╌>

There can be no legitimate criticism of Bill O’Reilly

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  11 years ago  •  21 comments

There can be no legitimate criticism of Bill O’Reilly

By Erik Wemple

It’s hard to trash 19th Century historians and the National Park Service, but Bill O’Reilly found a way.

Back in 2011, O’Reilly and his publishing pal, Martin Dugard, released “Killing Lincoln,” a book that contained some embarrassing errors . Rae Emerson, deputy superintendent of Ford’s Theatre National Historic Site (a unit of the National Park Service), wrote a long memo exposing those errors, and recommending that the book not be stocked at the theatre’s basement museum bookstore. Historian Edward Steers Jr. sneered, “If the authors made mistakes in names, places, and events, what else did they get wrong? How can the reader rely on anything that appears in ‘Killing Lincoln’?”

So how did O’Reilly respond? The backlash, he told Politico at the time , was a “concerted effort by people who don’t like me to diminish the book.” And he said this on his show, “The O’Reilly Factor”: “We well understand our enemies are full of rage at our success.”

Earlier this year, O’Reilly used the same strategy. Following revelations that Brian Williams had inflated his reportorial resume, a similar set of allegations descended on O’Reilly, as Mother Jones (where the Erik Wemple Blog Wife is a staffer), CNN, Media Matters and other outlets documented tall tales from the Fox News host’s very own history. His accounts of exploits in Argentina, Florida and other locales just didn’t match up with the fossil record, all of which put O’Reilly in a bind.

How to respond? Attack motives, of course. The reporting, snapped Fox News, was “nothing more than an orchestrated campaign by far left advocates Mother Jones and Media Matters,” said the network in a statement echoing various comments from O’Reilly himself about the political motives of his critics.

That’s called a pattern. And the ongoing dispute over “Killing Reagan,” the latest O’Reilly-Dugard collaboration, suggests that when O’Reilly decides on a strategy, he sticks to it. After a group of Reagan scholars objected to a key storyline in “Killing Reagan” — the the 40th president suffered a drop in mental fitness early in his first term — O’Reilly ripped away:

“The assassination attempt injured him grievously he was 70 years old when [John] Hinckley shot him,” said O’Reilly, who argued that to the public, it appeared that Reagan recovered fast, but that wasn’t quite the case. “How he overcame his story is stunning and the mark of a great man. Some folks don’t want that story told and this time, it’s not the left attempting to deceive us. It was zealous supporters of Ronald Reagan.”

More recently, O’Reilly has battled Washington Post columnist George Will over the book, with Will protesting that O’Reilly didn’t have the memo on which the centerpiece of “Killing Reagan” rests; didn’t interview a bunch of Reagan staffers who are available for interviews; and otherwise missed the story. O’Reilly is standing behind every word.

Whatever the dynamics, O’Reilly charges that Will’s motives cannot be pure. “The smears come mainly from one place — the Washington Post editorial page. That’s it. And they have been unprecedented: Three vicious columns attacking the book. Three,” said O’Reilly. “When Martin Dugard and I asked to print a column in reply, the paper said no. That’s disgraceful. And here’s why this is all happening. We have learned the publisher of the Washington Post, a man named Fred Ryan, who apparently does not want the truth told about Ronald Reagan. Ryan wants only praise and get this: He is also the chairman of the Reagan Library Foundation. That has not been disclosed by the Washington Post. Uh-oh. So there’s a huge conflict of interest, and Post readers are unaware of it. Ryan has an agenda, and his subordinates are doing his bidding.”

Q.E.D.: There can be no legitimate criticism of Bill O’Reilly.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2015/11/17/there-can-be-no-legitimate-criticism-of-bill-oreilly/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

This is not a satire, but I am sure it was written with tongue firmly in cheek.

That said I actually agree with Bill O'Reilly. Ether from being shot or the early symptoms of Alzheimer's Disease, there is no doubt that President Regan in his second term was dull acting, detached and uninterested in national issues. Personally I think Nancy was the President in the 2nd term as dementia was already beginning to show itself in him during his second term.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

That said I actually agree with Bill O'Reilly.

(?!)

Most, if not all, of O'Reillys' books have been found to be less than accurate to a degree well beyond acceptable parameters. 

While it is possible that Reagan may have been suffering from early Alzheimer symptoms in his later years, it it reasonable to assume, based on everything else O'Reilly published, that his book on Reagan also contains inaccuracies and exaggerations.  

IMO, agreeing with Bill O'Reilly regarding almost anything is a risky proposition.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Randy

Interesting article - I have not read any of O'Reilly's books, but I did watch the show a couple of times a few years ago - stopped because the rant and holler approach to reporting does not appeal to me.

I found the title of your article most interesting

There can be no legitimate criticism of Bill O’Reilly

I think a very accurate and informative article could be written with a variation of that title

There can be no legitimate criticism of Barrack Obama

 

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

I used the title the author of the article used. I always do. I don't change or add or subtract from the tile selected by the original author.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

I used the title the author of the article used. I always do. I don't change or add or subtract from the tile selected by the original author.

