Ben Carson Writes Washington Post Op-Ed On How To Defeat ISIS
Ben Carson: My plan to defeat the Islamic State
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...483_story.html
excerpts
.....Make no mistake about it: We are at war. It is not a war against an opposing nation. The Islamic State is not a sovereign in the territorial sense but is a sick and twisted ideology that seeks to engulf the region and turn back the clock to the Dark Ages. We must ask ourselves, how do we defeat an evil state of consciousness? What are the best approaches?
The Obama administration has proposed a largely political, containment-based solution that is fraught with risks, including coordinating with the Russians and Iranians to win back Islamic State-controlled territory in Syria and Iraq. The problem with this strategy is that neither of these nations is a trustworthy ally; legitimizing them would lead only to further destabilization. Empowering Russia would only embolden Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad. Doing business with the Iranians encourages their ambitions to control the territory from Iran’s eastern border to the Mediterranean, threatening our allies in Israel and Saudi Arabia.
To lead this fight, the United States must dramatically increase its efforts to appeal directly to the moderate Kurds, Syrians and Iraqis. We must convince them that the Islamic State poses a fundamental threat to their existence. And we must equip them with the means to convey that message to their people. This will require a multi-pronged communications strategy that leverages our strengths in media production and messaging, combined with cutting off traditional access routes to social media for radical Islamist groups.
.....Now, more than ever, the United States must be willing to lead the free world. We need to restore America’s standing by winning over the hearts and minds of populations affected by radical Islamist violence. And to do that we need to create a winning strategy to dismantle and destroy the Islamic State while planting seeds for a more peaceful, healthy and cohesive society in the war-torn regions of the Middle East.

When you read this entire article, the first thing that will occur to a lot of people is that Carson probably didn't write it.
The second is that he sounds an awful lot like he is suggesting things that we are already largely doing. He doesn't even mention using US troops as a impactful ground force in an all out attack on ISIS. He is about changing hearts and minds.
This op-ed smells suspiciously like a desperate candidate trying to rehabilitate his image which has been tarnished by his flubs on foreign policy.
Just reading the excerpts posted caused me to think that I wonder who wrote it for him. I can't read the whole article because the link says it's no longer available, but I'm sure I can find it somewhere on the net.
Just reading the excerpts posted caused me to think that I wonder who wrote it for him. I can't read the whole article because the link says it's no longer available, but I'm sure I can find it somewhere on the net.
Thanks for the link and yes it's obvious it was written for him. Sen. Jeff Sessions speech writers sound about right for this one.
''To lead this fight, the United States must dramatically increase its efforts to appeal directly to the moderate Kurds, Syrians and Iraqis. We must convince them that the Islamic State poses a fundamental threat to their existence. And we must equip them with the means to convey that message to their people. This will require a multi-pronged communications strategy that leverages our strengths in media production and messaging, combined with cutting off traditional access routes to social media for radical Islamist groups.
What the hell is he talking about. ''appeal to the moderate Kurds'', who the hell does he think is doing all the fighting against ISIS..The Kurds are..They have suffered over 7,000 dead since they started fighting ISIS.
True of the Kurds, which is why it is so frustrating that they have not gotten anywhere near the help from us that they should. Why is that? If we had, this would already be over. Let me ask again. Why aren't we helping the Kurds? The hope here is that you will actually try to find the answer to this yourself instead of hearing it from someone else and dismissing it.
Here is a good article on why the Kurds haven't already won...I will let you find out why were not helping them yourself. HINT: It has to do with Politics which means it has something to do with BO. It is also pretty much the same reason the "sanctions" I suggested will not happen. In case you missed it let me ask again: Why aren't we telling everyone that buys oil from ISIS that if we catch them there will be serious repercussions?
I believe some of the other "players" don't like the Kurds, such as Iraq. There is no hope to find a political solution without Iraqi participation.
The United States has put itself in the position of having to placate groups and forces in that ISIS region that do not co-operate with one another, and even oppose one another. How can we create a coalition that includes both the Kurds and the Iraqis when the Kurds and Iraqis oppose one another ?
96, Turkey is the stumbling block. They are a NATO member and have a ongoing war with the PKK in Turkey. They have been dead set against any support for either the Peshmerga (Iraq) or the YPG/YPP in Syria. That is the main reason. They have started to soften up on their stance with the Peshmerga and YPG, but are attacking the PKK in Turkey..There you have it.
As for your link, it's over a year old and the battlefield has changed dramatically. The Peshmerga have retaken all of their territory in Iraq, and the YPG has taken back much of their territory in Syria. Just a couple of days ago the YPG retook the Yazadi town of Sinjar. The Kurds have been joined by Yazadi volunteers and Assyrian troops.
The U.S. recently supplied the Kurds with 500 TOW missiles and ammo. In addition to air strikes.
I know you would like to blame Obama for every perceived failure, but the reality of it is, that war has always been and always will be political.
Yes, I would like to see more support for the Kurds in Iraq, Syria and Turkey. But if we supported the Kurds in Turkey we would be declaring war with a NATO member.
I agree. Unfortunately without Turkey on board, it's very difficult to give the Kurds more weapons. Personally I'd say Fuck Turkey and do it anyway, but they are a NATO ally and we can't violate that. The Turks are more afraid of the Kurds then they are of ISIS. I think that when ISIS makes a move into Turkey, the may come around to a batter way of thinking.
It has become painfully obvious that Carson and many other candidates haven't got a frickin' clue about foreign relations policy. I'm not merely talking about disagreeing with ideology, I mean there is a total lack of understanding, let alone expertise.
Not surprising for a man who thinks the pyramids were grain silos. The Syrian civil war has exploded into a regional sectarian conflict between Shia and Sunni. Obama will not use US ground troops and, without ground troops, air power (no matter how many bombs you drop) is insufficient to win a war. So Obama relies on the Kurds as a ground force. What Obama doesn't emphasize is that he's also relying on Iranian forces, the old Shia death squads, and Hezbollah (all Shia). ISIL is primarily in control of Sunni areas (because many Sunni support them as their best hope against the Shia). Even if the Kurds and Shia can seize some of these areas from ISIL, they cannot govern it because the Sunni/non Kurdish population don't want them there. In fact, the presence of such forces will increase resentment among the Sunni and ISIL will slither back in.
The Sunni are essentially in revolt against Assad in Syria and against the Shia-dominated government in Iraq. Obama is stupidly on both sides of this struggle, supporting the Shia in Iraq and the Sunni in Syria. If Carson's answer is to ask the Sunni to see the world as we see it and join the Shia death squads to defeat ISIL, then he's a fool. ISIL is like a mad dog and, as long as the mad dog primarily bites the enemy (i.e Shia), I suspect the Sunni can live with that. At times, even the Saudis (Sunni) have said as much. The Sunni aren't going to embrace the Shia anytime within the next 5,000 years and hoping otherwise is a complete waste of time. Send in American ground forces and wipe ISIL out NOW!
To lead this fight, the United States must dramatically increase its efforts to appeal directly to the moderate Kurds, Syrians and Iraqis. We must convince them that the Islamic State poses a fundamental threat to their existence.
Is this man so stupid as to think that they don't already know that?
Is this man so stupid as to think that they don't already know that?
Stop picking on rainman.
LOL!
If you want a laugh at carson's expense.