╌>

Donald Trump claimed last week that "thousands of people" in New Jersey celebrated as the World Trade Center towers came down.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jwc2blue  •  11 years ago  •  32 comments

Donald Trump claimed last week that "thousands of people" in New Jersey celebrated as the World Trade Center towers came down.

Donald Trump claimed last week that "thousands of people" in New Jersey celebrated as the World Trade Center towers came down.











<span class='image-component__caption' itemprop= Presidential candidate Ben Carson said he saw newsreel footage of Muslims in the U.S. cheering on the Sept. 11 attacks, but later clarified that this was actually footage from the Middle East. " data-pin-no-hover="true"> Scott Olson/Getty Images Presidential candidate Ben Carson said he saw newsreel footage of Muslims in the U.S. cheering on the Sept. 11 attacks, but later clarified that this was actually footage from the Middle East. Share on Pinterest



 

 

Republican presidential hopeful Ben Carson joined GOP rival Donald Trump in claiming that he, too, saw news footage of Muslim-Americans cheering as the World Trade Center towers fell on Sept. 11, 2001 -- despite the fact that no such footage has turned up yet.

 

"I saw the film of it, yes," Carson told reporters at a Monday campaign event, adding that it was documented by "newsreels."

 

But later that day, he walked back his comments,  telling ABC News that he "was thinking of the Middle East, not New Jersey." 


 


 

Trump caused a stir last week after he said there were "thousands of people" cheering in New Jersey as the towers fell.

 

"It was on television. I saw it," Trump said . "There were people that were cheering on the other side of New Jersey, where you have large Arab populations."

 

The Washington Post's Fact Checker gave the claim its lowest score  on Sunday.

 

On Monday, Trump doubled down, linking to an article that described a "number of people" who were "allegedly" seen celebrating the attacks, and demanded an apology.






 

Even though he initially agreed with Trump, Carson warned against demonizing all Muslims in the U.S. when he first made his comments.

 

"I don't know that on the basis of that we can say all Muslims are bad people," he said on Monday. "I think that would be a stretch."



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

The party went on all night in Dearborn, Mi. 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago

""I don't know that on the basis of that we can say all Muslims are bad people," he said on Monday. "I think that would be a stretch."

A stretch?  I suppose then that it's just "a stretch" to say that any old medical practitioner can separate Siamese twins.  

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   11 years ago

@hal-a-lujah :

" "I don't know that on the basis of that we can say all Muslims are bad people," he said on Monday. "I think that would be a stretch."

A stretch?  I suppose then that it's just "a stretch" to say that any old medical practitioner can separate Siamese twins.  

Yes it would be a stretch to say any old medical practitioner can separate Siamese twins.  Like anything that is new it isn't always successful, but not all surgeons, like in anything else have the same desires or abilities.

 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago
You missed my point.  A stretch is something that lies just outside of the truth.  When thousands of out of a population of BILLIONS exhibit a certain trait, then it's a clearly more than a stretch to say they're all the same. That's a bald faced lie, and it's inexcuseable.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   11 years ago

@hal-a-lujah :
You missed my point.  A stretch is something that lies just outside of the truth.  When thousands of out of a population of BILLIONS exhibit a certain trait, then it's a clearly more than a stretch to say they're all the same. That's a bald faced lie, and it's inexcuseable.

No offense Hal, but let me give you some examples of bald faced lies.  Evidently you are having a problem distinguishing between bald face lies and stretches.

 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

Calling all Muslims terrorists is not a bald faced lie - got it.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   11 years ago

@hal-a-lujah :

Calling all Muslims terrorists is not a bald faced lie - got it.

Disillusions as well.  Who called all Muslims terrorists?

You know we've finally came up with a definition to explain most of the difficulties we have when Reverend Wright's daughter was sentenced to two years in prison for stealing thousands of dollars designated to help the poor and AIDS patients when psychologist William Hillman testified that he found Wright to have a personality disorder that "placed a firewall between her and reality."

