╌>

Should The United States (and the West) Try And Control Events And Trends In The Middle East ?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  4 comments

Should The United States (and the West) Try And Control Events And Trends In The Middle East ?

I read a couple interesting articles today. One was by Richard Cohen of the Washington Post, who suggests the Paris attack completely dooms (or should doom) the presidential campaigns of Carson, Trump, Fiorina and Sanders. 

 

It is impossible now, as the Paris attacks are still fresh, to imagine a Ben Carson in the White House. It is impossible to envision such a man, bereft of foreign policy experience, acting as commander in chief. It is just as impossible to think of Donald Trump in the Oval Office. It is horrifying to imagine him sitting there, thinking of the world as a board game — real estate, of course, maybe Monopoly — convinced that the world will conform to his grandiosity. It is also difficult to see Carly Fiorna there, another one who thinks that ambition is the functional equivalent of experience. Bernie Sanders, too, has had his day.

I think his reasoning is self-explanatory. 

The second article comes from The Guardian via Raw Story  and relates how the U.S. and the western governments, particularly the UK ,"incubated " ISIS in Syria . Some people describe this as the U.S. "created" ISIS, but I think this is an inaccurate way of saying it. ISIS created itself, but the Guardian article explains how the Western governments , the U.S. mainly, uses one side or force or sect or group against another in that region, trying to keep the chessboard pieces moving in a manner that maintains "control" of the area , presumably to foster the geo-political and economic interests of the West. It's not that "we" wanted ISIS to be successful, we wanted them to counterbalance the "other side" in the ideological and "hearts and minds" war that is ongoing between the different elements of Islam. There must have been the belief in the beginning that ISIS would be more temperate and not the brutalizing murderous monster it has become. It was a forlorn belief, as we see. 

Much of what we see in the media today, as every political faction in America now tries to spin these events toward a favorable view of their stance, is just mindless blabbering. None of these people , on the left or the right, KNOW what to do. They KNOW what their ideological beliefs inform them to know, which is incomplete at best. 

Why do we need to control the middle east ?   Because of the oil? Because of Israel ? Because of "freedom" ? 

Maybe these are good reasons, but then we have to accept that things will go wrong. And we will be at war. And in the 21st century this translates to terrorism and surprise attack civilian casualties. 

And it's not Obama's fault, and it wasn't Bush's fault, in a personal sense. US foreign policy is bi-partisan. See the Council on Foreign Relations. 

Council on Foreign Relations





The Council on Foreign Relations, founded in 1921, is a United States nonprofit, 4900 member organization, publisher, and think tank specializing in U.S. foreign policy and international affairs, headquartered in New York City, with an addi…
 





 

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"...terrorism is now squarely in the eye of the beholder. And nowhere is that more so than in the Middle East, where today’s terrorists are tomorrow’s fighters against tyranny – and allies are enemies – often at the bewildering whim of a western policymaker’s conference call.

For the past year, US, British and other western forces have been back in Iraq, supposedly in the cause of destroying the hyper-sectarian terror group Islamic State (formerly known as al-Qaida in Iraq). This was after Isis overran huge chunks of Iraqi and Syrian territory and proclaimed a self-styled Islamic caliphate.

The campaign isn’t going well. Last month, Isis rolled into the Iraqi city of Ramadi, while on the other side of the now nonexistent border its forces conquered the Syrian town of Palmyra. Al-Qaida’s official franchise, the Nusra Front, has also been making gains in Syria.

Some Iraqis complain that the US sat on its hands while all this was going on. The Americans insist they are trying to avoid civilian casualties, and claim significant successes. Privately, officials say they don’t want to be seen hammering Sunni strongholds in a sectarian war and risk upsetting their Sunni allies in the Gulf."

 
 
 
Bloody Bill
Freshman Silent
link   Bloody Bill    11 years ago

Every single time we have tried to control events and trends in the Middle East we have made things worse. Every time. No exceptions.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Bloody Bill   11 years ago

Eventually, the American people will have to think about this. Right now almost no one does. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Those who supported Ron Paul do. 

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot


83 visitors