Obama Oversteps His Authority With Gun Orders
http://thenewstalkers.com/discussion/create_topic/cat=1/profile_id=2
Obama Oversteps His Authority With Gun Orders
White House/Instagram "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." —Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
In 2008, the Supreme Court laid to rest the once-simmering dispute over the meaning of the Second Amendment. In an opinion written by Justice Antonin Scalia, the court articulated the modern existence of the ancient right to keep and bear arms as a pre-political right.
A pre-political right is one that pre-exists the political order that was created to protect it. Thus, the court held, the origins of this right are the ancient and persistent traditions of free peoples and their natural inclinations to self-defense.
The court also characterized the right as fundamental. That puts it in the highest category of rights protected by the Bill of Rights. Though the origins of this right are from an era well before guns existed, the textual language in the amendment—"Arms"—makes clear, the court ruled, the intention of the Framers that its continuing purpose should be to recognize the right of people to keep and use the same level of technologically available arms that might be used against them.
That, in a nutshell, is the history, theory, and purpose of the amendment as the modern Supreme Court has found them to be. But as we have seen, the constitutional guarantees that were written to keep the government from interfering with our rights are only as viable as is the fidelity to the Constitution of those in whose hands we have reposed it for safekeeping. In our system, principal among those are the hands of the president; and sadly, today we have a president seriously lacking in this fidelity. And that lack is salient when it comes to the Second Amendment.
Earlier this week, President Barack Obama announced that he will sign executive orders that expand the size and scope of federal monitoring of the acquisition and use of guns—traditionally a matter left to the states—and he will interpret the laws in novel ways, establish rules and impose obligations that Congress rejected, and prosecute those who defy his new system.
The president has very little room to issue executive orders on guns because the congressional legislation in this area is so extensive, detailed, and clear. In addition to ordering your doctor to report to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) any mention you may make to the doctor of guns in your home, the president has decreed on his own and against the articulated will of Congress the obligation of all people who transfer any gun to any other person to obtain a federal gun dealer license. This is among the most cumbersome and burdensome licenses to obtain.
He has also decreed that any licensee who fails to perform a background check on the person to whom the licensee has transferred a gun shall be guilty of a felony. Give a BB gun to your nephew on his 16th birthday without a federal license and you can go to prison.
Can the president do that? In a word: No.
Under our system of government, only Congress can write federal laws and establish crimes. The president is on particularly thin constitutional ice here because his allies in Congress have proposed this very procedure as an amendment to existing law, and Congress has expressly rejected those proposals.
The president is without authority to negate the congressional will, and any attempt to do so will be invalidated by the courts. As well, by defining what an occasional seller is, beyond the congressional definition or the plain meaning of the words, the president is essentially interpreting the law, a job reserved for the courts.
By requiring physicians to report conversations with their patients about guns to the DHS, the president will be encouraging them to invade the physician-patient privilege; and I suspect that most doctors will ignore him.
Under the Constitution, fundamental liberties (speech, a free press, worship, self-defense, travel, and privacy, to name a few) are accorded the highest protection from governmental intrusion. One can only lose a fundamental right by intentionally giving it up or via due process (a jury trial resulting in a conviction for criminal behavior). The president—whose support for the right to keep and bear arms is limited to the military, the police and his own heavily armed body guards—is happy to begin a slippery slope down into the dark hole of totalitarianism, whereby he or a future president can negate liberties if he hates or fears the exercising of them.
We still have a Constitution in America. Under the Constitution, Congress writes the laws, the president enforces them, and the courts interpret them. The president can no more write his own laws or impose his own interpretations upon pre-existing laws than Congress or the courts can command the military.
As troubling as this turn of events is, it is not surprising. The president is a progressive, and the ideology of progressivism is anathema to self-help or individualism. He really believes that the government can care for us better than we can care for ourselves.
