╌>

What Happened When Colorado Springs Police Did Not Respond To 911 Call Reporting A Man On The Street With A Gun

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  13 comments

What Happened When Colorado Springs Police Did Not Respond To 911 Call Reporting A Man On The Street With A Gun
Here Is the Audio of the 911 Call Just Minutes Before the Colorado Gun Rampage

MoJo Blogs and Articles | Mother Jones

Star the article Mark as unread


More MoJo coverage of the Colorado Springs rampage

 
Did Colorado's Open Carry Law Delay Police Response to a Mass Shooter? Police Did Not Treat 911 Call About Colorado Gunman as "Highest Priority" Open Carry Gun Laws Make It Harder to Protect the Public, Police Chiefs Say
 

The Colorado Springs Police Department on Wednesday released the audio from two 911 calls placed last Saturday morning just prior to and during a deadly gun rampage. The first call came just 10 minutes before a man shot three people to death and was subsequently killed in a shootout with police. The Colorado Springs PD released the audio and a detailed statement following  several stories  by  Mother Jones  and other news outlets focusing on whether Colorado's open carry law may have played a role in how the police responded. 

In the first call, placed at 8:45 a.m. on October 31, resident Naomi Bettis told a dispatcher that she saw a man, later identified as 33-year-old Noah Harpham, walking around a building with a broken window across the street from her house. She said that he was carrying a black rifle and gasoline cans, and she described him as suspicious and "scary" at several points during the six-minute-long call. At one point she told the dispatcher that the man was going in and out of an upstairs apartment in the building. "It may be the guy that lives upstairs because he ran right up there, but he still shouldn't be holding a gun," Bettis said.

"Well it is an open carry state, so he can have a weapon with him or walking around with it," the dispatcher responded. "But of course having those gas cans, it does seem pretty suspicious so we're going to keep the call going for that." Bettis clearly sounded agitated during parts of the call: "I went out there to get in my Jeep," she said, "and I'm scared to death." When asked by the dispatcher whether anyone's life was in imminent danger, however, she answered no. "I just hope that this is, you know, not as bad as it is," Bettis said. Listen to the full call here:

 

Bettis  later told the  Washington Post  that she was put off by the dispatcher's comments regarding the state's open carry law, as if the dispatcher "didn't believe me." On Tuesday, Lt. Catherine Buckley of the Colorado Springs PD told  Mother Jones  that Bettis' first 911 call wasn't treated as "the highest priority call for service." In its statement released Wednesday, the department said the call was originally treated as a "priority 3" call, which "represents in-progress incidents involving property." One minute into the call, the incident was upgraded to a "priority 2" call, and changed to a possible burglary in progress, according to the statement. The department's priority scale  has six levels, with "priority 1" being the most urgent.

At the time of the first call, all officers in the area were on other calls, according to the department's statement. Then, one officer who became available during the call was instead dispatched to a disturbance in progress at a senior residential facility: "The call for service [near Bettis] was the same priority level as the disturbance; however, the disturbance at the senior center represented a threat to human life, while [Bettis’ call] (a possible burglary-in-progress) was at the time considered a threat to property."

"He's laying on the street dead"  After the initial six-minute exchange with the dispatcher, Bettis was told to call back if the situation changed. Ten minutes later, she did. "I just called a few minutes ago, and the guy came back out," she said, now sounding frantic and her voice shaking. "He fired the gun at somebody and he's laying on the street dead." Listen to the full call here: [ Warning:  Some may find the following audio disturbing.]

 

At that point, according to the statement from the Colorado Springs PD, all available police units and an ambulance were dispatched. Less than 10 minutes after that Harpham's three victims had been shot and he was killed by gunfire from police.

"Upon review of the 911  audio from the initial call for service the (dispatcher) responded in accordance with both the Colorado Springs Police Department policy and national protocols," the department said in its statement.

The department also released a 2011 training document with respect to how it handles the open carry issue:

"The mere act of openly carrying a gun in a non-threatening manner is not automatically to be considered suspicious behavior. Therefore, if we get a call from a citizen about a person who has a firearm in plain sight and they are not acting in a suspicious manner, they have not brandished it, discharged it, or violated any of the previous conditions; CSPD will not respond."

 

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/11/colorado-springs-shooting-911-calls-audio


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

A woman calls and says that she sees a man walking down the street carrying a long "rifle" and two gasoline cans, wearing an "army jacket and a blue cap", and 911 does not dispatch anyone immediately to the scene, but rather tells her in effect "we will get around to it". Because, people are allowed to walk around Colorado Springs toting long rifles with shoulder straps. 

In the meantime, the man with the rifle shot and killed a bicyclist and two women sitting on a porch. 

When the 911 caller calls back after 10 minutes and tells the dispatcher than the bicyclist is laying dead in the street and the man with the gun is walking around, the dispatcher asks the caller if "anyone is in danger right now ".  While this nonsense is taking place, the caller hears more shots (the women being killed ?)

Abominable. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Good lesson on why it is really up to you to protect yourself. Don't count on government to save your life. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

If the country still had any sanity, a man walking down the street openly carrying a rifle would be considered an imminent "threat" worthy of response by a patrol car. 

Imagine you are a Colorado Springs resident today. Will there be a "copycat" killer who will do this again ?  You can see someone walking down the street with a rifle today in Colorado Springs, and by their rules the police will not respond. 

