Chris Matthews Gives The Blunt Truth About Dr. Ben Carson - Will Anybody Care ?
l
"Let me finish tonight with this. I am baffled by the appeal of Dr Ben Carson. There, I've said it. He advocates tax policy based on the Old Testament on tithing as if ten percent is some blessed counsel to us , living in the 21st century. He argues that the Egyptian pyramids weren't built as tombs for the pharaohs , but rather as grain banks even though everyone in the world knows that King Tut and the rest of them began building their pyramids from the time of their youth as way stations for their deliverance after death. Why else did they equip those sealed chambers with all the things they would like to have in the afterlife. And why, to put in bluntly , is Dr. Carson right about this and every book on Egyptology wrong ? Is this a case where a gifted amateur shows us his beginner's luck ? Give me a break. The experts are right and he's wrong, and this is just another example of the wildness of listening to him. What does Dr. Carson know about the ancient Egyptians and their funerary practices? In effect, nothing.
What does he know about U.S. tax policy and it's complexity? In effect what he's read in the Bible. When asked why an amateur like him could do a better job than the political professionals he points to the founding fathers, calling them his fellow amateurs --- fact check -----practically all of the signers of the Declaration Of Independence were, committed, deadly serious men of public affairs, elected in their own States to serve on legislative bodies, all of which preceded the founding of the country. The country was founded by professionals doctor. And what is this talk about the Ark ? Noah's Ark. What relevance does this account from the Bible teach us today ? Well, Dr. Carson answers us. It teaches us that amateurs build boats better than professionals, he says. How else, he asks, do we explain the sinking of the Titanic. Well, you got me there doctor. "
Chris Matthews
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors

Chris Matthews is not all that polished, but he does get to the heart of that matter. What the hell is Ben Carson doing running for president ?
The media has begun to turn it's attention to him, and it is likely to not be a pretty sight. He is, today, embroiled in a big argument with CNN, which sent a reporter to talk to his childhood friends about the incident Carson speaks of in many of his political speeches, where he talks about his violent tendencies as a teen and how he was able to turn to religion to change his life. CNN has said that they cannot locate anyone who corroborates his stories about trying to stab some kid in the neck with a knife , and his other tales about his violent actions. CNN has spoke to a number of Carson's school classmates from the time and no one seems to remember Carson being anything but a mild mannered bookworm.
Yesterday he told an interviewer that all the founding fathers were amateur politicians, just like him, who had never held office prior to signing the Declaration of Independence, when the fact is that many of them held office in their own colonial legislatures. Then Carson said, I mean they didn't hold FEDERAL office. Well, Mr. Brain Surgeon, there was no federal office prior to the Declaration of Independence.
It's all going to fall apart for Carson, it is just a question of when.
What the hell was Barack Obama doing running for President? He'd never even held the same full time job for 4 years as an adult before running for President. And now the only person they can find to run has been an abject failure/criminal at every job she's had.
With those two examples staring them in the face, Democrats are barred from ever criticizing a candidate's qualifications.
You have gone off the deep end Sean. Blind hatred has clouded your judgement. Carson is most likely the most unqualified presidential candidate of modern times this side of Donald Trump.
He knows next to nothing about either foreign policy or domestic policy, which is more than bad enough. Now he has taken to making mistake after mistake (or careless lie after careless lie if you prefer). He said yesterday that the founding fathers were all amateur poltiicians, JUST LIKE HIM , and that none of them had ever held office, just like him. Sounds good right? Except it was completely untrue.
How many fact checkers are going to have to be assigned to this guy? It may singlehandedly bring down the unemployment rate !
This from a Hillary supporter. You can't even make this shit up.
Making shit up seems to be Carson's department.
He still has a hell of a lot of work to do to catch up to BO my friend....and Hillary for that matter. Considering who you support and how you have supported them, your complaints about "fabricating" couldn't be more ironic or hypocritical.
It has become obvious that the left will make up or exaggerate any issue to discredit Carson . I was on the fence about him but now I see he is the candidate worth supporting if for no other reason than to silence the lies from the left ...
I'm sure he will be thrilled to know that such a stable fellow as yourself has his back.
" Then Carson said, I mean they didn't hold FEDERAL office. Well, Mr. Brain Surgeon, there was no federal office prior to the Declaration of Independence. "
But ... but ... but, it was a true statement! I think the Captain Obvious guy on the Hotels.com commercials has got some competition.
So no leg tingle? Fickle.
Of course you don't address the content. How could you ?
Carson has as much experience as Obama had as an absentee senator and a failed community organizer. The Constitution dies not require an apprenticeship in state or local government. Carson's casual thoughts about ancient structures are irrelevant.
Chris Matthews Gives The Blunt Truth About Dr. Ben Carson - Will Anybody Care ?
Well if they use the same criteria for him as they do for Obama and Hillary, then I guess no one will care.
