╌>

So, is the mainstream media really left-wing, or even liberal, as those on the right love to claim?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

So, is the mainstream media really left-wing, or even liberal, as those on the right love to claim?

The Myth Of The Liberal Mainstream Media

"...First of all, it should be noted that the real world tends to have a liberal bias — at least what Cruz considers a liberal bias. Take climate change, for example. The fact that the climate is warming because of human activity is a completely uncontroversial notion; it is happening, and the vast majority of scientists agree that it will be catastrophic for humanity if nothing is done very soon. That the mainstream media does not contest the issue of climate change, or claim that it is some giant left-wing conspiracy, does not prove it is liberal, but that it is operating in reality. Cruz does not operate in reality, and believes climate change (i.e. science) is a “religion.” But just because Cruz believes this, or his deranged father, Rafael,  believes that evolution is a communist lie , does not mean that evolutionary biologists are communists or that climate scientists are religious fanatics — it means that Rafael Cruz and his son are delusional.

Now, before considering whether the mainstream media is really left-wing, one should look at who owns the media. Consider this: In 1983, 90 percent of American media was owned by 50 companies, and  by 2011, that number had fallen to six companies : CBS, Time Warner, Viacom, News Corp, Disney and GE, which subsequently sold its media holding, NBC Universal, to cable giant Comcast (which would, in turn, later try to merge with Time Warner Cable, although that deal eventually  fell apart ).

Thus, the media at large has one crucial goal: to make a profit. Not to serve the public, but to make money by selling advertisement spots to other corporations, whether they are selling new cars or tech products or pointless new drugs. All of this profit-making hardly sounds like the socialist media that Republicans would have everyone believe.

One has to look no further than the coverage of Donald Trump to see this strategy in action. The Donald and the media have been feeding off of each other over the past few months. Trump loves the attention, and the media loves the “Yooge” ratings that he brings. (The higher the ratings, the more the network can charge for advertising or subscriptions.) CNN, for example, has covered Trump as if he were a natural disaster, and even  bumped  a 1oth anniversary special for Hurricane Katrina to cover one of Trump’s rambling campaign events.

 

 


Now consider the media coverage of the democratic socialist Bernie Sanders, who has drawn massive crowds to his campaign events and last month broke a fundraising record. The media largely ignored Sanders, and when it finally came around, after his popularity and poll numbers were too big to ignore, the coverage was full of bias and mischaracterization. As Rima Regas  writes in Alternet :


“The most harmful way anti-Sanders media bias has been manifested is by omission. In this respect, the New York Times is joined by the vast majority of the mainstream media in not typically reporting on Sanders, especially on policy. Overall there is a version of a “wall of silence” built by the media when it comes to serious reporting and analysis of his policies; or when analyzing or reporting on the policies of his opponents, a failure to mention Sanders’ in contrast, especially when his is the more progressive position.”


Why would the media, if it were so left-wing, be so active in its coverage of a right-wing populist like Trump, and so quiet in its coverage of Sanders? The reality is, of course, that the corporate media (a much more appropriate term than mainstream media) is not left-wing. Now, many conservatives argue that the majority of journalists support the Democratic party, which is true. But what does this prove? As Noam Chomsky (a real leftist) has previously  pointed out :


“You could find that 99% of the journalists are members of the Socialist Workers Party, or some Maoist group, and that in itself would prove nothing about the media output. The issue is whether the media are free; are the media by their institutional structure free, to allow expression of opinion from whatever source, looking at any topic. If it turned out that 80% of the journalists were from one faction of the business party rather than another faction of the business party, would that tell you anything?”


 

Anyone who knows the history of left-wing politics understands that the media at large is not at all left-wing, but centrist at best. Again, just because the media lives in reality and does not dispute climate change, doesn’t mean that it is liberal, but that the conservative faction of the GOP has become increasingly delusional in its extremism.

The corporate media runs for a profit, and wouldn’t dare advocate any true socialist policies that woulds inflict pain on its business model. Sure, the media at large supports issues like gay marriage — but again, what does this prove? Is it a plot to destroy America, as Ted Cruz’s  cheerful father believes , or is it because America at large is becoming more socially tolerant?

