Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz are Cuban Americans, but most American Hispanics are Mexican. The two nationalities have had vastly different immigrant experiences.
Cuban immigrants account for less than 1% of the US population , but they are uniquely poised by our immigration system to receive power and status that, in just one generation, can produce a candidate – or two – ready to enter the political scene on a national level.That’s why, though most Hispanics lean Democrat , though they are the largest minority population in the US , and though Donald Trump’s entire presidential campaign should be a Hispanic recruitment coup for the Democratic party, it’s not actually surprising that the two Hispanic frontrunners in the presidential race, Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio, are both Republicans.
When pollsters say the vast majority of Hispanics lean Democrat, they’re speaking of Mexican Americans, who make up the largest group of Hispanics by a landslide. Nearly two-thirds of Hispanic Americans – 64% – are of Mexican descent. Sixty-five percent of those, or 22.3 million, are US-born. Hispanics of Mexican origin make up 11% of the US population. But Mexican and Cuban immigrants have had vastly different experiences immigrating to this country.
When Cubans are caught entering the United States without documentation, they’re granted refuge if they have at least one foot on US soil. Before 1980, when both Marco Rubio’s parents and Ted Cruz’s father arrived in this country, any Cuban could receive political refuge in the United States even if they were rescued at sea. A year after arriving, those Cuban immigrants could apply for permanent residency and eventually US citizenship. Think about that the next time you hear Ted Cruz’s father Rafael bragging about coming to the US legally .
Immigration policy is just the beginning of the Cuban immigrant’s advantage in the United States. During Fidel Castro’s Cuba, which lasted until 2008, US banks pioneered small business loans for Cuban exiles who had no credit or collateral in this country. With that startup capital, Cuban immigrants were uniquely set up by the American establishment to succeed financially. Their neighborhoods and communities were able to develop robust economic and political systems to support the success of newer Cuban immigrants. Their descendants had a fast track to join the American elite.
As a result, according to the Pew Research Center , compared with the rest of the Hispanic population in the United States, Cubans have a higher level of education, higher median household income and higher rate of home ownership.
Mexican Americans, on the other hand, inherit a legacy of discrimination that goes back to the founding of this country. The highly controversial Mexican American war , which secured Texas, California and the land in between for the US, is acknowledged by historians to be a land grab of dubious moral imperative. General Ulysses S Grant, who fought in it, said it was “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation. It was an instance of a republic following the bad example of European monarchies, in not considering justice in their desire to acquire additional territory.”
The legacy of over 150 years of Mexican Americans – and later, immigrants from throughout Latin America – being segregated into the poorest communities our country has to offer has resulted in Hispanic Americans’ devastatingly low educational attainment rate and high rates of poverty, unemployment, incarceration and poor health. These circumstances hardly provide a pool brimming with high-level political talent.
So Mexican Americans and other Hispanics are still not appearing in positions of national political power in proportion to their numbers – especially not within the Democratic party. In fact, a recent op-ed from NBC News points out that Bob Menendez is the only Latino Democrat in the US Senate, and he’s in danger of losing the job due to possible federal corruption charges. There are also only two Latino governors in the country, and they are both Republicans.
There are exceptions to these dire numbers. I know hundreds of them. Latinos who, despite growing up in less-than-ideal circumstances, managed through great parenting, the advantages won by civil rights activists of the baby boomer generation and some God-given brains, to rise to the top of their fields.
Joaquin is a US congressman, and Julián was the mayor of San Antonio and now serves as the US secretary of housing and urban development. Their mother, Rosie , is an activist who raised her sons on her own. She taught them to value community service and education, and they both graduated from Stanford University and Harvard Law.
They have been in the national spotlight since Barack Obama ran for re-election and I believe they are, wisely, waiting until they are a little older before one of them throws his hat in the ring for the White House – though there are rumors that Julián is on the shortlist to become Hillary Clinton’s running mate should she gain the Democratic nomination.
Texas Democratic party chairman Gilberto Hinojosa – the first Hispanic to hold the position – told me in a written statement that his organization believes many issues important to Latinos, such as increasing incomes, making debt-free college a reality, ensuring paid-family leave, improving healthcare and fixing a broken immigration system, have been well represented by the current list of Democratic presidential candidates, but his organization hopes that whoever wins the nomination will consider a Latino running mate. “Texas Democrats like Julián and Joaquin Castro have the values, government and leadership experience to be president,” Hinojosa said.
For today, Hispanics have a choice between voting for a party that openly hates them and one that takes them for granted, because who else are they going to vote for? How long can Democrats hold on to Hispanics with this tactic? If the Republicans keep recruiting conservative Cubans, sooner or later they will grab a larger share of the rest of the Hispanic vote, too.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/18/most-hispanics-vote-democrat-but-most-hispanic-politicians-are-republican-marco-rubio-ted-cruz?utm_source=esp&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=GU+Today+USA+-+Version+A&utm_term=138156&subid=14230036&CMP=ema_565a

I have a feeling that many supporters of Marco Rubio or Ted Cruz think that, because they are Hispanic, they will help the GOP get a large part of the Hispanic vote and help them win the White House. Both Rubio and Cruz will make the pitch that they'll bring in the Hispanic vote that the GOP can not win the White House without. They won't. If they want to attract a larger number of Hispanic votes, they need to nominate Jeb Bush because his wife was born in Mexico, his children are Mexican-American and they speak Spanish at home. Now granted Marco Rubio does speak Spanish, however he is Cuban-American and the largest majority of Hispanics in America are associated with Mexico and Central America. The bulk of Hispanics feel little or no connection at all with Cuban-Americans. If the GOP does nominate Jeb Bush they have a real chance of gaining many more Hispanic votes then if they nominate a Cuban Hispanic named Marco Rubio or a Cuban, Canadian Hispanic named Ted Cruz.
