Awesome 11-Year-Old Student Sues His Florida Public School For Failing To Teach Evolution
An 11-year-old boy and his lawyer father have slapped the Palm Beach County school board with a lawsuit for neglecting to teach evolution because of religious objections.
Brandon Silver is eager to learn all about evolution in his science class, but his school barely touches upon it because the fuddy-duddy administrators object to it for religious reasons. But because the Palm Beach County school district is a public school, disregarding science in favor of a particular religious belief is unconstitutional.
“We’ve been taught about adaptations to the environment but that’s not really a direct concept to evolution,” Brandon told WPBF .
Brandon took his concerns to his father, Barry Silver, who gladly agreed to help his son take on the school district.
“It’s such a magnificent story and it’s being neglected,” Silver said. “The students are being deprived of learning from it because certain religious people don’t like the story because it contradicts the Bible and we think it is terrible that children shouldn’t learn the truth about where they came from.”
So, last month, the Silvers slapped the district with a lawsuit aimed at making them actually teach evolution.
They even chose a specific date to file the lawsuit to coincide with a special anniversary.
“We filed this on Nov. 24, 2015, because on Nov. 24, 1859, Darwin published that incredible work about the origin of the species,” Silver explained.
The lawsuit claims that Palm Beach County school district is breaking Florida law by not providing the best quality education for students, which should include evolutionary science, a cornerstone of biology and many other scientific fields.
“There are currently schools and textbooks which provide false, misleading, and dangerous information about certain religions and purposely omit factual information if it appears unfavorable to them and/or politically incorrect, which cause Palm Beach County public school students not to receive a high quality education required by the Florida law,” the lawsuit says.
While the superintendent hasn’t seen the lawsuit yet, the Silvers hope to work something out with school administrators to solve the problem instead of going to court. If the school refuses, the Silvers intend to go the distance in their fight to put science in the classroom so that Brandon and his fellow students can get the best education possible without religion interfering.
“If they’re willing to sit down with us and talk about it and correct some of the things that are not proper in the school system about science we’re happy to resolve it with them,” Barry said. “If not, we’ll go ahead and serve it and we will vigorously litigate the lawsuit.”
Clearly, Brandon appears to be acting more like a well-adjusted adult than the school administrators who are putting their religious beliefs above the education of their students.
Pew Research reports that the United States currently ranks 27th in the world in science according to 2012 scores released by the Program for International Student Assessment.
One of the reasons why we rank so low is because lawmakers and school officials are too busy trying to inject religion where it doesn’t belong instead of focusing on actual scientific fact. As a result, our kids are getting confused and not getting the best education we can provide.
Schools, especially public schools, are no place for religion. That’s what churches are for. Science education should be about facts and evidence. If schools refuse to understand that, then they deserve lawsuit after lawsuit until our kids are given the education they deserve, instead of the one being forced upon them by religious extremists.

Science, we don't need no stinkin' science.
Exactly!
God will provide!
Nearly anything taught in high school is done at such a low level that it leaves out important exceptions . The low level theory of evolution leaves out important issues in biology while emphasizing only competition . These are not socially beneficial lessons .
Oh Florida, is there no end to your ignorance? This competition you've got going on with Texas is really out of hand.
Obviously you have no interest in "important issues in biology" ... no surprise there . Feel free to pretend there are none .
As usual, nobody has any idea what you are yammering on about. You and Karen should start a conversation, where you can both just speak your mind like that - coherence and relevance be damned!
Here's a tip: If you are confused about the point of an article, sometimes it helps jot just go to the last paragraph for clarity.
"Schools, especially public schools, are no place for religion. That’s what churches are for. Science education should be about facts and evidence. If schools refuse to understand that, then they deserve lawsuit after lawsuit until our kids are given the education they deserve, instead of the one being forced upon them by religious extremists."
Science education should be about facts and evidence.
I agree . Its a pity low level watered-down biology courses are about neither facts nor evidence . For example the role of cooperation is an essential part of biology but Darwin was only concerned with competition . That happens at certain times but at other times cooperation is the big factor .
I agree . Its a pity low level watered-down biology courses are about neither facts nor evidence . For example the role of cooperation is an essential part of biology but Darwin was only concerned with competition . That happens at certain times but at other times cooperation is the big factor .
Petey, I am not sure what you are talking about. Biology is an ongoing process of teaching from elementary to high school, as is evolution. Nothing is watered down. IN FACT, that is why there is AP Bio. To make sure that our brightest students are being prepped in the correct way. That does include evolution as does the ACT and soon the SAT.
Nothing is watered down.
Teachers have their own thin blue line . I've long suspected that . Thanks for providing supporting evidence ...
That is utter BS. Prove that. Oh wait, you can't. Because to get into any good university you have to have taken the bio AP and either the ACT or the SAT... none of which is watered down.
OH WAIT... my daughters got into John's Hopkins Pre med because of their watered down education I guess.. yeah that's the ticket.
Try again.
The average biology teacher is not worth listening to especially about evolution . As I said in a previous comment evolution focuses on competition but ignores cooperation . However cooperation is an essential part of the study of biology as any murmacologist would be happy to demonstrate .
