REPUBLICAN CONFUSION ABOUT BENGHAZI
I know we have gone over this somewhat extensively over the past few days, but this article makes one of the key points in a way I have been unable to successfully convey to our right wing friends.
-
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/political-animal-a/2015_10/what_i_learned_from_watching_t058283.php
As is often the case, reality is a bit more nuanced than Republicans try to paint it. We learned that when one of the leaders of the Benghazi attack - Ahmed Abu Khattala - was captured.
Despite extensive speculation about the possible role of Al Qaeda in directing the attack, Mr. Abu Khattala is a local, small-time Islamist militant. He has no known connections to international terrorist groups, say American officials briefed on the criminal investigation and intelligence reporting, and other Benghazi Islamists and militia leaders who have known him for many years… On the day of the attack, Islamists in Cairo had staged a demonstration outside the United States Embassy there to protest an American-made online video mocking Islam, and the protest culminated in a breach of the embassy’s walls — images that flashed through news coverage around the Arab world. As the attack in Benghazi was unfolding a few hours later, Mr. Abu Khattala told fellow Islamist fighters and others that the assault was retaliation for the same insulting video, according to people who heard him.
In other words, one of the leaders of the attack had no known connections to international terrorist groups and used the video as a tool to recruit fighters to join in the attack. On the other hand, it was not a spontaneous reaction from protesters. It was a planned attack. People like Rep. Jim Jordan seem incapable of grasping that kind of nuance.
Here he is lecturing former Secretary Clinton:
“You picked the video narrative. You picked the one with no evidence. And you did it because Libya was supposed to be…this great success story,” he said during one of his filibusters. “ You can live with a protest about a video. That won’t hurt you. But a terrorist attack will .”
That, my friends, is the best distillation of Republican confusion about Benghazi that you’ll find anywhere.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

"The line of questioning that came from Rep. Jim Jordan wasn’t new…it’s been the big accusation against President Obama, Susan Rice and Hillary Clinton from the get-go. The claim is that all of them tried to fool the American people into believing that the anti-Muslim video that was sparking demonstrations all over the Middle East (both peaceful and violent) was the cause of what happened in Benghazi, when it was really a “terrorist” attack. I guess they forgot about the shellacking Romney took during the 2012 presidential debate when Obama allowed him to dig a disastrous hole with, “ Please proceed, Governor .”
But overall, this argument tells us a lot about Republicans. Clinton got into trouble during a previous Congressional investigation about Benghazi when she basically asked why all that mattered. From a reality-based perspective, she had a point.
It seems that for Republicans, the death of a U.S. Ambassador and 3 other Americans wouldn’t matter as much if they were the result of protests rather than a terrorist attack. That kind of thinking is exactly why they get so perturbed that President Obama won’t call ISIS “radical Islamists.” It’s all about the words you use rather than the actions those words describe.
For as long as I can remember, Republicans have been trying to scare us with the words they use to describe our adversaries. During the Cold War and McCarthy hearings, it was all about “communists.” Reagan called the Soviet Union the “evil empire” and George W. Bush talked about the “axis of evil.” Instead of going after those who were responsible for 9/11, the Bush/Cheney administration launched a “global war on terrorism.”
Given all that, Republicans know that Benghazi isn’t an adequate vehicle for fear mongering unless we call it a “terror attack.” If, instead, it was the result of an angry mob reacting to an anti-Muslim video, that dilutes the message. But in the end, as Clinton said, what difference does it really make? Would our response be any different if there was a slight change in what we learned about what motivated the attackers? I’d suggest that a reasonable response (not the kind we got from Bush/Cheney to 9/11) would not."
In this interpretation, the attack was BOTH spontaneous and planned. The Republicans have put ALL their chips in this debate on the side of "one or the other". They have constantly alleged that the attack was "well planned " and "well coordinated", implying it had been many days or weeks in the specific planning.
WHERE is the evidence of this ? Who is LYING ?
Michael Morell was a deputy director of the CIA. He reviewed the video of the actual attack , and other information, and wrote an excellent article about this in Politico earlier this year. This is what he says about the attack
"There are a number of myths about what happened during the nighttime and early-morning hours of the Benghazi attacks. One misconception is that there was a single four-hour-long battle. Another myth is that the attacks were well-organized, planned weeks or even months in advance. In fact, there were three separate attacks that night, none of them showing evidence of significant planning, but each of them carried out by Islamic extremists, some with connections to al Qaeda, and each attack more potent than the one before. Since the definition of terrorism is violence perpetrated against persons or property for political purposes, each attack in Benghazi was most definitely an act of terrorism—no matter the affiliation of the perpetrators, no matter the degree of planning, and no matter whether the attack on the TMF was preceded by a protest or not (an issue that would take on enormous political importance in the weeks and months ahead).
