Did An Anti-Muslim Video Inspire The Benghazi Attack ?
I know this may sound like it's coming out of a time machine, but there was so much ignorance spouted about this yesterday, not only on NT , but everywhere, that I decided it merited a reappearance.
FACT: Intelligence Community, The Suspected Attackers, And Eyewitnesses All Linked The Inflammatory Anti-Islam Video To The Attacks
Senate Select Committee On Intelligence: Intel Reports Linked Inflammatory Video To Benghazi Attack. A Senate Select Committee on Intelligence review of the Benghazi attack found that "some intelligence suggests" an inflammatory video linked to violent protests around the region led terror groups to conduct "similar attacks with advanced warning":
It remains unclear if any group or person exercised overall command and control of the attacks or whether extremist group leaders directed their members to participate. Some intelligence suggests the attacks were likely put together in short order, following that day's violent protests in Cairo against an inflammatory video, suggesting that these and other terrorist groups could conduct similar attacks with little advance warning. [ Review Of The Terrorist Attacks On U.S. Facilities In Benghazi, Libya, September 11-12, 2012 , U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 1/15/14 ]
NY Times : Suspected Benghazi Ringleader Told Witnesses The Benghazi Attack Was In Response To Inflammatory Anti-Islam Video. According to The New York Times , Ahmed Abu Khattala, who was captured in June 2014 by U.S. military on an indictment for murder in connection with his role as a suspected ringleader of the Benghazi attack, "told fellow Islamist fighters" on the night of the attack "and others that the assault was retaliation for the same insulting video" mocking Islam that inspired demonstrations in Cairo:
During the assault on the American diplomatic mission in Benghazi, Libya, on the night of Sept. 11, 2012, Mr. Abu Khattala was a vivid presence. Witnesses saw him directing the swarming attackers who ultimately killed Ambassador J. Christopher Stevens and three other Americans.
[...]
On the day of the attack, Islamists in Cairo had staged a demonstration outside the United States Embassy there to protest an American-made online video mocking Islam, and the protest culminated in a breach of the embassy's walls -- images that flashed through news coverage around the Arab world.
As the attack in Benghazi was unfolding a few hours later, Mr. Abu Khattala told fellow Islamist fighters and others that the assault was retaliation for the same insulting video, according to people who heard him.
In an interview a few days later, he pointedly declined to say whether an offensive online video might indeed warrant the destruction of the diplomatic mission or the killing of the ambassador. [ The New York Times , 6/18/14 ]
NY Times : "The Attackers" In Benghazi "Did Tell Bystanders That They Were Attacking The Compound Because They Were Angry About The Video. " The New York Times reported that on the night of the Benghazi attack, attackers "did tell bystanders that they were attacking the compound because they were angry about the video" (emphasis original):
What do eyewitnesses say about the events in Benghazi? Were they related to the insulting video, or is that a red herring? And was the assault planned for the anniversary of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, or was it spontaneous?
According to reporting by David D. Kirkpatrick and Suliman Ali Zway of The New York Times, eyewitnesses have said there was no peaceful demonstration against the video outside the compound before the attack, though a crowd of Benghazi residents soon gathered, and some later looted the compound. But the attackers, recognized as members of a local militant group called Ansar al-Shariah, did tell bystanders that they were attacking the compound because they were angry about the video. They did not mention the Sept. 11anniversary. Intelligence officials believe that planning for the attack probably began only a few hours before it took place. [ The New York Times , 10/17/12 ]
Tags
Who is online
166 visitors

Some intelligence suggests the attacks were likely put together in short order, following that day's violent protests in Cairo against an inflammatory video, suggesting that these and other terrorist groups could conduct similar attacks with little advance warning. [ Review Of The Terrorist Attacks On U.S. Facilities In Benghazi, Libya, September 11-12, 2012 , U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 1/15/14 ]
Intelligence officials believe that planning for the attack probably began only a few hours before it took place. [ The New York Times , 10/17/12 ]
Notice that the New York Times reported this about one month after the attack.
