US sues Volkswagen over defeat device scandal
US sues Volkswagen over defeat device scandal -- original article
by Megan Geuss -- Ars Technica
----------------------------------------------------------
The Environmental Protection Agency is looking for injunctive relief and civil penalties
The US Department of Justice has sued Volkswagen Group (PDF) in a Michigan District Court on behalf of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), alleging that the automaker installed illegal defeat devices on almost 600,000 diesel passenger vehicles.
The lawsuit is the latest chapter in the fallout since the EPA published a notice of violation in September accusing Volkswagen of installing software on many of its diesel vehicles that would stop the car’s emissions control system from working properly during normal driving, but engage the emissions control system while the car was being tested in a lab, effectively helping Volkswagen cheat air quality regulators in the US.
A press release from the EPA said that approximately 499,000 diesel cars with 2.0 liter engines were found to have defeat devices, and some 85,000 cars with 3.0 liter engines were similarly implicated. The complaint filed by the Department of Justice suggests that the software to defeat the emissions control system in 2.0 and 3.0 liter cars was slightly different, however.
According to the complaint, during federal emissions testing, 2.0 liter engines from Volkswagen "run software logic and/or calibrations that produce compliant emission results” which the car's onboard system calls the “dyno calibration,” referring to the dynamometer that's used during emissions testing.
"At all other times during normal vehicle operation, the 2.0L Subject Vehicles’ ECM [electronic control module] software run a separate 'road calibration' that reduces the effectiveness of the emission control system.” The difference between the dyno calibration and the road calibration resulted in the widely quoted statistic that Volkswagen cars were releasing up to 40 times the permitted amount of nitrogen oxide (NO x ).
Volkswagen’s offending 3.0 liter diesel engines, however, "run software logic and/or calibrations that produce compliant emission results under an ECM calibration referred to as the “temperature conditioning mode.” At other times during normal vehicle operation, the 3.0L Subject Vehicles’ ECM software run a separate “normal mode” that reduces the effectiveness of the emission control system.” The result of these two modes was "increased NO x emissions by a factor of up to 9 times above the EPA-compliant levels.”
In the complaint, the DoJ notes that NO x is a highly reactive gas that can exacerbate asthma, emphysema, and congestion. "Additionally, recent scientific studies indicate that the direct health effects of NO x are worse than previously understood, including respiratory problems, damage to lung tissue, and premature death,” the complaint notes.
In addition to its accusations regarding defeat devices on Volkswagen Group cars, the Department of Justice accused the company of lying to or misleading federal regulators:
The United States’ efforts to learn the truth about the emission exceedances and other irregularities related to the 2.0L Subject Vehicles, including whether VW had committed the violations of federal law alleged herein, were impeded and obstructed by material omissions and misleading information provided by VW entities including at least VWoA and Volkswagen AG.
Even after EPA issued its September 18, 2015 Notice of Violation to Volkswagen AG, Audi AG, and VWoA, and Mr. Horn’s testimony before Congress, VW failed to come forward and reveal to regulators that the 3.0L Subject Vehicles contain one or more undisclosed AECDs, including the dual calibration strategy involving the “temperature conditioning mode” and the “normal mode.” The existence of this dual calibration strategy was uncovered only as a result of EPA and CARB’s diligence.
The DoJ and the EPA are asking the court to halt the sale of any vehicle that has been identified to include a defeat device and order the company to remedy the situation by fixing the affected cars. In addition, the US says that Volkswagen Group must pay civil penalties of $32,500 per affected car made before 2009 and $37,500 per affected car made after 2009 for each of two violations of the Clean Air Act, as well as between $2,750 and $3,750 for each defeat device found on the affected cars. Finally, US officials are demanding "up to $32,500 per day of violation occurring before January 13, 2009, and up to $37,500 per day of violation occurring on or after January 13, 2009 for violations of Section 203(a)(2) of the [Clean Air] Act.”
In a statement, Volkswagen Group of America said, "Volkswagen will continue to work cooperatively with the EPA on developing remedies to bring the TDI [turbocharged direct injection] vehicles into full compliance with regulations as soon as possible. In addition, we are working with Kenneth Feinberg to develop an independent, fair and swift process for resolving private consumer claims relating to these issues. We will continue to cooperate with all government agencies investigating these matters."