Why? The goal is to attract readers to the article. While the authors original title usually reflects an accurate depiction of the articles' content, often times it does not. I have come across many articles with misleading or uninformative titles, causing me to modify the original title or sometimes substitute my own.

I use other slightly larger sites, such as Aol.com, as a model for this practice. However, it is critical that any title use by the seeder not be misleading in any way. The idea is to pique the interest of anyone perusing your site so they pause and read your title in the hope that they will click on it and go to the article, where of course they will see the authors original title with the rest of the article. 

For this particular article, the title "There Can Be No Legitimate Criticism Of Bill O’Reilly", is clearly totally inaccurate, and misleading. But as you said, "I used the title the author of the article used",  so in this case to change that title would only serve to defeat it's purpose of attracting readers to the article and discussion.

How do you think I got here? I can usually resist the, 'you better read this goddamn article'  look of your avatar, but in this case, my intense dislike for Bill O'Reilly got the better of me.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Old ''Batttlefield Bill'' certainly has delusions of grander. I suppose that they took affect when he was wounded in the Falklands War. Indeed sitting in a coffee shop in Buenos Aries he spilled a hot latte in his lap.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

Burned balls while near the Falklands War certainty should qualify him for a medal of some type. A reporters wounded in action commendation at the very least. He probably had one printed up for himself to hang in his office. ;-)

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

O'Reilly is probably the best example of "us against them" in the news business over the past couple decades. He is always right and his critics and those who disagree with him are always wrong. It is more or less the constant theme of his program. 

I listened to part of his book "Killing Kennedy" on audiobook. O'Reilly reads his books himself so it is kind of like listening to his show. Anyway, I thought the book was entertaining. O'Reilly goes into a great deal of detail and "mind reading" of his subjects in his books. He puts thoughts in the characters heads that are not in evidence. But just as entertainment, not history, it wasn't bad at all. 

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    11 years ago

consider the source

Historians Rip O'Reilly's New Patton Book

Several historians who have researched Patton's life told  Media Matters  no real evidence exists to support O'Reilly's claim.

"Premising an assassination plot on something so uncertain as a traffic accident doesn't seem plausible," said Jonathan W. Jordan ... "The rapid onset of Patton's death is not inconsistent with a pulmonary embolism ... There is no smoking gun pointing toward poison smuggled into his Heidelberg hospital room. Exhumation and testing of Patton's body, while it would put the matter to rest, most likely would be a biological Al Capone's Vault."

...

Rick Atkinson, a historian and author of  several books  about World War II, agreed saying Patton's death was from injuries suffered in "a fender bender, outside Heidelberg, in the fall of 1945."

Robert H. Patton, the general's grandson and author of  The Pattons: A Personal History of an American Family , said both research and family lore discredit O'Reilly's version of events.

"Generally growing up our sense was the general's widow was satisfied that it was accidental," he said. "She was persuaded that it was an accident."

Robert Patton said his grandfather suffered from Phlebitis due to a blood clot he developed from a fractured leg between World War I and World War II. He said after he was paralyzed in the auto accident it worsened and eventually led to his death.

"The theory is he either died naturally or from a blood clot," the younger Patton said. "You're paralyzed, and that is what happens. My grandmother was with him constantly in the hospital."

Carlo D'Este, author of  Patton: A Genius for War,  said there was no reason for an assassination since Patton was close to death.

"You've got to look at what Patton's situation was. He was a quadriplegic, he was going to die anyway, he was totally immobilized, he couldn't move," said D'Este .  "What is the point of assassinating him and where did Stalin come from anyway? There have been a lot of claims made over the years and here is a new one. Sure, somebody could have snuck in the hospital, but why would you bother? You need to verify facts. That certainly raises a red flag with me."

The only other sources I could find echoing Robert H. Patton's comments were mediaite, Oreillysucks, crooksandliars, and message boards copying those. But I suspect those are actual quotes.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Cletus Wilbury   11 years ago

He writes biographies that are, for the most part, pure fiction and he get's away with it. Or at least he thinks he does because he keeps having them ghost written for him and putting his name on them.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    11 years ago

Bill O'Reilly Takes Offense

Fox News's Bill O'Reilly lashes out at Stephen for praising his plan to win the war on terror with a mercenary army.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Cletus Wilbury   11 years ago

I wish I had taken the time to watch that before seeing my therapist this afternoon. I would have brought my laptop along and she would have loved it!Happy

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Bill is coming out with an new book entitled, ''The Pyramids and Grain, The Real Story''.....My understanding is that he claims King Tut was buried in a grain silo.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

I bow to you

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

I have to repeat myself :-).  Prepare to get up and dance.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  pat wilson   11 years ago

That was fantastic! I have never seen that before, but I sure saved it! Thanks!Happy

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Agreed

 
 

Who is online





Igknorantzruls


89 visitors