Almost a year and a half later, when the Senate Intelligence Committee made it's final report, they concluded that what the Times had said was indeed a possibility.
"The CIA station chief in Libya reported to Washington within 24 hours of last month's deadly attack on the U.S. Consulate that there was evidence it was carried out by militants, not a spontaneous mob upset about an American-made video ridiculing Islam's Prophet Muhammad, U.S. officials have told The Associated Press."
Chris Hicks, who spoke to the doomed Ambassador as the attack was happening "The video was a non event"
Hillary Clinton that same day "We know that the
attack in Libya had nothing to do with the film. It was a planned attack—not a protest.”
Yet Hilary and Obama kept talking about mythical protests about a video for weeks. Everyone was aware within 24 hours there were no protests about the video, yet Hillary and the administration kept claiming there were protests that got out of hand.
THERE WAS NO PROTEST.
Sean, I know your utmost belief is invested into the story that Clinton LIED, rather than having been caught up in the fog and uncertainty of "war". Your belief continues to lead you into faulty thinking and analysis.
Everyone knows there was an attack. Some of them had automatic weapons. What is addressed in the material I posted here is the motive for the attack, a motive which could have led to confusion as to whether or not there had originally been a protest ala Cairo.
The Senate Intelligence Committee concluded that the attack could have been planned OVER A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME. They are talking about hours, not days or weeks. This also corresponds with what the man arrested for the attack says happened.
You need to go back at some point and read the text of what Clinton said about this particular aspect yesterday.
In the CIA talking point, they talk about a demonstration outside the consulate that later became an attack. As it turned out when the compound video became available many days later, there was no "demonstration", it was just an attack. But that doesn't mean the attack was not inspired by the video and it doesn't mean the attack was not put together is a short period of time ("spontaneous"). It is your misguided insistence that Clinton MUST be lying that is leading you to misunderstand this information.
It's interesting watching how far the left has moved the goalposts on this debate. In the immediate aftermath, the republicans criticized Obama and Hillary for claiming it was a demonstration over the video, rather than a terrorist attack. The Obama/Clinton party line was a "spontaneous protest."
We know now, and she understood on the night of the attack, there never was a protest. For weeks, the administration clung to the "protest" lie rather than admit it was a terrorist attack.
Now the Democrats want to ignore that lie and change the question. They want to pretend the question is limited to only whether the videos played a "role" in the attacks. Since no one can ever say what motivated each and every terrorist to attack the compound it's the perfect red herring. Who can say what what it was in the heart of each and every persona involved in the assualt and what their reasons were. Moreover, it takes the focus off the mythical "protest.".
So John, unless you can provide evidence that there were in fact protests, Hillary is a liar. (no news there, I know). At the same time, when speaking in public she claimed the assault was a protest that got out of control , while in private, she accurately called it a terrorist attack.
Clinton said on the night of the attack what everyone else in the world was thiinking, that this was likely connected to the protest in cairo, as a copy cat event.
When a terrorist group claimed responsibility , she changed to saying it was a more planned attack. A day later, when they reneged on responsibility, and the CIA assessment mentioned a "demonstration" at Benghazi as precursor to the attack, she said it was from a "protest" that escalated. This was the Susan rice period. When the video of the compound was released many days after that, she stopped saying anything about a protest. Clinton's public comments are all consistent with changing information. You hang your hat on that she said something else in "private", but what is the evidence of that?
Your fatal flaw is the assumption that the assessment that it was because of a "video" , or that it was done by a "terrorist" group are mutually exclusive, when they are not.
You are off the deep end.
MORE -
A Libyan Interior Ministry official says armed men have stormed the US consulate in east Libya's Benghazi and set it ablaze after a protest against a video deemed insulting to Islam's prophet, Muhammad, which was reportedly produced in America.
