╌>

Chicago's Top Cop Fired By Mayor Emmanuel

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  11 years ago  •  1 comments

Chicago's Top Cop Fired By Mayor Emmanuel

http://chicago.suntimes.com/news/7/71/1143320/sneed-exclusive-mccarthy-fired

 

Chicago Police Supt. Garry McCarthy has been fired by Mayor Rahm Emanuel, the mayor confirmed Tuesday.

McCarthy was called into City Hall on Monday and when he left City Hall he still had a job. But overnight, the mayor called McCarthy to tell him he was out, the Sun-Times’ Michael Sneed first reported.

Headlines from the Laquan McDonald controversy, as well those following the gang execution of Tyshawn Lee, had become too much, according to sources.


McCarthy appeared “shell-shocked” by the news, sources said.

At a morning news conference originally called to announce the appointment of a task force on police accountability, Emanuel said he and McCarthy had started “a conversation” about the direction of the department on Sunday, and by Tuesday, he was asking for McCarthy’s resignation.

Though McCarthy’s record “is a strong one, and one he can be proud of,” Emanuel said, “now is a time for fresh eyes and new leadership.”

Trust in the Chicago Police Department “has been shaken and eroded,” Emanuel said.

“Our goal is to build the trust and confidence with the public. And at this point and at this juncture in the city, given what we are working on, he has become an issue rather than dealing with the issues,” Emanuel added.

In short, he had become “a distraction,” according to the mayor, and “no one person trumps my commitment to the city of Chicago and its future.”

Emanuel appointed First Deputy Supt. John Escalante to serve as acting superintendent.

At the news conference, Emanuel also fielded questions about the questions swirling around how the city handled the fatal shooting of McDonald by Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke.

Emanuel noted that the city’s handling of the case is being investigated by the U.S. Attorney’s office, and he told the reporters that he hopes they will “await the results of that” review.

McCarthy, however, will not be around when those results come in. Tuesday, he was reminded that Chicago Police superintendents are like baseball managers and football coaches. They’re hired to be fired. Failure and crises are literally built into the job. When it comes, a head needs to roll. The sacrificial lamb inevitably is the man on top — even though he’s not responsible for the number of wins and losses.

McCarthy is no different. He’s a fighter who firmly believed he had earned to right to decide when the timing was right to retire from the pressure-cooker job after surviving a serious heart attack more than a year ago.

Emanuel didn’t give him that chance. Although Emanuel is fiercely loyal to his staff and hates the idea of creating political scapegoats, of serving up heads on platters, the pressure to get rid of McCarthy was coming from all sides. Ultimately, it became too intense for Emanuel to resist.

The final straw appeared to be  a front-page editorial in Tuesday’s Chicago Sun-Times . That followed the Washington Post and nearly every black elected official in the Chicago area.

McCarthy is a former operations chief at the New York Police Department who went on to run the police department in Newark, N.J.

He was hired by Emanuel shortly before the 2011 inauguration after the mayor’s first choice, former Chicago Deputy Superintendent Charles Ramsey, demanded a salary in excess of $400,000.

With his big ego, brash persona and fast-talking, outspoken style, McCarthy was a police chief out of central casting long before there was a locally-filmed television series called “Chicago P.D.”

During the 2012 NATO summit, McCarthy was hailed as a hero for leading his troops from the front and diffusing a potentially volatile confrontation with Black Bloc provocateurs at Cermak and Michigan. A grateful City Council passed a resolution praising his performance and jokingly calling him Chicago’s very own General Douglas McArthur.

Some wondered whether the mayor who is used to being the center of attention was privately seething about all of the attention directed at McCarthy when it was Emanuel whose political neck was on the line.

As recently as late October, McCarthy was sounding very secure in his job when he spoke at a gathering of the International Association of Chiefs of Police:

“Welcome to Chicago, to my adopted home that I’m never leaving,” McCarthy said then. “Thank you, mayor, for bringing me here. I know, I’m never leaving. Sorry.”

But the worm started to turn for McCarthy after his police strategies failed to reduce a surge in police shootings.