The first attack was on the State Department’s Temporary Mission Facility. We know from having monitored social media and other communications in advance that the demonstration and violence in Cairo were sparked by people upset over a YouTube video that portrayed the Prophet Muhammad negatively. We believe that in Benghazi—over six hundred miles away—extremists heard about the successful assault on our embassy in Egypt and decided to make some trouble of their own, although we still do not know their motivations with certainty. Most likely they were inspired by the prospect of doing in Benghazi what their “brothers” had done in Cairo. Some may have been inspired by a call Ayman al-Zawahiri— the leader of al Qaeda in Pakistan—had made just the day before for Libyans to take revenge for the death of a senior al Qaeda leader of Libyan origin in Pakistan. Still others might have been motivated by the video—although I should note that our analysts never said the video was a factor in the Benghazi attacks. Abu Khattala, a terrorist leader and possibly one of the ring leaders of the attacks, said that he was in fact motivated by the video. Khattala is now in US custody and under indictment for the role he played in the assault.
I believe that, with little or no advance planning, extremists in Benghazi made some phone calls, gathering a group of like-minded individuals to go to the TMF. When they attacked, at about 9:40 p.m. local time, the assault was not well organized—they seemed to be more of a mob who intended to breach the compound and see what damage they could do.
When you assess the information from the video feed from the cameras at the TMF and the Annex, there are few signs of a well-thought-out plan, few signs of command and control, few signs of organization, few signs of coordination, few signs of even the most basic military tactics in the attack on the TMF. Some of the attackers were armed with small arms; many were not armed at all. No heavy weapons were seen on the videotape. Many of the attackers, after entering through the front gate, ran past buildings to the other end of the compound, behaving as if they were thrilled just to have overrun the compound. They did not appear to be looking for Americans to harm. They appeared intent on looting and conducting vandalism."
Read more:
In fact, there were three separate attacks that night, none of them showing evidence of significant planning, but each of them carried out by Islamic extremists, some with connections to al Qaeda, and each attack more potent than the one before.
-
We believe that in Benghazi—over six hundred miles away—extremists heard about the successful assault on our embassy in Egypt and decided to make some trouble of their own, although we still do not know their motivations with certainty. Most likely they were inspired by the prospect of doing in Benghazi what their “brothers” had done in Cairo.
Abu Khattala, a terrorist leader and possibly one of the ring leaders of the attacks, said that he was in fact motivated by the video. Khattala is now in US custody and under indictment for the role he played in the assault.
I believe that, with little or no advance planning, extremists in Benghazi made some phone calls, gathering a group of like-minded individuals to go to the TMF. When they attacked, at about 9:40 p.m. local time, the assault was not well organized—they seemed to be more of a mob who intended to breach the compound and see what damage they could do.
In this interpretation, the attack was BOTH spontaneous and planned
Again, no evidence of a "demonstration," which is what the administration claimed knowing it was a terrorist attack the whole time. You keep trying to parse words and make it debate about spontaneous vs planned because then you get into the weeds of "well that depends on the what the meaning on spontaneous is"" It was an attack with mortars and RPGs. The mortar fire was so accurate because distances were paced off in advance. As was made clear in the hearing, this was just one in a series of terrorist attacks against the compound, it was not an isolated occurrence.
Play word games all you want. There were no demonstrations. As the email trail makes clear Clinton knew it was a terrorist attack from the get go. She consulted with Obama and then the "demonstration about a video" lie was started and the refusal to call it a terrorist attack began, in public at least. We know now she was calling it a terrorist attack in private at the same she was supporting the "demonstration" lie in public.
This pattern isn't new. Islamic terrorism is never terrorism to this administration. It's workplace violence or a random shooting of random people at a Jewish deli. It's always something else, this time it was a justified reaction to a "internet video"
As Jonah Goldberg wrote, " Remember, in the aftermath of the Benghazi attack, the Obama White House used the video lie to launch a national conversation on the limits of free speech. Obama even went to the U.N. and, before the whole world, put our free-speech rights in the dock. Blaming America, specifically our attachment to the First Amendment, is a much easier conversation for this White House — and the praetorian pundits who cover for it — than the White House’s unpreparedness and ineptitude in the face of Islamic terrorism."
Read more at:
Much easier to defend a riot started by a video than admit they ignored 600 requests for security as Islamic terrorists were running wild in a country we turned over to them.
Sean, according to Morell, and other reporting contemporaneous to the event, the attack on the State Dept. compound was not well planned, well co- ordinated , or well organized. Morell says, it was more like a mob. Is a mob closer to a protest or an international "terrorist" attack? You constantly talk about how Clinton "lied" about what happened? What are you doing and what are the fanatics at the National Review doing but lying when they say it was an "Al Qaida" attack along the lines of 9-11?
As the article I seeded today says, the Republicans have no concept of nuance. Y'all live in some fantasy land. Like the fantasy that Mitt Romney was winning the election, now you are seeing another fantasy fall apart.
People are tired of all your deliberate mischaracterizations and blatant falsehoods.