The Wrong Side of 'the Right Side of History'
President Obama espouses a facile faith in history bending toward perfection and morality—against evidence and reason.
Yuri Gripas / Reuters
President Obama espouses a facile faith in history bending toward perfection and morality—against evidence and reason.
Yuri Gripas / Reuters/ The Atlantic
Barack Obama has always evinced a fascination with history. He announced his candidacy in Springfield, Illinois, recalling Abraham Lincoln. He modeled his own cabinet after Lincoln’s “team of rivals.” He has compared his own accomplishments to his predecessors, and he invited historians to the White House for private conversations about where he might fit within the pantheon of American leaders.
If Obama’s interests run toward history, so does his rhetoric. “It's the answer that led those who have been told for so long by so many to be cynical, and fearful, and doubtful of what we can achieve to put their hands on the arc of history and bend it once more toward the hope of a better day,” he said the evening of his first election. Since then, the president has repeatedly deployed a series of phrases—especially “the right side of history” and “the wrong side of history”—that suggest a tortured, idealistic, and ultimately untenable vision of what history is and how it works.
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

Redbox Rules:
Read the article,
The topic is Mr Obama's views of history and what is and is not historical in nature.
Stay on topic and that topic is not me or my views on History.
It is not about issue politics but on how his view on history shapes his approach to politics.
Straying off topic is not tolerated and will be reported.
Any insults will be deleted as a matter of course.
I am the arbiter of what constitutes an insult and what doesn't.
Don't like it don't post.
Needless to say, Mr Obama is not a historian, in fact he is as I put it a creator of history in his belief. Rather than having history unfold around him he believes that he creates history.
In the political philosophy of history is moving toward perfection and he is at the forefront.
This is an impossible belief.
History moves in it own direction, it truths are for the philosophers of the future but it is always ongoing.
There is no perfection to anything historical it is or it isn't. Many people believe that we are coming into a Liberal Socialist age where all will be right and just.
I say in the realm of politics NOTHING is right or just,
It simply is.
On that basis Mr Obama's philosophy of how he views the world historically is completely wrong.
Any one wish to counter with a different viewpoint?
This obsession with being "historical" explains a lot about his inflated opinion of himself . And still no comprehension of anything in the economic arena . Economics doesn't bother with minor historical issues . The assumption is that the market adjusts itself without intervention [for the most part] .
Well most presidents have a large sense of how historical the office can be, but also most presidents allow the historical side of the office to come to them, they don't seek it out or try to create it.
But particularly, this president has a penchant for thinking that his view (one shared by a number of members here) is one that history is predetermined to be what they wish it to be, thereby looking on everything else with huge blinders on and just automatically disposing of anything that doesn't fit their historical world view.
Marx had this issue with the world was heading to a socialist utopia and to really understand him one must realize that he was predetermining the historical outcomes.
Never a good thing cause history seldom works out to how we predict it.
I mean specific little things are predictable in afterthought much like monday morning quarterbacking. Studying WWII one soon learns that the outcome of the war was determined once the US became involved. The only question was how long it was going to take.
Winston Churchill understood this implicitly and is why he reacted with almost glee when he heard the news that Pearl Harbor was attacked. He even ignored Roosevelt's request to not declare war on Japan until after the US had.
Churchill had his own agenda.
Overall WWII proved that the world was not marching to a greater socialist existence and a world of peace.
WWII destroyed the Marxist/Socialist ideal of history, it only took 70 years to prove it.
Basically History cannot possibly be preordained.
And all the claims of the great progressive movement taking over the nation and the world politically is a pipe dream.
And it is the same way on the conservative side.
I mean specific little things are predictable in afterthought much like monday morning quarterbacking. Studying WWII one soon learns that the outcome of the war was determined once the US became involved. The only question was how long it was going to take.
I agree with most of what you've said but I point out that this particular view of the inevitability of a German defeat tends to undercut your position that nothing is inevitable (I know you're conceding a bit on Monday morning quarterbacking). Although there are many who take your position, after studying the issue myself, it seems to me that our victory relied on both Britain and the Soviet Union staying in the war. If the Soviet Union had collapsed under German assault, the vast resources of the Soviet Union would have been under German control. Germany would have re-directed it's armies from the Soviet Union to westward positions and bolstered all coastal defenses. D-Day may have been impossible or nearly suicidal. Similarly, Britain's future was far from secure. It's main army could have been wiped out at Dunkirk and, even so, they lost most of their heavy weapons. Britain was under a Blitzkrieg and a blockade that, coupled with a loss of its army at Dunkirk, could have forced it to surrender. Without Britain as a base, we could not have launched an invasion of France. We were also invading through Italy but that could have easily gone either way because the Germany could reinforce its armies more easily by land than we could reinforce ours by sea. We may have been forced to withdraw from Europe. The whole thing could have resulted in a stalemate where neither could defeat the other . . . at least for a while.
There is no question One that such can be debated endlessly back and forth. And at the start of 1942 the issue was very much in doubt. But Germany gave up it's chance for complete victory in Europe in 1941. The Royal Navy would not have stopped the invasion and only proved the superiority of Airplanes over battleships a full year before Pearl Harbor and Singapore (Prince of Wales & Repulse sinkings).