I hope you learned something from the video and can now better distinguish the difference between a bald face lie and a stretch.   Carson could have said "really big stretch" or "more than a stretch" if you prefer, but other than that he didn't call all Muslims terrorists or bad people.

Facts are facts and bald faced lies are bald face lies, I already know the difference and I've provided educational material to try and help you understand it as well.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago
Lol, six - I'm going to go ahead and repeat Carson's quote for you, since it appears that you haven't bothered to read it word for word, and let it really sink in. "I don't know that on the basis of that we can say all Muslims are bad people," he said on Monday. "I think that would be a stretch." Carson "doesn't know" if we can say that all Muslims are bad (ie terrorists), but he thinks it would be just hyperbolic enough to not be a true statement. You want this idiot to be president? Btw, I'm not going to watch your link, because it has nothing to do with my comment. This (false) equivalency game you routinely play is a nothing but a distraction.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   11 years ago

@hal-a-lujah :

Lol - I'm going to go ahead and repeat Cardon's quote for you, since it appears that you haven't bothered to read it word for word, and let it really sink in.

" " "I don't know that on the basis of that we can say all Muslims are bad people," he said on Monday. "I think that would be a stretch."

Granted as you said that would be "more than a stretch".  That's true.  I agree with that, but you also said "That's a bald faced lie" and I just wondered if my video was any help to you in distinguishing the difference between a "bald faced lie" and leaving out the words "more than a" stretch"?

It has been nice chatting with you Hal.  Have a great day.  I've wasted too much time already and I have work to do, so I had better get on with it.  Starting later just means I get home later. Wink

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

The Washington Post's Fact Checker gave the claim its lowest score  on Sunday.

I don't believe Trump saw it.  He may have read about it and got it confused with the many of Muslims around the world celebrating.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

I wonder how many Americans cheered in front of their televisions during Shock and Awe.  

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   11 years ago

@hal-a-lujah :

I wonder how many Americans cheered in front of their televisions during Shock and Awe.

You mean Muslim Americans?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

Trump's claim defies common sense. The FBI didn't connect the attack to al-Qaeda until two weeks after the attack and al-Qaeda didn't claim responsibility until sometime thereafter. So the Muslim population of New Jersey didn't know the attack had anything to do with Islamic terrorism as the towers were falling down and had nothing to celebrate (even if they were inclined to do so). However, there was a claim that 5 Israelis (some of whom were allegedly Mossad agents) were seen dancing in the street after the attack (google dancing Israelis for more information).

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  1ofmany   11 years ago

@1ofmany :

Trump's claim defies common sense. The FBI didn't connect the attack to al-Qaeda until two weeks after the attack and al-Qaeda didn't claim responsibility until sometime thereafter. So the Muslim population of New Jersey didn't know the attack had anything to do with Islamic terrorism as the towers were falling down and had nothing to celebrate (even if they were inclined to do so). However, there was a claim that 5 Israelis (some of whom were allegedly Mossad agents) were seen dancing in the street after the attack (google dancing Israelis for more information).

You say two weeks?  The Washington Post Article was dated September 18, 2001.  Are you trying to say the Muslims celebrating this terrible event must have already known it was done by Muslims or just didn't like this place they were stuck in and were happy to see all those American buildings coming down.  It wouldn't be a stretch to think there are more just like them in this country, would it?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

You say two weeks?  The Washington Post Article was dated September 18, 2001.  Are you trying to say the Muslims celebrating this terrible event must have already known it was done by Muslims or just didn't like this place they were stuck in and were happy to see all those American buildings coming down.  It wouldn't be a stretch to think there are more just like them in this country, would it?

