Opinion writer
“And if they said, ‘yes,’ they would not be allowed in the country?”
Trump: “That’s correct.”
Brilliant. And very economical. That is, if you think that bloodthirsty terrorists — “people that believe only in Jihad, and have no sense of reason or respect for human life,” as Trump describes them — will feel honor-bound to tell the truth to an infidel customs officer. They kill wantonly but, like George Washington, cannot tell a lie. On this logic hinges the great Maginot Line with which Trump will protect America from jihad.
I decline to join the chorus denouncing the Trump proposal as offensive and un-American. That’s too obvious. What I can’t get over is its sheer absurdity.
Here’s a suggestion (borrowed from my Fox News colleague Chris Stirewalt ) to shore it up. At every immigration station at every airport in America , we will demand that every potential entrant — immigrant, refugee, student or tourist — eat a bacon sandwich. You refuse? Back home you go!
True, the Stirewalt Solution casts the net a bit wide, snaring innocent vegetarians and Orthodox Jews. But hey, as Trump said Tuesday , “We’re at war — get it through your head.” Can’t get squeamish about collateral damage.
Dozens of others have already pointed out how strategically idiotic is Trump’s exclusion principle. Absent a renewed Christian crusade against radical Islam — with those fabulous Hollywood-wardrobe tunics — the war on terror will be won only in alliance with moderate Muslims. Declaring them anathema is not the best beginning to coalition-building.
To take but the most obvious example: Our closest and most effective allies on the ground in the Middle East are the Kurds. Trump would turn them back at the Orlando airport. No Disney World for them. Or does he not know that they are Muslim?
It is embarrassing even to embark on such arguments. To treat “no Muslims allowed” as a serious idea is to give credit to what is little more than a clever stunt by a man who saw Ted Cruz beating him for the first time in the Iowa Monmouth poll and five hours later decided it was time to seize the stage again.
This got the thinkers going again. National Review’s Andrew McCarthy, whom I (otherwise) hold in considerable esteem, spent 1,000 words trying to tart up the ban in constitutional and statutory livery, stressing — hilariously — that he is dealing with the Trump proposal “in its final form.” As if Trump’s barstool eruptions are painstakingly vetted, and as if anything Trump says about anything is ever final.
Take his Syria policy. In September, he said we should wash our hands and just let Russia fight the Islamic State. Having, I assume, been subsequently informed that Vladimir Putin’s principal interest — and target — is not the Islamic State but the anti-Assad rebels, Trump now promises to “bomb the s---” out of the Islamic State.
I’m sure there’s a Trump apologist out there working to explain the brilliant complementarity of these two contradictory strategies. Just as a few months ago there was a frenzy of learned scholarship about the constitutional history of the 14th Amendment following another Trump eruption — the abolition of birthright citizenship.
Whatever the final outcome, Trump’s campaign has already succeeded, indelibly affecting both this race and the Republican future. At a time of economic malaise at home and strategic collapse abroad, Trump has managed to steer the entire GOP campaign into absurdities, like mass deportation of 11 million illegal immigrants, and impossibilities, like the exclusion of Muslims from our shores.
“No Muslims allowed” is the perfect example. President Obama’s Oval Office address on Sunday night marked a new low in his presidency. The shopworn arguments, the detached tone, the willful denial that there might be anything wrong with his policy were deeply unsettling for left, right and center. Even the New York Times had to admit “Obama’s Plans to Stop ISIS Leave Many Democrats Wanting More,” which is Timesese for Democrats Stunned by Vacancy in the Oval Office . Here was an opportunity for the Republican field to launch an all-out takedown of the Obama (and Hillary Clinton) foreign policy. Within less than a day, that opportunity was wiped out. Once again, it’s the Donald Show.

I rarely agree with him on anything, but he is right on a large part of this. Trump idiotic statements are ruining chances for a serious GOP candidate (meaning one that might stand a chance of winning the General Election) from coming forward. It's beginning to look like a Trump/Cruz ticket and a sure loser. As a liberal Democrat it's very encouraging!
I don't see any article or link.
Hmmmm....I see them both on firefox and chrome?
Unfortunately for the media, Trump has them, let's say by the private parts. When they ask a stupid question, he just gives them a stupid answer. He knows when he is being set up.
I wonder what Hillary Clinton's answer was to that question. Oh, that's right, she wasn't asked that question. Of course she's not going to worry about vetting them anyway.
Of course when ABC reports Syrian refugees are using fake passports and they've already discovered some.
Fake Syrian passports have already been discovered in Europe, most notably two used by suicide bombers in the horrific terrorist attack on Paris last month. The two men are believed to have slipped into Europe with a flood of Syrian refugees fleeing the violence in their homeland.
According to the source that provided the passport information to homeland security officials, Syria is awash in fake documents.
No one is interested in talking about that. They want to talk about something stupid like this.
Trump came up with the idea of banning all Muslims all on his own. Not in a response to a reporter's question. Yes sometimes they do ask stupid questions, but as someone who really wants to be President shouldn't he correct them and give a serious answer?
Also, even though I disagree with much of what he says most of the time, this is a serious columnist who wrote it.
The total number of Americans that Islamic terrorism has ever killed, combined , over the course of 50 years, is less than the population of one average size American small town.
Americans have to decide if they are going to be stampeded into paralyzed fear and/or rash actions by the words of pandering politicians.
And as was pointed out in an article that I posted the other day 83 people die everyday simply from falling down, yet we don't have a war on falling down and don't devote several days or weeks of news cycles to it every time someone dies from it.
I put this idiotic idea in the same line of his remarks where he says he's going to build a wall all of the way across our Southern border. In the first place he's never going to be President, so it's sort of a moot point. That said the Mexicans are laughing at the idea that they'll pay for it and then how does he build a wall down the Rio Grande river? Mexico is not going to let hm build it on their side and if he builds it on our side then we are completely conceding the rights to Mexico to one of the most major waterways in North America. I guess he could try to figure out a way to build one down the middle of the river, but I'd like to see the cost and plans on that idea.