╌>

States With Fewest Gun Controls Tend to Have Lowest Homicide Rates

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  18 comments

States With Fewest Gun Controls Tend to Have Lowest Homicide Rates
In response to the mass murders recently committed in San Bernardino, liberal reporters and bloggers jumped to conclusions about who was responsible and how to prevent such acts in the future. They turned out to be wrong.

The killers, Syed Farook and Tashfeen Malik, were supporters of ISIS, who had contact with overseas terror organizations. This devoutly Muslim couple were nothing like the angry white male loners from Christian backgrounds earlier suspected to be the shooters by liberal bloggers and journalists, who have long falsely claimed that mass shootings are committed by white men or caused by “white privilege.” The New York Daily News insinuated this by making the strange claim that “skinheads and neo-Nazis have shown pronounced influence in the area east of Los Angeles” in the region where the shootings took place.

Earlier, the bigoted Delaware Liberal blog advocated racial “profiling” of white males to prevent mass shootings, and said that “we don’t need to stop everybody from buying guns. Just preventing white males (between the age of 15 and 30 who talk about guns a lot) would work.” Similarly, Talking Points Memo’s Josh Marshall suggested “the possible use of profiling to limit access to fire arms … 1. Are you a man? 2. Are you white?”

Similarly, federal tax dollars subsidized left-wing “consultants” who published a race-baiting op-ed in the Washington Post falsely claiming that white men commit virtually all mass shootings, and that we need to collectively “hold them accountable” for a culture that spawns such killings. The website of consultants Charlotte and Harriet Childress boasts that they have “received close to a million dollars in grants from the National Science Foundation.” As the Wall Street Journal’s James Taranto notes, “The NSF is a federal agency, so your tax dollars have subsidized the authors of what can only be described as a racist rant.” He lists a number of well-known cases in which mass murders were committed by non-whites — including Korean immigrant Cho Seung-Hui (32 dead, 17 wounded at Virginia Tech in 2007) and Laotian immigrant Chai Soua Vang (6 dead, 2 wounded at Meteor, Wisc., in 2004) — cases that the Childresses ignored, even though they would be obvious to any competent researcher writing about this issue. The Childresses ignored even high-profile mass murders committed by non-whites that occurred in the Washington Post‘s own backyard, like the Beltway Sniper killings. Murderers in general are not disproportionately white: slightly less than half of all murders are committed by whites, even though they are a substantial majority of the overall population. By contrast, blacks, who are only 13% of the U.S. population, commit nearly half of America’s murders.

Yet, when GOP candidates offered “thoughts and prayers” for the victims, rather than rushing to endorse gun-control bills proposed by Congressional Democrats before having the facts about the shootings, they were immediately denounced by Democrats for doing so (even though those bills would not have prohibited these killers from obtaining a gun, as Reason’s Jacob Sullum notes in “How Background Checks and an ‘Assault Weapon’ Ban Failed in San Bernardino: Two of President Obama’s favorite gun control solutions did not prevent this week’s massacre.”)

As the Washington Post noted:

“Sen. Chris Murphy (D) of Connecticut … was particularly outspoken in his criticism of [Republican] politicians who offered prayers for the victims in San Bernardino … . The effort to cast ‘thoughts and prayers’ as trite reactions to horrendous events certainly represents a ratcheting up of the rhetoric.”
Even had this been an attack by a lone wacko, there’s no evidence that gun control would have prevented it. As lawyer David Kopel notes, the U.S. is not the only industrialized country with mass shootings. In the last few years, Germany has had several mass murders, including five murdered in Dilligen, 13 in Albertville, and 17 in Erfurt. So have Switzerland (14 in Zug); France (14 in Luxiol); Britain (12 in Cumbria in 2010); Spain (9 in Puerto Hurraco); and Norway (77 in 2011). Even countries that adopted stricter gun control laws, such as Australia, often only changed the weapon.