Yet he ignores recent history. Any attempt to make it more difficult for people to keep and bear arms not only violates the fundamental liberty of those people but also jeopardizes the safety of us all. Add to this the progressive tendency to use government to establish no-gun zones and you have the recipe for disaster we have recently witnessed. All of the recent mass killings in America—from Columbine to San Bernardino—have occurred in no-gun zones, where crazies and terror-minded murderers can shoot with abandon.
That is, until someone arrives with a gun and shoots back. Then the killer flees or is injured or dies— and the killing stops.
COPYRIGHT 2016 ANDREW P. NAPOLITANO | DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS.COM
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

Hopefully the courts will protect our rights.
I appreciate the position of those who fight for our 2nd amendment rights and it's important to have discussions and hear what others are thinking. This piece has some points that deserve further thought but it also has statements that are misleading or a misinterpretation of information. It's not accurate to suggest that if you give your nephew a BB gun you will go to jail. It's also irresponsible to give a blanket statement that obtaining a gun dealer license is the most cumbersome and burdensome license to obtain. You do need to fill out a form and certificate of compliance but the States determine which other requirements are needed. For me it's too early to form an opinion on the impact of this Executive Order or to become too concerned since it's not yet been determined whether he has the authority to enforce this order. Definitely something to keep an eye on.
You do need to fill out a form and certificate of compliance but the States determine which other requirements are needed.
I believe you have a misconception. They are not talking about a State business license. They are talking about the Federal Firearms License. And yes, it is very cumbersome process.
I've never applied personally so I could certainly have misunderstood. What exactly is the process?
Thanks - So I looked at the link and I see that in addition to the form and fingerprints there is also an interview process after the paperwork is sent to the applicant's local region. I guess this is where the State's requirements come in - not sure. I do know that preliminary background checks can be done within 72 hours - easy peasy. I've gone through very extensive background checks where I've had to fill out my complete history; provide information on every single job I've held and every member of my family. I've had my neighbors interviewed and I've had to go through an interview myself. Let me tell you - that was cumbersome. I guess it's a personal opinion on what one considers cumbersome. I can see where it would be a nuisance for those who would only be selling a gun maybe once in their life time or every couple years. I'm not sure whether this EO will be enacted but if it is hopefully they will realize that an alternate process should be established for those who don't fall within the current definition of gun dealer.
The Imperial Presidency again. Most of these illegal orders will be ignored or overturned in court. His crocodile tears won't change that.
Most of these illegal orders will be ignored or overturned in court.
Sounds to me like you don't want to do anything to help stifle gun violence in America.
His crocodile tears won't change that.
You're sure the man felt no emotion when he tried to talk about the 20 children killed at Sandy Hook. If you're sure about that it's likely because you simply are not capable of understanding and/or empathizing with the enormity of that tragedy.
I cried over those children, because I feel responsible as member of the society that failed those children, and I'm not the President of the United States, who bears a much larger burden regarding what happened to those little ones.
But, you're a different breed Kovy, I don't believe you have an a once of empathy in your DNA, so I'm sure you have no idea what I'm referring to..
Sounds like you are ignorant of my position, the relative risk of gun violence, and the bill of rights.
Sounds like you are ignorant of my position, the relative risk of gun violence, and the bill of rights.
Lets see.... you are aware that 30,000 +- Americans are killed by gunfire .... every year! But you don't give a fuck about that, as long as, "relative to the Bill of Rights", the 2nd Amendment in particular, is not imposed upon in order to promote gun safety.
However, I find it difficult to believe that you have given any consideration to the unalienable right to to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness mentioned in our Declaration of Independence. You also seem to be ignoring the fact that there are 9 other amendments in the Bill of Rights that collectively give us the right not to get shot.
11,000 deaths by gun violence in the US in 2014 (not 30,000) or a 0.003% probability. Relative risk indeed.
I would say the right to protect yourself with a firearm is a valuable element to life, library and happiness.
As the AP notes, these illegal acts by the President would have prevented exactly zero mass shootings.
As the AP notes, these illegal acts by the President would have prevented exactly zero mass shootings.
