╌>

Conservative media fail when they circle the wagons

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  11 years ago  •  6 comments

Conservative media fail when they circle the wagons

November 9

There are few things in conservative politics more unseemly than the circle-the-wagons mentality that washes over otherwise intellectually serious people as soon as one of the right’s standard-bearers is under siege from the mainstream media. On Sunday shows, conservative panelists rushed to defend Ben Carson, cheering his refusal to reply substantively to reports of inconsistencies in his biography. Few conservative voices raised the argument that Carson, running nearly entirely on his biography, had an obligation to answer all questions.

 

One exception to this distasteful trend, Joe Scarborough , took on Carson defenders in this exchange with Hugh Hewitt:

 


JOE SCARBOROUGH: In terms of Ben Carson. These stories do not add up. The conservative media knows they do not add up. How long do we sit back quietly and pretend that they do add up because we don’t want to offend our audience?

HUGH HEWITT: I don’t think that is what is going on here at all, we do not want to encourage the media to unify against Republicans and protect Democrats. We do not want to engage in the knifing of our candidates. . . . We do not want to be part of that gang.

JOE: My god, Hugh, my god. We have sat around this table … every day for six months digging in as deeply as we can into Hillary Clinton… Day in and day out.

MIKA [BRZEZINSKI]: More than anybody. . . .

JOE: What I’m saying is put it into perspective. If your only argument is that the media is covering Ben Carson for a day and a half but they haven’t covered Hillary Clinton’s problems long enough, that is not a very strong argument.

HEWITT: It is an incredibly strong argument with the Republican base.

MIKA: That doesn’t make it correct.

JOE: You’re just proving my point. If you are more interested in pleasing the Republican base, than winning the presidency, then keep that up.


 

And this gets to the fundamental problem: Why are conservative commentators, interviewers and reporters who claim to be unaligned with campaigns and legitimate debate moderators out to please the right-wing base rather than to inform the publi c?

 

There are a number of false assumptions that go into the embarrassing display we have seen in connection with Carson and so many others, and it is embarrassing given the desire of these voices to be treated as journalists, not activists, cheerleaders or participants in political events.

 

First, criticism and critique of the mainstream media, deserved and essential, does not negate the controversy at hand. It was no defense to Watergate to say the press and other liberal elites were out to get Richard Nixon. Revealing the motives or biases of the accused does not address the issues that are unearthed. It may be reason to evaluate the accusations more carefully, but not to exonerate the pol who is the subject of the inquiry.

 

The conservative under attack does not receive absolution by accusing the press of a double standard, by pointing to lapses in its coverage or by demanding the press address other concurrent controversies. As unfair as this may seem, the pol is seeking public office and therefore must assure voters he or she is worthy of office. The pol is not a media critic; he or she is an office-seeker. Moreover, as a practical matter, the aggrieved pol comes across as whiny and evasive.

 

Also, in many cases, conservatives’ perception that there was a lack of coverage and investigation of liberals is erroneous. They are actually frustrated with voters for not agreeing with the implications of the coverage. The mainstream media did cover the Rev. Jeremiah Wright’s relationship to then-Sen. Barack Obama; voters simply did not care.

 

Rather than encourage conservative candidates to stonewall, conservative media should urge disclosure. To begin with, this is a journalistic obligation — to insist on transparency and advocate for the public’s right to know, not for the campaign’s desire to avoid scrutiny in protest of the media’s motives. Moreover, as a practical advice, it is almost always counterproductive to stiff-arm the media; the feeding frenzy only intensifies.

 

If there is an imbalance in investigating liberals’ misdeeds and untruths, the conservative media should step up to do the job, not merely bemoan liberal outlets’ shortcomings. Publications like the Washington Free Beacon are doing just that.

 

In short, there are two unfortunate results of the woe-is-us reaction to the liberal media’s investigation of conservatives. First, it turns conservatives into whiners and victims, an unattractive face to display to voters. They don’t much care if the press is unfair; in most cases, they know it is. No one said life was fair or being a conservative in public life is easy. Second, it makes conservative media look foolish and unprofessional. One can critique the mainstream media or shame them into more coverage of liberals’ wrongdoings without sacrificing one’s obligation to vet candidates and educate voters.

Jennifer Rubin writes the Right Turn blog for The Post, offering reported opinion from a conservative perspective.

 

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/right-turn/wp/2015/11/09/conservative-media-fail-when-they-circle-the-wagons/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

First, criticism and critique of the mainstream media, deserved and essential, does not negate the controversy at hand. It was no defense to Watergate to say the press and other liberal elites were out to get Richard Nixon. Revealing the motives or biases of the accused does not address the issues that are unearthed. It may be reason to evaluate the accusations more carefully, but not to exonerate the pol who is the subject of the inquiry.

100% correct. Calling it a media smear does not negate the fact that he lied in the first place. It just makes him look whiny.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

In the "internet age" , there is no such thing as "media bias" , at least not a bias that is not countered by the other side. Right wing or conservative media is all over the place, from cable tv networks, to giant web sites , to twitter and other social media, to conservative newspaper conglomerates. No one sees or hears only one side unless they choose it to be that way.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Absolutely. Carson lied. Carson knows he lied. We know he lied. However he doesn't care because he knows that the right wing evangelicals don't believe that he lied and would support him even if they admitted that he lied because they want to believe and because they can scour the internet until they find people who will say anything that they want to hear that confirms what they have already decided to believe before even looking at if he did lie or not.

I saw a great documentary about professional pundits for hire who have lied about everything from smoking to fire-proofing to global climate change and they're all the same dozen or so people. They have been "experts" for hire on just about anything that a big company or industry want to be hidden, by using names like "Citizens for the Truth". The cigarette companies knew from the 1950's that smoking caused heart disease and cancer, so they hired "experts" from, basically non-existent think tanks, to go on TV and write columns in newspapers planting doubt. That's all it took for decades, was doubt planted by the cigarette companies, before the American public woke up. It worked because the smokers had people telling them what they wanted to hear and to hell with what the overwhelming science said and who were disguised from being seen as working for cigarette companies. As long as they could tell themselves that the science was still out on the issue, even though it wasn't, they could rationalize that next cigarette.

People who support Ben Carson are like the smokers who listened to the paid "experts" instead of the science, because the "experts" were saying what they wanted to hear, so they kept buying and dying. To them it doesn't matter that he thinks the Pyramids were used to hold grain or if he turned down a "scholarship" to West Point or that he (as a vegetarian) was caught up in a stick up at a Popeye's Chicken Restaurant or was given money for staying after class to take a test in a class that doesn't even exist, because he is saying what they want to hear and what they want to believe. He is the phony "expert" that they are going to listen to, no matter what. By attacking the press he is planting doubt and for most of his supporters that doubt is enough. Even when it's demonstrably lying.

 
 

Who is online






Sean Treacy


92 visitors