Since the 1996 national gun confiscation that President Obama has praised, Australia has had several mass murders by arson (the Childers Palace Fire killed 15 in 2000; the Churchill Fire in 2009 killed ten; and the Quaker Hill Nursing Home Fire in 2011 killed 21), and still some gun mass killings (the Hectorville shooting rampage killed three).

On December 1 in Paris, “President Obama said at a news conference, ‘I mean, I say this every time we’ve got one of these mass shootings; this just doesn’t happen in other countries.’” Is his statement true?

No. Not in the very country he was visiting at the time, France, where over 120 were recently killed by terrorists (the very reason he went there), despite strict gun controls. Similarly, on Nov. 20, 2015, mass shooters attacked a hotel in Mali, murdering at least 19 people. Although President Obama has relatives in Kenya, his statement suggests a lack of awareness of events there as well. On April 2, 2015, criminals murdered 142 students at the University College Campus of Garissa, in northeastern Kenya. Among the other mass shootings in Kenya in recent years are those as Lamu (29 murdered, July 5-6, 2014), Mpeketoni (53 murdered, June 15-17, 2014), Majembeni and Poromoko (15 murdered, two days after Mpekoni) and the Westgate Mall in Nairobi (67 murdered, Sept. 21, 2013). Kenya has extremely strict laws against the possession or carrying of firearms, as well as bows, as detailed in a Quinnipiac Law Review article.

For good or ill, gun control is a very small, perhaps insignificant part, of a general anti-crime strategy. Maryland and Washington, D.C. have much higher crime rates and higher homicide rates than neighboring Virginia, and they have much more gun control. One reason is that they have a worse criminal justice system that is softer on violent criminals. Gun control is so insignificant to overall anti-crime strategies that when politicians talk about it, I tend to view it as a diversion or deflection.

In fact, states with the least gun laws and fewest gun controls tend to have lower homicide rates and lower crime rates than the average state. Law Professor Eugene Volokh, writing at the Washington Post, notes that “states with more gun restrictions on average have very slightly higher homicide rates, though the tendency is so small as to be essentially zero.” But this actually understates the case against gun control, because, as I have explained earlier, this relies on data cherry-picked by gun control advocates, who excluded some safe, pro-gun-rights states from their data set. There is reason to believe that some gun control measures, such as restrictions on concealed carrying of firearms by law-abiding people, actually increase crime and homicide rates. http://www.cnsnews.com/commentary/hans-bader/progressives-jump-false-conclusions-after-san-bernardino-killings-will-gun

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

Gun control has never been about crime control.  It's all about control.  A government controlling its subjects.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Most murders are not "random", in that an individual known to the killer is the target. You do have "innocent bystanders" occasionally killed in a gang shootout. 

The comparison that evokes thoughts of "gun control" is the comparison between islamic terrorism and domestic terrorism , or between islamic terrorism and random madman shooting such as when someone shoots up a movie theater in order to kill as many people as possible because he hears voices and so forth. 

That strikes me as a fair comparison. IMO, there is no more chance that I will be killed in the grocery store by islamic gunmen than there is that I will be killed in the grocery store by a random disturbed gunman. Statistics bear this out. 

So why should I be more afraid of the Muslims, to the point of banning them from the country, when we do not as a nation do anything to prevent random massacres ( exact SOME gun regulation) ?

We need guns to protect us from ISIS ? 

Who will protect us from the people with guns ? 

This idea that everyone should walk around carrying a pistol on their hip might be the craziest thing I have heard in my lifetime. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

It's not a muslim only protection gun. The same gun you use to protect yourself from a white trash burglar or Muslim can also be used to get rid of a Black Disciple thug on the south side of Chiraq. It's up to you to protect yourself from the thug with a gun. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Why wouldn't we ban outsiders who have no right to be here if they support a violent theology? 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The States With The Most Gun Laws See The Fewest Gun-Related Deaths


 
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  A. Macarthur   11 years ago

For some reason, the headline does not fit in the reply field, nor can I remove it!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

 

The States With The Most Gun Laws See The Fewest Gun-Related Deaths

While it’s cer­tainly true that a num­ber of factors con­trib­ute to the high rates of gun vi­ol­ence in the U.S., a com­par­is­on of state laws versus rates of shoot­ing deaths does show a cor­rel­a­tion. The states that im­pose the most re­stric­tions on gun users also have the low­est rates of gun-re­lated deaths, while states with few­er reg­u­la­tions typ­ic­ally have a much high­er death rate from guns.

