╌>

What Kind of Bombing Campaign Against ISIS Do Republicans Want?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  19 comments

What Kind of Bombing Campaign Against ISIS Do Republicans Want?

What Kind of Bombing Campaign Against ISIS Do Republicans Want?


Posted:Mon, 16 Nov 2015 03:54:47 +0000

On Sunday night, France launched a series of airstrikes against ISIS in retaliation for the Paris attacks. The  Washington Post  called it a "furious assault." The  New York Times  called it "aggressive," CNN said it was a "major bombardment," and McClatchy called it a "fierce bombing campaign." The French themselves called it "massive," and the  LA Times , Fox News, and the  Guardian  agreed.

The French assault comprised 10 aircraft and 20 bombs.

Since the beginning of the American-led air campaign against ISIS, the coalition has launched 8,000 airstrikes and dropped about 28,000 bombs on ISIS sites in Iraq and Syria. In other words, we've been launching about 17 airstrikes and dropping 60 bombs per day. Every day. For over a year.

And yet this campaign is routinely described as feckless and weak.

We could certainly amp up the air campaign against ISIS, especially if we take Ted Cruz's advice and stop worrying about civilian casualties. But I guess I'd like to hear specifics. How many airstrikes do you think we need? We've done hundreds per day for short periods in other wars. Is that enough? Should we start ignoring Turkey and Iraq and our other allies and bomb wherever and whenever we want? Do you think that will be enough to put ISIS out of business?

Inquiring minds want to know. If President Obama's current campaign against ISIS is feeble and timid, what kind of campaign do you want? Can we hear some details, please?

 

http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2015/11/what-kind-bombing-campaign-against-isis-do-republicans-want



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Can anyone point out to me where our European allies or other allies have complained that the US military effort in the region is "weak " ?   The VICTIMS of the attack in Paris do not blame it on Obama or the weak US response to ISIS, do they ? 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Let's Take a Look at How Tough Republicans Would Be Against ISIS

Posted:Sun, 15 Nov 2015 19:10:17 +0000

Following the terrorist attacks in Paris, conservatives are eagerly taking the opportunity to accuse Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton of fecklessness and appeasement for not taking a harder line against ISIS. We need someone with the guts to lead, and who isn't afraid to use the term  radical Islam . Apparently that's important.

Maybe so. But ground troops are the only way to destroy ISIS in the short term, and the Republican presidential candidates have all been oddly reluctant to get behind a serious American invasion force. So before we allow them to get too  far up on their high horses about how tough they'd be, here's a reminder of what they were saying about ISIS  before two days ago.

Donald Trump  wants to take away oil fields controlled by ISIS, but has explicitly dodged the question of whether he would use a substantial ground force to do it. His preference is for an air campaign: "I would just bomb those suckers. That's right. I'd blow up the pipes. I'd blow up every single inch. There would be nothing left."

From Tuesday's debate: " If Putin wants to go and knock the hell out of ISIS, I am all for it, 100%. "

Jeb Bush  has previously ruled out a "major commitment" of ground troops. He would support a modest increase in "supportive" troops, and wants to unite the moderate anti-Assad forces in Syria. But he also thinks Trump is crazy.

From the debate: "Let ISIS take out Assad, and then Putin will take out ISIS?....That's not how the real world works. We have to lead, we have to be involved.  We should have a no fly zone in Syria. "

Carly Fiorina  has specifically said ground troops are unnecessary. Our allies should provide any troops necessary.

From the debate: "We must have a no fly zone in Syria.... We also have a set of allies in the Arab Middle East that know that ISIS is their fight ....King Abdullah of Jordan....The Egyptians, the Saudis, the Kuwaitis, the Bahrainis, the Emirati, the Kurds....They must see leadership support and resolve from the United States of America."

Marco Rubio  said last year the he would like to see a permanent US presence in the Middle East. "I'm not saying 100,000 troops, but certainly some level that allows us to project power quickly and confront challenges and threats." More recently, he's backed off that position: "ISIS is a radical Sunni Islamic group. They need to be defeated on the ground by a Sunni military force with air support from the United States." And this: "Intervening doesn't mean ground troops. Intervening can be a lot of things." His official position on his website specifically recommends air strikes, special ops, training, arms for Sunni and Kurdish forces, diplomacy, financial targeting, and better PR. It does not mention ground troops.

From the debate: "ISIS is now in Libya....Soon they will be in Turkey. They will try Jordan. They will try Saudi Arabia....They hate us because of our values. They hate us because our girls go to school. They hate us because women drive in the United States.  Either they win or we win, and we had better take this risk seriously,  it is not going away on its own."

Ben Carson  has suggested that ground troops "might" be necessary, but has declined to go any further.

From the debate: "We're talking about global jihadists....We have to destroy their caliphate. And you look for the easiest place to do that? It would be in Iraq. Outside of Anbar in Iraq, there's a big energy field. Take that from them. Take all of that land from them.  We could do that, I believe, fairly easily,  I've learned from talking to several generals, and then you move on from there."

Ted Cruz  has suggested that Kurdish pesh merga are all we need: "We need boots on the ground, but they don't necessarily need to be American boots. The Kurds are our boots on the ground." Cruz has generally dodged specific questions about sending in American troops, instead supporting an "overwhelming" American air campaign.

From the debate: Cruz declined to address ISIS during the debate.

And just for comparison, here is  Hillary Clinton  on her website:

ISIS and the foreign terrorist fighters it recruits pose a serious threat to America and our allies. We will confront and defeat them in a way that builds greater stability across the region,  without miring our troops in another misguided ground war. Hillary will empower our partners to defeat terrorism and the ideologies that drive it, including through our ongoing partnership to build Iraqi military and governing capacity, our commitment to Afghanistan’s democracy and security, and by supporting efforts to restore stability to Libya and Yemen.

So Hillary is a little bit more categorical about not using American ground troops, but basically she'd fit in just fine on the Republican stage. She supports an air campaign; she supports a no-fly zone in Syria; she supports arming the anti-Assad rebels; and she supports partnerships with our allies. If the Republican candidates are any tougher on ISIS than Hillary, they've been oddly timid about saying so.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Are you getting the picture?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

We should probably go with Trump's plan, since he just became our new president  (according to Ann Coulter.)

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

What a dumb question. How are civilians supposed to answer that question with specificity without access to classified intelligence? 

The only thing that matters is whether strategic goals are being achieved, and they obviously are not under the current leadership.  ISIS is expanding it's reach and is stronger than its ever been as its recent successes in France, Egypt and Lebanon demonstrate.

 

 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

A war cannot be won from the air. Germany couldn't do it with the blitz over England and we can't do it either. It takes ground troops and every military specialist has said so repeatedly from the very beginning. The French are bombing as a symbolic gesture the same as the Jordanians did in response to ISIS burning one of its pilots alive. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   11 years ago

People in the United States, and Europe for that matter, do not NEED to be afraid of ISIS. Even with this latest attack it is far more likely that one will be killed in an accident than one will be killed in a terrorist attack. 

We are in a "generational " war, mostly of ideology. There will be bad days for our side in that war. This is not the time for hysteria. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  1ofmany   11 years ago

It only took two bombs to beat Japan. 

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot


83 visitors