Unless of course Hillary Clinton picks Joaquin or Julian Castro as her VP running mate, in which case she will be the next President of the United States of America no matter who the GOP nominates to lose against her.
Since she doesn't need someone with Foreign Policy experience, since she has that covered herself, picking one of the Castro twins would be a brilliant move on her part. They both have huge futures in the Democratic Party. One of them will be America's first Hispanic President.
As more Mexicans climb the ladder of success doing the work liberals are too lazy to do they will turn away from the poverty creating Democrats. They have no desire to end up like the urban blacks. They see what happened to them when they traded their dignity for a foodstamp.
Can I have a hit of that? Come on man. Pass it over.
As more Mexicans climb the ladder of success doing the work liberals are too lazy to do
Picking grapes, tomatoes and lettuce? You think that they believe it's only liberal Americans who don't want to do those jobs? That is a completely irrational thought and comment. It makes no sense. It is not absurd, as much as it is disturbingly strange and strangely disturbing. You're not a liberal. So do you think that they think you are eager to get out in the hot sun and pick vegetables with them just because you're not a liberal and therefore they'll vote republican? Do you really have that low of an opinion of their intelligence? Your premise does not make any kind of rational sense. If only liberals don't want to do these jobs, then why are the fields not filled with young white conservatives?
I also think it's interesting that you managed to make racist stereotypical remarks about Black people in your comment. That they sold their dignity for food stamps. That's funny because my Psychiatrist in Los Angeles was definitely an urban Black man and I seriously doubt he collected food stamps or felt low in dignity.
The first time I moved to Los Angeles in 1990, even though I had been raised in a very small town my first job was at an Imperial Bank computer processing center at the corner of Western and Imperial in the heart of South Central. Many of my co-workers were Black and where we were located and they lived was definitely an urban area. Yet they all made a job living doing a god job and as far as I can tell from conversations, none of them were on Food Stamps or any kind of government assistance. In fact there are large sections of the greater Los Angeles area that are predominately Black and middle class. They work hard as cops, firefighters, various County or federal workers such as nurses, Social Security workers, VA hospital or services workers and medical workers and mail carriers and none of them seem to collect food stamps and they all seem to have retained their dignity.
The idea that urban Black Americans have somehow traded their dignity for anything, let alone food stamps (which more White people collect then Black, same with welfare) is a disgusting stereotype and incredibly racist. If you honestly believe it to be true then I actually feel sorry for you, because you have been lied to. You have been poorly educated about Races in America. Go to whoever taught you this lie and punch them as hard as you can, because they deserve it.
Randy,
I think that this article is a bit off base. In an NPR article:
Florida International University in Miami has been polling Cuban-Americans since 1991. Back then, 87 percent of Cuban-Americans supported the embargo, but after President Obama was elected in 2008, that shifted completely. For the first time in the poll's history, most Cuban-Americans said they disapproved of the U.S. embargo.
By 2011, that Obama effect had disappeared, Professor Guillermo J. Grenier, a co-principal investigator of the FIU Cuba Poll, told us. But in the 2014 poll, conducted this summer, a majority once again favored lifting the embargo.
Here's a few numbers from that poll :
— 68 percent of respondents favor restoring diplomatic relations with Cuba.
— Among younger respondents, 90 percent of respondents favor restoring diplomatic ties.
— When you include only registered voters, 51 percent of them support continuing the embargo.
— 69 percent of all respondents favor the lifting of travel restrictions impeding all Americans from traveling to Cuba.
— 53 percent of respondents said they would be likely to vote for a "candidate for political office who supported the re-establishment of diplomatic relations."
— A large majority — 71 percent — responded that the U.S. embargo of Cuba has not worked at all or has not worked very well.
I am glad that a majority of Cubans now support lifting the embargo (which I strongly support, along with normalizing relations with Cuba) and considering that it has been something that the President has been leading in it will probably turn more Cuban-Americans, especially the young ones born here in America toward the Democratic party.
In the Hispanic community Cubans are a very small minority and the majority of Hispanics in America don't relate to them at all and have nothing except language in common with them. Their immigration experiences are completely different considering a Cuban who managed to make it to the sand of Florida was practically guaranteed citizenship, plus low interest loans to help them get on their feet. That was not and is not the same experience as immigrants from Mexico and points South, which of course is much, much more difficult.
What I believe is that the GOP thinks all Hispanics are one big voting block and that if they present a Cuban-American for President, that they will automatically gain a large percentage of the Hispanic vote just because he speaks Spanish. That of course is not the way it works. Cuban-Americans are very very different then Hispanics from Mexico and Central America and the Hispanic from Mexico and Central America have traditionally voted Democrat, while the Cuban Americans have more traditionally voted Republican because of their hard core stance against Castro. As the older Cubans have died off it would seem that that is changing and changing in the favor of the Democrats.
Whoever wins the Presidency in 2016 can not do it without a majority of the Hispanic vote. It's simply not possible any longer. I believe the majority of the Hispanic vote is going to go for the Democrats and that bodes well from a President Hillary Clinton.