Brilliant New Leftist Idea: Abolish Private Housing!
Bad ideas never die. They never even fade away. They just lurk, waiting for the right moment to rear their ugly heads.
On that note, The Nation has come up with a brilliant new idea: abolishing private property.
This brand new, not at all tried-and-failed idea, pushed by Jesse Myerson, suggests that we “get rid of private housing.” He writes:
Plenty of time and effort have lately gone into analyzing a host of related crises—homelessness, unaffordable urban real estate, devastating gentrification, and a housing bubble whose burst landed us in the Great Recession. But the explanations tend to be incomplete, the attributions shortsighted, and the policies rearguard….The true culprit is so deeply embedded in American notions of wealth, rights, and property that we cannot see it for the terrible economy policy it is: private housing. Real estate as a store of private wealth is the rotten tree that sprouts these diseased branches, and the solution is to quit pruning twigs and chop the sucker down.
Hey, if destruction of all landholding didn’t destroy the Soviet Union and preclude the development of dozens of hunter-gatherer civilizations, why wouldn’t it work now?
Myerson says that land is owned by the government – a unique argument given that ownership of land predates organized government, and that American government was organized as an attempt to protect private property rights. He states:
Land, save the bits beneath one’s feet, can’t be “possessed,” as a phone or a shirt can…The entire apparatus by which housing is privately “owned” is created by the government’s decisions to subsidize or protect certain interests.
There is truth to the notion that the government “declares” certain property open for ownership. But in the absence of that declaration, people would still claim and settle property, as they have for thousands of years, since domestication of animals became a common human practice. That’s why adverse possession – the notion of claiming property through consistent use – is a part of American law.
Myerson continues by blaming private property ownership for segregation (mandated by law , of course), financial crises, and vacant lots held for years. These are all idiotic notions: segregation was mandated by government , financial crises have been largely caused by government intervention in the markets, and vacant land is worth less than land built up in populated areas unless government skews the market .
Myerson ends up proclaiming the virtues of public housing, a massive failure in the United States, by promoting Viennese housing from the 1920s. He concludes:
Private land policies are as evil today as they were almost 4 centuries ago when the Pilgrims near Bridgewater, Massachusetts, arrested Wampanoag people for hunting on a tract of land after the Pilgrims had “purchased” it. “What is this you call property?” the sachem, Massasoit, argued on that occasion. “It cannot be the earth, for the land is our Mother…. everything on it belongs to everybody and is for the use of all. How then can one man say it belongs to him only?” There was no satisfactory retort then, and there isn’t one now.
It turns out that those horrible land policies, which encouraged ownership and work, created the greatest civilization in the history of humanity, alleviating poverty for literally billions of human beings. The land ownership policies of the Wampanoag created nothing of note for thousands of years. Actually, when the original Pilgrims tried communistic property ownership, they almost starved to death. It’s also worth noting that the tragedy of the commons exists on the commons . It doesn’t exist in private parks.
But it’s evil to own land.
Why not extend that logic to all private ownership? Who says you can own animals? Or food? Or anything? Why not own everything in common, or turn it all over to government?
Because then you end up with Venezuela, where inflation is 200 percent, all in the name of the public good.
What idiocy. But don’t worry. No matter how bad the idea, it will always come back. Remember the Wampanoag.
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

Remember this. The next time you see an article about protecting the 1st, 2nd or any of our God given rights and you see someone saying "that is from a right wing sight", remember this is from "The Wire" and "The Nation" and they are serious.
a unique argument given that ownership of land predates organized government,
Actually, without government private property does not exist.
@johnrussell :
a unique argument given that ownership of land predates organized government,
Actually, without government private property does not exist.
Tell that to the Native Indians.
I believe that Indians found it remarkable that any would think that they actually "owned" any part of Mother Earth.
@larry-hampton :
I believe that Indians found it remarkable that any would think that they actually "owned" any part of Mother Earth.
It's good to see you Larry. I know that and understand that, but I assure you if a tribe was living in an area and another tribe decided to take it over a problem would arise and that would be be likened to ownership to the extent it was the land they were staying on and not the other tribe.
Good to see you as well Six; thanks!
I agree,,,merely making an observation.
@larry-hampton :
Good to see you as well Six; thanks!
I agree,,,merely making an observation.
Otherwise, why all the hoopla about the Europeans going back home.
Otherwise, why all the hoopa about the Europeans going back home.
I would be in a world of hurt. Being part Irish, English, Scottish, French Canadian, and American Indian, they would have to figure out which parts get sent back, and which parts stay.
I'd like to think my balls are all American.
;^)
The concept of government refers to people within a given society. The other group is under another government.