In October, the City Council’s Black Caucus demanded McCarthy’s resignation after another weekend bloodbath and after McCarthy replaced his retiring black first deputy Al Wysinger with John Escalante, who is Hispanic.

They renewed that call after the city released the incendiary video of white Police Officer Jason Van Dyke unloading 16 rounds into the body of black teenager Laquan McDonald. But this time, they were joined by nearly every black elected official in the state.

The Chicago Sun-Times may have put the final nail in McCarthy’s coffin with a front-page editorial demanding the superintendent’s ouster. The Washington Post, which helps determines a national image that Emanuel covets, had previously done the same.

The McDonald case and the surge in police shootings wasn’t the only credibility problem for McCarthy.
Last week, McCarthy dismissed as “nonsense” speculation that he was pressured into firing Detective Dante Servin for the 2012 shooting of 22-year-old Rekia Boyd to tamp down the political furor tied to the release of an incendiary video of the police shooting of Laquan McDonald.

“Nonsense. Nonsense. . . . If you’ve been at the Police Board meetings, what I’ve been hearing is a demand to make the decision. Here’s a case where we’re doing what the community wants. I’m making the decision. And somebody is going to criticize it saying it’s political? Come on. It’s ridiculous,” McCarthy told reporters after a police graduation ceremony at Navy Pier.

“Dante Servin made some incredibly poor decision making which ultimately resulted in a loss of life unnecessarily. He made a decision to get involved in something he shouldn’t have. He had a firearm he was not authorized to carry . . . When we make poor decisions, we have to be held accountable for it. That’s what this is all about. It’s about poor decision-making and the results obviously are tragic.”

One week after Servin was acquitted on involuntary manslaughter charges, McCarthy said the veteran detective should never have been indicted because he “hit the individual who he was aiming at” and “also happened to hit” Boyd.

The superintendent made those remarks on the day that riots broke out on the streets of Baltimore. The chairman of the City Council’s Black Caucus condemned the comments as insensitive. Mayor Rahm Emanuel was not happy at the time either.

At a time when police officers across the nation are under a microscope for allegedly disparate treatment of African-Americans, McCarthy also said at the time he was concerned at the time about the impact the case would have on the split-second decision-making by rank-and-file officers.

“When an officer gets themselves in a position where they have a fear that deadly physical force is to be used against them, that officer can’t hesitate. It provides a safety hazard for the officer,” the superintendent said.

“How is this going to affect policing in general and the Chicago Police Department? Because every single officer who’s out there now might be in a position where they hesitate and, as a result, they could lose their lives.”

How did McCarthy reconcile those remarks with his decision to fire Servin just as Chicago was bracing for the political fallout from the court-ordered release of the incendiary video of Police Officer Jason Van Dyke firing 16 shots into the body of 17-year-old Laquan McDonald.

“That’s honestly a silly question because you were talking about criminal charges [in April]. Administratively, decision making is something he needs to be held accountable for. There’s a big difference between criminal charges and administrative reconciliation of department rules. That’s the simple answer,” McCarthy said.

The superintendent didn’t flinch when asked how the timing could not be viewed as politically-motivated. McCarthy waited until the McDonald shooting video was about to be released before acting on a Servin case that has been on his desk for two months.

“This is something that the community has been demanding and now, when I do it, you want to say it’s done for a different reason? This is the process. This is the contractual obligation. We have to follow that process. Period,” he said.

Ald. Roderick Sawyer (6th), chairman of the City Council’s Black Caucus, said he didn’t buy McCarthy’s claim that politics played no role in the timing of Servin’s firing.

“Whoever twisted that arm, thank you. I only know one person who can twist an arm like that in Chicago,” Sawyer said, in an obvious reference to Emanuel.

“I’m glad McCarthy changed his tune. But I’m disappointed in the statement he made previously and why it took him so long to come around.”



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Police chiefs are something like sports coaches. You can't fire the players so you fire the coach, and you can't fire thousands of cops so you fire the chief (in Chicago the police chief is called "superintendent".)

 

McCarthy was brought in from New York, I guess hoping for a lower murder rate like they got there, but NY never had a gang problem as entrenched as Chicago's, at least not in recent decades. 

 
 

Who is online





113 visitors