 


 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   11 years ago

Quote from the linked article above.....

As of the fi­nal days of Au­gust, the United States has seen more than 200  mass shoot­ings  in 2015.

With the link to the now famous or infamous database of mass shootings depending on how you politically slant your mathematics.

So we have a biased response addressing another biased report.

Shootings are down, despite everyone claiming they are up, every fact based database clearly shows such. they have been going down for decades.

The only correlation that has followed this proven reduction for decades is the reduction in restrictive gun laws and the increase in private gun ownership.

Also proven fact, BUT, does that mean that one causes the other? not at all, but it is an indication that they do effect each other overall over time.

So we have a media that needs to pump the ideal that this is a violent society that will benefit from massive intervention in the form of gun control by the government. Such gun control being the removal of as many guns as they can possibly get removed from the hands of non government entities. despite their protestations to the opposite. (which usually fall flat on their face as they are being said since they are completely unbelievable)

But the media being the media, the masters at spinning situation into what they wish them to be cause they know that many people will accept what they say blindly, change the paramaters of the discussion so they can have more and more violence claims in an era when such incidents are actually declining.

By lowering the standard of what is counted, they dramatically increase the collective pool of incidents to rage about, thereby creating the impression that the shooting issue is getting worse not better.

And it is happening so fast now that the government isn't pushing the issue anymore. the media has taken it upon themselves to push the agenda. and as usual, their blind followers take up the mantra every bit as fast as Pavlov's Dog salivated to the ringing of the bell.

But to people who have watched and followed this for decades, see that the true pushers of the agenda are now coming out of the woodwork, the media itself. Since the government has no interest in Gun Control anymore. (don't get me wrong, the democrat politicians still have a ton of desire for it, but know it is never going to happen and their greatest tool to push it has been taken away, the politically slanted gun study. The response to the last one requested said we can't do biased studies anymore, they lost the scientists)

But the media could care less about truth and scientific fact, they are all about agenda and pushing ideals rather than investing in truth. Remember Pulitzer and Hearst? their great contribution to journalism had a strong yellow tinge that had nothing to do with truth or even basic honesty.

So we have it. the media pushing an agenda, one that does not match reality, that their willing dupes in society following along like the good little lemmings they are.

Been going on for well over 150 years, and will continue as long as there are people that understand that lies are more valuable than truth.

 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   11 years ago

So we have a biased response addressing another biased report.

I often do not take a side … mostly I show when a counter position exists … bringing an issue back to Square One.

That to me is often the most significant contribution that can be made to a heated issue.

Some profess to prefer "Fair and Balanced" … I like to poke folks in the eye with it … "beat them up with their own stick" choose your metaphor.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   11 years ago

To an extent I can agree my friend, as long as you accept that there are others who will view it as proverbial "Pouring gas on a Fire" or "Turning it into a revolving circle jerk"

Even I have to admit, sometimes it is hard to tell which is real and which isn't.

As least I tell the difference. (at lease I think I can, most of the time)

OH, BTW,

An average of 3.65 vs 3.92? statistically insignificant if based upon the same data-set, incompatible with each other if based upon different data-sets. since they are based upon different subsets of a single dataset they are incompatible with each other. at least on a scientific/mathematical basis.

which means that what the charts suggest as a truth is actually a lie, mathematically speaking that is....

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   11 years ago

There are already too many professionals willing to lie with statistics . Getting amateurs into the act too means a veritable flood of misleading or false info ...

 
 

Who is online






113 visitors