According to the EPA, the affected cars include the following:
2.0 liter diesel models and model years:
- Jetta (2009-2015)
- Jetta Sportwagen (2009-2014)
- Beetle (2013-2015)
- Beetle Convertible (2013-2015)
- Audi A3 (2010-2015)
- Golf (2010-2015)
- Golf Sportwagen (2015)
- Passat (2012-2015)
3.0 liter diesel models and model years:
- Volkswagen Touareg (2009-2016)
- Porsche Cayenne (2013-2016)
- Audi A6 Quattro (2014-2016)
- Audi A7 Quattro (2014-2016)
- Audi A8 (2014 – 2016)
- Audi A8L (2014-2016)
- Audi Q5 (2014-2016)
- Audi Q7 (2009-2015)
Tags
Who is online
143 visitors

It took a while for governments to finally come down on BP, after Deepwater Horizon. I'm wondering how long it will be for Volkswagen...
I'm just glad my Bug is a regular gas car. It sounds like the rest of the VW owners are in for a long, drawn out hassle, at the very least.
Hmmm... regular gas...
I wonder...
Believe me, I've been wondering if it'll expand to that ever since we bought it. Though we almost never use it. We've had it almost a year and have only put about 200 miles on it.
Well... More seriously... I don't think you're running a real risk. Gasoline pollution problems are more straightforward than diesel.
... ...
... ... of course, there are those pesky NOx
I have come to the conclusion that, no matter what car I buy, there is always going to be something to worry about with it.
I'm just glad my Bug is a regular gas car.
Your Bug?!! You drive a VW Bug?! I would never have imagined that you would be driving a Bug!
I can see it now, you driving through town with your shades and that beard looking like Mr. Baddass in your VW Bug.
Actually the Bug is our back up (spare) car, which is why it has so few miles on it. Our regular car is a Fiat 500L, like the pope rode in while he was in America. We traded in our MB SLK280 on it because the insurance and monthly payments on a Benz Roadster on a fixed income was sucking up money we could otherwise use on things like traveling. Sometimes you have to make sacrifices when you retire and ours was to stop buying Benzs
Besides, I look cool driving anything...except maybe a moped...
Besides, I look cool driving anything...
Here ya go Randy......!
How cool is that? !
A Pedal Bike? You mean like put my own energy into moving something? Perish the thought!
I can see it now, you driving through town with your shades and that beard looking like Mr. Baddass in your VW Bug.
Oh and the Bug is a convertible and everyone looks cool in just about any car when the top is down. Even a Bug.
I don't know but they need to come down hard.
A 500L is not exactly the ride I would expect to see you in either.
This is the kind of baddass ride I think is more your style.
I've had 5 Mustangs in my life. I loved the cars. I've had a 67, 73, 81, 84 and a 91. None of them were customized though. My current wife does not like them though, which is why we've had a Porsche, a Vette, and 3 MB's, a 450SL, a CLK500 and the 280SLK. I miss the days when were were working. (sigh). We did have a 98 Chevy Tracker as a spare car for 15 years! Loved that thing!
I think our sports car days are over though. Got to be more practical and the Fiat 500L is just the right size crossover for an old retired couple like us.
'My current wife' .......
(?!)
Don't let her see that.
Poor choice of words, especially when you talking about all the different cars you've owned. 8^)}
Well it's not like I can trade her in on another Benz. Can I?
Well it's not like I can trade her in on another Benz. Can I?
I'm not sure, I'll look into it, I think Apple has an app that calculates the relative value of future ex-wives vs used auto prices.
Does it take account of alimony?
Does it take account of alimony?
I think it pays it for you, but I may have read that part wrong.
My good friends Tim and Susan join Mrs. E. and me each year in warmer times going to local car shows.
The "Stang" driven by Steve Mc Queen in the famous chase scene in the movie Bulltt is the car of my dreams I will never own.
The Enochobile is also known as an OldsmoBuick. Every Olds I ever purchased had another GM motor in it. The motors ranged from Pntoiac to Buick engines.
Presently, I drive a Rolls Canardly. It is a 2001 OldsmoBuick Intrigue. It rolls down one hill, and can hardly get up another.
Enoch, tooting my "Ooga" horn.
Presently, I drive a Rolls Canardly. It is a 2001 OldsmoBuick Intrigue. It rolls down one hill, and can hardly get up another.
You can post some pretty funny comments E, you need to come out your shell more often.
I think our sports car days are over though.
* * * sigh * * *
Alfa Romeo 147
Alfa Romeo 147
Nice ride! 2001 European car of the year.
I loved that car! Then a young woman ran an intersection...
No way that looks like gas guzzling high carbon footprint conservatives car.
.....that looks like gas guzzling high carbon footprint conservatives car.
I'm surprised to see you admit Conservatives drive gas guzzlers.
Is that what he meant? I thought it was gibberish.
Is that what he meant?
I think so, depends on whether he he left the coma out on purpose or not.
I thought it was gibberish.
That's understandable, Dean is the NT king of one liner gibberish. 8^)}