Imagine you are on an island in the middle of nowhere. You are not sure if there are any other people on the island, but you know there is no government. So you build a nice house for yourself and are enjoying paradise. One day along comes someone who says he wants your house, and has enough thugs with him to take it from you.
Will your insistence that it is "yours" save you?
If on the other hand there is a government there, the house might be listed as belonging to you, and the government would protect your ownership rights.
@johnrussell :
Imagine you are on an island in the middle of nowhere. You are not sure if there are any other people on the island, but you know there is no government. So you build a nice house for yourself and are enjoying paradise. One day along comes someone who says he wants your house, and has enough thugs with him to take it from you.
Will your insistence that it is "yours" save you?
If on the other hand there is a government there, the house might be listed as belonging to you, and the government would protect your ownership rights.
Now you're talking about legally owning a piece of properly under government or settling on a spot you know no one owns. I promise you, if this happened you would see the matter as someone took your property. Of course I understand the government we've set up over the years should protect you unless of course they decide they want you house.
Then there's always that property tax thing and if you don't pay it no matter where you are in the USA, they will certainly take it from you, so now we come up with the question of whether anyone truly owns his/her property anyway? Problem solved....... No one owns their property, private property has already been abolished for a long time.
Any large city , or any city really, should have enough land set aside that it can be used for low income housing. Every inch of land doesnt need to be owned by gentrifiers and developers.
Six, let me ask you a question . Let's create a city, Newstalk City. Let's say that half the people who work and live in or near Newstalk City make 13 dollars an hour or less. Wouldn't you agree that half of the housing in or near Newstalk City should be afforable for people making 13 dollars an hour or less ?
Or do you think that people in the lower half of the economic scale should have to pay MORE of their income for housing than the other, better off, people do ?
@johnrussell :
Six, let me ask you a question . Let's create a city, Newstalk City. Let's say that half the people who work and live in or near Newstalk City make 13 dollars an hour or less. Wouldn't you agree that half of the housing in or near Newstalk City should be afforable for people making 13 dollars an hour or less ?
John, I have one philosophy I live by which deals with that question.
I believe I should be a part of those who help those who can not help themselves and I believe I should be a part of those who help those who can help themselves do it.
doesn't answer the question
do you think that people in the lower half of the economic scale should have to pay MORE of their income for housing than the other, better off, people do ?
@johnrussell :
doesn't answer the question
do you think that people in the lower half of the economic scale should have to pay MORE of their income for housing than the other, better off, people do ?
It's inevitable they will probably pay a larger percentage of their income for their housing than others who make far more money. You see John, I'm not a Socialist. I don't believe everyone is equal in respect to their abilities or accomplishments. I don't believe a person who has expended less energy toward making more money should be given the same amount as those who have sacrificed to become more self reliant on themselves.
I realize some people don't have the desire, motivation or mental abilities to get out of poverty. Those who are unable to improve their lives because they aren't able to do so for one reason or another society isn't obligated to help them, but I believe they should. But on the other hand, if you make a rule everyone pays the same percentage of their income for rent, then you take away the incentive to improve oneself. I'll give you an example where the incentive to do better is removed and everyone does worst.
It's inevitable they will probably pay a larger percentage of their income for their housing than others who make far more money. You see John, I'm not a Socialist. I don't believe everyone is equal in respect to their abilities or accomplishments. I don't believe a person who has expended less energy toward making more money should be given the same amount as those who have sacrificed to become more self reliant on themselves.
I realize some people don't have the desire, motivation or mental abilities to get out of poverty. Those who are unable to improve their lives because they aren't able to do so for one reason or another society isn't obligated to help them, but I believe they should. But on the other hand, if you make a rule everyone pays the same percentage of their income for rent, then you take away the incentive to improve oneself. I'll give you an example where the incentive to do better is removed and everyone does worst.
Six, in your heart you are a good man, I think. But you don't understand certain things. If there were not poor people, there would not be wealthy people. or "middle class people", they all exist in relation to one another. So it's not like people can decide to "better themselves" then at that time there would be no more poor people. Every single poor person in the country (or the world) could decide to better themselves , and try to do it, and there would still be poor people. Because there has to be for "wealth" to mean anything. Providing affordable housing based on income or wealth doesn't hurt you. Why would you care if the government provided it ?
Land developers are only interested in profit and they will price poor people out of housing if there is any chance they can get more rent for that apartment. It is said there are MANY thousands of people now who live in shelters or on the street in NYC because they cannot afford rent. Maybe if they move two hours away from their work they could find something. Why do you want people to suffer like that ? People who are already suffering from low wages so we can have more millionaires and billionaires.
This stuff is not an internet game Six. There is daily economic exploitation in this country, and God may not like that on judgement day.