Do you have ANY criteria for Carson? He says something that is untrue just about every day, often about subjects that have little to do with politics or government. He may be a habitual fabricator. Republicans have no idea because they have been too busy being happy that he is a "brain surgeon".
"He says something that is untrue just about every day, often about subjects that have little to do with politics or government. He may be a habitual fabricator."
LMFAO!!!!! You have just perfectly described BO, the only difference is he is too stupid to be a brain surgeon.
Truth and Chris Matthews - not usually seen together in a sentence or conversation
This is a hilarious story about Carson, and later down the page, Trump. I was going to post it as a separate seed but I know people get tired of seeing this great American spoken ill of.
----
Why Won't Anyone Believe Ben Carson When He Says He Tried to Attack His Mom With a Hammer?
Another day, another dubious claim of violence from Dr. Ben Carson, a man who, for whatever reason, would very much like you to believe he stabbed a friend in the stomach and tried to attack his own mother with a hammer.
Carson’s stories of unbridled childhood violence have been well-documented in his books, which present varying accounts of a few key stories. There’s the time he punched a classmate in the head with a metal lock. The time he threw a rock at a friend’s face. The time he tried to hit his mother in the head with a hammer. And the cornerstone of his redemption story: the time he stabbed a friend.
One of the formative stories in frontrunning GOP presidential candidate Ben Carson’s life, a tale… Read more
Carson’s accounts of these acts of violence—which allegedly occurred around 50 years ago—are, at best, inconsistent. He attributes the shift to the elapsed time, explaining to CNN, “Have you ever played that party game where you whisper into the person’s ear and then they tell it, and by the time it gets all the way back around it’s a different story? That’s what we’re talking about here.”
But CNN, in an investigation published Friday , couldn’t find a single person to play telephone with.
Carson now offers several explanations for the apparent contradictions raised by the CNN report. The first, and least convincing: he had already changed his ways by high school.
“I don’t want to expose people without their knowledge, but remember, when I was 14, when the knifing episode occurred, that’s when I changed, that’s when most of the people I talked to began to know who I was, they didn’t know me before then,” Carson told CNN . (As CNN points out, several of its sources were Carson’s friends and acquaintances from elementary school and junior high.)
Second: he used fictitious names in his books.
“I don’t like to generally bring them in, the names I used for instance are fictitious names because I don’t want to bring people into something like this because I know what you guys do to their lives,” Carson reportedly explained during a book stop in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida.
The third: the stabbing victim he repeatedly refers to as a “friend” was actually a close relative.
“The person that I tried to stab, I talked to today and said, ‘Would they want to be revealed?’ They were not anxious to be revealed, and it was a close relative of mine. I didn’t want to put their lives under the spotlight,” Carson reportedly told Megyn Kelly Thursday.
Not buying the “stabb” story is Donald Trump, who tweeted and deleted a surprisingly cogent, typo-riddled response this morning.
So we have a presidential candidate—a front-running presidential candidate—desperately trying to defend the claim that he nearly murdered multiple relatives, while his rival tries to plant seeds of doubt in the minds of voters.
If Ben Carson didn’t attack his own mother with a hammer, what else isn’t he capable of?
Why does anyone care that Obama is trying his best to economically equalize the races by bringing whites down ? They don't care . They agree with Obama's strategy . What is Obama doing to help the US economy ? Very little , but very few care . Obama : setting a new standard for low job performance ...
I want to see his birth certificate. He lies so much I just want to be sure he's using his real name.
I do too. Part of the job qualification is you are born here, it should be required and why on earth wouldn't anyone applying for the job come out with it as soon as it is brought up? (still waiting for the answer on that one)
I assume you're referring to Ted Cruz?
Chris Matthews Gives The Blunt Truth About Dr. Ben Carson - Will Anybody Care ?
I don't think they will. This man has shown himself to be constantly changing between out right lying and being just plain stupid. Even the GOP isn't ignorant enough (and boy, they are ignorant) to nominate this bio-hazard waste for the Presidency.
The Bible doesn't state that Joseph built the pyramids nor does it remotely imply that they were used for grain storage. Yet Carson uses the Bible to undergird a personal belief that isn't supported by the Bible, archeology, or common sense. That's disturbing because it gives me no confidence that he can tell fact from fiction or fiction from faith (yes I know that some don't see a distinction between fiction and faith but Carson isn't one of them). Then there's Carson himself saying that his temper is/was psychopathic but he controls it. Oddly, no one from his childhood remembers Carson as he remembers himself. To me, Carson looks like (and probably always looked like) the classic geek on his way to math class with his pencil protector neatly in his shirt pocket -- a classic target in certain neighborhoods. I'm no psychologist but Carson may have invented his tough guy persona -- a hyde character if you will -- as a counterbalance to his normal Jekyll image (which is low energy to the point of appearing medicated) as a way of simultaneously giving himself credit for his Vulcan-like ability to control his violent emotions and as a warning to bullies to beware of Hyde. Whether he controls a psychopathic temper or just invents it, he should be properly vetted before we put him in a position that could literally end all life as we know it.
