╌>

Fascism at Yale

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  10 comments

Fascism at Yale

Usually, we at Harvard are more than happy to see Yale students make fools of themselves on camera. The video that emerged this week of Yale students screaming down one of their professors might make for a good laugh, if its implications were not quite so serious. It’s a scene we’ve seen played out far too often at college campuses in recent years, and it deserves to be called by what it is: a nascent form of fascism.

In case you haven’t heard, Yale has recently endured a firestorm of protest after a lecturer that presides over one of the undergraduate colleges questioned whether concerns about the offensiveness of Halloween costumes had gone too far in impinging on free speech.

In response, hundreds of protesters gathered on the quad, calling for Nicholas and Erika Christakis to be removed from their roles. Nicholas voluntarily came to discuss the matter with them, and soon, a crowd of students enveloped him.

The video is chilling.

One student is heard saying, “Walk away. He doesn’t deserve to be listened to.” When Nicholas started to explain himself, a student yells, “Be quiet!” and then proceeds to lecture him. When Nicholas calmly and politely says “I disagree,” the protestor explodes, screaming, “Why the fuck did you accept the position?! Who the fuck hired you?! You should step down!” Then, finally, “You’re disgusting!”

The problem here isn’t that people disagree with what Nicholas said. The problem is that they are calling for reprisals against Nicholas and Erika simply for saying it. This recent movement of university students to use administrative procedures to punish speech with which they disagree should be called by its rightful name: proto-fascism.

Several days later, students disrupted an event held by the William F. Buckley, Jr. program that was designed to highlight the importance of free speech. According to reports by the Yale Daily News, several attendees were spat on as they left.

Once again, the problem isn’t that you disagree with what the event said (though, if you disagree with an event about the importance of free speech, that might be a cause for concern itself), but that you are using a tactic—spitting—that constitutes battery, and should never be used against someone for expressing beliefs that you disagree with.

I understand that it can sometimes be difficult for college students today to tell the difference between fascist methods and non-fascist methods of advancing their beliefs and agendas. Luckily, I spent my senior thesis studying the rise of fascism in Europe, and am happy to give a few, easy tips about whether the activity you are engaged in adopts fascist tactics or not. To make it even easier, I’ve put it in table form:

Tactic Fascist or Not Fascist? Explanation
Blocking people you disagree with on Facebook Not Fascist Maybe a bad idea, but you’re not actively transgressing on another person’s right to speech.
Calling for people to be fired for expressing their beliefs Fascist You are (1) calling for reprisals (2) for people expressing what they believe.
Organizing a protest against an editorial you disagree with Not Fascist You are condemning a belief you disagree with, but not trying to punish the speaker for saying it.
Calling to defund a newspaper for publishing an editorial you disagree with Fascist You are (1) calling for reprisals (2) for people expressing themselves.
Putting up fliers demeaning people that disagree with you Not Fascist Using an ad hominem attack is silly and hurtful, but does not use positions of authority to punish free speech.
Spitting on people attending a meeting you disagree with Fascist You are (1) committing a crime against someone (2) because they exercised their free speech.
Calling for a University to change its seal Not Fascist You are not punishing anyone for their beliefs. Not fascist in the slightest!
Tearing down fliers that you disagree with Fascist You are (1) committing a crime against someone’s property (2) because they exercised their free speech.
Condemning people for wearing offensive Halloween costumes on Facebook Not Fascist You are expressing indignation at someone else’s choices, but not calling for them to be punished because of their expression.
Calling for students to be expelled for wearing offensive Halloween costumes Fascist You are (1) calling for reprisals (2) for people expressing themselves (even if in a hurtful, offensive way).

Of course, this isn’t an exhaustive list, but it’s a good starting point. Ask yourself the question: Am I calling for people to be officially sanctioned because of what they believe, or am I committing a crime against someone because of what they believe? If the answer is yes, you are probably engaging in fascist tactics.

Given the public outcry, it seems that the majority of people, including the majority of progressive liberals, believe that Yale students calling for the resignation of those professors have gone too far in punishing free speech. The problem is that no one is willing to stand up to them. If we are going to begin anywhere, we are going to begin by calling them by their rightful name.

They are fascists.

They are fascists.

They are fascists.

Bill Barlow is a 3L at Harvard Law School.

http://hlrecord.org/2015/11/fascism-at-yale/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

As a matter of historical accuracy, you could replace the word “fascist” with “Communist,” or “Leninist,” or “Stalinist,” etc. and that chart would be just as accurate. Free speech has received many, many, mortal wounds from people proudly marching under those banners. Communists have a long and storied record of getting people fired — and killed! — because they dissented from the latest politically correct orthodoxy. I applaud Barlow’s recognition of the nature of these goons and buffoon s. But it’s worth recognizing that fascist behavior is not incongruous with radical left-wing behavior. Indeed, it is synonymous with it. And when you opt to call utterly typical left-wing behavior you don’t like “fascist” you are in a very real way absolving the left of crimes that stem wholly from its nature. By all means, call them fascists. But let’s not forget they are still left-wingers.

Read more at:

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

Sounds like a real barnburner of a thread Sean. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Granted it's not as timely or earth shattering  as whether Ben Carson found a $10 dollar bill 40 years ago, but we try and make do.  

I hear Ben Carson didn't replace a divot the first time he went golfing. Can you spam 50 articles on the subject please? 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

I waiting for the insider photos of how Ben arranges his underwear in his drawer. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

He's clearly not executive material. Socks go on the left side.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

I don't think too many people who read NT are concerned with obscure manifestations of political correctness at Yale, but we shall see. 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

This article should be required reading at all colleges & universities in the US . Maybe it will provide a much needed perspective in the liberal bastions of PC speech .

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

If someone, or a group , lobbied to have the Dallas Oregon city council discipline Mickey Garus, or if they started a petition for him to resign from the city council, would that constitute "political correctness" in your view ? 

 

Dallas, Oregon City Council member Micky Garus compared Muslims to Hitler and  called them “pure evil”  in a Facebook post.

Garus said the U.S. was “heading down an extremely dangerous path” because the Muslim population was growing rapidly. According to The Oregonian, Garus linked his post to a story by Glenn Beck’s The Blaze, which pointed out that three Muslim candidates had been elected in Michigan.

“Those who practice Islamic Faith, ‘Muslims’ pose a grave threat to our culture,” Garus wrote.

 

“Do you feel comfortable having this growing Muslim population in our country, knowing that their ultimate goal is too [sic] cleanse the earth of all nonbelievers?” the city councilor asked. “Are we okay allowing them to take over our local, state and eventually federal governments?”

“If I were talking about Hitler or the Nazi party, would you be offended?” he continued. “And just like the Jewish people, Austria, and much of Europe, whom believed there was no danger and did nothing to prevent Hitler, and the Nazi’s rise. I fear we will suffer a similar fate if not more barbaric.”

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

Well written. The Yale students act like animals. I doubt they will use their education for anything productive. 

 
 

Who is online



Sean Treacy


96 visitors