So you're absolutely sure the EO's are illegal, and you're absolutely sure they would not have prevented even one of the death ........
...... and you're absolutely sure they will not prevent people from being killed going forward.
That's some pretty powerful insight Sean.
I see you're so sure the AP report you refer to is so definitive that you didn't feel it necessary to provide us with a link so we can see what it says for ourselves.
I'm sure Jerry. I challenge you. Of the shootings that the Crier In Chief mentioned, I challenge you to look them up, look up the shooters, and find just one of them that got their guns from an online sale without a background check. Or bought them from another individual without a background check.
To be sure, the San Bern shootiers didn't buy their guns from a dealer. They got them from a friend. But, since California already has a law against private sales without a BG check, it's pretty clear that didn't work.
So. Yes. I'm sure this guy is right when he says it would have done nothing to stop any of the shootings. Prove it wrong.
Of course. It's more artificial feel good legislation from the artificial feel good party.
Taking guns out of hands mentally ill people won't help. Now that's insanity. Thinking the second amendment means every American has the right to a gun. That was never intended. The only reason the amendment was added the United States had no military no way to protect our country in its infancy with out a military. There fore the amendment came into being. The second amendment has no current need to exist. There is more gun violence in the United States than any other country in the world. The NRA is itself a terrorist organization feeding on the scared.
SCOTUS disagrees with you. They win.
My god Bush attacked an Aspirin factory. Obama wants to get guns out of Peoples hands who are on the Terrorist list, Those who are mentally ill. Frelons You want everyone to be able to have a gun. That falls right in with NRA they get richer the worse the killings get. More people are scared and the process just gets worse and worse. They agreed with what Obama is doing they said he had the power to fix it. No new laws were required. Well they were right stand back and watch. Your and your ilk were unwilling to propose a fix or answers basically no matter how bad it got by God you had your gun. The constitution was meant to be a living document so we the 80 plus percent want the second amendment flushed out of the Constitution we now have the biggest strongest Military in the world. We have military bases across the country. Air planes that can reach any part of the United States in minutes. And you want a frigging gun not to protect your country but to protect yourself and your family. This is getting farther from civilization all the time. Im sure your many years in the Military protecting your country gave you this need to hold something of substance.
Lol. Clinton bombed the aspirin factory, and Obama wanted to strip people of human rights without due process or possibility of appeal. Keep digging...
Duer process is not required. Like the Presidential Candidates said Obama had the right and process to make this happen. Your NRA and Presidential candidates suggested he could do it he didn't need their help or anyones help. Watch what you ask for as you got it. I'm sure those very words have been said or repeated on this very site. Well your getting your wish. President Obama you go man.
We need to start a movement to eliminate the Second Amendment my guess citizens agree and you will loose by a figure of two to one maybe more.
It's a bit hard to parse your post. However, are you employing the "they did it too!" defense? Due process is an important base of jurisprudence, and I would object to any official eliminating it. Your argument is empty.
And I'm afraid any attempt to repeal a fundamental human right will be quite unsuccessful. Sorry. Your dreams of facism will not be fulfilled any time soon.
Your dreams of facism will not be fulfilled any time soon.
The idea that America is anywhere even near being threatened by coming a "Fascist" state is absurd to the point to where you may want to try a different tactic, since that one destroys the credibility of anyone who tries to say it. It's like calling the President a dictator or Hitler or a Nazi. It's just silly and childish. We are as far away from a Fascist state (or becoming one) as one could possibly be. I realize that it's a word that some (who don't know what Fascism really is) like to use, however it is beyond reality to apply it to America.
You should read more carefully. The poster I replied to wanted to repeal the 2nd ammendment, a basic human right. My response stands, and I forgive your mistake.
It's his right to feel that way and to try. If this were a fascist nation or even in danger of becoming one, he would not have that right.
Your response remains incorrect. Though it is your right to have that opinion, since this is not a Fascist nation.
If this were a fascist nation or even in danger of becoming one, he would not have that right.
