Viewpoint Diversity in the Academy
Truth is a process, not just an end-state. The Righteous Mind was about the obstacles to that process — confirmation bias, motivated reasoning, tribalism, and the worship of sacred values. Given the many ways that our moral psychology warps our reasoning, it’s a wonder we’ve gotten as far as we have, as a species. That’s what’s so brilliant about science: it is a way of putting people together so that they challenge each other and cancel out each others’ confirmation biases and tribal commitments. The truth emerges from the interaction of flawed individuals.
But something alarming has happened to the academy since the 1990s: it has been transformed from an institution that leans to the left, which is not a big problem, into an institution that is entirely on the left, which is a very big problem.
Data from Higher Education Research Institute, based on a survey of college faculty conducted every other year since 1989. Plotted by Sam Abrams.
Nowadays there are NO conservatives or libertarians in most academic departments in the humanities and social sciences. The academy has been so focused on attaining diversity by race and gender (which are valuable) that it has created a hostile climate for people who think differently. The American Academy has become a politically orthodox and quasi-religious institution. When everyone shares the same politics and prejudices, the disconfirmation process breaks down. Political orthodoxy is particularly dangerous for the social sciences, which grapple with so many controversial topics (such as race, racism, gender, poverty, immigration, politics, and climate science). America needs innovative and trustworthy research on all these topics, but can a social science that lacks viewpoint diversity produce reliable findings?
What I am trying to do
I am a non-partisan centrist, and I am very concerned about the loss of viewpoint diversity in the academy. I believe the problem is amplified by the rising political polarization of the United States more generally. I therefore teamed up with two dozen professors in psychology and other disciplines (most of whom are not conservative) to create the site HeterodoxAcademy.org. Our goal is to make the case, consistently and forcefully, that the academy must increase viewpoint diversity.
If you want to understand the cultural transformation that has occurred at American universities since the 1990s here is my suggested reading list:
1) The Coddling of the American Mind (With Greg Lukianoff, in The Atlantic). This essay gives the overview of the new culture spreading across universities, in which students are demanding “safe spaces,” “trigger warnings,” and administrative mechanisms for cataloguing and punishing “micro-aggresssions.” We explain where this culture came from and why it is so bad for the students’ own mental health, as well as being devastating to the free exchange of ideas upon which the pursuit of truth depends.
2) Where microaggressions really come from . This is my summary of an extraordinary essay by sociologists Bradley Campbell and Jason Manning. They show how a new “culture of victimhood” is emerging on America’s most progressive college campuses in which the main paths to gaining prestige are either to advertise one’s victimhood or to attack others in the name of defending victims. This culture weakens students and guarantees unending strife. This essay is essential reading for anyone who thinks that campus protesters’ demands for more sensitivity training, affirmative action, and ethnic studies centers are going to help future students feel less marginalized on campus. In fact, those measures are likely to backfire. College presidents and deans who validate the protesters’ accusations and give in to their demands are committing their institutions to a firmer embrace of victimhood culture, which means that in a few years they can expect: thinner skins, more anger, more feelings of marginalization, more accusations of racism/sexism, more restrictions on free speech, and more demands for… more victimhood culture. This could well turn into a death spiral for any college that starts down this path. But once a university has lost all of its political diversity, there’s nobody left on campus who is willing to stand up and say “um, maybe this is a bad idea, here’s another way to look at things.”
3) True diversity requires generosity of spirit . This is a case study of the most egregious witch-hunt so far — the persecution of dean Spellman at Claremont McKenna, for the crime of writing a helpful email with one ambiguous word. I say why current diversity approaches should be reconfigured around the principle of charity — we must give each other the benefit of the doubt if we are to live with diversity.
4) How Marcuse made today’s students less tolerant than their parents. by April Kelly-Woessner. Describes the resurgence of influence of Herbert Marcuse, who argued in the 1960s that true “liberating” tolerance requires suppressing all non-progressive voices. Kelly-Woessner shows the big split in American opinion on matters of free speech: Millennials embrace Marcusian ideals much more than did previous generations, and it is this moralistic illiberalism that leads to the witch-hunts and ultimatums that are sweeping across American college campuses since Halloween 2015. (Two months after Kelly-Woessner posted the essay, Pew research published strong confirmation of her argument: 40% of Millennials OK with limiting speech offensive to minorities ).
5) The Yale problem begins in high school . This is a report of a strange experience that happened to me when I gave a talk at a progressive private high school. I came to see that “the Yale problem” — the angry demands for changes that will make future generations even angrier — has its roots in high school. Many students at elite schools are learning to judge ideas not by their content but by the “privilege” or victimhood of the speaker. They arrive at Yale (and other colleges) unready to participate in a marketplace of ideas; they demand “safe spaces” and the punishment of students or professors whose ideas make anyone in a protected category feel “marginalized.”
More at http://righteousmind.com/viewpoint-diversity/
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

Fero, I'm having a problem having the links open for me...It is probably on my end since we are getting the ''great flood'' over the last couple of days.
I'll be back later to see if I can get to them.
Sounds darn interesting.
Totally agree with this indies POV.
Having two college kids, I often hear the discussion about safe spaces. Their school is not one of those that has them, but it is part of the school dialog since they are in a major college town (Baltimore). I have to say, that I blame the parents of these kids as much as the universities. It is the parents that taught their children that nothing they did was wrong, that everyone was a winner and don't hurt juniors feelings with a little discipline. I saw this happen while my girls were little and I was part of the PTA and school board. The nonsense I heard there from the parents used to make me want to barf. Thank goodness there were a some parents who felt the same way that I did.
In the long run, they are not doing their children any favor. They will have to go out into the real world at some point where they will face real aggression and not micro. I hope they are wearing "Depends" then, or they might really need a safe space to go and hide.
I wonder what the influence of gender is in developing this problem ...