According to Fact Checker, the September 18th article only stated that "a number of people" were "allegedly" seen celebrating. Fact Checker dismissed this as simply an allegation that was never substantiated. Even if it happened, there is no evidence that it was connected to Muslims. If there were any people celebrating, perhaps it's the same type of loons who had picnics at hangings. So I explain it the same way the Post did: there's no evidence that it ever happened.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  1ofmany   11 years ago

  the September 18th article only stated that "a number of people" were "allegedly" seen celebrating

 there's no evidence that it ever happened

The Washington Post's own reporter  got the story from the Jersey City Police Department and " confirmed the JCPD's information via interviews of eyewitnesses of the celebration ".

That's the very definition of evidence.  To claim it doesn't exist is dishonest. 

T he FBI didn't connect the attack to al-Qaeda until two weeks after the attack and al-Qaeda didn't claim responsibility until sometime thereafter

Following Khobar Twoers, the USS Cole, etc.. it didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that it was Islamic Terrorism from the get go. Moreover, news reports quoting government sources were blaming Al-Queda on that day.   The idea that no one knew it was Islamic terrorism for weeks is simply absurd. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

@sean-treacy :


Do you believe the Washington Post from 2001, or the Huffington Post from 2015 about things that happened in 2001?

Everything you have put up in that comment is correct Sean.  Kind of like the same mentality of the Sharia Law when a woman gets raped she has to have thousands of me to stand up for her in order to get the rapist charged and her not stoned. LOL

Check this out.

I live in Jersey and Trump is right: Muslims DID celebrate on 9/11 in NJ . . . we saw it!

and this....

Muslims Celebrated The Sep 11 Attacks

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

The Washington Post's own reporter  got the story from the Jersey City Police Department and " confirmed the JCPD's information via interviews of eyewitnesses of the celebration ".

That's the very definition of evidence.  To claim it doesn't exist is dishonest. 

It's an allegation. Allegations may be true or false and I haven't seen anything to show that anyone determined the allegations were true.

Following Khobar Twoers, the USS Cole, etc.. it didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that it was Islamic Terrorism from the get go. Moreover, news reports quoting government sources were blaming Al-Queda on that day.  The idea that no one knew it was Islamic terrorism for weeks is simply absurd. 

You're confusing speculation with knowledge. But the focus here is Trump's claim that thousands of people were in the streets of New Jersey, that they were Muslims, and that they were celebrating the destruction of the towers. Every part of this statement is completely and utterly unfounded.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

@1ofmany :

According to Fact Checker, the September 18th article only stated that "a number of people" were "allegedly" seen celebrating. Fact Checker dismissed this as simply an allegation that was never substantiated. Even if it happened, there is no evidence that it was connected to Muslims. If there were any people celebrating, perhaps it's the same type of loons who had picnics at hangings. So I explain it the same way the Post did: there's no evidence that it ever happened.

What fact checker Iofmany?  It was the Post who did the fact checking, my friend.  They didn't even check their own newspaper that had the article in it.  Maybe you haven't read the article I put up from the Washington Post?  The guy who dismissed it is the same one who criticized Trump, but The Washington Post's article dated September 18, 2001 did not dismiss it as this is the only thing the Washington Post had in it about the incident in its newspaper dated September 18, 2001 below.  Nowhere did they dismiss anything.  If you read the entire Washington Post article I've put up for you here, I think you will accept it was a real possibility to be true that there were people in a Muslim community in New Jersey doing exactly what was printed in the newspaper, not thousands as Trump has said.

From the Washington Post dated September 18, 2001

"In Jersey City, within hours of two jetliners' plowing into the World Trade Center, law enforcement authorities detained and questioned a number of people who were allegedly seen celebrating the attacks and holding tailgate-style parties on rooftops while they watched the devastation on the other side of the river."

There are many things in that article including this which is quite telling as well.

From the Washington Post dated September 18, 2001.