It is a sad situation. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

I'm not with you. It's Elk season around here right now. Here in Vail you are not allow to drive up the mountain. People park in town and walk right through the middle of town to get to the base of the mountain and head up hunting. We see people walking down the street with rifles around here and nobody freaks out. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

They should keep it in a bag or case until they get to the hunting area. It's not complicated. 

But it is a moot point since Colorado allows anyone anywhere to walk around with open guns. 

911 did not immediately send a cop to the scene in Colo Springs and three innocent people ended up dead. There is your open carry in action. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

As opposed to Chiraq where it is not allowed. How is that working out there? 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

No one is killed in Chicago by someone who was allowed by law to walk down the street with a gun in his hand. 

In Colorado Springs a woman called in a threat and basically nothing was done. I hope the gun lovers are happy. 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago
“Shoot Any Bad Guys”: Arizona Grandfather Arrested After Leaving 5-Year-Old Girl In Desert With Loaded Handgun While He Went Out For a Cheeseburger
JONATHAN TURLEY
Star the article Mark as unread

Paul-Armand-Rater_3490361b  Paul Armand Rater, 53, is facing  two counts of felony child abuse and one count of felony child endangerment  after he gave a loaded and cocked .45-calibre handgun to his 5-year-old granddaughter and left her in the desert. I told her to “shoot any bad guys.”

The incident happened near their home in Buckeye (about 30 miles west of Phoenix). The little girl was later found by her mother and a volunteer firefighter wandering for hours in the desert with the still cocked and loaded .45 handgun.

As for Rater, he was located in a store and said that his vehicle broke down. He said that he left the girl under a tree in the desert because she was complaining she could not walk any more. He admitted leaving her with the gun “while he went for a few drinks and a cheeseburger.”

That should do it for a sentence and jail time.

Fortunately a felony conviction will likely bar Rater for owning weapons in the future.

What do you think the appropriate sentence should be?

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

Good lesson on why it is really up to you to protect yourself.

Dean -  if you were the guy on the bike, what would you have done to protect yourself?

Perhaps the woman should have just shot him, you know feeling threatened and all.  Why call 911, she could use the stand your ground b/s and just have blown him away.  She didn't, because she is a woman with a brain who called upon law enforcement to handle her concerns....they did a piss poor job!

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  LynneA   11 years ago

I listened to both of the 911 calls, and they really put the emergency system in a poor light. The second call, right after the caller tells the dispatcher that someone is laying on the street dead and the gunman is still on the loose, the dispatcher asks the caller if anyone is in danger "now". It is tragically absurd on the face of it, as two women were then subsequently killed by the deranged shooter. 

We can pretty much guarantee this will not be the last incident like this. When responsible citizens call in threats like this they should be checked out immediately, not 10 or 15 minutes later .

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

JR, after hearing and reading this scenario my first thought - citizens who are concerned will need to lie in order to garner the response they're looking for.  This woman was scared, if she said he pointed the gun at her in a menacing manner they would have rolled a squad immediately. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  LynneA   11 years ago

I think you are right Lynn, she should have lied and said the gun was pointing at her. Maybe those three people would still be alive. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"It wasn't a matter of if, but when it would happen. On Saturday in Colorado Springs, a man exercising his right under state law to openly carry a rifle in the streets went on a rampage, killing three people before police took him out in a hail of bullets. Just before the attack, an alarmed neighbor saw the man walking around armed and dialed 911. The dispatcher explained to her that it was legal to carry a gun in public. Her 911 call wasn't deemed urgent—the police did not process it as "the highest priority call for service," a  Colorado Springs PD official confirmed  to  Mother Jones  yesterday. She soon dialed 911 again, after the killing had begun.

Exactly when and how the two 911 calls played out remains unclear: The Colorado Springs PD has so far denied open records requests and refused to provide any further information about the calls, citing an ongoing investigation into the rampage. [ Update:  Audio of the calls has been released,  listen here .] The 911 caller, Naomi Bettis, spoke further to local news outlet  The Gazette  late Tuesday:

"I didn't like the first dispatcher," Bettis said. "Because she says 'You know in Colorado, they do have an open/concealed weapon law.'" Bettis said the time between her 911 calls was "not very long, but it seemed like forever."

The Gazette  also interviewed several Colorado police chiefs about how the state's open carry law affects their mission to protect public safety. Their responses were sobering:

Police chiefs contacted by  The Gazette  declined to comment specifically on Saturday's shooting spree, because it remains under investigation.  But they said calls related to weapons being carried openly are steeped in nuance — often leaving dispatchers and officers in a difficult spot.

"The problem that we all face is that we never have all the information," said Fountain Police Department Chief Chris Heberer.

Evans Police Department Chief Rich Brandt, who also serves as president of the Colorado Association of Chiefs of Police, said he was unaware of a uniform system for handling those calls, such as where to prioritize them against the myriad other 911 calls received daily.

Heberer said 911 call takers generally try to gauge callers' level of panic, and whether or not someone openly carrying a gun appears out of place.

Dispatchers' challenges are similar to those of officers on the street, who have increasingly met people carrying guns — both openly and concealed.

Heberer stressed the need to respect gun holders' constitutional right to have guns, and their ability to carry them in public. And he said officers must approach calls more carefully as a result.

"Situational awareness is that much more important," Heberer said.

Despite long-running efforts by the National Rifle Association and other lobbying groups to persuade Americans otherwise, there is  clear empirical evidence  with mass shootings that armed civilians don't stop bad guys with guns. The question now is whether the looser gun laws pushed by the NRA and others also prevent the police from doing so."

 
 

Who is online

Sean Treacy


107 visitors