Bravo and well said!
Bravo and well said!
Oops! Look where that comment ended up Randy. It has absolutely relationship the comment above it.
That's why I've been trying to convince everyone, that in spite of the cumbersome process we have to go through on this new cumbersome format we have, it is absolutely necessary to create a block quote above all new comments so everyone knows what everyone is referring to with their comments.
LOL! I like where it ended up beneath saying he might be senile too.
Bravo and well said!
Oops! It's moved again, I don't know how long it will stay there, but this time you're complimenting my comment, thanks.
(See what I mean when I say you always have to use block quotes?)
I want to see his birth certificate. He lies so much I just want to be sure he's using his real name.
You're kidding, right? I mean you really can't be serious with a comment like that.
Yep. I have a theory that the real Dr. Carson is being held hostage somewhere and that the GOP is running a complete moron in his place for President.
I mean the real Dr. Carson can not possibly be this stupid. Could he?
I mean the real Dr. Carson can not possibly be this stupid. Could he?
No, we all know Carson is very intelligent, but he's obviously just an amateur when it comes to politics.
IMO, he thinks his outrageous comments are going to bring him media coverage, and that it did!
But Carson is no Donald Trump, and it's not working for him. The stupid shit he's espousing is just making him look like a stupid shit.
I'm not so sure. I think it's possible that biology and medicine are all he knows how to do properly and that religion has made him downright stupid on everything else. It does that to some people.
Either that or he's senile.
The Bible doesn't state that Joseph built the pyramids nor does it remotely imply that they were used for grain storage.
Let's face it, the guy has reveled himself as a complete fucking screwball. What is most disturbing is that there are so many screwballs ready to follow him.
Carson said he had a psychopathic temper and tried to stab somebody to death as a youth. If that's true, then he was/is a homicidal psychopath. That alone warrants lots of media questions and dwarfs his looney pyramid theory. Of course if it's not a true story then he's just a run if the mill liar.
I'm betting run of the mill liar. That said, if he really did act like he claims he acted, then I hope he has had lots and lots and lots of therapy since then and continues to get therapy along with medications, because if he hasn't (IMHO) and isn't, then he will explode sooner or later.
You have a tendency to judge others from your perspective as a certified mental mess . Not everyone is that way ...
I loved in his press conference when he said Barack Obama didn't have to go though what he is going through.
He's right! Barack had it a LOT worse from the press then Ben has had it so far. It's not even CLOSE!!! Relax Ben, it's all part of the vetting and the press is going to crawl up into your asshole. Welcome to the big leagues, child. Get used to it and stop whining.
I loved in his press conference when he said Barack Obama didn't have to go though what he is going through. He's right! Barack had it a LOT worse from the press then Ben has had it so far. It's not even CLOSE!!! Relax Ben, it's all part of the vetting and the press is going to crawl up into your asshole. Welcome to the big leagues, child. Get used to it and stop whining.
What I find astounding is that Carson is complaining that the press is investigating the very narrative about his youth that Carson himself put forward to explain who he is. He said he had a psychopathic temper that led him to try and hit his mother in the head with a hammer and stab somebody to death (he was unsuccessful because the knife was deflected by a belt buckle). So he is a self-described homicidal psychopath. I think if Obama had said that, he would have been excoriated but Carson expects to just say it and glide by. On top of that, Carson stated that (contrary to archaeology and common sense) God has enlightened him to believe that the pyramids (structures of nearly solid rock) were built as granaries rather than tombs. The press should ask a lot questions to establish at a minimum whether, and to what extent, Carson is mentally unbalanced. He is running for President not head of the KGB or leader of a cult.
Exactly, 1 of Many.
People apparently think Carson should be exempt from scrutiny because he is a man of God and a famous doctor. Uh, no.
I am seeing more and more articles popping up saying that Carson and his handlers are grifters, con men using this presidential campaign as a money making operation.
I am seeing more and more articles popping up saying that Carson and his handlers are grifters, con men using this presidential campaign as a money making operation.
I'm seeing that as well. You posted an article about Carson's involvement with Mannatech that implied he was sleazy simply for doing paid advertisements. I disagreed with that specific implication and although I haven't changed my mind (yet), I do give you credit for recognizing before I did that there's something not quite right with this guy. I encourage you (and others) to keep posting your thoughts because they are helpful sometimes in sorting through my own.
And I'll bet his books are selling like wildfire and his speaking fees are skyrocketing or at least they will be after he drops out or doesn't get the nomination and goes on tour. He's not going to get nominated and he knows it, so why not run to make some extra bucks?
Yeah, I mean it's not like some nasty reporters went back and dug up dirt on him. HE DUG UP DIRT ON HIMSELF! Certainly he has no right to complain when the media asks him about the dirt.