Investigators also detained three men in Elizabeth, N.J., who were carrying a large amount of cash and a one-way ticket to Syria. The three men, Ahmad Kilfat, 45, Mohammad Mahmoud Al Raqqad, 37, and Nicholas Makrakis, 27, were in a red Pontiac that matched an FBI description of a vehicle connected with the attacks.

Anyway, I hope this helps. Thanks - six

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

What fact checker Iofmany?  It was the Post who did the fact checking, my friend.  They didn't even check their own newspaper that had the article in it.  Maybe you haven't read the article I put up from the Washington Post?  The guy who dismissed it is the same one who criticized Trump, but The Washington Post's article dated September 18, 2001 did not dismiss it as this is the only thing the Washington Post had in it about the incident in its newspaper dated September 18, 2001 below.  Nowhere did they dismiss anything.  If you read the entire Washington Post article I've put up for you here, I think you will accept it was a real possibility to be true that there were people in a Muslim community in New Jersey doing exactly what was printed in the newspaper, not thousands as Trump has said.

I suppose it's possible, in the sense that elves may exist because people claim to see them, but there is no proof of it. Saying that there is no proof of it, as the Fact Checker states, is to dismiss it. A police report detailing what the police went to investigate does not make the allegation in the report true and I haven't seen anything from the police stating that they thought anything actually occurred.

There are many things in that article including this which is quite telling as well. From the Washington Post dated September 18, 2001.

Investigators also detained three men in Elizabeth, N.J., who were carrying a large amount of cash and a one-way ticket to Syria. The three men, Ahmad Kilfat, 45, Mohammad Mahmoud Al Raqqad, 37, and Nicholas Makrakis, 27, were in a red Pontiac that matched an FBI description of a vehicle connected with the attacks.

The fact that the police detained three men who may have been involved in the attack does not, to me, make it more or less likely that Trump's statement is true . . . especially, since I see no automatic connection between terrorists and Muslims such that Muslims must know what terrorists are doing.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Do you believe the Washington Post from 2001, or the Huffington Post from 2015 about things that happened in 2001? 

 

Trump says that he saw this with his own eyes on television and that it was well covered. But an extensive examination of news clips from that period turns up nothing. There were some reports of celebrations overseas, in Muslim countries, but  nothing that we can find involving the Arab populations of New Jersey .

Kessler has spent the day re-writing and re-re-writing that confident assertion. As of now, that last sentence currently reads:

There were some reports of celebrations overseas, in Muslim countries, but nothing that we can find involving the Arab populations of New Jersey  except for unconfirmed reports .

When Kessler says "nothing that we can find", he didn't have to search very hard. After a two-minute Google search, Powerline's John Hinderaker turned up  the following :

In Jersey City, within hours of two jetliners' plowing into the World Trade Center, law enforcement authorities detained and questioned a number of people who were allegedly seen celebrating the attacks and holding tailgate-style parties on rooftops while they watched the devastation on the other side of the river.

What demented fringe conspiracist website would traffic in such nonsense? Well, in fact, it was Glenn Kessler's own newspaper,  The Washington Post , which published the story on September 18th 2001. Is it an "unconfirmed report"? Well, Kessler's colleague,  Post  reporter Serge Kolvaleski, said in a 2003 email that he got the story from the Jersey City Police Department and " confirmed the JCPD's information via interviews of eyewitnesses of the celebration ".

Was Kessler aware, while researching his "fact-check, that a  Washington Post  reporter had interviewed "eyewitnesses of the celebration"? As it is, a so-called "fact-checker" who claims "an extensive examination" turns up "nothing that we can find involving the Arab populations of New Jersey" was apparently ignorant of the fact that his own newspaper had carried such a story.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

What is the purpose of mentioning that an unknown number of Muslims (Trump said "thousands and thousands", making me think he has little idea what a thousand people on the street looks like) , danced on New Jersey rooftops ?, other than to insinuate that all Muslims are potential terrorists. THAT is what Trump meant to say, and did in that sense did say. 

 
 

Who is online







113 visitors