Obama's Iran Deal is the Opposite of What He Promised the American People
Theres a confusing debate underway on the merits of the new nuclear agreement with Iran announced today. The Obama administration and its supporters are praising the accord as a historic achievement for world peace. The presidents critics claim it is a terrible agreement that will bolster the nuclear program of a state sponsor of terror. Both sides are throwing around nuclear terminology, timelines, and minutiae about the agreement.
How to make sense of this? I believe best way is to judge this agreement against President Obamas own statements.
In 2007, when he was beginning his run for president, Senator Obama told a conference of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) that the world must work to stop Irans uranium-enrichment program.
On October 22, 2012, during a presidential debate with Mitt Romney, Mr. Obama said: Our goal is to get Iran to recognize it needs to give up its nuclear program and abide by the U.N. resolutions that have been in place....But the deal well accept is they end their nuclear program. Its very straightforward.
In December 2013 at a Brookings Institution forum, President Obama said: They dont need to have an underground, fortified facility like Fordow in order to have a peaceful nuclear program. They certainly dont need a heavy-water reactor at Arak in order to have a peaceful nuclear program. They dont need some of the advanced centrifuges that they currently possess.
This is what the president said about the Iran nuclear program to get elected. This is what the president told the American people to reassure them about the Iran talks. The agreement announced today does not come close to meeting these statements and promises.
Under the deal, Iran will keep its entire nuclear infrastructure. After the IAEA certifies compliance with easy-to-meet requirements, U.N. Security Council resolutions pertaining to Irans nuclear program will be lifted and Tehran will get an estimated $100 billion in sanctions relief.
Iran is currently enriching uranium with about 9,000 centrifuges. About 6,000 will be kept operational; about 5,000 will continue to enrich. Another 10,000 many non-operational will be put in storage or unplugged. However, no centrifuges will be destroyed or removed from the country.
Iran also will continue to develop advanced uranium centrifuges while the agreement is in effect. However, unlike the interim agreement, which set the stage for the nuclear talks and barred Iran from testing advanced centrifuges with uranium (a provision Iran violated in mid 2014), the new agreement requires only that R&D of advanced centrifuges be tested in a manner that does not accumulate enriched uranium. This means Iran will be allowed to do more-intensive testing of advanced centrifuges than was permitted during the nuclear talks.
Under the agreement, Iran is supposed to dilute its enriched-uranium stockpile, convert some of it to fuel plates for a small research reactor, or sell it on the open market. Diluting its enriched uranium could be reversed in a few months possibly much faster if Iran uses advanced centrifuges.
A bizarre aspect of this part of the agreement is that Iran will receive natural uranium for any enriched uranium it sells. This will help preserve Irans enrichment capability and also solve a problem it has concerning access to natural uranium. (Iran has little natural uranium and its uranium mines are running out.
) Iran has agreed to replace the core of its Arak heavy-water reactor, which is under construction, so it will produce less plutonium and to send the spent fuel rods of this reactor out of the country. However, it will be permitted to operate the Arak reactor, a significant reversal of pre-2013 U.S. policy that work on this reactor be halted permanently because it is a serious nuclear-proliferation threat. Because of this new provision, Iran will develop its expertise on operating and building heavy-water reactors during the period the agreement is in effect.
This adds up to an agreement that will shorten, not lengthen, the time to an Iranian nuclear weapon.
Some of the worst U.S. concessions concern Irans eleventh-hour demand to lift embargoes on conventional arms and ballistic missiles. Effectively verifying this agreement will be impossible, since the 24/7 inspections promised by President Obama and Secretary of State John Kerry in their speeches today apply only to Irans declared nuclear program and supply chain. The IAEA can press for inspections of military sites and other suspect nuclear sites, but the agreement does not provide for any penalty if Iran refuses to grant IAEA inspectors access.
Some of the worst U.S. concessions concern Irans eleventh-hour demand to lift embargoes on conventional arms and ballistic missiles. The conventional-arms embargo will stay in place for five years, and the ballistic-missile embargo will be in place for eight years but will be lifted sooner if the IAEA definitively clears Iran of any current work on nuclear weapons. The IAEA is very unlikely to find evidence of current nuclear-weapons work, as it wont be allowed to inspect non-declared nuclear sites where this activity is taking place. This means these embargoes could be lifted much sooner.
To defend an agreement that legitimizes Irans nuclear program, President Obama could possibly claim that Iran can be trusted because it has begun to act like a responsible member of the international community. However, we know it hasnt. A State Department report from last June found that Irans sponsorship of worldwide terrorism has continued and did not decline in 2014 during the nuclear talks. Iran also is stepping up its efforts to destabilize the Middle East and continues to back the Assad regime and an insurgency in Yemen.
As American supporters and detractors of the nuclear deal engage in a heated debate over the next two months before Congress votes on a resolution of disapproval of the deal, the most important question to resolve is whether President Obama had a mandate from the American people to negotiate this terrible and dangerous agreement. Would he have won the 2008 or 2012 presidential elections if he gave even a hint of a deal like this? Would Congress have supported this abrupt change in American foreign policy if the president had kept it informed about his nuclear diplomacy with Iran and consulted with the Hill during the talks?
The answers to these questions are clearly no.