The Patriot Act has effectively removed our rights under the 4th amendment . Which amendment is next to go ?
Your right Bush is the one who declared war on third world countries Twice. Oh he didn't pay for them. Took tons of money out of Social Security as well. If your a weapons man we'll Bush the Bushmaster that goes back a ways. Im retired military and I saw military men loose their life needlessly and weapons were involved.
I'm soooo glad that neither Clinton nor Obama used ugly military force on less developed nations....
Comparatively speaking both have been very restrained. We are using airstrikes in Syrian to support the civil war and he did use ugly military force to kill Osama bin Laden and some Somali pirates though, so guilty as charged there. As for Clinton he used force to bring about a peace in the war in a civil war in Bosnia. Quit effectively and without a large invasion I might add.
So they are only relatively evil?
They are all relatively "evil" if that's the word you choose to use. Washington was. As was Lincoln. FDR, LBJ, Nixon, Reagan, Bush. Take your pick. An unfortunate part of being the Commander in Chief of the United States Military is that sometimes you need to use it. Some use it wisely. Other do not.
So, back to the topic. When these Executive Orders go into effect, how many law abiding citizens will have their guns taken away?
And how many law abiding citizens have had their guns taken away under this Presidential Administration so far? Statistics please.
I answered your questions multiple times. If you want to continue your circular, very non-liberal argument just reread the previous posts over and over again...
I answered your questions multiple times.
Where?
In this thread. Hint. Look above.
Ah yes. The answer is none. Thank you and I apologize for missing your answer.
I don't know how many folks are on the watch list. It's secret. That's the problem.
With respect to the latest executive orders, I never claimed they would immediately result in gungrabbing. I claimed they were illegal and would not prevent any deaths.
IYHO.
Of course. I'm not a lawyer. I can only predict that they will be overturned.
I don't know how many folks are on the watch list. It's secret. That's the problem.
If you were a federal law enforcement agency and you were investigating someone or suspicious that someone might be a terrorist...would you tell them?
Nope. But I wouldn't take away their rights to travel or own guns either. That's what due process is about.
There are people on the list for no reason, with no recourse.
Also the legislation would prohibit sales, actually additionally scrutiny, not outright prohibition, to the purchase of firearms by people on the government's "No Fly List", which is a different list then the "Terrorist Watch List". If you are mistakenly on the government's "No Fly List" you can petition to have your name removed and if they don't, the ACLU will help. Or you can hire your own attorney.
And again, what does any of this have to do with the President's Executive Orders of today?
Nothing at all. You asked whether Obama had tried to take guns from law abiding citizens previously. Yes, he did.
No. I asked if he HAD taken guns from law abiding citizens.
No. You asked if he had THREATENED to do so. He has.
So guns are for a new Government to evolve to replace the current government by force. Gun owners unite to kill our government and wage war right here in America. Right Jefferson51 is that what your intending. You make the elimination of the Second Amendment even more important more urgent.
And more futile.
As soon as someone proposes gun controls that would be effective (unlike the latest imperial orders) without infringing on my civil rights, I will be happy to support them.
I strongly support the 2nd Amendment right for anyone of legal age to to own and use as many flintlock firearms as they choose to. Fits the 2nd and doesn't violate anyone's civil rights.
Fortunately, SCOTUS does not agree with your interpretation.
Under your system, can we have cannon and Greek fire catapults, too? That could be fun.
An "arm" is something that can be carried by a single person (according to Scalia. (Wasn't he on the SCOTUS all the way back then too?)), so no cannons. Sorry.
Besides, cannons and Greek-fire catapults were not flintlocks.
And the SCOTUS can always change it's mind. Plus there are Amendments. And Constitutional Conventions where everything is up for change.
BUT WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH THE TOPIC OF THE PRESIDENT'S EXECUTIVE ORDERS??????????
Who knows? You made the claim that the second ammendment only applied to flintlocks. Are you Amish?
I am an atheist, as most here know.
As am I.
