By A Landslide, Political Insiders Say Carson Can't Win
“He will just keep talking and marginalize himself with his bizarre comments.”
In both parties, by landslide margins, insiders are convinced Ben Carson won't last. Many believe his lack of policy depth will doom him.
By Katie Glueck
11/06/15 05:10 AM EST
Politico Illustration—Getty
Ben Carson may be flying high in the polls for now, but he can't win the Republican nomination.
That's according to more than 80 percent of Republicans in this week's POLITICO Caucus, our survey of the top strategists, operatives and activists in Iowa, New Hampshire, South Carolina and Nevada.
“Smart guy - Yes; Nice guy — Yes; Ready for the presidency — Hell No!” offered one New Hampshire Republican, who like all participants was granted anonymity in order to speak freely, and responded via an online survey.
“Questions are going to get tougher and tougher which should hopefully expose his lack of depth,” predicted a South Carolina Republican.
“Honestly," said a Nevada GOP respondent, "I believe he will tire of the attention that the front-runner or one of the front-runners will garner, and will write a best-seller about the experience.”
Carson, nevertheless, won his biggest vote of confidence in Nevada, where one third of GOP participants said he had the staying power to win the Republican nomination. Otherwise, in Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina, less than a quarter said the same of the retired pediatric neurosurgeon, who has no previous political experience.
“He is most often described as a sweet, honest and genuine man, but he's naive and ignorant about major issues facing the country,” a South Carolina Republican said. “He says wacky things and makes too many unforced errors. He may win Iowa, but he won't be [able] to go the distance.”
Carson's worst prospects come in New Hampshire, where social conservatives tend to struggle — more than9-out-of-10 Republican participants there said he did not have the ability to go the distance.
“As the scrutiny of him becomes more intense, the vague and frankly disturbing lack of understanding he displays of significant policy issues will catch up with him,” a New Hampshire Republican said. “It is surprising that this late into a very intense nomination battle he remains seemingly detached from the reality of [issues].”
Added another New Hampshire Republican, “By all accounts Dr. Carson is a nice, likable, smart man who is wholly unqualified to be President of the United States. The brightest lights shine on the front runner which will show the fatal flaws of his candidacy - specifically his lack of policy depth and understanding of foreign affairs.”
Last month, Iowa Caucus insiders said Carson was building the strongest ground game in the state. But in this week’s survey, 84 percent of Iowa GOP respondents concluded that won't be enough to capture the nomination. Many questioned Carson’s readiness, noting that even if he makes it past Iowa, the lack of a knowledge base will catch up to him. The doctor has already stumbled over a number of policy questions ranging from Cuba to whether a Muslim should be president.
“He may have the staying power to win Iowa, perhaps even South Carolina, but it don't see him winning the nomination,” said one GOP insider from Iowa.
Agreed another, “He may make it through Iowa. Maybe New Hampshire. But will not be able to sustain multiple state contests on a single day, like Super Tuesday. He will crack under the intense pressure of long days, rapid fire primaries, and no policy statements to talk about. Personality only takes you so far.”
Insiders also raised questions about his campaign spending. Carson pulled in the biggest fundraising haul in the GOP field in the third quarter of the year, but spent a lot of money to get there, relying on pricey techniques like direct mail and telemarketing.
“He is spending too much to raise a dollar,” a Nevada Republican said. “That will catch up with him eventually. The cost of fundraising will be his biggest enemy in the end.”
Those who did see a path to the nomination for Carson pointed to his deeply committed supporters and to polls that show he is acceptable to a broader swath of the GOP base than other rivals.
“He can win a war of attrition. Carson's people are true believers. He is a truly different candidate who can hold his base. And he could grow it. Look at his net favorables. He's not objectionable the way Trump and Cruz are to many. He can be the last guy standing, ” said a South Carolina Republican.
Added a Nevada Republican, "There is no doubt that Dr. Carson has a devout following. His ability to connect with voters is something other candidates haven't been able to do and is invaluable in a caucus state.”
Among Democratic insiders, however, 94 percent predicted he would not not be the GOP nominee.
“Carson is a disaster waiting to explode. Even the smart social conservatives know it,” an Iowa Democrat said.
“He has a lot of support with the evangelicals, but many moderate and establishment Republicans think he has too many questionable views, policies and opinions," added a New Hampshire Democrat. "He also has not offered very many specifics relative to his economic plans.”
But given the political forces that have poweredDonald Trump's rise, several insiders said Carson, too, could beat the odds.
“This is the year that has confounded all the rules. A mild-mannered quirky neurosurgeon beloved by evangelicals just might make the cut,” a New Hampshire Democrat said. “He also has amassed a veritable fortune in campaign donations which could take him all the way to a brokered convention.”
More likely, suggested a neutral Nevada insider: “He will just keep talking and marginalize himself with his bizarre comments.”

“As the scrutiny of him becomes more intense, the vague and frankly disturbing lack of understanding he displays of significant policy issues will catch up with him,” a New Hampshire Republican said. “It is surprising that this late into a very intense nomination battle he remains seemingly detached from the reality of [issues].”
Added another New Hampshire Republican, “By all accounts Dr. Carson is a nice, likable, smart man who is wholly unqualified to be President of the United States. The brightest lights shine on the front runner which will show the fatal flaws of his candidacy - specifically his lack of policy depth and understanding of foreign affairs.”
Wow , insider leftists telling it like they want it to be ... What a sick joke .
@petey-coober :
Wow , insider leftists telling it like they want it to be ... What a sick joke .
Hey Petey here is another article from Raw Story maybe these guys can use. Just trying to be helpful, you know since the Politico proved to be incorrect. Hey Libs, maybe you can use this one. I'm sure there are more. I'll look at Salon, Slate and The Atlantic for you Libs.
You check out Daily Kos, Daily Beast and Common Dreams. We'll find something to get em with.
To start, here is the Raw Story article....
Ben Carson can’t handle basic journalism because he’s a basic clown
That's all we can do Petey. They need all the help they can get, you know.
I don't even think he's likeable. Who likes a lying braggadocio?
I don't like him...