The Iran deal is the complete opposite of what President Obama promised the American people about how he would handle the Iranian nuclear program . Congress was kept in the dark about the talks, to stop lawmakers from interfering with an agreement the president knew he could never sell to the American people.
This is more than a bad deal. President Obama has betrayed the American people by agreeing to the kind of agreement with an enemy of the United States that he said he would not agree to. It is vital that Congress hold the president to his original promises by rejecting this agreement on a strong bipartisan basis and send a signal to the world that if a Republican is elected president in 2016, this deal will be declared null and void on his or her first day in office.
Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/421191/iran-deal-nuclear-agreement-obama-betrayal

The jihadi nucluer stimulus in action:
A few weeks ago the AP leaked parts of an annex confirming that a major power would be working with the Iranians to develop next-generation centrifuge technology at the Fordow underground military enrichment bunker. Technically the work wont be on nuclear material, but the AP noted that isotope production uses the same technology as enrichment and can be quickly re-engineered to enriching uranium. The administration had once promised Congress that Iran would be forced to dismantle its centrifuge program. The Iranians refused, so the administration conceded that the Iranians would be allowed to keep their existing centrifuges. Now the international community will be actively sponsoring the development of Iranian nuclear technology. And since the work will be overseen by a great power, it will be off-limits to the kind of sabotage that has kept the Iranian nuclear program in check until now.
The original goal of the talks was to make the Iranians take physical actions that would prevent them from going nuclear if they wanted to: dismantling centrifuges, shuttering facilities, etc. The Iranians said no to those demands, and the Americans backed off. The fallback position relied 100% on verification: yes the Iranians would be physically able to cheat, the argument went, but the cheating would be detected because of an anytime-anywhere inspection regime. That is not what the Americans are bringing home.
It's no use, Sean. Those who are happy with this deal are unwilling to consider the possibility that they were wrong. They argue that the only alternative is war - and that isn't even what Israel wants.
Have you thought about building a fallout shelter yet?
Buying land away from a big city seems like a good idea in the next decade or so.
And what alternative course of action would you take?
It is all very well to stand back and take political potshots, but to what end?
All that I see is whining and belly aching for purely political reasons. I have not seen, nor do I expect to see, anything substantive coming of all this kvetching.
The deal is there, it is what we have to debate. Specifically, the question that we need to ask is are we safer now with this deal and does it forestall the acquisition by Iran of a nuclear device as opposed to continuing without the deal? All else is political grandstanding.
If we are truthful, I think we will find the answer to that question is yes, we are safer for the length of the deal than we are without it.
Congress has yet to approve this "deal" - which Obama said will go through because he will quash any resistance coming from Congress.
Obama is doing nothing more that shoring up his "legacy" - I made a deal with Iran - something no other U. S. president has done.
Simple as that.
I feel about equally safe either way. I probably have a better chance of being hit by lightening than being nuked by Iran with or without the deal.
It does exactly that. What it is not is a broader deal on myriad other issues we have with Iran. (But, who knows, maybe the gates are open for making some other deals, similarly limited in scope and do-able with hard negotiations).
So you ask, "Does it slow it down?" Yes. "Does it slow it down in a...
Let's see:
First, taking the military option off the table was a massive mistake. Even if you have no intention of using it, announcing it simply gave the game to Iran. If international diplomacy is poker, taking the military option off the table is like announcing your hole cards are worthless and showing them to the table.
Keep existing sanctions in place and implement the bipartisan Kirk-Menedez sanctions that Obama threatened to veto if Iran moves forward with development.
Support Israel and give it a free hand to do what it wants. I believe in supporting allies, Obama believes in undercutting and isolating them while toadying up to an enemy with American blood on its hands.
Maintain sabotage and espionage programs like Stuxnet.
Support internal dissent movements. Unfortunately, Obama helped the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and Al-Queda in Libya but sat on his hands during the Green Revolution in 2009. All of this might have been avoided had Obama been as tough on our enemy as he was on our ally Mubarek.
yes, we are safer for the length of the dealthan we are without it.
How? Making it easier for Iran to obtain a bomb, which the deal certainly does, willonlyfurtherdestabilizethe middle east and lead to additional proliferation. The Sauds will certainly doeverythingintheir power to obtain a bomb now.
The have been "allowed" to pursue since day one because our administration has no support of its allies nor do they have the cajones to back up their word.
Choose water availability.
Nobody has bothered to address the title of this article - that Obama has done the opposite of what he promised to do. He erased his red lines, he is nothing more than a paper tiger and a disappointment to those who originally had faith in him.
It does exactly that.
Please read Obama's promises. It's impossible to conclude that this deal ends their nuclear program. Even Obama's toadies don't claim that.
So you ask, "Does it slow it down?"
Even your own link contradicts your earlier statement that the agreement lives up to Obama's promises.
One thing the NPT recognizes is that the peaceful uses of nuclear technology cannot be limited: the science is no longer a secretand the technologycan be built from scratch. We need to be prepared for a world in which nuclear technology proliferates but nations sign on to shun the non-peaceful uses of the technology. We do better if our companies market nuclear technologies to countries like Iran and are hands-on in their programs.
Please remind us of his red lines and what promises he made.
1st,
So what?