is going up. And families across the spectrum, they’re doing better. 

“Trickle-down economics hits in the 1980s and you just watch this reverse. So from 1980 to 2012, that’s the latest year for which we have data, the 90 percent, everybody outside the 10 percent, do you know how much they got? They got zero percent of income growth; 100 percent of income growth — GDP kept going up — 100 percent of income growth went to the top 10 percent in America.”

—Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), remarks in various venues.

Sen. Warren has repeated a version of these remarks in a variety of high-profile settings, including on the “Late Show with Stephen Colbert.” Readers have asked if her frame of reference is correct. Did the bottom 90 percent of income earners in the United States get 70 percent of the wage growth from 1935 to 1980—and then zero percent of the growth after 1980?

This is a very interesting but highly technical issue. Warren pitches it in a fairly partisan manner — everything turned south after “trickle-down economics” (i.e., President Ronald Reagan) was introduced. She also offers somewhat simplistic reasons (such as the creation of the Securities and Exchange Commission) for the shift in income growth, though her staff says she was not intending to exclude other factors.

Where do these numbers come from?

The Facts


Warren derived her numbers from data collected by two well-known economists,  Emmanuel Saez  of the University of California at Berkeley and  Thomas Piketty  of the Paris School of Economics. Most economists agree that the two men have assembled a comprehensive data set that helps examine the distribution of market income over time.

Here are the things captured in the data: wages, net self-employment income reported on income tax returns, taxable interest and dividends, rental income, and so forth.

But there are limitations. Social Security and unemployment benefits are not counted. Neither are government transfer payments, such as food stamps or veterans benefits. The data also does not include noncash items, such as employer-provided health insurance. Lastly, the impact of income and payroll taxes are not part of the calculations, even though the rich pay most of the taxes — and some lower-income workers actually receive payments such as the Earned Income Tax Credit that offset all of their federal payroll and income taxes.

In other words, the numbers show part of the income picture— essentially the wages. They do not necessarily show everything that Americans receive to help them pay for the things they consume, be it food stamps (for the poor) or company-provided health insurance.

“The income items Piketty and Saez omit tend to equalize incomes of rich and poor,” said  Gary Burtless , an economist at The Brookings Institution who specializes in income distribution. “More importantly, an increasing percentage of the gross incomes received by Americans is excluded from the income measure tabulated by Piketty and Saez.”

In essence, Warren is just focusing on the income that is reported on a tax return—not all of the items that help families pay for the things that they consume.

There is a bit of an irony here. By focusing on wage income, Warren is not counting the impact of programs often celebrated by Democrats as success stories. Indeed, the official poverty rate also does not count the impact of those programs, which is why the Census Bureau in recent years has developed an alternative version that does include such impacts.

But at the moment, a fuller set of data only goes back to the early 1960s, making the lengthy comparison highlighted by Warren all but impossible. But the income divide highlighted by Warren shrinks when the missing data is part of the equation.

The Congressional Budget Office in 2011 produced  a report  that focused on the after-tax resource flow available to a family to pay for its consumption. Families in the top 1 percent saw their after-tax income triple from 1970 to 2011, but other groups also saw a sizable improvement in household incomes.

“Instead of showing that the incomes of low- and middle-income families barely budged after the late 1970s, the CBO tabulations suggest that Americans in the bottom one-fifth of the distribution saw their real net incomes climb by almost 50 percent,” Burtless said.  “Those in the middle fifth of the distribution saw their incomes grow 36 percent.”

 

THE REST     https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2015/10/23/elizabeth-warrens-claim-that-the-bottom-90-percent-got-zero-percent-of-wage-growth-after-reagan/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

I think this is an astonishing article , which should frighten anyone who wants to see "income inequality" lessened.

The Washington Post fact checker essentially says that Warren is not really correct because when you include Social Security and government "entitlements" such as welfare and food stamps and EITC as INCOME, then all the "gains" in income no longer go to the top 10 percent. The fact checker also mentions employer provided health insurance. (Of course, many American workers no longer receive employer provided health insurance. They may get it through work but they pay all the cost themselves).

Many "conservatives" particularly on the libertarian end, want to end or diminish safety net programs, the very programs that the fact checker says allows the "90 percent" to have made any gains in income at all during the past 40 years. 

No one should be counting "entitlement" programs as income for the purpose of claiming that income inequality is not as bad as it seems. It is very dishonest considering that many who say income inequality is not an issue want to cut these programs out of existence in some cases. 

 
 

Who is online




108 visitors