╌>

Lawyer For Alabama Cop Who Body Slammed And Paralyzed 57 Year Old Man From India Says It Was The Victim's Fault 'He Should Have Spoke English'

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Lawyer For Alabama Cop Who Body Slammed And Paralyzed 57 Year Old Man From India Says It Was The Victim's Fault  'He Should Have Spoke English'


Jury asked to convict officer of civil rights violations







 

 

HUNTSVILLE, Ala. -- 

(AP) An Alabama police officer slammed an Indian man to the ground for no reason, causing spinal injuries that left the man partially paralyzed, and should be convicted of a federal civil rights crime, a prosecutor told jurors Tuesday in the officer's second trial.

But a defense lawyer said the man was to blame for his own injuries and suggested he was partly at fault for visiting the United States without knowing how to speak English.

Opening statements began moments after attorneys picked a jury of 11 women and three men, including two alternates, to hear officer Eric Parker's second trial on using excessive force against 58-year-old Sureshbhai Patel.

Jurors deadlocked in Parker's first trial in September, and U.S. District Judge Madeline Haikala declared a mistrial.

Prosecutor Robert Posey told jurors that Parker, 27, was riding with a rookie officer as a trainer for the Madison Police Department in suburban Huntsville when the two answered a call about a suspicious person walking in the neighborhood where Patel had just arrived from India days earlier to live with his son, daughter-in-law and grandson.

A caller reported seeing a black man in a knit cap peering and walking into garages on a cool February morning, Posey said, and Parker and the other officer spotted the brown-skinned Patel as they pulled into the area in their police car.

"The officers don't see Mr. Patel doing anything suspicious. He's just walking down the street," Posey said.

After several moments of failing to communicate with each other because Patel didn't speak English and Parker didn't speak Patel's language, Parker grabbed Patel and threatened to "put him on the ground" before slamming the man face-first into a yard, Posey said.

"I expect the evidence will be that there was no good reason for this use of force," Posey said. Later, Parker tried to justify the takedown to supervisors, the prosecutor said.

But defense attorney Robert Tuten disagreed, saying that Parker only responded to escalating threats from Patel in the manner in which he was trained.

"This case is about a police officer doing his job," Tuten told jurors.

Patel kept "jerking away" and walking off from police despite realizing they were officers and understanding their use of the word "stop," Tuten said, and he refused commands to remove his hands from his pockets.

"There are people out there in the world who will kill a police officer just because he's a cop, and (officers) have to be aware of that," Tuten said.

Tuten called the language difficulties between Patel and Parker "unfortunate," but he said anyone who comes to the United States is expected to follow the law and speak the dominant language.

"Here, we speak English," Tuten said.

Haikala conducted jury selection out of public view after issuing an order Monday saying some witnesses in Parker's first trial violated a court order by improperly following testimony through live blogs, presumably of news media outlets covering the case.

Haikala did not identify the witnesses who violated her order to stay away from trial coverage, and her order made no mention of any sanctions. But she issued an order saying audience members aren't to use smartphones and other devices in the courtroom during the retrial, to lessen the chances of moment-by-moment coverage.



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Cop Claims Brutal Assault On Indian Grandfather Was Justified Because ‘We Speak English Here’ (VIDEO)

AUTHOR :  RANDA MORRIS   OCTOBER 27, 2015 11:50 PM

Defense lawyers representing an Alabama police officer who stands accused of violating the rights of a 57-year-old man blamed the victim in court today. During opening statements, attorney Robert Tuten told jurors that the officer’s brutal attack on the man was on his own fault. He stated that Sureshbhai Patel, a native of India, had no business coming to the United States if he doesn’t know how to speak the language.

Mr. Patel was body-slammed by Madison, Alabama police officer, Eric Parker, in February. The assault left him partially paralyzed.

As  Addicting Info   reported in February , Officer Parker approached Patel after the a 911 caller racially profiled him. The caller reported seeing “a really skinny black guy,” with “a toboggan on.” Even though the caller said Mr. Patel was “just walking,” he also reported being “afraid to go to work and leave his wife at home alone.”

Mr. Patel came to the United States from India, where he worked as a farmer all of his life. He was brought to the country by his son, Chirag Patel, a U.S. citizen who is employed by a defense contractor, as a software engineer, in Huntsville. He brought his father to the United States after his baby was born prematurely, because he and his wife needed help caring for the child.

Video  of Parker slamming the 57-year-old grandfather to the ground was published by al.com on  YouTube , earlier this year.

According to Parker’s defense attorney, Mr. Patel had it coming. He’s not paralyzed today because the cop brutalized him without cause. In fact, the entire thing is his own fault.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

So, if some American goes to Germany , and happens to look suspicious to some local yokel, the German cops would be justified in beating the crap out of the American because he didn't speak German ? 

Ay yi yi

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Who comes up with this shit?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago

The title of this article reminds me of a classic joke:

What do you call a lawyer at the bottom of the ocean?

A good start.

 
 

Who is online


Sean Treacy


110 visitors