BTW bringing up your personal experience does not co-opt my point . All it does is expose the bias in academia against cooperation in the study of biology .
Petey,
Evolution isn't just survival of the fittest nor is it taught that way. But it is taught on the high school level as how it is reflected through DNA.
Here, knock yourself out and see what we teach in NYS:
Evolution isn't just survival of the fittest nor is it taught that way.
Your 1st link shed no light on the topic . I will simply mention that evolution does NOT cover the subject of cooperation . It doesn't even cover the subject of symbiosis which leaves a gaping hole in the subject of biology .
Your 1st link shed no light on the topic . I will simply mention that evolution does NOT cover the subject of cooperation . It doesn't even cover the subject of symbiosis which leaves a gaping hole in the subject of biology .
Then look at my second link and you will see that it covers all of that on an elementary level, so there is no gaping holes.
Also, given that you know that I am a biology teacher, try not to make this personal. I resent that.
you know that I am a biology teacher
Actually I didn't but that ignores the point I made above . There is a bias in academia for competition & against cooperation . Any theory that does not cover both is incomplete .
Yes you do, Rich. We have had extend dialog about what I taught, and so I do take this rather personally when you imply that because I am a biology teacher that I am hiding behind my profession and being sneaky. And in fact you are wrong. competition & cooperation as a matter of survival is taught. I am unsure where you got the idea that those concepts were not.
when you imply that because I am a biology teacher that I am hiding behind my profession and being sneaky.
Find those words in what I wrote ... but you can't . I am not making a statement about you personally . I am making a statement about a defect in the study of evolution . If there is discussion about cooperation in the theory of evolution , feel free to post a link or an excerpt to that effect . To my knowledge there is no such discussion .
The mortar of biology is dna, passed from generation to generation. It's easy to overlook or refuse to consider a creator of that same biological process. So, it is with little knowledge of our own history or of the omnipresence required to create our world, we muddle through and try to resolve the issue without complete understanding. I'll leave the door open...the evolution itself just may be a creation too.
I support the constitutional issue and say no to public schools becoming evangelical madrasas. Teach about them all or teach none.
It's easy to overlook or refuse to consider a creator of that same biological process.
Intelligent Design is not overlooked nor does anyone refuse to consider it. Even when it is mentioned with being named.
ID does not pass the first hurdle of the scientific method: there is no evidence at all.
If God is an omnipotent trickster, then the Flood could be true, too. An omnipotent trickster could create an entire universe in six days, complete with detailed evidence of thirteen billion years of history... just to screw with the minds of some of the inhabitants of one planet out of zillions.
What kind of "God" is that trickster?
ID is an insult to God.
An omnipotent trickster could create an entire universe in six days, complete with detailed evidence of thirteen billion years of history
Whaaa !!! Are you saying my 500 million year old Trilobite is just a prank ?!?
ID?
I was thinking more along the lines of a boat, built by whoever. The voyage is not created, it evolves from launching the boat.
Seems simple to me, teach science in public school, teach religion in church. What's so hard about that?
Climatology is a religion but it is taught in schools .
Politicizing science is as lame as politicizing a chicken sandwich. I'll let you idealogues fall down that rabbit hole by yourselves.
Tell that to Al Gore AND James Hansen among others .
Why? Gore's a politician with whatever agenda politicians have and I've never heard of the other guy. I don't base my acceptance of science on whatever happens to be spouting out of the mouths of the chattering class. Why do you?
The fact that you don't know who James Hansen is says all that needs to be said .
Wasn't he the Muppets guy? Besides, I never went to Columbia.
Google is your friend ... Trust it on certain topics .
Nah, I'd rather google porn.
Al Gore is not a scientist. I don't care what his views are on climate change. And this article is not about climate change but evolution. There are no AP's or college boards being given in climate change.
this article is not about climate change but evolution.
Also about the opposite subject creationism and its related topic religion .
Creationism is faith based Evolution is science based. The public schools are for teaching science.
Somehow I think that point, good as it is, will fail to hit home.
Evolution is science based.
Not if it leaves out important aspects of biology ...
But it doesn't no matter how many times you repeat that. Bring proof or it is just words.
Was this comment directed at me ? If so I suggest you find info about cooperation within the theory of evolution . If you do that I will give in .
Here Petey:
Very interesting Perrie . I didn't see anything in that article about the theory of evolution . Did you ? As far as I can tell evolution still focuses on competition ...
Great XX... believe whatever you like. But when it comes to public education, science is taught and out DNA tells us that we are millions of years old, so evolution is taught, since that is science based, not faith based.
There are no "Missing Links". And we didn't come from Monkeys but deviate from them. And in fact, we can trace the humanoid species pretty far back through our DNA and even more specifically by mitochondrial DNA. So yes we can see proof.
Furthermore, I don't believe that the good doctor believes this. If I were a betting person I would say he is playing for his audience. He studied about DNA, and understands all the implications of history tied up in them. So I truly doubt anything he has said about this since his run for the presidency.
He studied about DNA, and understands all the implications of history tied up in them. So I truly doubt anything he has said about this since his run for the presidency.
Ummm... Perrie??
Crazy people have no trouble believing two contradictory things at the same time...