And then there is the whole discussion line on if Hitler had only allowed his generals to run the war and stayed the hell out of it.
Hindsight is always 20/20.
But, that is one of the points this article is trying to express, there are no guarantees in history, the study of history can provide guidance and wise counsel, but it cannot predict the future.
And,
any one relying on their sense of history to guide them by claiming pre-knowledge of how something will turn out is badly deceiving themselves. Much Like Reagan and his belief in what he was doing in Nicaragua. Johnson's & Nixon's beliefs in what they were doing in Vietnam,
History is replete with the proof that a pre-ordained belief in anything is most usually a false belief in ones own infallibility.
There is no question One that such can be debated endlessly back and forth. And at the start of 1942 the issue was very much in doubt. But Germany gave up it's chance for complete victory in Europe in 1941. The Royal Navy would not have stopped the invasion and only proved the superiority of Airplanes over battleships a full year before Pearl Harbor and Singapore (Prince of Wales & Repulse sinkings).
Agreed. I'll offer one more example from WWII that underscores the point that the future is unpredictable, especially in war. In the late 1930s, Stalin decided to invade tiny Finland before Hitler did it. The Soviet Union's main army was larger than the entire population of Finland. The Fins were vastly outnumbered and outgunned but, rather than surrender, they fought back against an army they could not hope to defeat. When the Fins ran out of ammunition, they fought with knives. When they had no vehicles, they fought on skies. When they couldn't otherwise stop a tank, they threw Molotov cocktails at point blank range and jammed logs in the treads of moving tanks. In the end, the Fins had to cede some of their land to the Soviets but their unbelievable courage and determination allowed them to remain independent. What the Fins proved is that the most important variable in war is the will to fight and the will to fight is never predictable.
Until lions have their historians, tales of the hunt shall always glorify the hunters. ~African Proverb
Every morning in Africa, a gazelle wakes up. It knows it must run faster than the fastest lion or it will be killed.
Every morning a lion wakes up. It knows it must outrun the slowest gazelle or it will starve to death.
It doesn't matter whether you are a lion or a gazelle.
When the sun comes up, you better start running. -African Proverb...
There is an interesting idea or two floating around here, but in the end this article is much ado about nothing.
Obama believes that the initiatives for marriage equality, universal health care, social justice, immigration reform , the "Arab spring", etc are all things that would come as inevitable developments. It is rhetoric. So what ?
But in actuality, they are but chapters in the living of life as a human who get to decide how he is going to live. there is nothing inevitable about any of them. and they can change in a short time depending on just about anything.
Rhetoric is the art of revealing without revealing. Saying without really saying.
Essentially your rhetoric is you saying what you believe every one believes.
The point of the article is saying that the rhetoric that leaders use, tell one of his sense of direction and how he believes. Mr Obama's rhetoric says that he believes that whatever he believes is inevitable. and therefore will come to pass even if he isn't around to see it.
Marx believed implicitly in the eventual dominance of the socialist construct as eventually taking over the planet. It hasn't and never will. He predicted the outcome of history to conform to his own belief system.
Mr Obama does the same thing.
But then again most powerful leaders do to some extent.
But the reality is what they believe is as fleeting as any singular thought that runs through anyone's head.
And is irrelevant in the larger scope of history.
Excellnet article.
Obama's belief in history as some sort of force whose willl can determined as it moves inexolerably towards a predetermined outcome is naive is hell.
history doesn't care who wins and doesn't believe in right or wrong. Things can get better just as easily as they get worse.
Big Deal.
All presidents use their own style of rhetoric.
It's not rhetoric. It's a staple of the Marxist interpretation of history which was , and to some extent still is, the dominate school of hisotrical thought in american universities. Obama's showing his intellectual roots.
Obama appears to be a really bad, (or non-existent) Marxist then.
The ideology purity of you deep thinkers on the right is a hoot.
It's not intellectual purity my friend, it is being witness to and understanding the scope of history.
Which in reality is nothing to bank on. What is a hoot to you as a dismissive of the point, drives the point home more forcefully than any other counter argument.
People who try to live their lives by a predicated course by anyones prediction of history, is bound to repeat history endlessly.
Nothing is inevitable when it come to the course of human history since, like a herd of cattle or sheep, the course can be changed simply because each individual decides to follow the other without much thought. The notion that one can be on the wrong side of history before history unfolds essentially tells an opponent that his defeat is inevitable so he should give up now. Except that defeat is only inevitable if he gives up. Sometimes David beats Goliath and the tortoise beats the hare.
EXACTLY!
I wonder if he was writing history by attacking Libya and if it turned out the way he thought it would. I'm afraid the answer to both is YES.
If you believe that Mr Obama is a president who wants to tear down instead of build. You are absolutely right.
I tend to agree with this assessment with one proviso, he doesn't intend the outcome to be that way. He intends to build.
The problem with his approach is this, before you can tear down and build anew, you have to have absolute control. Why?
Because without it (complete total control) you subject yourself to the whims of others and their visions of what is being done. and in that case, whatever it is usually fails.
No one builds a house on a piece of property until they own it free and clear or at least has full legal control over it.
One's point above, it doesn't always turn out like you think it will when many minds are involved at the same time..