Rubio and Cruz did well for themselves in bashing the abhorred media, but what does CNBC care, the ratings were great (though significantly lower than the first two debates), and the  network made $250,000 for each 30 second commercial . And this, my fellow comrades, is what the corporate media is all about.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"...This entire fiasco reveals a couple of thing about American politics and the media today. First, it shows how childish the entire Republican field has become, and how tough questions are no longer permitted in GOP circles. It displays how easy Republicans really have it, when all a candidate has to do when confronted about his abysmal voting record or challenged with a question on his divisiveness is to shout that the “liberal media” is out to get him (Hillary Clinton does not have this luxury when every other question is about her emails — after all, the MSM is her super PAC).

As for the media, this all shows how ratings and clicks and profit are more important than integrity. Trump has decided to negotiate directly with networks because he knows how much leverage he really has. The New York billionaire brings in “Huge” ratings — a fact that he is never quiet about — and his presence will most definitely boost advertising revenue for whichever hosting network. (CNBC charged $250,000 for each 30 second commercial.)

This is all rather reminiscent of the classic Sidney Lumet film, “Network,” in which the fictional television network, UBS, decides to keep their longtime anchorman on the air after he suffers a nervous breakdown on live TV, which ends up boosting the networks ratings. “Network” was made in 1976, and over the years, the media and political world seem to have moved increasingly closer to this fictional universe, or as Lewis Black  said last December  on “Meet the Press”:

 
 

“We’ve moved closer to living at the corner where satire and reality intersect.”

The rise of cable news networks, internet blogging and right-wing radio has flooded the media world over the past couple of decades, as well as creating a hyper-partisan atmosphere (not to mention social media, which has made it possible for anyone and everyone to voice their opinions online — many of whom are anonymous trolls). However, while the media has become increasingly saturated, it has also become concentrated in its ownership. While in 1983, 90 percent of the media was owned by 50 companies, by 2011,  it had fallen to six massive corporations  with the single-minded goal of making a profit.

All of these factors have made the rise of a reality-TV candidate like Trump inevitable. Profit, entertainment, partisanship, consumerism — all the perfect ingredients for an absurd candidate like The Donald. The corporate media’s obsession with Trump arrises from its desperation for ratings and clicks and increased advertising and subscription revenue. Like Howard Beale (the anchorman in “Network”), Trump’s outrageous comments and bravado have been too rich in ratings for networks to give up.

And so Trump is negotiating with networks for the terms for his participation in the debates. He knows how bad they want him there, and therefore he is going it alone instead of cooperating with the RNC and other Republican candidates. Throughout most of the twentieth century, television networks did not make (or expect to make) profit off of their news broadcasts. News was a kind of public service, and it was more about gaining prestige than making money — that was for sitcoms and game shows to do. But as the internet has made it harder for networks to profit off of their (increasingly expensive) programming, and the news/opinion business has been flooded with competition, the need for ratings (or clicks online) has become more imperative. In other words, news has become fully embedded into our consumerist society. In real life, a network would have probably taken Howard Beale off the air back in 1976, but today? At the very least a cable network would pick him up (or he’d get a reality show) to exploit his mental imbalances.

 

Over the past few months, the Republican primary and the rise of Trump as a politician have moved us closer and closer to that corner where satire and reality intersect. And with Trump at the negotiating table, it is bound to become even more surreal."

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I guess from the perspective of a Stalinist, from which this is written, the media is not left wing.  

 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

I guess there are those who would use the term "liberal" as a dirty word, and would consider Attila the Hun to be liberal.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

It wasn't always this way, and I do not like what it has become.  William Shirer is, no doubt, rotating in his grave, as is Walter Cronkite...

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Of course it's not liberal. That's a bullshit cop out excuse and applause line from the right when they haven't got a good answer to an honest question or one of them fucks up, gets caught and it appears on TV or in the papers. It's horseshit.

 
 

Who is online





142 visitors