Witnesses say Tuesday's attack left much of the consulate burned. It came hours after ultraconservative Islamist demonstrators in Egypt climbed the walls of the U.S. Embassy in Cairo to protest the film.
Wanis al-Sharef, an interior ministry official in Benghazi, says the attackers stormed the consulate after firing in the air.
[Associated Press, 9/11/12 ]
Oh no! The anointed one is in trouble! Let's spread some lies to deflect. Her constituents will believe anything!
"It remains unclear if any group or person exercised overall command and control of the attacks or whether extremist group leaders directed their members to participate. Some intelligence suggests the attacks were likely put together in short order, following that day's violent protests in Cairo against an inflammatory video, suggesting that these and other terrorist groups could conduct similar attacks with little advance warning. [ Review Of The Terrorist Attacks On U.S. Facilities In Benghazi, Libya, September 11-12, 2012 , U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 1/15/14 ]"
Some intelligence suggests the attacks were likely put together in short order, following that day's violent protests in Cairo against an inflammatory video, suggesting that these and other terrorist groups could conduct similar attacks with little advance warning.
Why do people refuse to accept the possibility of this highly possible, if not likely, scenario?
No, it did not.
To quote Hillary Clinton (in private) "We know the attack in Libya had nothing to do with the film. It was a planned attack – not a protest.”
In public, she was promising to get the maker of the video.
I notice John also completely ignores Clinton and Obama's statements about a protest. Why is that?
The U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence begs to differ with both of you.
Was there a protest john?
Sean , if everyone knew right after the attack that it was a terrorist attack and only a terrorist attack, why did a congressional committee conclude 16 months later that the attack may have been at least partially inspired by the video protest in Cairo?
Every single congressional investigation and clintons hand picked state department review concluded there was no protest. Look it up.
This is what the Intelligence Committee concluded
Some intelligence suggests the attacks were likely put together in short order following that day's violent protests in Cairo against an inflammatory video
not that ambiguous.
even if it is ambiguous , was it really worth 4 years of investigation?
hell no.
Straight from the Bought and paid for by Clinton herself ARB:
"The special Accountability Review Board set up by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to investigate the Sept. 11 attack on the U.S. diplomatic mission in Benghazi, Libya, confirmed that there was nothing “unusual” taking place outside the mission in the hours before the attack, that there was no protest"
From Susan Rice herself:
"there was no protest or demonstration in Benghazi," Rice said.
You are missing the point. The Senate Intelligence committee ascribed some relevance to the video as related to the events in Benghazi.
You are missing the point. The President and Clinton were blaming protests that Clinton knew never occurred.
Never mind Sean.
You are a hopeless case.
All I've ever heard people say in testimony is that this video nonsense did not come from them. So, after all these hearings and investigation, who has ever been identified as the source? No one owns up to thinking the video was a factor but you keep sayimg that it was reasonable to believe it. Absent some evidence to the contrary, it was a convenient lie told to avoid exploding Obama's re-election narrative that the terrorists were on the run when, in fact, they were running at us on the anniversary of 911.
There is considerable anecdotal evidence that the video helped to inspire the attack. I have discussed a dozen times online in the past few years.
The claims can be found on the internet.
There is considerable anecdotal evidence that the video helped to inspire the attack. I have discussed a dozen times online in the past few years.
Anecdotes are no more reliable to prove a video inspired protest than they are to establish the existence of Bigfoot. No one has ever identified himself as the source of this nonsense probably because no one ever actually thought it. Just another lie, especially if Hillary was involved.
It has been reported from numerous sources that people on the scene during the attack mentioned the video as a reason they were doing it.
The original CIA assessment mentioned the video as a reason for the attack.
What do you people want? This was the fog of war.
Who, in the Obama administration, thought it was a video? Name please.
Ok john. Lets just pretend for a moment that it was about the video. What does that change? It only shows that the so called religion of peace is brutal when its so called prophet is questioned. So even if it was about the video, it is still islamic terrorists behind it. Attributing the blame to a video doesn't make it any less a terror attack.