Common ground and commonsense! I will send you a follower request.
Accepted and returned.
And the SCOTUS can always change it's mind.
Really Randy? So SCOTUS could change their minds on Abortion too right? Or Gay Marriage? Or Obamacare?
The Supreme Court overthrew Dred Scott. That was the decision that allowed Southern slave owners to take their human property into the territories.
I can carry a mortar so guess thats legal. Rocket launcher yep I can carry. Bazooka I can carry. A gun is in fact a weapon not a pet but have seen idiots hold them like their in love. The Second amendment is no longer fulfilling a National security need. A very large amount of Militia members are not educated many not even a high school education. One advantage of education is observation by professionals to provide another way to identify mental issues to get them help. But they can still own a weapon. If we all call a gun what it is a weapon it might sink into some very thick skulls.
Do we need well trained militias I think not. Ever see mental midgets racing around the woods or the desert playing war games like 8 yer olds. Their mental growth seemed to have stopped at that age. Militias were needed in our country to protect against attack by other countries. I believe our Army, Navy Air Force and Marines and National Guards fulfill that need.
President Obama do your thing help protect us our morally and mentally weak people and mentally sick from hurting themselves or others. Their very rage over the thought of loosing their weapon is a significant sign they need help. The Constitution is a living document we need to change it.
Ever see mental midgets racing around the woods or the desert playing war games like 8 yer olds. Their mental growth seemed to have stopped at that age.
Perfect description of the bulk of the "militia" (and most of the "open carry crowd" too) I've seen, including that group of morons up in Oregon. They run around the woods playing army like 8 year olds in their camouflage, military toys and semi-auto assault rifles and they they don't even seem to realize that, far from looking threatening, they look like beer-bellied clowns whose mommies dressed them funny. Who do they think they're scaring? The government? That's a joke! Other people? Most of them (myself included) are more in danger of dying laughing at them in their clown suits. Then they give themselves names that almost always have the word "Patriot" in them, while the real American Patriots of old would laugh at them too. Patriots? More like overgrown Boy Scouts.
Far from inciting fear, they incite jokes. I think they're funnier then all hell to look at, until one of them like a Timothy McVeigh type kills a bunch of people (because the bulk of the them are really deluded and drunk on what they think is their "power") and then they get the needle. Good. Put them down. Dangerous, yes, but dangerous clowns and buffoons above all.
Grow up! The government is not coming after your guns and there is not going to be a new Revolution or Civil War for you to fight in. You're just making asses out of yourselves.
Different strokes for different folks. Just as we support homos freedom to dance around limp wristed in fairy costumes we support these guys freedom to do what they want. I suspect most of them wouldn't want to live your lifestyle either. It's our freedom that makes this a great place to live.
Most of them do live my lifestyle (the older retired ones anyway) and yours. The vast majority of gay people live the usual lives of the boring as you and I do. They own or rent homes or apartments, have jobs, pay their bills, pay taxes, vote, shop at the same stores, eat at McDonald's, go on vacations, get married (now), serve in the US military, have children and go to church. For the majority their day to day lives are no different then any straight people's lives are.
I strongly support the 2nd Amendment right for anyone of legal age to to own and use as many flintlock firearms as they choose to.
That has got to be one of the stupidest comments ever uttered here on this site. If the 2nd Amendment only applies to flinlocks, then the 1st only applies to parchment and quill pen.
Sorry Randy, but SCOTUS has ruled in many, many cases that the rights of the Constitution apply to modern technology just as they did to the technology of the day.
Well said.
Oh if the Scotus says its legal then all the BULL SHIT about repealing the Affordable Care ACT is idiotic based on your premise. But then again Republicans scream ignore the law. Now those are words that get me riled up. The best way to stop this idiocy is at the Voting booth. Vote Bernie Sanders fowling in the footsteps of Franklin d. Roosevelt. Both Democratic Socialist both for the middle class and poor and against big Corporations and the rich elite. Obama and the Executive orders are to help the masses.